Prison visitor centres and support services review: main report

This report presents the first full independent review of Scottish Government-funded Prison Visitors' Centres (PVCs) and support services in Scotland.


Chapter 2: Rapid evidence and management information synthesis (WP1)

  • Overall, WP1 shows that PVCs perform a recognisable set of functions, adapted to local context, and that these functions align strongly with the national PVC logic model and performance framework.
  • The analysis identifies common activity types whilst recognising that not every service delivers or records activity in the same way.
  • The evidence base is strongest for activity, reach, and immediate experience.
  • The evidence base is weaker for sustained outcomes, child voice, contact quality, equity, referral follow-through, and system change. These are evidence and measurement gaps, rather than indicators of poor delivery.
  • For the wider Review, the implication was practical: retain the existing PVC logic, recognise local variation, and strengthen the evidence base through a small number of targeted measures and qualitative approaches rather than a large new monitoring burden.

Introduction

WP1 synthesised existing monitoring information and policy material on PVCs. Its purpose was to establish what PVCs do, how current evidence links activity to intended outcomes, and where the evidence base is strong, partial, or limited.

WP1 was not an impact evaluation. It assessed the current evidence base and identified what can and cannot currently be concluded from available documentation. Detailed evidence registers, coding decisions, and audit material are retained in the Part 2 Supporting Evidence report at Appendix B.

What PVCs do

The WP1 evidence map identified seven broad activity types across the PVC network. These align closely with the National Performance Framework for Prison Visitors’ Centres in Scotland, particularly its focus on improving visits, providing independent information and support, representing families’ needs, and maintaining informed practice.

Table 3. WP1 activity taxonomy for PVCs

Activity type

What this includes

Example

Welcome & first contact

Reception, orientation, reassurance, emotional support and practical guidance for visitors.

Helping first-time visitors understand arrival, security and visit processes.

Child-focused support

Play provision, child-friendly environments, preparation for visits and safeguarding-aware practice.

Activity packs, play spaces or supported bonding visits.

Practical support & signposting

Advice and practical help on travel, benefits, housing, finance, childcare, health and wider support.

The Assisted Prison Visits Unit (APVU) travel support, foodbank information or referral to community services.

Family contact facilitation

Activities that enable or improve contact between people in prison and families.

Resolving barriers to visits or explaining contact arrangements.

Voice & advocacy

Helping families raise concerns, give feedback or resolve issues with prison systems.

Comments, processes, forums or informal escalation through staff.

Partnerships & coordination

Joint working with SPS, Family Contact Officers, statutory services and third-sector partners.

Coordinating with prison staff, NHS or family support organisations.

Digital inclusion

Support to access digital information, services or communication routes.

Help with online information or digital contact routes.

This taxonomy provides a consistent way to compare different PVC models, including physical PVCs and support-service arrangements.

Evidence coverage across activities and outcomes

The evidence map summarises how strongly existing materials link PVC activities to intended outcome domains. A “low” rating means the link is weakly documented or inconsistently measured, not that activity is absent or ineffective.

The five outcome domains used were:

  • Visitor experience: visitors feel welcomed, safe, informed, less stressed and more confident.
  • Child wellbeing: children feel safer, supported and better able to experience visits positively.
  • Family relationships: contact is more positive, consistent or relationship supporting.
  • Access to services: families are more aware of and able to access practical, emotional or community support.
  • System navigation: families better understand and engage with prison systems and sources of help.
Table 4. Evidence coverage heatmap

Outcome domain →

Activity type ↓

Visitor experience

Child wellbeing

Family relationships

Access to services

System navigation

Welcome & first contact

High

Low

Medium

Low

Medium

Child-focused support

Medium

High

Medium

Low

Low

Practical support & signposting

Medium

Medium

Low

High

Medium

Family contact facilitation

High

Medium

High

Medium

Medium

Voice & advocacy

Medium

Low

Low

Low

High

Partnerships & coordination

Low

Low

Medium

Medium

Medium

Digital inclusion

Low

Low

Low

Medium

Low

Evidence strength key:High = repeated and consistent evidence across multiple documents, settings or evidence types. Medium = evidence exists, but is partial, uneven, narrative-heavy or not supported by shared indicators. Low = evidence is limited, descriptive, site-specific or not routinely measured.

Evidence is strongest for outcomes closest to direct PVC provision, including welcome, practical support, information, and visitor experience. Evidence is weaker where outcomes require follow-up, standardised definitions or system-level data, such as child wellbeing, contact quality, equity, and system change.

