Prison visitor centres and support services review: main report

This report presents the first full independent review of Scottish Government-funded Prison Visitors' Centres (PVCs) and support services in Scotland.


Appendix D. Prison Visitors' Centre Review - Family Members Survey (Work Package 3)

1. Introduction

This appendix presents detailed findings from the Family Members Survey. It provides supporting tables and summary commentary to accompany the main report. The appendix is organised by survey section so that readers can follow the questionnaire structure and locate specific findings easily. Full tables are included for each question area, with Chapter 4 of the main report presenting the headline findings through narrative summary.

2. Methods

The Family Members Survey gathered information about respondents’ visiting circumstances, background, travel arrangements, and experiences of Prison Visitors’ Centres or support services. It included questions on satisfaction with provision, additional needs, barriers to asking for or accessing help, services accessed or wanted, and whether respondents had received information or referrals to other services. Open-text questions invited respondents to suggest how Prison Visitors’ Centres, support services, and prisons could better support families.

In total, 198 responses were recorded. This included 71 paper responses, which were manually entered by the research team. Not all questions were answered by all respondents, either because respondents skipped questions or because some questions were only relevant to particular groups.

2.1 Data collection

The survey was hosted on Jisc Online Surveys. It opened on 22 January 2026 and closed on 18 June 2026. Participation was voluntary. A privacy notice informed respondents about the purpose of the survey and how the data would be used in the report and recommendations. The survey was promoted through a variety of channels, including PVC provider organisations, Families Outside, the Community Justice Voluntary Sector Forum, the Scottish Centre for Crime and Justice Research network, and other networks known to the researchers.

The survey included a mixture of fixed-response questions, tick-all-that-apply questions, rating/grid questions, and open-text questions. Some questions used routing, meaning respondents were only asked questions relevant to their earlier answers. Any personal data were deleted, and responses were anonymised before reporting.

2.2 Analysis approach and reporting conventions

Survey data were exported from Jisc Online Surveys as a coded CSV file with a corresponding key file. The data were imported into RStudio Desktop for preparation and checking. Variables were reviewed against the questionnaire and key file, labelled, and organised by question type.

Single-choice questions were summarised using frequency counts and percentages. Multiple-response questions were summarised by the number and proportion of respondents selecting each option. Grid questions were summarised across response categories for each item. Open-text responses were reviewed separately and are summarised thematically where relevant.

Results are presented as the number of respondents selecting each answer (N) and the percentage selecting that answer (%). Percentages are based on the number of respondents who answered each question, excluding missing responses. ‘Prefer not to say’, ‘not sure’ and similar response options are retained where they were selected by respondents. Percentages may not always sum to 100 due to rounding, and for multiple-response questions percentages may total more than 100 because respondents could select more than one answer.

Most tables are based on all respondents who provided a valid answer to the relevant question. A small number of tables are based only on specific subgroups, including respondents who visited with children and/or young people, and respondents who said they needed help during visits but did not ask for it. These subgroup tables are clearly identified in the text.

2.3 Notes on interpretation and limitations

Findings should be interpreted with some caution where response numbers are small, particularly for subgroup tables or categories selected by only a small number of respondents. As with all voluntary surveys, the findings reflect the views of those who chose to take part and may not represent the experiences of all families using Prison Visitors’ Centres or support services.

3. Survey findings

This section presents the detailed survey findings, organised by topic. It includes summary tables for each question and accompanying notes where relevant.

3.1 Demographics

The tables in this section are based on questions that all respondents could answer if they chose to. However, not every respondent answered every question. Where the number of responses is lower than the full survey sample of 198, the table is based on the number of respondents who provided an answer to that question.

