Prison visitor centres and support services review: main report
This report presents the first full independent review of Scottish Government-funded Prison Visitors' Centres (PVCs) and support services in Scotland.
Chapter 11: Recommendations
The Review supports the value of Prison Visitors' Centres (PVCs) and support services, particularly their contribution to making prison visiting more welcoming, understandable and manageable. It also shows that this contribution depends on the wider infrastructure within which PVCs operate. Funding, commissioning, governance, prison leadership, staffing, physical facilities, information flows, referral pathways, and local relationships all influence what PVCs can achieve.
Given these systemic complexities, the recommendations are presented in two groupings. First, seven high-level recommendations identify the principal actions required from named organisations. Second, 30 outcome-based recommendations describe the preferred future for PVCs, prison visiting, and wider family support.
Central to the recommendations is the development of national minimum quality standards for prison visiting, PVCs, and support services. These standards should establish the minimum provision that every family can expect, whilst allowing purposeful local adaptation above that level. They should represent a floor rather than a ceiling and should cover both the independent PVC or support-service offer and the elements of prison visiting for which SPS is responsible.
High-level key recommendations
Key recommendation 1: Scottish Government and SPS should jointly lead the development, agreement, implementation, and monitoring of national minimum quality standards for prison visiting, PVCs, and support services.
The standards should be developed with Families Outside, including the National PVC Lead, PVC providers, the private prison operator and other contracted partners where relevant, families, people with lived experience of imprisonment, and appropriate national and local partners.
They should clearly distinguish the responsibilities of PVC and support-service providers from those of SPS and prison establishments. At a minimum, they should cover:
- visible and welcoming independent support;
- staffing during agreed core visiting periods;
- accurate and accessible information;
- practical guidance and navigation;
- waiting facilities, toilets, privacy, and confidential space;
- child- and family-sensitive provision;
- support for teenagers, neurodivergent people, and people with additional or sensory needs;
- equality, accessibility, and inclusion;
- safeguarding;
- visitor voice, advocacy, complaints, and escalation;
- referral and warm-handover arrangements;
- workforce skills, training, supervision, and support;
- dedicated family-facing prison capacity, including Family Contact Officers;
- prison/PVC partnership arrangements;
- visiting environments, refreshments, and communication about changes or cancellations; and
- proportionate monitoring, quality assurance, and shared learning.
The standards should be clearly specified, monitored, and subject to defined accountability and service-improvement arrangements. Local services should be able to exceed or adapt the standards in response to population, geography, estate, and family need.
Key recommendation 2: Scottish Government should undertake a formal review and options appraisal of the future PVC commissioning and provider model.
The appraisal should inform the next substantive funding and commissioning arrangements and should explicitly assess:
- whether the current number of providers should be reduced;
- value for money, including duplicated management and administrative overheads;
- national, regional, multi-site, and single-provider options;
- the balance between national consistency and local responsiveness;
- provider capability and specialist family-support expertise;
- continuity of trusted local relationships;
- independence from SPS;
- the relationship between PVC provision and wider family support;
- performance-management and quality-assurance arrangements;
- transition and mobilisation risks; and
- how justified local adaptation can be retained within a more coherent national system.
The appraisal should not assume that one particular provider configuration is necessarily preferable. It should identify the model most likely to deliver the agreed minimum quality standards, value for money, clear accountability, and continuity of family support.
As part of this review, Scottish Government should resolve the current ambiguity surrounding the role of Families Outside and the National PVC Lead. The future model should clearly allocate strategic leadership, national coordination, provider support and improvement, grant or contract management, performance management, quality assurance, escalation, and formal accountability. No organisation should be expected to oversee or assure provider performance without the authority and mechanisms required to discharge that responsibility.
Key recommendation 3: Scottish Government should review the level and future mechanism of PVC funding against the actual cost of delivering the national minimum quality standards.
The review should recognise that flat cash funding has resulted in a reduction in the purchasing power of the PVC resource and has affected staffing, opening hours, workforce retention, visit coverage, partnership work, child- and family-sensitive activity, wider support, and evidence requirements.
Future arrangements should:
- be proportionate to the service expectations placed on PVCs;
- support realistic staffing and management costs;
- enable coverage of agreed core visiting periods;
- support workforce retention, training, and supervision;
- provide stability for partnership and referral work;
- allow proportionate monitoring and national coordination;
- support planned service improvement; and
- include a periodic review or uplift mechanism that avoids sustained real-terms erosion, subject to normal public-sector budgeting and scrutiny.