Evidence capture and gaps

How evidence is currently produced

Existing evidence comes from funding applications, interim and end-of-year reports, national monitoring returns, local management information, visitor feedback, case examples and strategy/guidance material. These sources provide a useful account of delivery, but vary in how they define outcomes, count reach and record change. Applications and guidance documents are useful for identifying intended activities and outcomes, but they do not evidence achievement. Interim and end-of-year reports often provide delivery evidence and examples, but outcome indicators are uneven. National MI provides output and interaction data, but it is partial and commonly interaction-based rather than person-based. It can show scale and activity but does not provide a national dataset for unique reach, outcomes or impact.

Evidence gaps

The gaps below are limitations in the evidence base, not judgements that PVC activity is absent or ineffective. They matter because they constrain what can be concluded and what later WPs need to test.

Table 5. WP1 evidence gaps and issues for later testing

Rank

Evidence gap

Why it matters

What later work packages were able to test

1

No standardised outcome measures

Limits comparison across establishments and prevents robust conclusions about which activities are associated with which outcomes.

Whether stakeholders shared a common understanding of core outcomes, and whether simple outcome indicators could be tested through surveys and qualitative fieldwork.

2

Unclear counting rules for reach

Limits statements about who is reached, how often, and whether support is concentrated or distributed.

How providers currently define and record reach, including unique visitors, repeat visits, family groups, contacts and interactions.

3

Child voice and child outcomes underdeveloped

Weakens confidence in claims about children’s experience and wellbeing beyond descriptive accounts.

How child-focused support is delivered in practice, and what proportionate or safeguarded ways of understanding child experience may be feasible.

4

Limited demographic/ equity analysis

Limits assessment of whether provision is equitable or meets different needs.

Whether families experience different barriers to access, and whether providers collect or could collect minimal equality/needs information safely.

5

Baselines and comparators often missing

Limits ability to describe change over time or distinguish service effects from wider context.

What baseline information exists across sites, and how changes in context, staffing, regime or delivery model shape interpretation.

6

Contact quality not operationalised

Visit counts do not show whether contact felt positive, manageable or relationship-supporting.

How families, staff and people in custody understand good-quality contact, and whether simple survey questions can capture this meaningfully.

7

Referral take-up not tracked

Shows signposting/referrals were made, but not whether families accessed support or benefited.

Whether families act on signposting or referrals, what helps or prevents take-up, and how providers understand follow-up.

8

Service expectations not consistently evidenced

Makes it unclear what “expected service” means across sites and models.

How expectations are understood by providers, SPS staff and stakeholders, and how service models vary across establishments.

9

Voice to system change trail unclear

Limits claims about whether family feedback leads to operational change.

Whether issues raised by families are escalated, acted on and recorded, and how visible this is to families, providers and SPS.

10

Transition/mobilisation impacts not measured

Limits understanding of continuity and family experience during provider or model change.

Whether provider or model changes affected awareness, access, trust, continuity or experience, and how these changes were managed locally.

These gaps affect how confidently the review can interpret several areas of evidence. Without shared counting rules, interaction totals cannot safely be treated as unique reach. Without contact-quality measures, family contact facilitation can be described, and counted, but not linked consistently to relationship outcomes. Without referral follow-up, signposting can be counted but not connected to whether families accessed or benefited from support. These limitations reflect a wider challenge across justice and linked services, where outcomes emerge through interactions between families, practitioners, services and prison processes, making the contribution of any single contact or intervention difficult to isolate through routine data.

Cross-establishment findings

WP1 shows a recognisable national model with significant local variation. PVCs tend to welcome visitors, provide information and practical support, facilitate contact, support children, represent family voice, and work in partnership with the prison. However, the balance of these functions differs by establishment (prison) and delivery model (who is providing the service).

Some PVCs appear to operate mainly as welcome and information points, whilst others provide more intensive support. Some are located before security, others after security or within support-service models. These differences can affect the visiting experience as well as what data can realistically be collected.

WP1 can say confidently that PVCs provide a recognisable family-support offer, with documents that commonly claim PVCs improve the visiting experience. The limitation is that tracked outcomes are strongest for outputs and immediate experience, whilst longer-term outcomes are often inferred rather than measured.

Overall, the evidence library is sufficient for a credible baseline and gap analysis. It is not sufficient to assess or compare delivery models or attribute longer-term change to PVCs alone.

How WP1 informed the wider review

WP1 provided a baseline for interpreting the wider review. It clarified where existing evidence was strong enough to support description, and where later work packages needed to add detail, explanation, and stakeholder interpretation. The activity taxonomy and outcome domains provided a shared structure for WP2 theory refinement. The evidence gaps shaped WP3 survey content and WP4 case study prompts. WP5 will provide the point at which these WP1 evidence gaps are interpreted alongside survey findings, qualitative evidence, observation, and stakeholder judgement, before any final recommendations are made.

Contact

Email: justice_analysts@gov.scot

Back to top