Prison visitor centres and support services review: main report
This report presents the first full independent review of Scottish Government-funded Prison Visitors' Centres (PVCs) and support services in Scotland.
Chapter 6: Perspectives of PVC providers
- PVC providers described a common core role centred on welcoming families, providing information and practical support, and helping make prison visiting more manageable.
- Many interviewees described the initial welcome as a basis for identifying and responding to wider needs, although views differed on how far PVC activity should extend beyond the visit.
- Relationships with prison colleagues were generally described positively and supported practical problem-solving, family-focused activity and communication with families.
- PVC providers reported substantial work to support children and young people, but provision was shaped by physical space, prison arrangements, staffing and resources.
- Funding constraints affected staffing, opening hours, continuity, planning and the range of support that providers felt able to sustain.
Introduction
This chapter presents the perspectives of PVC providers, including frontline staff, managers and volunteers who participated in the qualitative fieldwork (n=28). The evidence was collected through 25 individual and group interviews conducted in person or online. The chapter is also informed by 14 service-level survey responses submitted by nine provider organisations.
The chapter reports on the following five main themes:
- basic provision makes prison visiting more welcoming, dignified and manageable;
- PVCs can provide wider support, although providers differed on the scope of their role;
- collaborative working with prisons supports visitor and family-focused activity;
- PVCs support child-focused visiting, but provision is constrained by space, prison arrangements and resources; and
- funding constraints affect staffing, coverage and continuity.
Further supporting quotations and lower-frequency findings are provided in the Part 2 Supporting Evidence Report at Appendix H. Unless otherwise stated, numerical findings in this chapter are drawn from the provider survey.
Overview of PVC provider perspectives
PVC providers described a recognisable core role centred on welcoming families, providing information and practical support, and helping make prison visiting easier to manage. Survey responses showed several areas of common provision across services, although the physical space, staffing, opening hours and wider support available differed considerably.
Interviewees commonly described the initial welcome as a basis for developing trust, understanding family circumstances and identifying wider needs. Some providers offered more extensive family support, activities or connections to community services. Others understood the role more narrowly as support linked directly to visiting and questioned whether a broader remit could contribute to inconsistent provision.
Interviewees generally described constructive relationships with prison colleagues, although these required sustained effort and could be affected by changes in prison staff, leadership or provider. Funding and staffing were the most consistently reported constraints, affecting coverage of visiting sessions, continuity, partnership activity and the range of support providers felt able to offer.
Basic provision makes prison visiting more welcoming, dignified, and manageable
‘“I find it warm and welcoming, it’s a home from home”, and you hear that every day’ [CJ03PVC]
‘We primarily will welcome families into the centres and we’re there to provide information or signpost different resources’ [SS04]
PVC providers identified a common foundation to provision despite differences between establishments and service models. All 14 survey respondents reported providing information about prison visiting and prison-related issues, information about wider needs, referrals to partner organisations and access to toilets.
Interviewees consistently described welcoming families, answering questions and helping make visits easier to manage as central parts of their role. They referred to the planning and attention involved in creating a warm environment, making staff visible and responding appropriately to families arriving in unfamiliar or stressful circumstances.
The facilities available to support this role varied. Interviewees from two services raised concerns about families being unable to access toilets before security when the PVC was closed. Food and refreshments were also described as important to visitor dignity, although only 10 of the 14 survey respondents reported being able to offer food or drinks.
Interviewees referred to staffed tea-bar facilities having been replaced by vending machines in some prison visit rooms. These were described as expensive, unreliable or limited in what they offered. The survey did not establish how widespread this arrangement was across the estate.
Interviewees believed that the welcome, information and practical support they provided affected how prepared and reassured families felt before visits. Several also emphasised the knowledge and judgement required to respond informally to families, whilst suggesting that this expertise could be overlooked because much of the work occurred through everyday conversations rather than formal interventions.
PVCs can provide wider support, although providers differed on the scope of their role
‘We will support you with anything. Anything. And if we can’t, we’ll find someone who can.’ [AP02PVC-Fa]
‘That is our main job, to make people in that horrible situation a friendly face and a smile. And sometimes that's all people need. So it's not about the skill or upskilling [staff], it's that bubbly personality that, yeah, I want to talk to you and I can make conversation even if somebody can't.’ [AP08PVC-F]
PVC providers commonly described working flexibly in response to families’ circumstances. For many interviewees, an initial welcoming interaction created an opportunity to understand what a family needed and determine whether practical help, emotional support, information or connection to another service would be useful.
Interviewees who supported this broader approach described PVCs as bridging services between families, prisons and community support. They gave examples of responding to financial, housing, health, relationship, parenting and substance-use concerns, either directly or by helping families identify relevant services.
Some interviewees described their PVC as operating in a community-centre or hub-like way. Others reported delivering programmes or support within the prison alongside SPS, Sodexo or specialist partners. These examples showed that, in some establishments, the provider role extended beyond the immediate visit.
This approach was not universally supported. A minority of interviewees questioned whether intensive or wide-ranging family support fell within the intended remit of PVCs. They were concerned that an expansive role could create inconsistency, particularly where some providers had greater access to charitable funding, specialist staff or community services than others.
Interviewees therefore shared a commitment to responsive support but differed in how they understood its appropriate scope. The main point of agreement was that PVC staff should recognise needs and help families identify appropriate support, even where the service could not meet those needs directly.
Collaborative working with prisons supports visitor and family-focused activity
‘If there’s an issue, we’re problem solving together.’ [AP03PVC-F]
‘It is not a "them and us" here but we do follow their policies.’ [CJ06]
PVC providers generally described positive working relationships with prison colleagues. Nine of the 14 survey respondents characterised the relationship as highly collaborative, three as collaborative and two as somewhat collaborative.
