Prison visitor centres and support services review: main report

This report presents the first full independent review of Scottish Government-funded Prison Visitors' Centres (PVCs) and support services in Scotland.


Appendix J. Qualitative themes and examples (Families Outside staff)

This appendix provides supplementary qualitative evidence from interviews and focus groups with Families Outside staff beyond the summary provided in the Part 1 Main Report at Chapter 8. The first table supports the main themes used in the ‘Perspectives of Famillies Outside’ chapter. The second table captures other salient supplementary themes identified during the analysis.

Quotes are verbatim extracts from people in custody and are attributed using participant IDs.

Table J1. Consistent Families Outside themes

Main Theme: Families need support beyond the visit

Qualitative Examples:

"It's not just about the prison experience. It's not just about the justice system. It is about housing and health and mental health and prevention and, you know, being targeted by the media. It's about travel and transport. It's about your children's engagement in school. It's about, you know, all of these issues that don't fit neatly into one category where one agency can take comfortable ownership of it." [Families Outside staff #1, female]

"We can't just provide the sticking plasters. We have to provide the preventative stuff as well." [Families Outside staff #1, female]

"Families need support at where works for them best." [Families Outside staff #6, female]

"So, it might be the visitor centre, but that might be the initial point of contact, but actually where it would suit them better is in the community, in their home, somewhere else, on the phone, but that's not going to happen through the visitor centre, but that might be their first moment of contact where that could be opened up a bit better." [Families Outside staff #6, female]

"Families that don't visit are still impacted often in the same way." [Families Outside staff #2, female]

"The reality is that a lot of people don't visit. And so, it's how, and one of the things that Families Outside focuses on is making sure we can try to reach people in that situation as well." [Families Outside staff #1, female]

Main Theme: Inconsistent local implementation creates unequal family experiences

Qualitative Examples:

"And actually, what you need then is when you're walking into that space is people who are consistent across the board and the consistency is the thing we're missing. A consistency across all the visitor centres where you have the same approach, the same welcome, the same recognition that ‘you are valued and cared for and we are here to listen’. And I'm not saying that they don't deliver that… they do. And I do think every prison; every part of the estate is different. But actually, what families need is to know whatever door they walk into, they'll get that same approach." [Families Outside staff #6, female]

"It doesn't need to look the same. They need to know it's going to be the same approach and that they feel safe as soon as they walk in that door because they'll recognise that response from somebody." [Families Outside staff #6, female]

"There doesn't seem to be any sort of equal approach to Scotland." [Families Outside staff #8, female]

"You know, the consistency of knowing what to expect, knowing what it's going to be like, knowing how they operate, knowing how, you know, what you're going to be met with, what resources are there, who the people are, like none, the consistency there is, well, it's not, it's non-existent." [Families Outside staff #10, female]

"Lack of consistency is a huge one, I think, and that's a big problem across the estate." [Families Outside staff #2, female]

"I think that there at least has to be a minimum sort of set of standards or things that families can expect." [Families Outside staff #13, female]

Main Theme: Support is more visible and trusted when provision is relational and consistently available

Qualitative Examples:

“There should be that literally warm welcome as soon as someone comes in the door, that offer, that kind of consistency, the space… it’s that consistency of welcome and then I think knowing that whatever time you visit there will be someone there.” [Families Outside staff #6, female]

“It just breaks that barrier because they don’t have that uniform on. It just makes it a lot less daunting.” [Families Outside staff #2, female]

“What the physical space looks like isn’t as important as the approach you take within that space.” [Families Outside staff #6, female]

“The colourful space, the tables laid out, it’s got a kitchen, there’s refreshments.” [Families Outside staff #10, female]

“It looks familiar, it feels comfortable.” [Families Outside staff #10, female]

“There’s nowhere to have a private conversation with a family member.” [Families Outside staff #13, female]

“To me that’s just basic human kindness.” [Families Outside staff #14, female]

“There is a real community that they’ve built in that visitor centre.” [Families Outside staff #9, female]

“When it works well, it can work really well.” [Families Outside staff #6, female]

Main Theme: Wider support depends on clear roles, local partnership and functioning referral pathways

Qualitative Examples:

“I don’t think I can ever remember taking a one-to-one referral from a visitor centre. And also, like, I very rarely get family members phone and saying, ‘The visitor centre gave me your number.’ I guess that’s quite concerning because it’s a national helpline, so all the visitor centres would come to the helpline.” [Families Outside staff #2, female]

“We get loads of referrals from social workers, teachers, housing, other third-sector organisations. We get loads of referrals from all there. So, it seems strange that that’s the place that we get the least from when they’re with the family members.” [Families Outside staff #2, female]

“Those referrals are still, are still not coming.” [Families Outside staff #7, female]

“What you want is some sort of collaborative relationship and not a competitive one… now it’s almost like we’re falling over each other trying to support families.” [Families Outside staff #1, female]

“The nine different providers, there’s not those strategic conversations with how we can work together because the organisations are so very different.” [Families Outside staff #11, male]

“I really think the service that we can provide is much different to what can be provided in a visitor centre.” [Families Outside staff #2, female]

“There is a misconception that we do the same job, but we absolutely don’t.” [Families Outside staff #8, female]

“What does this support look like for you on the outside of this visitor centre?” [Families Outside staff #10, female]

“What they do is so crucial and so vital for what they have, but they’re only there for how often that person visits.” [Families Outside staff #2, female]

“If we want to get the best outcomes for visitors, you have to work in partnership with the prison.” [Families Outside staff #5, female]

“I actually do more work with the prison than I do with the visitor centre, bizarrely, around families.” [Families Outside staff #14, female]

