Prison visitor centres and support services review: main report
This report presents the first full independent review of Scottish Government-funded Prison Visitors' Centres (PVCs) and support services in Scotland.
Chapter 4: Perspectives of family members
- Family members generally valued PVCs as places to pause, prepare and access support before and after prison visits.
- Three quarters of survey respondents (75%, n=144) were satisfied or very satisfied with the services provided by PVCs and support services.
- Visiting was emotionally and practically demanding, whilst PVCs were commonly experienced as calmer and less formal than other parts of the prison visit.
- The approach and availability of PVC staff shaped how welcomed, informed and supported families felt.
- Child-friendly support helped families manage visits with children, although the wider visit environment and arrangements were not always suited to different ages and needs.
Introduction
This chapter presents the perspectives of family members (n=22) visiting a loved one in prison. The evidence was collected through 17 semi-structured individual and group interviews involving 22 family members and an online survey completed by 198 family members and other visitors.
The chapter reports on the following six main themes:
- visiting frequency and travel circumstances vary considerably;
- PVCs can make visiting feel calmer, but the physical environment matters;
- PVCs provide reassurance, preparation and connection;
- families experience the different stages and spaces of the visit in different ways;
- staff approach shapes how supported families feel; and
- child-friendly support helps make visits more manageable for families with children.
Further supporting quotations and lower-frequency findings are provided in the Part 2 Supporting Evidence report at Appendix F. Unless otherwise stated, numerical findings in this chapter are drawn from the family member survey. Full survey tables are provided in the Part 2 Supporting Evidence report at Appendix D.
Overview of family member perspectives
Family members described prison visiting as important but often emotionally and practically demanding. Visits could require careful planning around travel, cost, work, caring responsibilities, booking arrangements and the needs of children. Several interviewees described the wider effects of imprisonment and visiting as making them feel that they too were serving a sentence.
PVCs were generally valued as places where families could wait, prepare and access information or support. Travel, booking systems, security, communication, visit-room conditions and staff interactions also shaped families’ experiences. Interviewees therefore distinguished the support provided by PVCs from difficulties arising elsewhere in the visitor journey that PVC staff could not directly control.
Visiting frequency and travel experiences when visiting vary significantly
‘I can’t afford it, but it’s never stopped me.’[JD03FM-F]
Family members described a wide range of visiting circumstances. Most survey respondents were visiting partners (42%, n=83), whilst others were visiting adult children (29%, n=56), siblings (11%, n=21), other relatives or close friends. Interviewees included people with recent experience of visiting and others who had visited regularly over several years, sometimes across more than one prison and with experience of establishments both with and without a PVC or support service.
Interviewees described visiting from monthly to several times per week. Weekly visits were most common in the survey, reported by 42% of respondents (n=82). Some said they rarely missed a visit, whilst others described cancellations, booking problems, changes in arrangements or personal circumstances interrupting attendance. Open-text survey responses also described frustration when visits began late or felt too short after the time and effort required to attend.
Most interviewees travelled by car, whilst others relied on public transport. Some did not identify travel time or cost as a major concern, particularly where they lived nearby or could drive. Others described lengthy, complex or expensive journeys. Survey respondents highlighted gaps in travel support for groups such as students and pensioners and the frustration of travelling for several hours only to find that a visit had been cancelled.
PVCs can make visiting feel calmer, but the physical environment matters
‘You just get that warm… homely feeling when you come in.’ [CJ08FM-F]
Family members commonly described PVCs as calmer and less formal than other parts of the prison environment. Interviewees referred to clean and comfortable spaces where they could settle before a visit. Comfortable seating, plants, televisions, newspapers and activities for children helped some centres feel welcoming and safe.
Interviewees also described limitations in the physical environment. Some PVCs felt cramped or restrictive when several families were present, whilst others had uncomfortable seating, inadequate cleanliness or waiting areas in poor condition. Open-text survey responses referred to toilets that were not always clean or in working order and to a lack of suitable outdoor space.
Clear information, guidance and signposting were valued where they helped families understand what to expect, deal with a problem or identify further support. Some interviewees nevertheless reported gaps in information, particularly before a first visit. They suggested that clear prison-specific information should be available before families travelled rather than relying on questions being answered only after arrival.
PVCs are a source of reassurance, preparation, and connection
‘It gives you somewhere to sit and I suppose prepare yourself.’ [KG03FM-M]
‘We’ve all formed a good friendship.’ [CJ08FM-F]
Family members described PVCs as providing emotional as well as practical support. More than half of survey respondents rated feeling welcomed and respected by the PVC or support service as very good (54%, n=102), with a further 21% (n=40) rating it good and 16% (n=30) rating it okay. Interviewees particularly valued this support when visiting was unfamiliar, emotionally difficult or involved a first visit.
Interviewees described arriving early to gather themselves, have a hot drink and speak with staff they had come to know. These interactions could provide reassurance before the visit and somewhere to talk afterwards. Support was often described as informal, but its familiarity and accessibility were central to how families experienced it.
