Prison visitor centres and support services review: main report
This report presents the first full independent review of Scottish Government-funded Prison Visitors' Centres (PVCs) and support services in Scotland.
Appendix I. Qualitative themes and examples (prison staff)
This appendix provides supplementary qualitative evidence from interviews with prison staff beyond the summary provided in the Part 1 Main Report at Chapter 7. The first table supports the main themes used in the ‘Perspectives of prison staff’ chapter. The second table captures other salient supplementary themes identified during the analysis.
Quotes are verbatim extracts from prison staff and are attributed using participant IDs.
Table I1. Consistent prison staff themes
Main Theme: PVCs help make visits calmer and more manageable
Qualitative Examples:
“I just think they’re good with… just their presence, the way they come across and the way they come in, they know it’s a welcoming centre and the people that work there are really welcoming. It’s not like you’ve got someone in the office hiding away. They’re right forward talking to them. Anything they’ve got, any questions.” [Prison staff #15, female]
“She’s a big help to us… It’s good to have her to speak to families and she’s not in a white shirt. I feel like a lot of people can be intimidated by it. A lot of children can be intimidated by it. It doesn’t matter if we’re going over with smiley faces.” [Prison staff #4, female]
“The Visitor Centre is a great support for us and a good link to other people outside.” [Prison staff #10, male]
“The visit centre is there to support the families… they feel comfortable, they feel relaxed. [PVC staff member] might spot something, and she passes it on to the staff.” [Prison staff #7, female]
“I think having a visitor’s centre is very important to the families visiting the establishment. A warm welcome goes a long way, not just in this environment but just in general.” [Prison staff #6, female]
Main Theme: Collaborative working supports family-focused practice
Qualitative Examples:
“It’s a very good relationship that’s set up between them. If something needs… one way or another we work well together. If something can’t be done, justify why it can’t be done, then that’s fine. At the same time, if something can be done, then we’ll go and do it.” [Prison staff #9, male]
“So, we are listening to what the dads would like and trying to make that happen so that they have a wee bit more involvement.” [Prison staff #6, female]
“We all seem to be on the same page with everything.” [Prison staff #14, female]
“I do, I kind of get on with them all and I’ve managed to build rapport with them and things like that, and they come to me with anything as well.” [Prison staff #14, female]
“[PVC staff member] can just come and ask me or [colleague]… she follows through as well.” [Prison staff #7, female]
Main Theme: Family contact is valued, but awareness and resources constrain support
Qualitative Examples:
“The staff make it run well. It’s the staff at the end of the day. There was a bit of time where visits were a bit of a struggle because it was all new staff and all that and very little experience, and the loss of that experienced staff.” [Prison staff #9, male]
“I think it’s an excellent service but I’m not sure that it’s advertised enough. Even throughout the staffing group, because I wasn’t even aware of it. I knew it was there, but I didn’t know what they done or anything until I came into the role I’m in just now. So, I think if the staff that is working in the residential areas, if they were more aware of what they offered…” [Prison staff #15, female]
“They’re actually doing more than enough, and the stuff that they’re maybe not doing is more because of our constraints.” [Prison staff #1, female]
“Down here it’s more of an understanding and sympathetic role... there’s a wee bit more respect between the officers and the prisoners in that sense... people don’t want to mess with their visits.” [Prison staff #9, male]
“How can I be a [family focused role, identifying role removed] for like 540 people?” [Prison staff #7, female]
“We’re very limited to the money that we’ve got.” [Prison staff #12, female]
Main Theme: Booking and refreshments can undermine visits
Qualitative Examples:
“That’s one of my biggest complaints… that’s the biggest, aye, is this booking.” [Prison staff #3, female]
“Nationally, it would be good to see some sort of online booking.” [Prison staff #1, female]
“The system we use is called CMS… it just needs the times changed on it. You will see about 30-odd emails a day that the staff are having to pick up.” [Prison staff #9, male]
“We’re trying to get them [virtual visits] extended, but that’s not SPS. That’s a third party. So, it’s like you contact them and you hear nothing back.” [Prison staff #3, female]
“I don’t think [the vending-machine provision] is the greatest. They get refilled twice a week and usually by the weekend, they’re empty. They can’t get a tea and coffee… the sandwich machine sells really quick.” [Prison staff #11, female]