Table D1. Sex (n=192)

Sex

N

%

Female

160

83.3

Male

28

14.6

Other (please specify)

2

1.0

Prefer not to say

2

1.0

Table D2. Age (n=188)

Age

N

%

18-24

8

4.3

25-34

40

21.3

35-44

38

20.2

45-54

45

23.9

55-64

37

19.7

65+

19

10.1

Prefer not to say

1

0.5

3.2 Background

The tables in this section are based on questions that all respondents could answer if they chose to. However, not every respondent answered every question. Where the number of responses is lower than the full survey sample of 198, the table is based on the number of respondents who provided an answer to that question.

Table D3. Prison(s) currently or previously visiting (n=195)

Prison

N

%

HMP Barlinnie

85

43.6

HMP Perth

34

17.2

HMP & YOI Polmont

32

16.2

HMP Edinburgh

26

13.1

HMP Addiewell

24

12.1

HMP Kilmarnock

21

10.6

HMP Low Moss

16

8.1

HMP Glenochil

13

6.6

HMP Shotts

13

6.6

HMP & YOI Grampian

11

5.6

HMP Greenock

7

3.5

HMP & YOI Stirling

6

3.0

HMP Dumfries

4

2.0

HMP Inverness

4

2.0

I haven't visited prisons previously

0

0.0

Note: Multiple responses were allowed, so percentages may exceed 100%

Table D4. Main or only prison visited (n=197)

Prison

N

%

HMP Barlinnie

74

37.6

HMP Perth

29

14.7

HMP & YOI Polmont

22

11.2

HMP Addiewell

16

8.1

HMP Edinburgh

15

7.6

HMP Kilmarnock

15

7.6

HMP Low Moss

6

3.0

HMP Glenochil

5

2.5

HMP & YOI Grampian

5

2.5

HMP & YOI Stirling

3

1.5

HMP Shotts

3

1.5

HMP Greenock

2

1.0

HMP Dumfries

1

0.5

HMP Inverness

1

0.5

3.3 Visit context and frequency

The tables in this section are based on questions that all respondents could answer if they chose to. However, not every respondent answered every question. Where the number of responses is lower than the full survey sample of 198, the table is based on the number of respondents who provided an answer to that question.

Table D5. Who the respondent is visiting (n=196)

Person being visited

N

%

Partner

83

42.3

Child (including adult children and step-children)

56

28.6

Sibling (including step-siblings)

21

10.7

Friend

14

7.1

Wider family (e.g., auntie, uncle, niece, nephew, cousin, any in-laws)

12

6.1

Parent (including step-parents)

7

3.6

Prefer not to say

3

2.0

Colleague

0

0.0

Other

0

0.0

Table D6. Custodial status of person being visited (n=194)

Custodial status

N

%

Sentenced

144

74.2

On remand

43

22.2

I am not sure

5

2.6

Prefer not to say

2

1.0

Table D7. Frequency of visit (n=194)

Frequency of visit

N

%

First time

6

3.1

Less than monthly

13

6.7

Monthly

43

22.2

More than twice a week

30

15.5

Twice a week

20

10.3

Weekly

82

42.3

3.4 Visiting with children or young people

The tables in this section are based only on a subgroup of respondents who reported that they visit with children and/or young people. These tables include responses about the ages of the children and young people they visit with, and how respondents think children and young people feel about the visiting experience.

Table D8. Whether the respondent visits with children or young people (n=197)

Visit with children/young people

N

%

No

136

69

Yes

59

29.9

Prefer not to say

2

1.0

Table D9. Age range of children/young people (n=58)

Age range

N

%

Under 5

26

44.8

5-8

23

36.2

9-12

21

39.7

13-17

17

29.3

Note: One respondent skipped this question

Table D10. Perceived feeling of visiting (children/young people) (n=59)

Perceived feeling

N

%

Very negative

2

3.4

Mostly negative

1

1.7

Mixed

15

25.4

Mostly positive

27

45.8

Very positive

11

18.6

Not sure

3

5.1

3.5 Getting to the Prison Visitor Centre or support service

The tables in this section are based on questions that all respondents could answer if they chose to. However, not every respondent answered every question. Where the number of responses is lower than the full survey sample of 198, the table is based on the number of respondents who provided an answer to that question.