Multi-year funding should be used where possible to support continuity, planning, and workforce stability.
Key recommendation 4: Scottish Government should formally refresh and mandate the national PVC oversight and implementation group to oversee delivery of the recommendations, minimum quality standards, and future commissioning arrangements.
The group should include Scottish Government, SPS, Families Outside, the National PVC Lead, PVC providers, the private prison operator and relevant contracted partners, alongside appropriate representation from families and people with lived experience.
It should establish:
- a sequenced implementation plan;
- named organisational ownership;
- agreed timescales and review points;
- reporting and assurance arrangements;
- clear routes for escalating performance or quality concerns;
- responsibilities for requiring and monitoring corrective action;
- arrangements for sharing national learning; and
- a process for periodically reviewing the minimum quality standards.
Until any revised commissioning and accountability arrangements are implemented, Scottish Government should remain the clearly identified route for formal escalation where provider performance or compliance with funded expectations requires intervention.
Key recommendation 5: SPS should establish and resource a consistent minimum family-contact infrastructure across all Scottish prisons.
As a national minimum quality standard, SPS should ensure (directly and through its contractual arrangements where relevant) that every Scottish prison has at least one appropriately trained, dedicated Family Contact Officer whose principal responsibility is family contact.
The role should have protected capacity and should not be routinely redeployed to cover unrelated staffing gaps. One dedicated FCO should be regarded as the minimum rather than the optimum model; larger establishments and prisons with more complex populations will require additional dedicated capacity.
SPS should also require each establishment to have a clear local operating agreement with its PVC or support-service provider. This should cover access, communication, information sharing, family-focused activity, safeguarding, visitor voice, use of space, privacy, issue escalation, and joint review. Supporting family contact and enabling effective independent PVC provision should be treated as core elements of prison visiting rather than matters dependent on local goodwill or individual relationships.
Key recommendation 6: SPS should review the current contractual arrangements for visit-hall refreshments and replace the vending-machine-led model at the earliest contractually and operationally practicable opportunity.
Every prison visit hall should provide reliable access to:
- tea and coffee;
- cold drinks;
- sandwiches or equivalent light food; and
- affordable, healthier snacks suitable for adults and children.
A staffed tea or coffee bar, or an equivalent reliable service, should be the expected minimum provision. Vending machines may supplement this offer but should not be the sole or primary source of food and drink.
The future model should recognise that visitors may have travelled considerable distances, that some visits take place around mealtimes, and that sharing food and drink can support ordinary family interaction. It should also respond to stakeholder concerns about a refreshments offer dominated by sweets, chocolate, and sugary drinks, particularly during visits involving children.
Key recommendation 7: Scottish Government should lead the development of a proportionate national evidence, quality, and learning framework for PVCs and support services.
The framework should be aligned with the revised PVC ToC, LM, and national minimum quality standards. It should use shared definitions and proportionate measures to improve evidence on:
- unique reach and repeat contact;
- equality of access;
- visitor experience;
- child and family voice;
- quality and manageability of family contact;
- referral and warm-handover follow-through;
- visitor voice and issue resolution;
- safeguarding;
- service quality; and
- short- to medium-term outcomes.
The framework should support accountability and improvement without imposing data requirements that reduce the time available for direct family support.
Outcome-based recommendations
Outcome theme 1: National minimum quality standards and local flexibility
- Outcome-based recommendation 1.1: Every family visiting a Scottish prison experiences the nationally agreed minimum standard of support and provision. This includes a respectful welcome; visible independent support; accurate information; practical guidance; appropriate waiting, toilet and privacy facilities; child- and family-sensitive provision; routes into wider support; and safe ways to raise concerns.
- Outcome-based recommendation 1.2: The national minimum quality standards clearly identify the distinct but complementary responsibilities of PVC and support-service providers, SPS, prison establishments, the private prison operator, and other contracted partners. Each element is linked to clear expectations, indicators, evidence requirements, escalation routes, and review arrangements.
- Outcome-based recommendation 1.3: Local variation is purposeful, transparent, and justified by the prison population, geography, estate, regime, or family need. Local services can adapt or exceed the minimum standards, but no family receives less than the agreed minimum because of historical arrangements, unclear expectations, or inequitable resourcing. Support-service models in establishments without a full PVC are clearly specified and resourced.
