Prison visitor centres and support services review: main report
This report presents the first full independent review of Scottish Government-funded Prison Visitors' Centres (PVCs) and support services in Scotland.
Chapter 7: Perspectives of prison staff
- Prison staff generally valued PVCs for helping families feel welcomed, informed and calmer before and after visits.
- Positive working relationships between PVC and prison staff supported practical problem-solving, communication with families and child- and family-focused activity.
- Prison staff linked positive family contact with the wellbeing of people in custody and, in some accounts, with reduced tension and stronger safeguarding awareness within prisons.
- The contribution of PVCs was less visible where services were not consistently staffed, awareness amongst prison staff was limited or operational arrangements restricted joint working.
- Booking processes, waiting times, catering, available resources and the diversity of prisons and families shaped how consistently positive visiting experiences could be provided.
Introduction
This chapter presents the perspectives of prison staff working across the prison estate (n=16). Two participants held national or multi-establishment roles, whilst 14 worked within one of the nine local establishments visited as part of the study fieldwork. The sample included Family Contact Officers, Operations Officers, First Line Managers for Visits or Gates, Family Case Managers and staff with strategic responsibilities. Their level of direct contact with PVC staff and visiting families varied according to role and local arrangements.
The chapter reports on the following five main themes:
- PVCs help make visits calmer and more manageable;
- collaborative working supports family-focused practice;
- family contact is valued, but awareness and resources constrain support;
- booking, waiting and refreshments can undermine visits; and
- local provision needs to respond to different prisons and families.
Further supporting quotations and lower-frequency findings are provided in the Part 2 Supporting Evidence report at AppendixI .
Overview of prison staff perspectives
Prison staff generally described PVCs and their staff positively. PVC workers were valued as approachable, knowledgeable and practical and as able to offer families a different form of contact from uniformed prison staff. Their presence was described as helping families settle before visits, understand arrangements and raise practical concerns.
Interviewees connected family support with the wider prison environment. Positive visits were described as important to the wellbeing of people in custody, and some associated calmer and better-supported family contact with reduced tension and improved awareness of safeguarding concerns. These benefits were most visible where PVC and prison staff worked closely together.
Interviewees also identified limits. PVCs were not staffed for every visit in all establishments, awareness of their role varied amongst prison staff, and FCOs and other family-facing staff worked within wider operational and resource pressures. Booking systems, waiting times and catering were recurring sources of frustration. Interviewees also emphasised that establishments and family populations differed, requiring local adaptation within a recognisable family-support offer.
PVCs help make visits calmer and more manageable ‘I just think they’re good with… just their presence, the way they come across and the way they come in, they know it’s a welcoming centre and the people that work there are really welcoming. It’s not like you’ve got someone in the office hiding away. They’re right forward talking to them. Anything they’ve got, any questions. So, just their presence and the way they welcome themselves is really good.’ [RF02PS-FF 1Per]
‘She’s a big help to us... It’s good to have her to speak to families and she’s not in a white shirt. I feel like a lot of people can be intimidated by it. A lot of children can be intimidated by it. It doesn’t matter if we’re going over with smiley faces. [AP04PS-FF]
Prison staff described PVCs as beneficial to families, people in custody and the prison. Interviewees particularly valued workers who were visible, approachable and able to speak with families before and after visits. Their non-uniformed role was described as reducing some of the formality and anxiety associated with entering a prison.
Interviewees described PVC staff providing reassurance, answering questions and helping families deal with practical problems. This support was especially valued when families were unfamiliar with arrangements, had travelled a long distance or arrived distressed. PVC staff were also described as understanding local processes and explaining them in a family-facing way.
Some interviewees linked better-supported visits with calmer interactions for people in custody and families. PVC staff could also notice changes in a family member’s presentation or family dynamics and pass concerns through local safeguarding arrangements. These accounts positioned PVC support as relevant to both the immediate visit and the wider prison environment.
The availability and visibility of this support were not consistent across all visiting sessions. Interviewees described PVCs being open without staff present, opening hours not covering all visits and families or prison staff having limited awareness of what support was available.
Collaborative working supports family-focused practice
‘It’s a very good relationship that’s set up between them. If something can’t be done, justify why it can’t be done, then that’s fine. At the same time, if something can be done, then we’ll go and do it.’ [JD03PS-M]
‘So, we are listening to what the dads would like and trying to make that happen so that they have a wee bit more involvement.’ [CJ01PS-F]
Prison staff described examples of PVC and prison staff working together to improve family contact. Interviewees referred to child-focused visits, seasonal activities, visitor forums and practical arrangements that allowed people in custody to contribute to occasions such as a child’s birthday.