Informal peer relationships also developed through repeated use of PVCs. Interviewees described exchanging information and emotional support with other visitors, sometimes maintaining contact outside the prison setting. Some survey respondents reported relying heavily on other visitors for practical information about the prison.
Several interviewees felt that visiting would be more daunting or difficult without a PVC. They believed families would have fewer opportunities to prepare, ask questions, receive reassurance or obtain support when something went wrong.
Families experience the stages and spaces of the visit differently
‘The visiting centre is much more…relaxing than it is inside!’ [SM01FM-F]
Family members described visiting as a sequence of different spaces and processes. Depending on the establishment, this could involve arriving at or passing through the PVC, checking in, waiting, moving through security, entering the visit room and leaving the prison afterwards. Interviewees’ accounts showed that each stage could influence how they felt when the visit began.
PVCs were commonly described as a supportive part of this process, whether families used them routinely or simply valued knowing that help was available. Experiences of security were more mixed. Interviewees generally accepted the need for security, and some described the process as quiet or straightforward. Others experienced it as intense or uncomfortable, particularly where communication felt abrupt, scrutiny felt excessive or the process was difficult for children to understand. A small number felt that security should be more stringent.
Privacy within visit rooms also varied. One survey respondent felt prison staff observed without listening, whilst an interviewee described staff sitting close enough to hear conversations. Others described rooms as noisy enough for visitors to overhear one another. One interviewee contrasted feeling safe and looked after in the PVC with feeling less comfortable once inside the visit room.
Some interviewees described visit rooms as calm, adequate or spacious, whilst others found them uncomfortable, colourless or poorly regulated in temperature. Refreshments were an important part of these accounts. Vending machines in visit rooms were often described as expensive, unreliable, limited in choice or slow to use. Interviewees valued being able to buy food for the person they were visiting and described sharing food as one way of potentially making contact feel more ordinary.
Staff approach shapes how supported families feel
‘The most important thing is probably the people staffing it.’ [RF01FM-MF]
‘Due to the kindness from the visitor centre we feel relaxed at visiting the prison.’ [Survey respondent 87]
Family members described PVC staff as central to how supported they felt. Interviewees commonly characterised staff as friendly, approachable and able to put people at ease. They described staff speaking with visitors, responding to distress, sharing information and signposting to other services. Open-text survey responses also highlighted knowledgeable and non-judgemental support.
Interviewees valued having staff available before visits, but some described difficulties obtaining help when PVCs were unstaffed, particularly at weekends. The physical availability of a centre did not provide the same support where no worker was present to answer questions or respond to emerging needs.
Experiences of prison staff were more mixed. Some interviewees described helpful, respectful and friendly interactions, whilst others felt uncomfortable or judged. They also reported variation in how rules were applied, how information was communicated and how concerns were handled. Some recognised that prison staff worked within a demanding environment and that wider pressures could affect these interactions.
Interviewees also described disruption, changes or cancellations without adequate notice, with some learning of changes only after travelling to the prison. Others found it difficult to contact staff outside visiting times. These communication gaps were reported as adding uncertainty and stress, particularly where families had already invested substantial time and money in attending.
Child-friendly support helps make visits more manageable for families with children
‘A good variety of toys, books and colouring content... which all adds to the good, calm and welcoming environment for visits.’ [Survey respondent 93]
Family members visiting with children described the prison environment as sometimes difficult for children to understand. Almost one third of survey respondents visited with children (30%, n=59), and six interviewees had current or previous experience of doing so. Interviewees described child-friendly spaces, activities and positive engagement from PVC and prison staff as helping children feel calmer before entering the visit.
Interviewees distinguished normal social visits from child-focused visits, including visits locally described as PLC, bonding, family or children’s visits. Child-focused visits were valued because they allowed the person in custody to move around, play and interact more directly with children. Normal visits could be more difficult where children did not understand why the person they were visiting had to remain seated or why movement and physical contact were restricted.
Suggestions included longer, more frequent or more flexible child-focused visits, particularly for families travelling long distances. Some interviewees considered 45 minutes too short for children to settle and spend meaningful time with the person they were visiting.
The survey and interviews included children across a wide age range, including younger children and teenagers. Interviewees described younger children benefiting from toys and play spaces, whilst older children were more likely to ask questions about the prison and visit process. Some families said these considerations influenced whether they brought children to the prison or used virtual contact instead.
Interviewees also described neurodivergent children and children experiencing anxiety finding the setting difficult. Sensory resources were available in some establishments but not others. Suggestions included more support for additional needs, age-appropriate resources for older children, toys and activities within visit rooms, and clearer information about what children should expect.
Family member interviewees described practical and emotional pressures associated with bringing children, including school timings, searches, waiting and restrictions on access to child-focused visits. Open-text survey responses added examples of children becoming restless during delays, visit times changing at short notice and long journeys feeling disproportionate to short visits. Across these accounts, child-friendly support was valued primarily for making visits more understandable, age-appropriate and manageable.
Contact
Email: justice_analysts@gov.scot