Outcome theme 2: Commissioning, funding, and sustainability
- Outcome-based recommendation 2.1: PVCs and support services are commissioned through a coherent model that supports consistent quality, clear accountability, specialist family-support expertise, and effective national coordination whilst retaining appropriate local responsiveness.
- Outcome-based recommendation 2.2: The number and configuration of PVC providers are demonstrably justified by service quality, value for money, local need, and organisational capability. Avoidable duplication of management and administrative overhead is reduced, and the resources available are directed as far as possible towards frontline family support and service quality.
- Outcome-based recommendation 2.3: PVC funding reflects the actual cost of delivering the national minimum quality standards and enables providers to plan, retain skilled staff, cover agreed visiting periods, maintain continuity of relationships, contribute to partnership work and meet proportionate evidence requirements without relying on unsustainable additional fundraising.
- Outcome-based recommendation 2.4: Any change in provider, commissioning structure, or delivery model is supported by a planned mobilisation and transition process. Families, people in custody, staff and partners experience continuity of support, information, trusted relationships, safeguarding arrangements, and referral pathways during the transition.
Outcome theme 3: Governance, leadership, and accountability
- Outcome-based recommendation 3.1: Strategic leadership, national coordination, provider support, grant or contract management, performance management, quality assurance, escalation, and formal accountability are explicitly allocated. Families Outside and the National PVC Lead have a clearly defined role with responsibilities matched by appropriate authority, and no organisation is expected to manage performance through influence and goodwill alone.
- Outcome-based recommendation 3.2: National oversight of PVCs includes meaningful, safe, and accessible participation from families and people with lived experience. Progress against the recommendations and minimum quality standards is routinely reviewed, with concerns, risks, required corrective action, and improvement learning reported through clear governance arrangements.
- Outcome-based recommendation 3.3: Every prison has a written and routinely reviewed local partnership agreement with its PVC or support-service provider. The agreement defines communication, access, information sharing, family support, safeguarding, visitor voice, issue escalation, use of space, joint activity, and responsibilities for resolving local problems.
Outcome theme 4: SPS family-contact infrastructure and the prison/PVC interface
- Outcome-based recommendation 4.1: Every Scottish prison has at least one appropriately trained, dedicated Family Contact Officer whose principal responsibility is family contact. The role has protected capacity, is not routinely redeployed to unrelated duties and is scaled above the minimum where the establishment's size, population, or complexity requires it.
- Outcome-based recommendation 4.2: SPS leadership treats family contact and the effective operation of independent PVCs as core prison responsibilities. Staff working across visiting, security, reception, residential, and management functions understand the needs of families and the role of PVCs and apply family-aware, trauma-informed, and respectful practice consistently.
- Outcome-based recommendation 4.3: PVC and support-service staff have the practical conditions required to perform their role, including timely access to prison-specific information, suitable space, privacy, communication and IT facilities where required, involvement in relevant family and visiting forums, and clear routes to resolve operational and safeguarding concerns. Effective collaboration is not dependent solely on individual staff relationships.
Outcome theme 5: The visitor journey and physical visiting environment
- Outcome-based recommendation 5.1: The whole visitor journey is designed and reviewed from a family perspective. This includes travel information, booking, confirmation, notification of changes or cancellations, arrival, waiting, security, movement through the prison, the visit itself, departure, and access to follow-up support.
- Outcome-based recommendation 5.2: Visitors have consistent access to facilities that support dignity and reduce avoidable stress. These include a suitable place to wait, clean and accessible toilets, baby-changing facilities, private or confidential space, comfortable and well-maintained visiting environments, and age-appropriate play, quiet, and sensory provision.
- Outcome-based recommendation 5.3: Every visit hall offers reliable, affordable, and healthier food and drink, including hot and cold drinks, sandwiches, or equivalent light food and suitable snacks for adults and children. A staffed tea or coffee bar, or equivalent reliable service, is available as the principal offer; vending machines are supplementary rather than the sole provision.
Outcome theme 6: Information, advocacy, and visitor voice
- Outcome-based recommendation 6.1: Families have access to clear, accurate and prison-specific information before, during, and after visits. This includes booking, confirmation, security, visit rules, property, money, clothing, travel assistance, child-focused visits, telephone and video contact, support services, and routes for resolving problems.
