Prison visitor centres and support services review: main report

This report presents the first full independent review of Scottish Government-funded Prison Visitors' Centres (PVCs) and support services in Scotland.


Chapter 1: Introduction

PVCs are independent services provided by non-statutory, not for profit organisations independent of the prisons they work alongside. This chapter provides some important background information on common challenges experienced by families affected by imprisonment, briefly charts the evolution of PVCs in the UK and Scotland, before setting out the current landscape in Scotland.

Background

Research with families affected by imprisonment has grown rapidly over the last two decades, both nationally and internationally (Deacon, 2022a). In Scotland, this has been matched by a range of policy and practice innovations developed to support families, such as: the expanded provision of PVCs, the development of the SPS Family Strategy, and the introduction of mobile telephones during the COVID-19 pandemic to assist families in maintaining contact (HMIPS, 2020, 2022; National Prison Visitor Centre Steering Group, 2017; SPS, 2017).

These supports are welcome given the well-established harms that families often experience as a consequence of imprisonment. These include, but are not limited to: housing instability, loss of childcare or social support, reduced social inclusion, poor mental health, financial pressures, and the need to dedicate considerable time and effort to supporting the person in custody (see, for example Comfort et. al. 2016; Condry & Minson, 2021). The effects of these can be enduring and may reinforce existing social and structural inequalities. For example, recent research concluded that imprisonment plays a key role in creating, deepening and sustaining poverty in families in Scotland (Nugent, 2023; Wakefield & Wildeman, 2014). Impacts can also be gendered. Expectations around caring and care-giving manifest here in women caring for those incarcerated whilst continuing to run their households, often with diminished resources (Jardine, 2019). Children’s experiences of imprisonment can vary depending on their age (and other factors). Common experiences include negative impacts on school attendance and performance (for example, children may be hesitant to attend school due to bullying on account of the imprisonment or may have attendance affected by visiting the prison); feelings of loss at this developmentally critical time; being confused about what has happened or is happening and being concerned about their family member in prison; and having to take on additional responsibilities in the home (Cooper et al., 2023; Minson, 2019; Payler, Cooper and Bennett, 2025).

Whilst visiting is often highly valued by both families and their loved ones ‘inside’, family members experience considerable barriers to visiting such as time, cost, the restrictions of the prison regime, shame, stigma, and poverty (Foster, 2019a; Garneau & Lehalle, 2021). Geographical distance, often coupled with reliance on public transport, compounds challenges for many (Families Outside, 2024). Once families arrive at the prison, the visiting environment can feel unwelcome, noisy, and there can be a lack of privacy (Hutton, 2016). Relationships and interactions between prison staff and visitors are highly variable, but often they can be strained (Lockwood et. al., 2002). The lack of information, or the inconsistency of information, available to families about the intricacies of visiting (for example, how to arrange visits, and what to expect when they arrive), has long been criticised (Mills & Codd 2008; Peart & Asquith 1992).

Finally, the diversity of families, and family relationships can shape the visiting experience. For instance, women typically receive less family support due to the gendered nature of caring labour. Young people, older people, and people convicted of particularly serious or stigmatising offences (e.g. sexual offences), may have their family relationships mediated through the justice system in different ways (see for example Crawley and Sparks, 2005; Meek 2008, Deacon, 2023).

Given the challenges of imprisonment generally, and visiting specifically, the role, and potential of PVCs is significant, and since the opening of the first PVC in the UK, more than 40 years ago at HMP Pentonville (England), increasing recognition has been paid to the role of PVCs in improving family contact and relationships (Home Office 2004; Scottish Government, 2015).

Before focusing on Scotland, it is important to emphasise that no one ‘model’ of PVCs exists in Scotland or elsewhere (Foster, 2019b). Variations in practice may stem from differences in the physical location (for instance prior to, or after, prison security checks), the range of organisations engaged in offering this service (Loucks, 2002; Woodhall and Kinsella, 2018), and also the local needs of families. As Barry noted some time ago, “visitors’ centres, where they exist at all, mean different things to different people” (Barry, 2009:3).

Prison Visitors’ Centres in Scotland

In Scotland there are 11 PVCs and 3 “Support Services” which offer a more limited provision in prisons where a full PVC cannot be accommodated. As shown in Table 2 below, these correspond to 14 of Scotland’s 17 prisons. Three prisons do not have a PVC or Support Service, but these are unique establishments with different family/visiting set ups: HMP Castle Huntly, Scotland’s only ‘open’ prison, and the two Community Custody Units, the Lilias Centre and the Bella Centre for women prisoners. Of Scotland’s 17 prisons, 16 are run by the Scottish Prison Service (SPS), and one (HMP Addiewell) is run by Sodexo, a private sector company which works under contract to the SPS. HMP Kilmarnock was run by a private company, Serco, for 25 years until 2024.

