Prison visitor centres and support services review: main report

This report presents the first full independent review of Scottish Government-funded Prison Visitors' Centres (PVCs) and support services in Scotland.


Appendix F. Qualitative themes and examples (family members)

This appendix provides supplementary qualitative evidence from family member interviews and survey open-text responses beyond the summary provided in the Part 1 Main Report at Chapter 4. The first table supports the main themes used in the ‘Perspectives of family members’ chapter. The second table captures other salient supplementary themes and detailed practical issues identified during the analysis.

Examples are drawn from interview summaries and open-text survey responses. Interview examples are attributed using participant IDs. Survey examples are attributed using survey response row numbers.

Table F1. Consistent family member themes

Main Theme: Visiting frequency and travel experiences when visiting vary significantly

Qualitative Examples:

Subthemes reflected: distance and journey time; travel cost and affordability; work and caring commitments; access to travel support; visit frequency and practicality.

"It is a lot to pay £35 each way in the taxi for 45 minutes, especially as I can’t make it every week." [Family member #1, female]

“If I stayed locally, I would visit more. It’s just working it around work schedule and stuff like that that’s challenging.” [Family member #14, male]

“I can’t afford it, but it’s never stopped me” [Family member #9, female]

"There is no travel support for full time students or pensioners who don’t claim benefits. It costs a lot of money for me to visit." (Survey respondent #7)

“It is often very hard to get a weekly visit due to how busy the visits are and for the children we visit once a month so we try to get a double visit due to there being 3 children and the visit is only 40 mins but it is a 10 hour round trip to travel there and back, as it is nearly 200 miles away one way. This is often very difficult and it is not appropriate to travel with the kids all that way for 40 mins. The staff in the visitors centre and very friendly and helpful, but trying to speak to an FCO or my partner to explain to hall staff about the distances involved is very tricky. I often do not find out till the morning if we have a visit or not.” (Survey respondent #105)

“I have never been able to get my £50 travel costs. Nobody is helping. They just keep giving me the same form to claim online I don’t know how to do it. Travel... is hours long and expensive and I have never had what I know I’m entitled to. The jail say it’s nothing to do with them. My son is doing a ten year sentence and I have visited every fortnight or monthly because I can’t afford it all the time” (Survey respondent #191)

Main Theme: PVCs can make visiting feel calmer, but the physical environment matters

Qualitative Examples:

Subthemes reflected: comfort and atmosphere; waiting space and facilities; refreshments; the physical environment reducing or adding to stress.

"It is quite nice and cosy, comfortable." [Family member #1, female]

"It’s not like a waiting room, it’s like table with chairs round it and she’s got lovely wee plants on the tables." [Family member #21, female]

"I think it’s a good space now. It’s certainly come a long way in the last four years." [Family member #14, male]

“You just get that warm... homely feeling when you come in.” [Family member #2, female]

"You can go upstairs, watch tv, have a drink and chat to other visitors - that all makes visiting less stressful." [Family member #1, female]

“Hot drinks selection in waiting area or vending machine would be ideal for long waits before visit” (Survey respondent #6)

Main Theme: PVCs are a source of reassurance, preparation, and connection

Qualitative Examples:

Subthemes reflected: emotional preparation before visits; reassurance and practical support; peer connection with other families; opportunities to ask questions and compose oneself.

"I think what’s quite good is you’re in there with everybody who’s in the same boat as you." [Family member #13, male]

“The visitor space is a good space because it is where obviously you meet before you go into the into the visit and going to the visit can be a very daunting experience.” [Family member #16, female]

“Does it have value? Yes, because it gives you somewhere to sit and I suppose prepare yourself mentally” [Family member #15, male]

“We’ve all formed a good friendship because we’re all here for the same reason and we’ll message each other” [Family member #2, female]

"[Staff member] asked if I wanted a cup of tea, and took me to the office where I was able to compose myself and ask questions. It meant the world to me." (Survey respondent #179)

Main Theme: Families experience the stages and spaces of the visit differently

Qualitative Examples:

Subthemes reflected: differences between the PVC and prison environment; movement through reception, security, and practical support; differences in experiences of PVC and prison staff.

"It’s a lot more easier here [in the PVC]. It’s a lot more humane here. Over there [in the prison], it’s just the attitude of the staff, where it’s completely different here from over there." [Family member #4, male]

"Trying to get from reception to the hall is a bit of a palaver." [Family member #20, female]

"Down the stairs yes, up the stairs not so much, because anything can happen." [Family member #15, male]

“I would say the visiting centre is much more... warmer. I think especially for people who bring their kids, it’s much more calm and everyone’s super, super friendly. It’s just more relaxing than it is inside! [Family member #20, female]

“There are too many barriers between support services and actual prison issues.” (Survey respondent #12)

Main Theme: Staff approach shapes how supported families feel

Qualitative Examples:

Subthemes reflected: distance and journey time; travel cost and affordability; work and caring commitments; access to travel support; visit frequency and practicality.

