Prison visitor centres and support services review: main report

This report presents the first full independent review of Scottish Government-funded Prison Visitors' Centres (PVCs) and support services in Scotland.


Appendix E. Prison Visitors' Centre Review - Providers Survey (Work Package 3)

1. Introduction

This appendix presents detailed findings from the Providers Survey. It provides supporting tables and summary commentary to accompany the main report. The appendix is organised by survey section so that readers can follow the questionnaire structure and locate specific findings easily. Full tables are included for each question area, with Chapter 6 of the main report presenting the headline findings narrative summary.

Unless otherwise stated, tables are based on all 14 provider responses. Where a question was not answered by all respondents, this is noted below the relevant table.

2. Methods

The Providers Survey gathered information about the Prison Visitors’ Centres and support services delivered across Scotland. It included questions on service provision, staffing, referral and partnership arrangements, support offered to families, perceived strengths and challenges, and views on how services could be improved. The survey also included open-text questions, allowing respondents to provide further detail about their experiences and perspectives.

In total, 14 responses were recorded. Not all questions were answered by all respondents, either because respondents skipped questions or because some items were not applicable to all services.

2.1 Data collection

The survey was hosted on Jisc Online Surveys. It opened on 17 December 2025 and closed on 18 July 2026. Participation was voluntary. A privacy notice informed respondents about the purpose of the survey and how the data would be used in the report and recommendations. Any personal data were deleted, and responses were anonymised prior to reporting.

2.2 Analysis approach and reporting conventions

Survey data were exported from Jisc Online Surveys as a coded CSV file with a corresponding key file. The data were imported into RStudio Desktop for preparation and checking. Variables were reviewed against the questionnaire and key file, labelled, and organised by question type.

Single-choice questions were summarised using frequency counts and percentages. Multiple-response questions were summarised by the number and proportion of respondents selecting each option. Grid questions were summarised across response categories for each item. Open-text responses were reviewed separately and are summarised thematically where relevant.

Tables are presented using counts and percentages. Unless noted below the table, percentages are based on all 14 respondents. Where one or more respondents did not answer a question, the base is noted below the relevant table. Percentages may not always sum to 100 due to rounding, and for multiple-response questions percentages may total more than 100 because respondents could select more than one answer.

2.3 Notes on interpretation and limitations

Findings should be interpreted with caution due to the small number of responses. The results provide useful insight into provider perspectives but should not be read as statistically representative. As with all voluntary surveys, the findings reflect the views of those who chose to take part.

3. Survey findings

This section presents the detailed survey findings, organised by topic. It includes summary tables for each question and accompanying notes where relevant.

3.1 Service profile and delivery context

Table E1. Prison supported by the service

Prison

N

%

HMP Addiewell

1

100

HMP Barlinnie

1

100

HMP Dumfries

1

100

HMP Edinburgh

1

100

HMP & YOI Grampian

1

100

HMP Glenochil

1

100

HMP Greenock

1

100

HMP Inverness

1

100

HMP Kilmarnock

1

100

HMP Low Moss

1

100

HMP Perth

1

100

HMP HMP & YOI Polmont

1

100

HMP Shotts

1

100

HMP & YOI Stirling

1

100

Table E2. Service location in relation to the prison

Prison

N

%

At the prison, before security

6

42.9

At the prison, after security

8

57.1

Offsite

0

0.0

Somewhere else

0

0.0

Table E3. Services offered

Prison

N

%

Information about prison visiting and prison issues

14

100

Information about wider needs/issues

14

100

Referrals to partner organisations

14

100

Toilets

14

100

Helpline or telephone enquiries

13

92.9

One-to-one support

13

92.9

Somewhere to wait

13

92.9

Children’s visits

12

85.7

Space to play

12

85.7

Digital supports

11

78.6

Wider activities

11

78.6

Food or drink

10

71.4

Other

5

35.7

Note: Multiple responses were allowed, so percentages may exceed 100%

Table E4. Accessibility features available

Prison

N

%

Accessible toilets

14

100

Easy-read materials

13

92.9

Step-free access

9

64.3

Large print materials

6

42.9

Hearing loop

4

28.6

Information in multiple languages

4

28.6

Other

2

14.3

Note: Multiple responses were allowed, so percentages may exceed 100%

3.2 Staffing, training, and support

Table E5. Number of staff and volunteers reported by services (n = variable)

Staffing arrangement

Total

Range

Median

Mean

Full time (N=13)

17

0-6

1

1.3

Part time (N=14)

38

1-6

3

2.7

Part time (under 16 hours) (N=14)

18

0-4

1

1.3

Part time (16-29 hours) (N=14)

19

0-4

1

1.4

Volunteers (N=14)

70

0-15

5.5

5

Table E6. Staff and volunteer training in the last 12 months (n=13)

Training received

N

%

Safeguarding

13

100

Trauma informed practice

10

77

Children's needs or rights

8

62

Equality and inclusion

7

54

SPS processes/Sodexo

7

54

Other (please specify)

5

38

Note: Multiple responses were allowed, so percentages may exceed 100%. One respondent did not answer this question. Percentages are based on the 13 respondents who answered.