Main Theme: Funding, governance and accountability constrain national consistency

Qualitative Examples:

"I don't think it is the right model… for me, there's a gold standard and there's, it will do… and I think for many years we've done lots of… discussion with Scottish Government, we've done a lot to try and get that consistency." [Families Outside staff #5, female]

"And it doesn't because having nine different providers over 14 sites, it's just, it's not going to work. It doesn't work. It doesn't work because you have different organisations who have overall, their organisation has different organisational desire, if you know what I mean." [Families Outside staff #5, female]

"I think the Scottish Government funding that we've had has stayed literally at the same amount for 7, 8, 9, 10 years. So, no cost of living uplift even. So, what was, you know, covered a significant amount of cost nine years ago, doesn't touch the edges now. So that's a major issue." [Families Outside staff #6, female]

"So, the combination of the three just means that it doesn't matter. You can work really, really hard, but your budgets get tighter and tighter." [Families Outside staff #6, female]

"There's no repercussions if you don't." [Families Outside staff #11, male]

"We just went through our second restructure in two years because of lack of funding." [Families Outside staff #10, female]

Main Theme: Children’s rights, equality and family voice are recognised but unevenly realised

Qualitative Examples:

“The differences that are provided for children visiting is something that doesn’t sit well with me. It’s some of the things I always struggle with, especially when I read the funding reports or I hear about what’s going on. I don’t like how there is such a huge variation.” [Families Outside staff #5, female]

“That is seen as a privilege and a luxury that they provide, not that families and children have a right to contact a loved one.” [Families Outside staff #13, female]

“Travel sometimes can be very traumatic, can be very lengthy.” [Families Outside staff #7, female]

“The female population does not get a lot of in-person visits.” [Families Outside staff #13, female]

“I often feel that it’s Families Outside that voice the opinions.” [Families Outside staff #2, female]

“It’s actually awful that we are not in a position to reassure a family member.” [Families Outside staff #2, female]

“The complaints process is there to hold the prisons accountable and there’s not enough of that anyway, in my opinion.” [Families Outside staff #2, female]

“They’d carried out a massive, big surveying questionnaire from the families of what they would like to see in their visitor centre and asked the visitor centre staff what would help them, and then all of a sudden it got lost.” [Families Outside staff #14, female]

Table J2. Additional Families Outside themes

Main Theme: Support needs extend beyond physical prison visits

Qualitative Examples:

"Families that don't visit are still impacted often in the same way." [Families Outside staff #2, female]

"I've got two families on my caseload just now that don't visit the prison. They just won't go." [Families Outside staff #2, female]

"We also support people where somebody's died in custody." [Families Outside staff #2, female]

"Yeah, the option of video calls is really important as long as it's not, they're not restricted to that, but yeah." [Families Outside staff #1, female]

"The reality is that a lot of people don't visit." [Families Outside staff #1, female]

Main Theme: Local relationships, dedicated roles and the physical environment shape delivery

Qualitative Examples:

“If we want to get the best outcomes for visitors, you have to work in partnership with the prison.” [Families Outside staff #5, female] “I think that person needs to be a dedicated person who is trained and that is their sole focus rather than being pulled here, there, and everywhere.” [Families Outside staff #7, female] “I actually do more work with the prison than I do with the visitor centre, bizarrely, around families.” [Families Outside staff #14, female] “And I have an excellent relationship with them and also the senior staff and the general officers themselves.” [Families Outside staff #12, female] “[Name of prison] has been a lot more proactive.” [Families Outside staff #7, female] “What the physical space looks like isn't as important as the approach you take within that space.” [Families Outside staff #6, female] “The colourful space, the tables laid out, it's got a kitchen, there's refreshments.” [Families Outside staff #10, female] “There's nowhere to have a private conversation with a family member.” [Families Outside staff #13, female]

Main Theme: Family voice and national accountability are underdeveloped

Qualitative Examples:

“I often feel that it's Families Outside that voice the opinions.” [Families Outside staff #2, female] “It's very, it's actually awful that we are not in a position to reassure a family member.” [Families Outside staff #2, female] “The complaints process is there to hold the prisons accountable and there's not enough of that anyway, in my opinion.” [Families Outside staff #2, female] “They'd carried out a massive, big surveying questionnaire from the families of what they would like to see in their visitor centre and ask the visitor centre staff what would help you and then all of a sudden it got lost.” [Families Outside staff #14, female] “You're there to sort of guide and steer and encourage.” [Families Outside staff #5, female] “[The National PVC Lead] sits very much in the middle and does the mediation work.” [Families Outside staff #6, female] “There's no repercussions [for PVC providers] if you don't.” [Families Outside staff #11, male]

Main Theme: The provider model and organisational roles remain contested

Qualitative Examples:

“I think it should be a national service that's contracted to one.” [Families Outside staff #11, male] “With family support at the forefront of what it is that they are delivering, it would make the most sense.” [Families Outside staff #10, female] “I don't understand why Families Outside is not doing this job.” [Families Outside staff #10, female] “It's about having that local relevance, I suppose. You know, what you need to have in Shotts is very different from what you'll need to have in Edinburgh, for example.” [Families Outside staff #1, female] “I really think the service that we can provide is much different to what can be provided in a visitor centre.” [Families Outside staff #2, female] “There is a misconception that we do the same job, but we absolutely don't.” [Families Outside staff #8, female] “What does this support look like for you on the outside of this visitor centre?” [Families Outside staff #10, female] “What they do is so crucial and so vital for what they have, but they're only there for how often that person visits.” [Families Outside staff #2, female]

Contact

Email: justice_analysts@gov.scot

Back to top