Prison visitor centres and support services review: main report
This report presents the first full independent review of Scottish Government-funded Prison Visitors' Centres (PVCs) and support services in Scotland.
Chapter 8: Perspectives of Families Outside staff
- Families Outside staff described prison visiting as one point of contact within a wider experience of practical, emotional, financial, and relational need associated with imprisonment.
- PVCs were viewed as potential entry points into wider support, although this depended on families encountering visible, trusted, and consistently available staff.
- Local adaptation was considered necessary, but variation became inequitable where access to core information, support, and facilities depended on the establishment being visited.
- Relationships between PVCs, Families Outside, and prisons were uneven. Several interviewees reported few routine referrals from PVCs and uncertainty about organisational roles.
- Funding, governance, and accountability were viewed as limiting national consistency, whilst children’s rights, equality, family voice, and advocacy were recognised in principle but unevenly realised.
Introduction
This chapter presents the perspectives of Families Outside staff who participated in the qualitative fieldwork (n=14). The evidence was collected through seven individual and group interviews. Participants included Senior Managers, Regional Managers, the National PVC Lead, Regional Support Family Coordinators, and the Families Outside Helpline Coordinator.
Families Outside staff contributed experience of direct and community-based family support, helpline provision, work with prisons and PVC providers, and national coordination through the National PVC Lead role. Their accounts therefore addressed both families’ wider needs and the organisation of the PVC system.
The chapter reports on the following six main themes:
Families need support beyond the visit;
- inconsistent local implementation can create unequal family experiences;
- support is more visible and trusted when provision is relational and consistently available;
- wider support depends on clear roles, local partnership and functioning referral pathways;
- funding, governance and accountability constrain national consistency; and
- children’s rights, equality and family voice are recognised but unevenly realised.
Further supporting quotations and lower-frequency findings are provided in the Part 2 Supporting Evidence report at Appendix J.
Overview of Families Outside’s perspective
Families Outside staff described PVCs as potentially important points of contact within a much wider system of family support. Families affected by imprisonment could require help with housing, finances, health, education, transport, caring responsibilities, relationships and emotional wellbeing. These needs could become visible around a prison visit, but they could not necessarily be addressed within the immediate visit setting.
Interviewees described positive local practice where PVC staff were visible, welcoming, trusted and connected to prison and community partners. They did not, however, regard the presence of a PVC space as sufficient in itself. The value of provision depended on whether staff were available, families understood what support was offered and there were functioning routes into further help.
The principal system-level concerns related to consistency, referral pathways, role clarity, funding and accountability. Interviewees distinguished appropriate local adaptation from inequitable variation. They also described few routine referrals from PVCs into Families Outside services, uneven local relationships and uncertainty about how responsibility for wider family support was shared.
Families need support beyond the visit
‘It's not just about the prison experience… It is about housing and health and mental health and prevention … travel and transport... children's engagement in school. It's about, you know, all of these issues that don't fit neatly into one category.’ [APFO01-F]
Families Outside staff described imprisonment as affecting multiple areas of family life. Interviewees referred to housing, income, health, caring responsibilities, children’s education, transport, relationships and emotional wellbeing. These needs did not necessarily begin or end with a prison visit and could require support from several organisations.
PVCs were viewed as possible points at which needs could become visible. Interviewees described the value of workers noticing concerns, having informal conversations and helping families identify an appropriate source of support. The potential contribution of a PVC therefore extended beyond identifying a need. It depended on whether families could make a trusted and workable connection to further help.
Interviewees also emphasised that many families affected by imprisonment did not attend prison visits. Some were unable to visit because of distance, cost, health, caring responsibilities or prison arrangements. Others did not want contact, experienced relationship breakdown, were not wanted at visits by the person in custody or relied on telephone and video contact.
A support model centred on physical attendance at a PVC was therefore described as reaching only part of the wider family population. Interviewees considered community, telephone and home-based support important for families whose circumstances or relationships meant that prison-based contact was not suitable or accessible.