Table D11. How respondents travel to visit (n=196)

Main mode of travel

N

%

Car

125

63.8

Bus

29

14.8

Other (please specify)

19

9.7

Train

16

8.2

Taxi

6

3.1

Walk

1

0.5

Table D12. Typical one-way cost of the travel (n=194)

Cost range of travel

N

%

£0

18

9.3

Up to £5.00

31

16.0

£6-10

48

24.7

£11-19

37

19.1

£20+

54

27.8

Prefer not to say

6

3.1

Table D13. Typical one-way travel time (n=194)

Time range of travel

N

%

Less than 15 minutes

12

6.2

15 – 30 minutes

47

24.2

31 – 60 minutes

61

31.4

Over an hour

42

21.6

Over two hours

32

16.5

3.6 Experience of the Prison Visitors' Centre or support service

Table D14. Ratings of aspects of the most recent or typical visit (n= variable)

Aspect of visit

*VG/G N

VG/G %

Okay N

Okay %

P/VP N

P/VP %

NN/NA N

NN/NA %

Facilities for children (N=190)

82

43.2

34

17.9

15

7.9

59

31.1

Feeling welcome and respected by the PVC or support service (N=190)

142

74.7

30

15.8

12

6.3

6

3.2

Information about how to visit (N=192)

126

65.6

36

18.8

20

10.4

10

5.2

Refreshments (N=193)

115

59.6

44

22.8

30

15.5

4

2.1

Support for coping with a loved one's imprisonment (N=192)

107

55.7

28

14.6

38

19.8

19

9.9

Toilets (N=192)

101

52.6

59

30.7

26

13.5

6

3.1

*Key: VG/G = Very good/Good, P/VP = Poor/Very poor, NN/NA = Not needed/Not applicable

Table D15. Satisfaction with the service received at the Prison Visitors’ Centre or support service: most recent/typical visit (n=194)

Satisfaction rating

N

%

Very satisfied

87

44.8

Satisfied

66

34.0

Neither satisfied nor dissatisfied

29

14.9

Very dissatisfied

7

3.6

Dissatisfied

5

2.6

3.7 Getting support and information

The tables in this section are based on questions that all respondents could answer if they chose to. However, not every respondent answered every question. Where the number of responses is lower than the full survey sample of 198, the table is based on the number of respondents who provided an answer to that question.

Table D16. Reported additional needs when accessing the Prison Visitors’ Centre or support service (n=186)

Additional need

N

%

None / no additional needs

120

64.5

Mental health or wellbeing support

25

13.4

Financial support/advice

19

10.2

A disability or long-term health condition (including mobility needs)

14

7.5

Prefer not to say

12

6.5

Caring responsibilities

7

3.8

Other (please specify)

7

3.8

Support with communication (e.g., hearing/speech/understanding information)

3

1.6

Housing or homelessness support

2

1.1

Information in a different format (e.g., large print, easy read, audio/visual)

2

1.1

Information in a different language

2

1.1

Note: Multiple responses were allowed, so percentages may exceed 100%

Table D17. Whether respondents needed help during visits but did not ask for it (n=191)

Needed help but did not ask

N

%

No

136

71.2

Yes

41

21.5

Not sure

14

7.3

Table D18. Main reasons for not asking for help (n=40)

Reason for not asking for help

N

%

Did not feel comfortable asking

15

37.5

Worried about consequences

11

27.5

Did not know help was available

9

22.5

Did not think it would help

7

17.5

Did not have time

6

15.0

Other (please specify)

6

15.0

Prefer not to say

1

2.5

Note: This table is based only on respondents who said there had been times during visits when they needed help but did not ask for it. Multiple responses were allowed, so percentages may exceed 100%.