The Scottish Government has funded PVCs since 2016/17 under Section 10 of the Social Work (Scotland) Act 1968. This funding includes cross-directorate contributions from Community Justice, Prisoner Healthcare, and from Children and Families and provides for a National Prison Visitor Centre Lead (situated within Families Outside – Scotland's only charity that solely supports families affected by imprisonment). These services are delivered by ten different providers (inclusive of the National Prison Visitor Centre Lead) as outlined in Table 2 (see below).

The significant financial investment from the Scottish Government announced in 2015 (Scottish Government, 2015) to support the work of PVCs and related policy developments have been argued to have progressive potential in delivering a coherent policy approach to safeguarding the rights of families affected by imprisonment (McCarthy & Adams, 2017). There is a clear consensus PVCs should not only improve visiting, but also provide support, information and advocacy (National Prison Visitors Centre Steering Group, 2017). Thus, PVCs are well placed to support the delivery of the SPS Family and Parenting Strategy (2024-29) and are arguably essential to realising a vision of trauma informed practice with Women and Young People in prison which enables those in custody to maintain and build positive family and community relationships (SPS 2021a; 2021b). The work of PVCs also advances a core strand of the Scottish Government’s Vision for Justice (‘A Just, Safe and Resilient Scotland’, 2017), and contributes to flagship policies for reducing child poverty, respecting children’s rights and achieving the best outcomes for their futures such as The Promise (Independent Care Review, 2020) and Best Start, Bright Futures (Scottish Government, 2022).

Given this context, PVCs play a vital role in mitigating some of the serious and often lasting harms experienced by families affected by imprisonment, although with some exceptions (e.g. Foster, 2019b; Woodall & Kinsella, 2018), the potential and impact of PVCs is poorly evidenced to date. Moreover, whilst some improvements have been made, including in the Scottish context, families continue to report that accessing accurate information that pertains to a particular prison can be challenging (Jardine, 2019; The Diffley Partnership and KSO Research, 2025).

Table 2. Provider organisations

Prison/Young Offender Institution (YOI)

Service

Provider

Table 2 maps out current PVC provision in Scotland alongside provider details:

HMP Addiewell

PVC

Cyrenians

HMP Barlinnie

PVC

The Croft

HMP Edinburgh

PVC

Barnardos

HMP Glenochil

PVC

Forth Valley Inclusion

HMP & YOI Grampian

PVC

Apex Scotland

HMP Kilmarnock

PVC

Recovery Enterprise Scotland

HMP Low Moss

PVC

Early Years Scotland

HMP Perth

PVC

CrossReach

HMP & YOI Polmont

PVC

Apex Scotland

HMP Shotts

PVC

Getting Better Together

HMP & YOI Stirling

PVC

Forth Valley Inclusion

HMP Dumfries

Support Service

Early Years Scotland

HMP Greenock

Support Service

Early Years Scotland

HMP Inverness

Support Service

Apex Scotland

NPVCL

National PVC Lead

Families Outside

Whilst space does not allow for a full description of the variety of models of PVCs across Scotland, it should be noted that there are important differences which shape the operation of PVCs and the experiences of the visitors who use them. These include, but are not limited to, variations in:

  • The physical space – PVCs in Scotland range from large purpose-built centres to one or two small offices, to having very limited or no dedicated space at all.
  • The location – by virtue of the prison they are connected to, some PVCs are readily accessible by public transport whilst others are remote.
  • The building, regime, and population of the prison.
  • Whether the PVC is located before security (n=6) or after security (n=8).
  • Which provider holds the contract, whether they run multiple PVCs, and how long they have been operating the PVC.
  • The access that providers might have to additional financial resources, their success in securing further funding, and their ability to host volunteers or students on placement.
  • Opening times and the ability to have PVC staff present to cover all visits.

Study Aim and Research Themes

Whilst sensitive to these differences, the purpose of this work was not to evaluate different models of PVC. Rather, the overarching aim of the Review was to:

  • explore and review the nature of PVC support services at establishments for families affected by imprisonment (which complements work by SPS); and
  • learn from current practice, needs and priorities to consider options for the future development of support services, reflecting on capacity and resources.