Interviewees described joint working as helping PVC staff understand prison rules and arrangements, whilst helping prison staff become more aware of the pressures experienced by families. Established relationships also enabled staff to raise practical issues, obtain information and resolve problems affecting visits.
Some interviewees described contributing to Family Strategy Groups, Visitors’ Forums and visitor consultations. Others supported activities delivered within the prison, including child-focused visits, seasonal events and other family-contact work. In these establishments, PVC involvement extended into the planning and delivery of wider family-focused activity.
Interviewees reported dedicating considerable time to developing these relationships. Changes in provider, prison management, FCO staffing or other personnel could interrupt established ways of working and require relationships to be rebuilt. PVC location also affected involvement, with some interviewees feeling that being situated behind the secure line made participation in prison-based activity easier.
Interviewees with experience across more than one establishment described considerable variation in day-to-day prison arrangements. They also recognised operational pressures facing SPS and Sodexo staff, including shortages, competing duties and changes in policy or procedure. PVC teams sometimes needed to adapt their activity at short notice in response.
Interviewees described mixed influence on wider prison culture. Some felt sustained PVC involvement had increased awareness of family experiences and contributed to more family-focused practice. Others continued to observe difficult interactions between prison staff and visitors despite constructive relationships with senior managers or family-facing teams.
PVCs support child-focused visiting, but provision is constrained by space, prison arrangements and resources
‘Because it really is, it’s just fantastic, they just – go – and they’re free. You’ve got dad down the bottom of the football net, you’ve got dad over here with the couple of weans, and then up here, the telly with the beanbags, watching a DVD and we’ve got board games, we’ve got drawing, we’ve got painting – anything they want.’ [CJ07PVC-F]
‘So, we’ll see children visit from 0 to maybe 12, 13 and then from that age till maybe 18 is very low numbers, even in a very busy prison.’ [CJ05PVCF]
PVC providers described substantial activity intended to support children and young people. Ten of the 14 survey respondents reported using children’s rights resources or frameworks within their work.
Interviewees gave examples of age-appropriate activities, toys, books, activity packs, sensory resources, quiet areas and family events. Some PVC teams led or contributed to child-focused visits and special occasions within prison visit rooms. Others sought to make PVC spaces more welcoming through decoration, play areas or mascots.
Survey responses indicated that most services had a mechanism for consulting children and young people. Seven reported collecting feedback routinely, five collected it occasionally and eight reported using children’s feedback to improve provision. Interviewees also described attempts to support neurodivergent children through sensory resources or adapted spaces.
Survey respondents generally assessed child and family outcomes positively. Seven felt their service had fully or mostly achieved improved wellbeing for children and young people, with a further four reporting some achievement. Nine reported fully or mostly achieving improved contact with parents, whilst eight reported this level of achievement for contact with other family members.
Interviewees nevertheless identified significant constraints. Some PVCs and visit rooms had insufficient space for play, arts and crafts, quiet activity or sensory provision. Several described visit rooms themselves as poorly suited to children, regardless of the support available in the PVC.
Prison timetables and visiting arrangements could also limit child-focused practice. Interviewees described sessions scheduled too late for younger children or at times that could encourage families to remove children from school. Available spaces, approval processes and staffing affected the frequency and accessibility of child-focused visits.
Teenagers were identified as a group receiving less support. Interviewees commonly reported lower visiting numbers amongst teenagers and greater difficulty identifying suitable activities. One provider was developing a dedicated teenage area, whilst others identified technology as a possible means of engagement. Cost, security restrictions and limited resources constrained what could be offered.
Insufficient and short-term funding constrains staffing, planning, and PVC availability
‘So, I've always said we run a full -time service because we're open six days a week, but we have a part-time salary. It's a part-time team.’ [SS02PVC-F]
‘You can’t do a really excellent gold standard job on bronze money.’ [AP03PVC-F]
PVC providers identified funding and staffing as major constraints on delivery. Half of survey respondents (n=7) did not feel that current funding allowed them to plan fully for the future or deliver all the work they believed was required.
Most services reported obtaining funding beyond the central Scottish Government allocation. This included charitable funding (n=9), funding from SPS (n=2), contributions from the provider organisation (n=2), local authority funding (n=1) and other sources (n=3).
Interviewees reported that the Scottish Government allocation had not kept pace with inflation and staffing costs. Several said that core funding alone was insufficient to deliver their current range of work. One described making redundancies, whilst others reported relying on volunteers or additional charitable funding.
Applying for external funding was described as time-consuming, competitive and administratively demanding. Interviewees also criticised annual funding arrangements, which they believed made staff retention, forward planning and service continuity more difficult. Multi-year funding was commonly preferred.
Interviewees described several staffing consequences. These included fractional contracts, difficulty covering sickness and annual leave, managers undertaking frontline shifts, reliance on volunteers and occasional unpaid evening or weekend work. Some felt that covering frontline delivery reduced the time available for management, partnership development and fundraising.
Coverage differed between establishments. Some interviewees reported staffing most visiting sessions, whilst others described operating with minimal staff or being unable to provide staff during a substantial proportion of visits. In some settings, the physical PVC remained available as a waiting area even when no PVC worker was present.
Across interviewees’ accounts, funding and staffing affected opening hours, continuity of relationships, involvement in child-focused activity, partnership work and the extent to which services could offer support beyond the immediate visit.
Contact
Email: justice_analysts@gov.scot