Prison visitor centres and support services review: main report

This report presents the first full independent review of Scottish Government-funded Prison Visitors' Centres (PVCs) and support services in Scotland.


Appendix C. Evaluation theory of change and logic model

Theory of Change

A Theory of Change (ToC) provides a comprehensive explanation of how and why a desired change is expected to occur in a given context. It maps the causal pathways from inputs and activities to outcomes, whilst making explicit the assumptions and contextual factors that underpin the change process.

A Logic Model (LM) is a visual representation of the programme’s components, which typically includes inputs, outputs, and outcomes.

Whilst the terms are sometimes used interchangeably, they serve distinct but complementary purposes:

Table C1. Purpose and key features – Theory of Change vs Logic Model

Concept

Purpose

Key features

Theory of Change (ToC)

Articulates the overarching logic and rationale for change

Focuses on assumptions, context, and causal pathways

Logic Model (LM)

Visualises programme components and their relationships

Includes inputs, activities, outputs, and outcomes

A well-constructed LM is grounded in a solid ToC. In essence, the ToC provides the logic that informs the structure and content of the LM.

Thus, Theories of Change are an overview theory which indicates a cause-effect mechanism and particular outcomes which might be achieved or an articulating of the change process within an intervention and description of the sequence of events linking an intervention’s activities to its long-term outcomes. Often, substantive programmes or interventions will have an established ToC prior to any evaluation. Although a detailed LM had been established prior to this evaluation (Evaluation Support Scotland, 2025), no such ToC had been documented[1].

A project ToC and LM are not the same as an evaluation ToC and LM. They may be very similar. A project ToC and LM are concerned with the delivery of such in achieving is measurable objectives, inputs, outputs and outcomes. Whilst an evaluation study will take full cognisance of such, its purpose is to evaluate not monitor and it layers on additional context and evidence considerations onto the ToC and LM before reaching final research evaluation commentaries.

In following Mayne’s six-step CA model the starting point for the team was to develop a reasoned ToC. In essence this has meant the evaluation taking the given core premise or assumption as the starting point or scaffold for the study. As there was no prior model to the evaluation the research team had to construct a retrospective development of a ToC (represented below).

PVC Evaluation Theory of Change

  • IF → (1) independent, third-sector PVCs and support services offer a welcoming soft landing around prison visits, (2) provide timely information, advice, and advocacy, and (3) connect families to wider support;
  • THEN → (1) visitors, including children and young people, are more likely to be able to navigate prison visiting processes through a more welcoming and less anxious environment; (2) constructive family contact is easier to sustain where it is wanted, safe, and appropriate; and (3) people in custody and prison staff will benefit from improved relationships with visitors;
  • OVER TIME THIS MAY CONTRIBUTE TO → (1) improved wellbeing for some children, families, and people in custody, (2) reducing some harms associated with imprisonment, and (3) making a small indirect contribution to safer reintegration, children’s rights, health and justice, poverty reduction, reduced reoffending, and social inclusion.

Logic Model development

Theories of change are often detailed through LMs. The terms LM and ToC are sometimes used interchangeably. However, there are clear differences. The ToC provides the summary focus of any project, intended change and outcomes. LMs graphically illustrate the detailed programme components. ToCs link outcomes and activities to explain how and why the desired change is expected. A good LM has a solid ToC to guide it. Essentially, a ToC is what puts the logic into a LM.

The aim of our Review is to make some credible claims about the proposed chain of events in the ToC and these are then detailed or extrapolated out into a LM. Any claims of credibility for the ToC or the likely contribution of the project to observed outcomes derive from:

1. Evidence that planned activities took place. These are the inputs and outputs of any intervention programme.

2. Analysis, through multiple data sources, of expected (and unexpected) results (i.e. PVCs delivered the type of results that were expected?). These are the outcomes of the intervention.

3. Accounts of other factors that are likely to have influenced the results observed (i.e. what other (external) factors have been taken account of in terms of the effect they have on the ability of PVCs to successfully deliver the services they were designed to do).

4. Finally, the evidence that supports claims laid out in 1, 2 and 3.

When combined, these considerations become the stages and details of any LM.

A short-life working group was convened to discuss and refine the pre-existing PVC programme logic model that was developed through support from Evaluation Support Scotland in 2025. Both meetings of the working group layered more of the detail of the LM shared in this report. The meetings essentially identified, discussed, and agreed:

  • inputs, outputs, and likely outcomes;
  • influencing factors (assumptions and external factors); and
  • evidence sources (that were then mapped onto the various components of PVCs).

The developed LM is available at: Evaluation Logic Model

Contact

Email: justice_analysts@gov.scot

Back to top