- Outcome-based recommendation 6.2: Information is available in accessible formats that meet different needs, including easy-read, large-print, translated, digital, non-digital, and age-appropriate formats. Responsibility for reviewing and updating information is clearly assigned so that families are not reliant on outdated or informal advice.
- Outcome-based recommendation 6.3: Visitor voice, advocacy, complaints, and issue-escalation routes are visible, independent where appropriate, safe, and trusted. Families can raise concerns without fear of negative consequences for themselves or the person in custody, receive acknowledgement and feedback, and can see where recurring concerns have informed service or prison improvement.
Outcome theme 7: Child- and family-sensitive visiting
- Outcome-based recommendation 7.1: Child- and family-sensitive visiting is embedded within the national minimum quality standards and is not dependent on local goodwill, exceptional staff effort, or short-term funding. Provision responds to different ages, developmental stages, family relationships, neurodivergence, anxiety, disability and sensory needs, including the needs of teenagers.
- Outcome-based recommendation 7.2: Where contact is wanted, safe, and appropriate, visit arrangements support ordinary and meaningful family interaction. This includes sufficient time for children to settle and reconnect; appropriate movement, play, and physical contact; suitable activities; opportunities to share food; and visit spaces that support rather than unnecessarily constrain family relationships.
- Outcome-based recommendation 7.3: Decisions about family contact, including children's visits, are informed by children's rights and views, family safety, trauma, coercion, domestic abuse, safeguarding concerns, and the circumstances and needs of carers. No assumption is made that all family contact is automatically positive or appropriate.
Outcome theme 8: Equality, access, and safeguarding
- Outcome-based recommendation 8.1: PVCs, SPS, and wider partners routinely identify and respond to barriers associated with poverty, travel distance, rurality, transport, disability, neurodivergence, language, digital exclusion, stigma, age, gender, caring responsibilities, and family circumstances. Equality considerations are embedded in standards, funding, service design, and monitoring.
- Outcome-based recommendation 8.2: Families who do not visit, visit rarely, cannot access a PVC or are not already connected to support have clear alternative routes to information and assistance. Telephone, digital, community, and wider family-support routes ensure that the family-support offer does not reach only those who are most visible at prison visits.
- Outcome-based recommendation 8.3: Safeguarding is clearly embedded in PVC and prison visiting practice. Staff and volunteers understand their responsibilities and have access to training, supervision, and clear referral and information-sharing pathways covering child and adult protection, domestic abuse, coercion, financial pressure, and wider family safety.
Outcome theme 9: Wider family support and referral pathways
- Outcome-based recommendation 9.1: PVCs, Families Outside, and relevant local statutory and third-sector services operate clear, named, and trusted referral and warm-handover pathways. With appropriate consent, families are supported to make contact, understand what will happen next, and access further help, rather than receiving information alone.
- Outcome-based recommendation 9.2: Families can access support beyond the immediate visit for practical, emotional, financial, housing, health, education, relationship, and caring needs. PVCs are not expected to meet all needs directly, but responsibilities for identifying needs, making connections, following up referrals, and escalating gaps in local provision are clear.
Outcome theme 10: Workforce, evidence, and continuous learning
- Outcome-based recommendation 10.1: The skilled, relational, practical and reactive work undertaken by PVC staff and volunteers is recognised in staffing models, job design, pay and conditions, recruitment, training, supervision, volunteer support, commissioning, and monitoring. Services have enough capacity to provide visible support during agreed core visiting periods.
- Outcome-based recommendation 10.2: Monitoring and evidence systems use shared definitions and capture more than activity and footfall. They provide proportionate evidence on unique reach, equality of access, visitor experience, child and family voice, contact quality, referral follow-through, visitor voice, safeguarding, service quality, and short- to medium-term outcomes.
- Outcome-based recommendation 10.3: Monitoring, family feedback, staff experience, co-interpretation, quality assurance, and cross-establishment learning are routinely used to improve practice and review the minimum quality standards. Evidence requirements remain proportionate and do not unnecessarily reduce the time available for direct support.
These recommendations are mutually reinforcing. National minimum quality standards cannot be achieved without sufficient funding, clear commissioning and accountability, SPS family-contact infrastructure, effective local relationships, a skilled workforce, and proportionate evidence systems. Progress will require coordinated national and local action, clearly assigned responsibility, sustained resourcing and routine review, whilst retaining the flexibility needed to respond to different prisons, communities, and family circumstances.
Contact
Email: justice_analysts@gov.scot