Prison visitor centres and support services review: main report

This report presents the first full independent review of Scottish Government-funded Prison Visitors' Centres (PVCs) and support services in Scotland.


Chapter 3: Evaluation Theory of Change and logic model for Prison Visitors’ Centres (WP2)

Introduction

Consistent with the Review’s CA approach, a ToC and LM short-life working group was convened to discuss and refine the pre-existing PVC programme LM (developed through support from Evaluation Support Scotland in 2025) into an evaluation LM. By integrating this as WP2 the Review was grounded in the agreed logic of how PVC services are intended to work. The updated evaluation LM guided fieldwork and analysis and served as a tool for participants to reflect on whether their experiences aligned with expected outcomes. It also provided a framework for interpreting findings and informing the final ‘performance story’ of PVCs.

Full details of the ToC considerations and a copy of the fully developed LM are provided in the Part 2 Supporting Evidence report at Appendix C.

Theory of Change

The ToC and evaluation LM should set out how PVCs are expected to contribute to change, what assumptions need to hold, what evidence is needed, and what alternative explanations must be considered. It should not assume that PVCs alone facilitate long-term changes for families, children, people in custody, or prison systems. Instead, it should provide a structured way to assess whether PVCs make a plausible, important, and evidence-supported contribution to reported changes, whilst recognising the influence of wider prison, family, community, and policy factors.

Following discussions with the Project Advisory Group and the short-life working group, the PVC ToC was agreed and depicted as shown below.

PVC Evaluation Theory of Change

  • IF → (1) independent, third-sector PVCs and support services offer a welcoming soft landing around prison visits, (2) provide timely information, advice, and advocacy, and (3) connect families to wider support;
  • THEN → (1) visitors, including children and young people, are more likely to be able to navigate prison visiting processes through a more welcoming and less anxious environment; (2) constructive family contact is easier to sustain where it is wanted, safe, and appropriate; and (3) people in custody and prison staff will benefit from improved relationships with visitors.
  • OVER TIME THIS MAY CONTRIBUTE TO → (1) improved wellbeing for some children, families, and people in custody, (2) reducing some harms associated with imprisonment, and (3) making a small indirect contribution to safer reintegration, children’s rights, health and justice, poverty reduction, reduced reoffending, and social inclusion.

The refined ToC rests on three linked functions of PVCs.

1. PVCs may provide a welcoming, non-stigmatising “soft landing” around prison visits. A calm and respectful welcome can help reduce immediate stress, particularly for first-time visitors, children and young people, and families who have had previous negative experiences of prison systems. Where the PVC is not the first point of contact, this role is more about reassurance, orientation, and practical guidance.

2. PVCs help families understand prison visiting. They provide information and advice around visiting arrangements, security processes, property rules, and support routes. They can also help visitors raise concerns or resolve practical barriers where prison processes or communication are unclear.

3. PVCs connect families to wider support. Families affected by imprisonment may face practical, emotional, financial, relational, and safeguarding needs that go beyond the visit itself. PVCs cannot meet all of these needs directly, but they may help families identify relevant sources of support and, where appropriate, connect them to relevant services.

The ToC proposes that if these functions are delivered well, visitors are more likely to be able to navigate prison visiting processes through a more comfortable environment. Constructive family contact may be easier to sustain where it is wanted, safe, and appropriate. People in custody and prison staff may also benefit from improved relationships with visitors, particularly where better information, preparation, and communication reduce avoidable tension.

The ToC indicates that PVCs may contribute to improved wellbeing for visitors and people in custody, and reduce harms associated with imprisonment. Their contribution to wider outcomes such as safer reintegration, children’s rights, health and justice, and poverty reduction, may be small and indirect.

Key causal pathways

The evaluation LM identifies several connected pathways through which PVCs may contribute to change.

A welcoming and emotionally safe “soft landing” may reduce immediate stress and help visitors understand what will happen. This can make visitors feel more settled, less intimidated, and more able to engage with the visit and with support.