FCOs and other family-facing staff were prominent in these accounts. Interviewees described listening to families and people in custody, coordinating activities with PVC staff and adapting arrangements where possible. Some initiatives were led by prison staff, whilst others depended on PVC staff, partner organisations or shared delivery.
The strength of these relationships varied by role, establishment and local history. Some interviewees worked with PVC teams routinely, whilst others had limited contact. Relationships were also described as developing after provider or staffing changes. Where joint working was established, practical issues could be addressed more quickly and family-focused activity was easier to organise.
Collaborative practice remained dependent on staff time, prison routines and operational priorities. Interviewees described commitment to family work but acknowledged that staffing pressure and competing duties limited what FCOs, visits staff and PVC teams could provide.
Family contact is valued, but awareness and resources constrain support
‘Down here it’s more of an understanding and sympathetic role... there’s a wee bit more respect between the officers and the prisoners in that sense... people don’t want to mess with their visits.’ [JD03PS-M]
‘How can I be a [family-focused role] for like 540 people?’ [JD01PS-F]
Prison staff generally recognised the importance of family contact for people in custody and their relatives. Interviewees associated positive contact with motivation, emotional stability and the maintenance of relationships outside prison. Some also described visits as contributing to a calmer and more respectful environment because people in custody valued family contact and did not want to jeopardise it.
Awareness of families’ experiences and of the role of PVCs was less consistent across the workforce. Interviewees suggested that staff with less direct contact with families did not always understand the practical and emotional pressures associated with visiting or the support PVCs could provide. Family-focused training, greater visibility of PVC activity and stronger communication between family-facing and residential staff were identified as ways of improving the consistency of staff responses.
Staffing, experience and competing operational demands also affected the availability and continuity of family support. Prison-based family roles could cover large populations and be affected by staff shortages, redeployment and competing responsibilities. Interviewees also described periods in which the loss of experienced staff disrupted established relationships with families and made visits more difficult to manage. PVC staffing and opening hours varied between establishments and visiting sessions. Support therefore remained uneven even where prison staff recognised the importance of family contact and the value of PVC provision.
Booking, waiting and refreshments can undermine visits
'[On provision of vending machines] I don’t think is the greatest. They get refilled twice a week and usually by the weekend, they’re empty. They can’t get a tea and coffee… the sandwich machine sells really quick.' [KG01PS-F]
‘The system we use is called CMS… it just needs the times changed on it. You will see about 30-odd emails a day that the staff are having to pick up.’ [JD03PS-M]
Prison staff identified practical aspects of visiting that could make the experience more difficult for families. Booking arrangements were a recurring concern. Accounts described variation in how bookings were managed, how requests were recorded and how far in advance visits could be arranged. Some also identified limitations in local booking systems, which created additional administrative work for staff.
Interviewees described families waiting whilst arrangements were checked and local processes creating confusion or perceived unfairness. These difficulties could be particularly frustrating where visitors had travelled a long distance or had limited opportunities to attend.
Catering was another repeated concern. PVCs were said to commonly offer hot drinks and some provided food, but provision within visit rooms was often dependent on vending machines. Interviewees described machines as expensive, poorly stocked or limited in healthier options, with popular items sometimes unavailable later in the week.
Booking and catering were therefore identified as practical areas where clearer processes and relatively modest changes could improve the visit experience, even within wider financial and operational constraints.
Local provision needs to respond to different prisons and families
‘The broader population picture is evolving.’ [AP02PS-F]
‘We have quite a few children who are non-verbal… in parenting class bringing in partners to teach Makaton. We have a lot of children who are neurodiverse, so we are making the play area in the visits room a sensory area.’ [CJ01PS-F]
Prison staff emphasised that establishments differ in size, location, population and visiting arrangements. They therefore did not expect family-support provision to look identical across the prison estate. Local practice was described as needing to respond to the population held, the physical environment and the needs of visiting families.
Interviewees working in establishments accommodating women commonly described low uptake of visits. They also referred to the increasing complexity of some women’s circumstances and the different forms of family support that may be required. Families of people convicted of sexual offences were described as experiencing acute stigma and, in some cases, requiring additional support.
Interviewees also described families with health conditions, disabilities, neurodiversity, caring responsibilities or other needs that affected visiting and needed to be addressed. Both PVC and prison staff were reported as making local adjustments where possible.
Contact
Email: justice_analysts@gov.scot