"[PVC staff] make you feel comfortable; make you feel comfortable before you actually go up into the actual visiting room itself." / “[prison staff] make you feel really uncomfortable... and it’s not nice because it brushes off on the loved ones when they eventually get up the stairs as well. That then could cause a reaction for your loved one towards a member of staff, and then that’s your loved one will then get put on report. It’s a vicious circle.” [Family member #15, male]

"[PVC staff are] very welcoming, you just feel like a normal person." [Family member #20, female]

"The prison staff are great... there’s no judgement." [Family member #22, female]

“The most important thing is probably the people staffing it.” [Family member #17, male]

“Due to the kindness from the visitor centre we feel relaxed at visiting the prison and the front reception officers on duty are kind. The visitor centre staff are very much needed they are supportive and impartial and know how to help children feel comfortable especially when you are anxious about your loved one whom you are visiting.” (Survey respondent #87)

"The staff in the [PVC] are outstanding friendly hardworking empathetic and resolve issue’s quickly they make you feel at ease and offer so much support." (Survey respondent #9)

"Honesty they are superstars amazing bunch of ladies who go above and beyond to help visitors with advice or problems” (Survey respondent #9)

Main Theme: Child-friendly support helps make visits more manageable for families with children

Qualitative Examples:

Subthemes reflected: toys, play and activities; staff engagement with children; creating a calm and welcoming environment; making family contact more meaningful; differences between ordinary and child-focused visits. .

"It’s good for the kids. It’s quite comfortable" / “[the PVC] puts [child] in that mood, where [they’re] in a good mood and [they’re] happy before [they] goes. I think if we were just sitting in the visiting room with no toys or that… the boredom would just put him in one of those moods". [Family member #4, male]

"They’re great for the kids, they’ve got toys, and colouring in." [Family member #22, female]

“[Child was] a bit tentative at first, but I think again the visitor centre staff made us feel quite welcome, offered them a drink, and they were quite happy to take that. They got through the visiting, and I think they go quite regularly now as well. I think it was an okay experience for them.” [Family member #13, male]

“I think it would be good to have the time that my grand[child] spends with [their] dad to be more meaningful. That could be something as simple as sitting down and having tea with him. If it’s a five o’clock visit and [child] can sit down and have something to eat with him, I think that would be more rewarding for both my son and my grand[child]. I know they did used to do that years ago” [Family member #14, male]

“Visitor centre staff are very welcoming and take time to speak to my child and engage with them. They have a good variety of toys, books and colouring content for use in the visiting room as well as in the waiting area downstairs, which all adds to the good, calm and welcoming environment for visits.” (Survey respondent #93)

"Would recommend more toys in actual visit room to keep kids amused." (Survey respondent #195)

"My children really enjoy family visits but do not enjoy the normal visits at all.” (Survey respondent #126)

Table F2. Additional family member themes

Main Theme: Families want more workable visit times and longer visits

Qualitative Examples:

“I just think the biggest thing for me is the option of visit times, but I totally understand there’s restraint with that, to a certain degree.” [Family member #14, male]

“They’ve changed the times and I just feel that they’re no, suitable for people that’s got school kids.” [Family member #10, female]

"It would be nice if the visits were a full hour instead of just 45 minutes." (Survey respondent #7)

"Would like visits to start on time as delays could cause issues at other end of visit." (Survey respondent #172)

"Longer visits, especially at the weekend." (Survey respondent #177)

Main Theme: Booking systems need improvement

Qualitative Examples:

"It’s not very sophisticated the systems they’ve got it’s all paper based." [Family member #17, male]

“It is extremely difficult to book the visit, it can take up to an hour to get through on the phone to book with the phone either ringing out or a recorded message to call back later, only being able to book the day before at the earliest. This can be stressful considering the travel to get their takes almost 2.5 hours.” (Survey respondent #82)

“Improve booking system for visits so visitors can see confirmed visits or be notified as prisoners are not always reliable and ensuring they are booked or confirmed.” (Survey respondent #76)

“Better phone booking system for visits” (Survey respondent #82)

Main Theme: Families need timely information and clear routes to answers

Qualitative Examples:

"There’s lots of leaflets and information booklets." / "It’s quite good for information." [Family member #21, female]

"There’s no guidance for anybody." [Family member #17, male]

"Somewhere there should be an idiot’s guide, or a parent’s guide." [Family member #18, female]

"First time visitors need an information pack explaining what to expect before, during and after a visit." (Survey respondent #51)