The specific objectives of the Review (and research themes) were to:

  • Understand how PVCs and support services are delivered in practice (theme: current practice).
  • Capture strengths, challenges, and lessons from experience to date (theme: learning).
  • Identify practical and evidence-based choices for how PVCs could be supported, organised, and funded in the future (theme: future options for support, organisation and funding).
  • Assess how PVCs promote equality and uphold children’s rights, and what more can be done to address barriers and inequalities (theme: equality and children’s rights).

Study design

This section provides a summary of Contribution Analysis (CA), the chosen evaluation framework for the review. It is an evaluation approach that is recognised and used by The Scottish Government.

The origins of CA lie in the work of Mayne (2001,2011), who developed it as an analytical tool for situations where designing an ‘experiment’ or using experimental approaches to test cause and effect by relying on a counterfactual case were either impractical or impossible. Accordingly, CA is amongst a group of evaluation methodologies that combine practical insights and theory to evaluate more complex, multi-agency programmes where direct attribution is rarely possible. These systems often involve multiple people and actions, both directly and indirectly, and CA helps determine how and why a system contributes to observed outcomes (Livingston et al., 2020).

CA researchers explore existing knowledge and gather quantitative and qualitative ‘evaluative evidence’ from a range of sources to tell the ‘performance story’ about how a particular policy, programme, or service activity is contributing to particular outcomes in the short, medium, and long terms.

Whilst asserting that these stages should be creatively modified by those adopting CA, Mayne (2011) outlined a six-stage CA model as follows:

1. Set out the cause-effect issue (or attribution problem) to be addressed.

2. Develop the postulated theory of change (ToC) and risks to it.

3. Gather the existing evidence on the theory of change.

4. Assemble and assess the ’performance story’, and challenges to it.

5. Seek out the additional evidence as required to populate the theory of change.

6. Revise and strengthen the performance story and check for validity from study participants.

These stages are sequential, but not wholly linear, i.e. they can be co-occurring and inform each other.

CA begins with an account of the cause-effect to be explored where the focus is on the ‘plausibility’ of the relationship being suggested given the size and reach of the activity in question. Thereafter CA is based on a theory of change; a broad ‘big picture’ theory which focuses on how particular outcomes might be achieved. In addition, some applications consider more micro-level ‘logic models’ (LMs) for particular activities, showing a results chain which links inputs and outputs with outcomes.

Study methods

The study comprised of five distinct and overlapping work packages (WPs):

  • WP1: A rapid evidence and management information (MI) synthesis of secondary data (i.e. collation of existing evidence).
  • WP2: A ToC and LM short-life working group.
  • WP3: Two national surveys – PVC providers and family members/other visitors.
  • WP4: In-depth qualitative research with all stakeholders involved in prison visits.
  • WP5: Two online co-interpretation & option-building workshops.

Full details of study methods and our approach to analysis is provided in the Part 2 Supporting Evidence report at Appendix A, with a summary of the methods provided in the table below.

Recruitment, sampling, and activity completed

A summary of study methods, recruitment, sampling, and activity completed is presented in table 3 below. Fieldwork activities took place between March and May 2026.

Table 3. Summary of study methods, recruitment, sampling and activity completed

Method / Work Package (WP): WP1: Rapid evidence and management information synthesis

Description:

A rapid evidence and management information (MI) synthesis of secondary data (i.e. collation of existing evidence), including PVC grant reports, policy documents, the existing PVC LM, and all available monitoring data, to establish a baseline of current provision and outcomes. This desk-based review mapped what data exists (and gaps) regarding PVC activities and effectiveness.

Method / Work Package (WP): WP2: Theory of Change and logic model short-life working group

Description:

A ToC and LM short-life working group was convened to discuss and refine the pre-existing PVC programme LM that was developed through support from Evaluation Support Scotland in 2025. The evaluation LM guided fieldwork and analysis and served as a tool for participants to reflect on whether their experiences align with expected outcomes. It also provided a framework for interpreting findings and informing the final ‘performance story’ of PVCs.

Number:

  • Two meetings took place with a total of five stakeholders across the two sessions.

Method / Work Package (WP): WP3: National surveys

Description:

Two national surveys were conducted to gather broad quantitative evidence. One survey was for all PVC providers, with one response required per service. This survey was designed to systematically profile each service’s provision (facilities and activities), staffing and opening hours, referral and partnership working, funding sources, data collection practices, and approaches to equality and child-friendly practice. The second survey was made widely accessible for family members and other prison visitors to capture their experiences, needs, and outcomes. This survey was designed to explore how families access PVC support, perceived value of the services, any barriers or enablers to using PVCs, and outcomes such as improved wellbeing, understanding of prison processes, and maintaining family contact.