Table E7. Access to staff supervision or debriefing

Frequency of supervision/debriefing

N

%

Yes, routinely as planned

9

64.3

Yes, often, but not always as scheduled

4

28.6

Occasionally, sporadic

1

7.1

No

0

0.0

The follow-up question was only applicable to respondents who indicated that staff supervision or debriefing was not routinely or regularly available. One respondent was routed to this question and identified limited staff capacity as the reason.

Table E8. Frequency of turning people away or limiting support due to capacity (n=13)

Frequency of capacity-related limits

N

%

Never

10

76.9

Rarely

1

7.7

Sometimes

2

15.4

Often

0

0.0

Note: One respondent did not answer this question. Percentages are based on the 13 respondents who answered.

3.3 Partnership working with prisons

Table E9. Prison roles routinely worked with

Prison roles worked with

N

%

Family Contact Officers

13

92.9

Prisoner-facing roles

13

92.9

Visits staff

12

85.7

Policy roles

6

42.9

Senior leadership

9

64.3

Other (please specify)

5

35.7

Note: Multiple responses were allowed, so percentages may exceed 100%

Table E10. Working relationships with prison colleagues

Level of working relationship

N

%

Highly collaborative

9

64.3

Collaborative

3

21.4

Somewhat collaborative

2

14.3

Minimally collaborative

0

0.0

Not collaborative at all

0

0.0

Table E11. Whether services record issues raised by families

Consistency of recording family issues

N

%

Yes, routinely

6

42.9

Yes, mostly

6

42.9

Sometimes, informally

2

14.3

No

0

0.0

Not sure

0

0.0

3.4 Funding and sustainability

Table E12. Service funding sources

Funding source

N

%

Scottish Government

14

100

Charitable funding

9

64.3

Other

3

21.4

Scottish Prison Service

2

14.3

Service provider

2

14.3

Local Authority

1

7.1

Note: Multiple responses were allowed, so percentages may exceed 100%

Table E13. Extent to which current funding supports planning and delivery

Funding source

N

%

Not at all

2

14.3

To a small extent

5

35.7

To some extent

2

14.3

To a great extent

2

14.3

Fully

3

21.4

3.5 Management information and data quality

Table E14. Management information routinely collected (n=13)

Types of management information collected

N

%

Number of children visiting

13

100

Number of visitors

13

100

Number of referrals made

12

92.3

Outcomes of direct work

11

84.6

Partnership working arrangements

11

84.6

Outcomes of work to promote children’s rights

8

61.5

Outcomes of work to promote equality and diversity

8

61.5

Whether referred support was taken up

8

61.5

Whether referred support helped

7

53.8

Visitor relationship to person in custody

5

38.5

Other

2

15.4

None

0

0.0

Note: Multiple responses were allowed, so percentages may exceed 100%. One respondent did not answer this question. Percentages are based on the 13 respondents who answered.

All responding services reported that they collect management information. The follow-up question on reasons for not collecting management information was therefore not applicable, and no table is presented.

Table E15. Frequency of analysing MI to improve practice (n=13)

Frequency of information analysis

N

%

Quarterly

10

76.9

Monthly

3

23.1

Never

0

0.0

Occasionally

0

0.0

Note: One respondent did not answer this question. Percentages are based on the 13 respondents who answered.

Table E16. Routine collection of demographic or equality-related information

Frequency of data collection

N

%

All the time

3

21.4

Most of the time

2

14.3

Some of the time

5

35.7

Not at all

4

28.6

Table E17. Reasons for not routinely collecting demographic/equality information

Reason not routinely collected

N

%

Safeguarding/privacy

5

56.6

Not required

4

44.4

Insufficient time

1

11.1

Other

1

11.1

Lack of systems

0

0.0

Note: Five respondents did not answer this question. Percentages are based on the 5 respondents who answered.

Table E18. Ability to provide aggregated management information (n=12)

Ability to provide aggregated information

N

%

Yes

9

75.0

Partially

2

16.7

No

1

8.3

Note: Two respondents did not answer this question. Percentages are based on the 2 respondents who answered.