Inconsistent local implementation can create unequal family experiences ‘What you need then… is people who are consistent across the board and the consistency is the thing we're missing… what families need is to know whatever door they walk into, they'll get that same approach.’ [APFO04-F]
‘You know, the consistency of knowing what to expect, knowing what it's going to be like, knowing how they operate, knowing how, you know, what you're going to be met with, what resources are there, who the people are, like none, the consistency there is, well, it's not, it's non-existent.’ [APFO06-F]
Variation across establishments was a prominent concern amongst Families Outside staff. Interviewees described PVC provision as a collection of local arrangements rather than a clearly understood national service. They recognised that establishments differed in population, geography, facilities and local need and that provision should respond to these differences.
Their concern was the point at which local variation became inequitable. Interviewees described families receiving different levels of information, privacy, practical support, child- and family-sensitive provision and access to further help depending on the establishment visited. Families experiencing similar needs could therefore encounter substantially different support.
Interviewees gave examples of warm, proactive and well-connected local provision. They also described settings where support was less visible, facilities were limited or families were unclear about what was available. These differences were associated with physical space, staffing, prison leadership, provider arrangements and local relationships.
Interviewees did not argue that every PVC should operate identically. Their accounts supported a clearly defined core provision that families could expect across establishments, combined with transparent local adaptation to the prison context and family population.
Support is more visible and trusted when provision is relational and consistently available
‘There should be that literally warm welcome as soon as someone comes in the door… the consistency of welcome and then I think knowing that whatever time you visit there will be someone there.’ [APFO04-F]
‘It just breaks that barrier because they don’t have that uniform on. It just makes it a lot less daunting.’ [APFO02-Fa]
Families Outside staff described the way support was offered as central to whether families recognised and engaged with it. Interviewees believed that visible, approachable and non-uniformed staff could provide reassurance and create an opening for support where families felt anxious, judged or uncertain about approaching prison services.
A warm welcome, practical help, refreshments and access to private conversation were described as parts of a dignified and trusted offer. Interviewees considered these ordinary interactions important because families might disclose concerns gradually rather than arrive with a clearly expressed request for help.
Physical space could enable or constrain this work. Comfortable and familiar environments were described positively, whilst the absence of privacy could prevent sensitive conversations. Interviewees nevertheless emphasised that the approach taken within a space was at least as important as the building itself.
Interviewees distinguished the existence of a PVC from the availability of meaningful support. Some described strong local relationships, consistently available workers and a sense of community within the PVC. Others referred to provision that was intermittently staffed, narrowly focused on information or insufficiently visible to families passing through.
The relational potential of PVCs therefore depended on visibility, continuity and staff availability. A physical waiting area did not provide the same function where families had little opportunity to meet, know or trust the people providing support.
Wider support depends on clear roles, local partnership and functioning referral pathways
‘And what you want is some sort of collaborative relationship and not a competitive one. Because a lot of the visitor centres, especially during COVID, started doing outreach because they had the funding and had to be seen to be doing something. And so now it's almost like we're falling over each other trying to support families.’ [APFO01-F]
‘I don't think I can ever remember taking a one-to-one referral from a visitor centre.’ [APFO02-Fa]
Families Outside staff described the intended relationship between PVCs and wider family support as complementary. Interviewees viewed PVCs as able to provide immediate support around visiting, identify emerging needs and gather family feedback. Families Outside could provide helpline, one-to-one and community-based support beyond the prison visit.
In practice, partnership was described as uneven. Interviewees reported positive working relationships with some PVC providers and prison teams, but limited contact or uncertainty in other establishments. Access to PVC spaces, communication between organisations and understanding of respective roles varied locally.
Several interviewees reported receiving few or no routine referrals from PVCs, despite receiving referrals from social work, education, housing and other third-sector organisations. They viewed this as a missed connection because PVC staff encountered families whose wider needs might otherwise remain unidentified or unsupported.
Interviewees also described uncertainty about the boundary between PVC activity and Families Outside support. Some felt that the organisations’ roles were mistakenly understood as interchangeable, whilst others described overlap or competition where providers had extended into outreach and wider family support. This could make it unclear which organisation should respond and how families should move between services.