Number:

  • Family members (198)
  • PVC providers (14)

Method / Work Package (WP): WP4: Multi-site qualitative case studies

Description:

In-depth qualitative research was conducted at a sample of nine prisons (including one prison that is covered by each of the nine PVC provider organisations). The sample was chosen purposively to reflect the diversity of Scotland’s custodial estate and PVC service models, including a male long-term prison, a local prison with a large remand population, the national women’s prison, a YOI, and prisons in both urban/central belt and more rural areas. At each selected site, we employed multiple qualitative methods to gather rich, triangulated data: interviews and focus groups with families/visitors; interviews with individuals in custody; interviews with PVC staff and volunteers; interviews with prison staff; and interviews and focus groups with Families Outside staff and advisors. To further adapt to the custodial setting, our researchers conducted non-intrusive observations of the visitor journey at all nine sites – observing the entrance/security process, the atmosphere and facilities of the visitor centre/waiting area, and the flow of families through visits.

Number:

  • Family members (22)
  • People in custody (24)
  • Providers (28)
  • Prison staff (16)
  • Families Outside (14)

Method / Work Package (WP): WP5: Co-interpretation and option building workshops

Description:

Two online co-interpretation & option-building workshops were facilitated following the close of the main fieldwork activities. Rather than leaving the interpretation of findings solely to the research team, we actively involved stakeholders in co-interpreting findings and generating recommendations. As the study progressed, we held iterative workshops (e.g. mid-point and near the end of analysis) with the National PVC Steering Group and other key stakeholders (Families Outside staff, SPS representatives, and a small number of family representatives or “lived experience” advisors). In these sessions, we presented emerging findings (in accessible summary form) and facilitated discussions to validate the results, explain any surprises or gaps, and collaboratively brainstormed practical options for future PVC provision. This co-production element was a central expectation of the project and ensures that our final recommendations are grounded, feasible and have buy-in from those who would implement or be affected by them. For example, if surveys and interviews highlight a particular gap (say, limited support for children’s play), the workshop can explore solutions and best practices to address it. By involving the Steering Group throughout, we also created a feedback loop to refine our analysis and ensure no important issue is overlooked.

Number:

  • Workshop #1 participants (7)
  • Workshop #2 participants (9)

Language considerations

The world of criminal justice and prisons is full of jargon and abbreviations. We have chosen to use, as far as possible, ‘people-first’ language which emphasises the individuality, equality, and dignity of people rather than defining people primarily by a problem or issue. We want to emphasise the importance of language in helping to challenge and reduce the pervasive stigma that is still attached to being a person or family member affected by imprisonment.

We define ‘family member’ broadly, and this was conveyed in the participant facing materials. Our definition of family member includes but is not limited to: parents, partners, children, siblings, aunties, uncles, cousins, nieces, nephews, grand-parents, grand-children, and step-relations and in-laws. We also recognised that some individuals may view close friends as family members, on account of the closeness of the relationship, and we welcomed their inclusion. However, the overwhelming majority of family member respondents (survey) and interviewees were visiting those that would be legally classed as such. Due to preference, we describe all those who completed the survey as ‘respondents’ (WP3) and all those who took part in an interview as ‘interviewees’ (WP4).

Different prisons across the custodial estate use different terms to differentiate ‘standard’ visits from ‘family focused’ ones, and this was reflected in the varied terminology used by the different groups of interviewees. ‘Standard’ visits were variously described as ‘traditional’ visits, ‘social’ visits, and ‘normal’ visits. The family focused visits were variously described as ‘children’s’, ‘Play, Learn, Connect (PLC)’, ‘family’ or ‘bonding’ visits. We use a combination of terms in this report, often due to wanting to use interviewees’ own words, but wish to highlight the differentiation in visit ‘type’.

For reasons for brevity, and in recognition of their shared role and function, from here onwards, we use the term PVC to describe all 14 settings. Therefore, we include both ‘full’ PVCs (n=11) and support services (n=3) in our discussion of PVCs in this report. However, we do recognise that these are not necessarily inter-changeable.

Study limitations

The study has a number of limitations which we highlight in the respective sections of this report but bring together here.

Due to time and budgetary constraints, it was not possible to include all 14 PVCs as a case study. There are nine case studies, and 14 PVCs. All 14 PVCs are captured in WP3’s survey, but we recognise this is not a substitute for an in-depth case study involving interviews with a range of individuals and groups (i.e. the family members, the PVC staff, the prison staff and the people in prison in these establishments).

Contact

Email: justice_analysts@gov.scot

Back to top