Table D19. How the Prison Visitors’ Centre or support service has helped (n=variable)

Area of support

*AL/QL N

AL/QL%

SW N

SW%

AL/NA N

AL/NA %

NA N

NA %

Access information (n=190)

89

46.8

27

14.2

43

22.6

31

16.3

Deal with problems caused by imprisonment for person in prison (n=187)

58

31.0

27

14.4

56

29.9

46

24.6

Deal with problems caused by imprisonment for you or other family members (n=186)

53

28.5

28

15.1

53

28.5

52

28.0

Feel better about visiting (n=187)

101

54.0

18

9.6

41

21.9

27

14.4

Feel less judged or stigmatised (n=188)

96

51.1

15

8.0

45

23.9

32

17.0

Keep in contact with the person in prison (n=187)

73

39.0

25

13.4

44

23.5

45

24.1

Help any children maintain relationship with parent in prison (n=186)

39

21.0

9

4.8

27

14.5

111

59.7

Help any children maintain relationship with other family in prison (n=187)

36

19.3

8

4.3

26

13.9

117

62.6

*Key: AL/QL = A lot/Quite a lot, SW = Somewhat, Al/NA = A little/Not at all, NA = Not applicable

Table D20. Challenges in accessing help or support (n=185)

Challenge reported

N

%

None (I’ve been able to get the help I need)

82

44.3

I haven't needed any help or support

35

18.9

Didn’t know what help was available / hard to find information

26

14.1

Cost (e.g., travel, phone/data, other costs)

20

10.8

Wasn’t offered support (or wasn’t sure how to ask for it)

17

9.2

Not enough time (e.g., before/after visits)

15

8.1

Transport/travelling made it difficult

12

6.5

Other (please give brief details)

12

6.5

Support isn’t available when I need it (e.g., opening times don’t fit)

10

5.4

Prefer not to say

6

3.2

The support available isn’t what I need

6

3.2

Waited too long / hard to get an appointment

5

2.7

Note: Multiple responses were allowed, so percentages may exceed 100%

Table D21. Access to services whilst visiting (n=190)

Service accessed

N

%

Toilets

158

83.2

Food or drink

157

82.6

Somewhere to wait

108

56.8

Information about prison visiting and prison issues

94

49.5

Information about wider needs/issues

41

21.6

Somewhere for children to play

41

21.6

One-to-one support

35

18.4

Referrals to partners or other services

32

16.8

Children’s visits

31

16.3

Wider activities e.g. family days or Christmas parties

20

10.5

Other (please give brief details)

2

1.1

Note: Multiple responses were allowed, so percentages may exceed 100%

Table D22. Services visitors would like to access but have not been able to support (n=87)

Service visitors wanted to access

N

%

Other (please give brief details)

25

28.7

Information about prison visiting and prison issues

24

27.6

Information about wider needs/issues

20

23

One-to-one support

19

21.8

Referrals to partners or other services

18

20.7

Wider activities e.g. family days or Christmas parties

15

17.2

Food or drink

12

13.8

Children’s visits

8

9.2

Somewhere to wait

3

3.4

Toilets

3

3.4

Somewhere for children to play

2

2.3

Note: Multiple responses were allowed, so percentages may exceed 100%

Table D23. Information and referrals to other support services (n=189)

Information/referral received

N

%

Neither of these

82

43.4

I have been given information about other services

76

40.2

Not sure

21

11.1

I have been referred to another service for support

14

7.4

Note: Multiple responses were allowed, so percentages may exceed 100%

3.8 Overall experience of visiting

The tables in this section are based on questions that all respondents could answer if they chose to. However, not every respondent answered every question. Where the number of responses is lower than the full survey sample of 198, the table is based on the number of respondents who provided an answer to that question.

Table D24. Overall satisfaction with Prison Visitor’s Centre or support service (n=192)

Level of satisfaction

N

%

Very satisfied

68

35.4

Satisfied

76

39.6

Neither satisfied nor dissatisfied

32

16.7

Dissatisfied

7

3.6

Very dissatisfied

9

4.7

Contact

Email: justice_analysts@gov.scot

Back to top