Table E19. Confidence in accuracy and completeness of nationally submitted data

Ability to provide aggregated information

N

%

Very confident

6

42.9

Fairly confident

7

50.0

Mixed confidence

1

7.1

Low confidence

0

0.0

3.6 Support for children, young people, and families

Table E20. Available child-friendly features

Child-friendly features

N

%

Age-appropriate play materials

13

92.9

Baby change

13

92.9

Breastfeeding space

8

57.1

Information tailored for children and young people

8

57.1

Quiet/sensory area

6

42.9

Other

3

21.4

Table E21. Use of children’s rights resources or frameworks (n=13)

Use of children’s rights resources/frameworks

N

%

Yes

10

76.9

No

3

23.1

Not sure

0

0.0

Note: One respondent did not answer this question. Percentages are based on the 13 respondents who answered.

Table E22. Extent to which feedback is collected from children and young people about their visit experience (N=14)

Extent of feedback collection

N

%

Yes, routinely

7

50.0

Yes, occasionally

5

35.7

No, but we would like to

1

7.1

No, and it is not appropriate/feasible

1

7.1

Table E23. Use of feedback from children and young people (n=12)

Use of feedback collected

N

%

Use it to make improvements to the service

8

66.7

Other

3

25.0

Securely store it for future reference

1

8.3

Disseminate it amongst staff

0

0.0

Nothing

0

0.0

Note: Two respondents did not answer this question. Percentages are based on the 2 respondents who answered.

3.7 Service development priorities and outcomes

Table E24. Priority services and resources if resources were unconstrained

Priority service/resource

N

%

Children’s visits

9

64.3

Information about prison visiting and prison issues

7

50.0

Food or drink

6

42.9

Quiet/sensory area

6

42.9

Accessible toilets

5

35.7

Somewhere to wait

5

35.7

Space to play

4

28.6

Toilets

4

28.6

Note: The table above shows the five highest-ranked priority areas; where responses were tied, all items with the same score have been included.

Table E25. Other service priorities if resources were unconstrained

Priority service/resource

N

%

Age-appropriate materials

3

21.4

Wider activities

3

21.4

Baby change

2

14.3

Digital supports

2

14.3

Helpline or telephone enquiries

2

14.3

Information about wider needs/issues

2

14.3

Information tailored for children and young people

2

14.3

One-to-one support

2

14.3

Referrals to partner organisations

1

7.1

Step-free access

1

7.1

Other

1

7.1

Breastfeeding space

0

0.0

Easy-read materials

0

0.0

Hearing loop

0

0.0

Large print materials

0

0.0

Note: The table above shows the remaining response options, including those selected less frequently or not selected by any services.

Table E26. Perceived achievement of visiting-related outcomes

Visiting-related outcome

NA/PA

N

NA/PA

%

SA

N

SA

%

MA/FA

N

MA/FA

%

Families have easier access to information

0

0.0

0

0.0

14

100

Improved visiting experiences

0

0.0

0

0.0

14

100

Relationships are improved between families and prison

0

0.0

5

35.7

9

64.3

*Key: NA/PA = Not achieved/Partially achieved, SA = Somewhat acheived, MA/FA = Mostly achieved/Fully achieved

Table E27. Perceived achievement of outcomes for families

Achievement-related outcome

NA/PA

N

NA/PA

%

SA

N

SA

%

MA/FA

N

MA/FA

%

Better quality contact with the person in prison

3

21.4

3

21.4

8

57.1

Children and young people have improved contact with a parent in prison

3

21.4

2

14.3

9

64.3

Children and young people have improved contact with other family members in prison

3

21.4

3

21.4

8

57.1

Families have easier access to practical supports

0

0.0

1

7.1

13

92.2

Relationships are improved within the family

1

1.7

6

42.9

7

50.0

*Key: NA/PA = Not achieved/Partially achieved, SA = Somewhat acheived, MA/FA = Mostly achieved/Fully achieved

Table E28. Basis for assessing mostly or fully achieved outcomes

Basis for assessment

N

%

Partly tracked, partly judgement

7

50.0

Mainly judgement/experience

3

21.4

I did not answer 'Mostly' or 'Fully achieved' to any outcome

3

21.4

Tracked using routine data/tools

1

7.1

Not sure

0

0.0

Table E29. Challenges encountered in delivering this work

Delivery challenge

N

%

Capacity (staffing)

13

92.9

Capacity (financial resource)

9

64.3

Securing funding

6

42.9

The severity of issues facing families

6

42.9

Working with the SPS/Sodexo

5

35.7

The severity of issues facing children

3

21.4

Working with other partners

3

21.4

Other

2

14.3

None of the above

0

0.0

Note: Multiple responses were allowed, so percentages may exceed 100%

Contact

Email: justice_analysts@gov.scot

Back to top