“It would be nice to see the tea bar get opened back up again.” [Prison staff #1, female]
“People are bringing their kids up and it’s just sweets and chocolate.” [Prison staff #1, female]
“[The sandwiches and wraps] are super-pricey and super dry, but they are there.” [Prison staff #6, female]
Main Theme: Local provision needs to respond to different prisons and families
Qualitative Examples:
“Families are so diverse as well because it’s not… you’re not a homogenous group.” [Prison staff #2, female]
“It’s not always the traditional mum, dad, two children and that kind of thing.” [Prison staff #3, female]
“Massively, because different jails have got different prisoner groups, for a start.” [Prison staff #1, female]
“[Prison name] has a very different visitor kind of cohort than, say, a local jail.” [Prison staff #2, female]
“We have quite a few children who are non-verbal… in parenting class bringing in partners to teach Makaton. We have a lot of children who are neurodiverse, so we are making the play area in the visits room a sensory area.” [Prison staff #6, female]
“We’re seeing more and more children with additional needs.” [Prison staff #3, female]
“We’ve got a lot of ethnic [minority] groups as well.” [Prison staff #7, female]
“You don’t want to deviate too far away from national guidance, but you do need to have your own policies.” [Prison staff #1, female]
“So, it can’t be a one-size-fits-all.” [Prison staff #2, female]
Table I2. Additional prison staff themes
Main Theme: Women in custody were reported to receive fewer in-person visits
Qualitative Examples:
“It’s very rare that we have more than seven females in the Visit Room at once. They just don’t tend to get a lot of visits.” [Prison staff #12, female]
“I’ve previously worked in the male estate, and I was very surprised when I came here to see how little uptake there was on the visits. The women just don’t seem to have the same support as the men have in my experience." [Prison staff #16, female]
“Women do not get many visits – double female session usually has empty spaces.” [Prison staff #11, female]
Main Theme: Changes in prison staffing or PVC provision can disrupt continuity
Qualitative Examples:
“So, it’s lacking a bit more now, because the visitors in general don’t have an extra person there all the time, which they’re usually always there. Then we don’t see them as often and since they don’t take anything… not don’t have anything to do with us, but they’re not involved in the visits anymore, so we don’t cross paths as often." [Prison staff #14, female]
“The staff make it run well It’s the staff at the end of the day. There was a bit of time where visits were a bit of struggle because it was all new staff and all that and very little experience, and the loss of that experienced staff.” [Prison staff #9, male]
“I think when [PVC provider was involved in visits] it was quite nice because it was a bit of separation and they would interact. We were obviously still there, and the family contact officer was still there, but I think having [PVC provider] there was good for that side of things because that’s not happening now it’s just strange not having that support there.” [Prison staff #12, female]
Main Theme: Joint working enabled family-focused events and activities
Qualitative Examples:
“We’ve actually been hauled in to doing the veterans event… we’ve got families coming in. We’ve got a lot of veterans down the Hall. We’re going to do a wee spread for them, get the buffet on, cakes and stuff. We’ve got flags and bunting and stuff, make it special, get some pictures with their families… They’ve maybe got PTSD, and they don’t like the surroundings. So, we’re going to make it a calm environment, get the cards, the dominoes, nice and chill and allow their families and stuff to come in.” [Prison staff #6, female]
“For the Easter party on the Friday, we’ll bake on the Thursday, and we’ll make the biscuits, the traybakes and things like that. So, they’ll get an opportunity then to be involved in the party. They’re doing the decorations, they’re helping make the cakes and they’re helping us plan where we’re going to put everything… we’re listening to what the dads would like and then we’re trying to make that happen, so then they’ve got a wee bit more involvement.” [Prison staff #6, female]
Main Theme: Operational arrangements can limit equitable access to family contact
Qualitative Examples:
“The number of people coming in has dropped since they’ve changed to this regime… because of the times… people trying to get here from their work.” [Prison staff #9, male]
“I can give them ten minutes in the room, but I can’t give them an extra ten minutes on the computer, because it cuts off.” [Prison staff #10, male]
“I think we should have something else put in place for ones that don’t have kids… have a different type of visit for people who… don’t have kids, or a grandparent. The only problem would be trying to staff the two things at the one time.” [Prison staff #9, male]
Contact
Email: justice_analysts@gov.scot