The strength of local partnership also depended on prison relationships and the availability of dedicated family-facing roles. Some Families Outside staff described strong direct relationships with prisons and FCOs, whilst others had more limited links with the PVC provider. Pathways into wider support could consequently rely on individual relationships rather than a routine and understood process.
Interviewees did not generally attribute weak referral pathways to a lack of commitment amongst individual PVC workers. They located them within a wider system involving multiple providers, different organisational approaches, local prison expectations, unclear boundaries and concerns about duplication. A functioning gateway role therefore required agreed roles, visible referral routes and cooperation between PVCs, Families Outside and prisons.
Funding, governance and accountability constrain national consistency
‘I don't think it is the right model… for me, there's a gold standard and there's, it will do… and I think for many years we've done lots of… discussion with Scottish Government, we've done a lot to try and get that consistency.’ [APFO03-F]
‘I think the Scottish Government funding that we've had has stayed literally at the same amount for 7, 8, 9, 10 years. So, no cost of living uplift even. So, what… covered a significant amount of cost nine years ago, doesn't touch the edges now. So that's a major issue.’ [APFO04-F]
Families Outside staff linked variation in delivery to the funding, commissioning and governance of PVCs. Interviewees questioned whether a coherent national service could be secured through multiple providers with different organisational priorities, capacity, access to additional funding and relationships with prisons.
The National PVC Lead role was described as supporting coordination through shared learning, provider communication, review of reports, mediation and feedback to Scottish Government. Interviewees also noted that the role did not carry direct operational authority over providers. Where expectations were not met, coordination could therefore depend on guidance, influence and escalation rather than direct levers of accountability.
Funding was described as insufficient and fragmented. Interviewees referred to flat core funding, rising delivery costs, competition for charitable funding and the administrative demands of maintaining several funding streams. These pressures were associated with staffing, continuity, opening hours and the range of support providers could sustain.
Views on the preferred provider model were not uniform. Some interviewees believed that a single national provider, or closer integration of PVC provision with wider family support, could improve consistency. Others emphasised the local knowledge, relationships and community connections that different providers could bring.
The shared concern was not support for one particular organisational model. It was whether the current arrangements provided clear expectations, sufficient resources, effective coordination and meaningful accountability for the provision families received.
Children’s rights, equality and family voice are recognised but unevenly realised
‘The differences that are provided for children visiting is something that doesn't sit well with me… I don't like how there is such a huge variation.’ [APFO03-F]
‘That is seen as a privilege and a luxury that they provide, not that families and children have a right to contact a loved one.’ [APFO07-Fb]
Families Outside staff described children’s rights and equality as recognised in policy and within the intentions of many PVC and prison staff. Interviewees also gave examples of positive local work with children and families, including workers who understood the effects of imprisonment and prison visiting on children.
Interviewees nevertheless described substantial variation in children’s experiences between establishments. Differences included the availability and frequency of child-focused visits, suitable spaces and activities, age-appropriate support, privacy and adjustments for children with additional needs. Interviewees viewed this as an equality issue where children in similar circumstances could receive different levels of support according to the establishment visited.
Equality concerns extended beyond children’s provision. Interviewees referred to distance, transport, income, disability, health, caring responsibilities, gender and wider family circumstances as affecting whether people could visit and use PVC support. Women in custody were reported to receive relatively few in-person visits, whilst families who did not visit or visited infrequently were particularly likely to remain outside a prison-based support model.
Family voice, complaints and advocacy were also described as underdeveloped. Interviewees questioned whether families always had safe, visible and trusted routes to raise concerns. Some felt that Families Outside was required to voice issues on families’ behalf because feedback and complaints arrangements did not consistently provide reassurance or demonstrate what action had followed.
Interviewees also identified a potential tension in the position of PVCs. Their independence could make them trusted by families, but their ability to resolve concerns depended on maintaining constructive relationships with prisons. Interviewees were uncertain about how concerns were escalated, whether families received feedback and how far PVCs could challenge prison practice without affecting local partnership.
Contact
Email: justice_analysts@gov.scot