"Make information clearer." (Survey response #171)

Main Theme: Experiences of the security process were mixed

Qualitative Examples:

"Going through security is quite quiet." [Family member #3, male]

“I understand that the search is for a reason, but of course it doesn't make you feel comfortable.” [Family member #16, female]

"It’s [security] not nice but that’s what they do." [Family member #21, female]

“The security is far too lax.” [Family member #15, male]

“It’s part of me getting in to see my partner and if that’s what I need to go through, I’ll do that. But it’s not overly invasive. I don’t find it overly invasive. I would say that going through the airport is probably more invasive than anything. It’s not overly bad.” [Family member #22, female]

Main Theme: The physical visit environment affects comfort

Qualitative Examples:

"The visits room is either really hot or really cold." [Family member #18, female]

"Quite sterile. The seats are quite uncomfortable as well.” [Family member #15, male]

"Lack of warm within the visit hall, it’s always cold and very dirty, always feels rushed before visit.” (Survey respondent #161)

Main Theme: Basic facilities and refreshments matter during waits and visits

Qualitative Examples:

"The vending machines, they’re horrible. Sometimes they work, sometimes they don’t work." [Family member #15, male]

"Everything is so expensive" in the vending machine. [Family member #21, female]

“Lack of quality food its rubbish in vending machines that are always broke, tea and coffee machine is disgusting sandwich/ wrap machine is always half empty and poor quality food.” (Survey respondent #161)

"The snack machine side of things is ridiculous, from the prices and the working or non working status of them." (Survey response #11)

"Provide refreshments in the waiting room - tea/coffee." (Survey response #179)

Main Theme: Support is most effective when staff are visible, available and consistent

Qualitative Examples:

"There was always a staff presence and I don’t mean just in the office, the staff were always out with the office to meet visitors." [Family member #19, female]

"If it was staffed at the right times." [Family member #17, male]

"There’s not as many staff" / "you come in Saturday Sunday, there’s none". [Family member #18, female]

"Most staff helpful and friendly - helps put us at ease." (Survey respondent #172)

Main Theme: Communication, advocacy and working relationships with the prison are important, but not consistent

Qualitative Examples:

"I think the lack of communication. When you’re trying to get in touch with somebody for support or whatever, the communication is awful." [Family member #4, male]

"Good advocacy and a good working relationship with the prison they’re based in. They’re the two key things." [Family member #19, female]

"Tell us what going on." (Survey respondent #16)

“There are too many barriers between support services and actual prison issues.” (Survey respondent #12)

"Answer the phone and/or return calls/messages left. Have a better way of confirming visits as I have driven 5 hours after receiving an email from prison the day before I travelled to say visit was confirmed and booked to be told on arrival it had been cancelled 2 weeks previous due to a family event. " (Survey respondent #17)

Main Theme: Family contact continues beyond the visit, so phone and video contact also matter

Qualitative Examples:

"The prison phones... sometimes that doesn’t work - I can’t hear him and the phone will just cut out." [Family member #1, female]

"I think they could probably work something for the phone calls to be a bit cheaper." [Family member #20, female]

"Virtual visits... just don’t work." [Family member #19, female]

"Phone calls to families should be free." (Survey respondent #14)

Main Theme: Support that is visible even when not used

Qualitative Examples:

"I know that I could ask them and they’d be there in a heartbeat." [Family member #2, female]

"With consideration to the fact I didn't require nor look for support services, I recognise that there was none readily available (should I have) or easily accessible for other people and families who do need or would greatly benefit from it. I wasn't aware that Prison Services/Visitors' Centres could offer/refer or even give information about support services which are available to individuals and families." (Survey respondent #25)

"Anything I have asked, the answer and support was there." (Survey respondent #189)

Main Theme: Families feel punished too

Qualitative Examples:

“There are times when you feel like you’re the one that’s actually in prison because of the way that the staff speak to you.” [Family member #13, male]

“It is really hard. It’s hard. It’s not just them that are punished; it’s the families as well.” [Family member #4, male]

“Feels like the families are getting punished too.” (Survey respondent #79)

Main Theme: Families need accessible ways to raise concerns and feel heard

Qualitative Examples:

“Any concerns I've got, I direct it always at [PVC staff]... I raised a complaint [with SPS] and I’ve never heard nothing back.” [Family member #11, female]

“Nothing was done with my complaint. They lost every single complaint I put in, written complaint was lost and wasn’t dealt with, and I’m still actually waiting to hear back.” [Family member #15, male]

“The complaints system used by families at [prison] is not fit for purpose... PVC could advise visitors of their right to complain and direct them to bodies which would advocate for them.” (Survey respondent #71)

Contact

Email: justice_analysts@gov.scot

Back to top