Information, advice, and practical guidance form a second pathway, helping to reduce uncertainty and prevent avoidable problems. This supports visitors to understand what to expect before, during, and after the visit, and to navigate PVC and prison systems, processes, and rules.

Advocacy and problem-solving provide a third pathway. PVC staff may identify issues affecting visitors and, where appropriate, raise or resolve them with prison staff or partners. This can reduce barriers, strengthen visitor voice, and support more responsive prison processes.

Child- and family-sensitive visiting is central. Children and families may need preparation and support that is sensitive to age, rights, trauma, stigma, and family circumstance. This includes features such as child-friendly spaces, activities, changing facilities, and refreshments, as well as age-appropriate information. This pathway recognises that family contact should be supported where appropriate, and that children’s needs and rights require active consideration.

PVCs may also help families access support beyond the visit itself. Where relevant services exist and families are able to access them, they can help families address wider issues that affect visiting and family support. Finally, partnership, learning, and system influence may improve role clarity, consistency, and responsiveness across PVCs, prisons, Families Outside, and Scottish Government.

Conditions that affect contribution

The LM does not assume that PVCs operate in isolation. Their contribution is shaped by wider conditions that may strengthen, weaken, or interrupt the causal pathways.

Sustained funding and clear policy expectations influence staffing, opening hours, facilities, monitoring, and coordination. If expectations grow without matching resource, PVCs may struggle to deliver a consistent core offer.

Prison-level capacity, leadership, and culture are also central. Overcrowding, staff shortages, operational disruption, security pressures, and local gatekeeping can affect access, visiting quality, and the ability of PVC staff to work constructively with prison colleagues. Supportive prison leadership and family-aware practice can therefore strengthen PVC provision.

Provider capacity and role clarity also matter because the quality and consistency of PVC delivery depend heavily on staff skills, training, and organisational support.

Visitor awareness and trust are also essential. Families need to know that the PVC exists and experience the service as independent, safe, and helpful. The physical environment can support or constrain the model, as can logistical and financial barriers, accessibility, and the availability of wider services. The model also depends on a careful understanding of family contact, which should not be assumed to be positive in all circumstances.

Unintended consequences and risks

The LM identified several risks and unintended consequences that the Review was designed to test.

  • Visiting may become an additional burden for some families because of practical, financial, logistical, or emotional pressures.
  • Access and quality may also be uneven because of differences in provider models, physical space and location, staffing, and local relationships.
  • Some parents or carers may worry about the normalisation of imprisonment for children.
  • Children may also experience confusion where rules differ across visit types, for example around physical contact, movement, or play.
  • Family contact may not always be safe or appropriate. Some relationships may involve safeguarding concerns.
  • PVCs may also face increased expectations without sufficient resource, creating risks of staff pressure, unmet demand, and a less clear core role.
  • Monitoring requirements may create burden if they take time away from direct support without producing useful learning.
  • PVCs may face tension between maintaining independence and advocacy whilst relying on constructive prison partnerships, which could constrain how concerns are raised or resolved.
  • A visit-centred model may mainly reach families who already attend prisons or use services, leaving those who do not or cannot visit less visible and less likely to receive support.

Implications for the evaluation

The ToC and evaluation LM provided a framework for the whole Review. Survey questions were designed to test awareness, use, experience, barriers, perceived support, and reported short- or medium-term outcomes. Interviews and focus groups explored mechanisms, assumptions, variation between sites, and unintended consequences. Observations were designed to examine welcome, accessibility, visibility, child-friendliness, physical environment, and practical navigation. PVC provider and prison evidence tested capacity, partnership working, monitoring, role clarity, and issue-resolution. Co-interpretation workshops (WP5) were designed to help test whether the emerging contribution story was plausible and whether alternative explanations had been considered fairly.

Contact

Email: justice_analysts@gov.scot

Back to top