Prison visitor centres and support services review: main report
This report presents the first full independent review of Scottish Government-funded Prison Visitors' Centres (PVCs) and support services in Scotland.
Appendix B. Rapid evidence and management information synthesis (WP1)
Introduction
This appendix provides supplementary assurance for the WP1 evidence map and gap analysis in the main report. It explains what evidence was reviewed, how judgements were made, and what the evidence can and cannot support. It does not reproduce the full evidence register, decision log or coded extraction workbook; those working materials are retained by the study team for audit if required.
The appendix is included to support transparency for the commissioner. It should be read as an audit note rather than a second findings chapter.
|
Evidence source |
What it contributed to WP1 |
Main limitation for interpretation |
|---|---|---|
|
Establishment-level funding, progress and evaluation packs (12) |
Local evidence on planned activity, reported delivery, provider learning, feedback/case examples and locally claimed outcomes. |
Outcome measures and reporting detail varied across establishments and providers. |
|
National policy, strategy and guidance documents (6) |
National expectations, logic model, performance framework, intended outcomes and service standards. |
These documents define intent and expectations; they do not evidence delivery or impact. |
|
National MI / monitoring reports (3) |
Aggregated information on activity, interactions, support categories and selected national themes. |
Useful for scale and activity, but commonly interaction-based rather than person-based. |
|
Transition / closure report (1) |
Context on continuity, mobilisation, provider change and risks during service change. |
Specific to one service/context and not generalisable without primary research. |
|
Outcome area |
Commonly claimed in documents |
Usually evidenced or tracked in WP1 |
|---|---|---|
|
Visitor experience |
Families feel welcomed, safer, better informed and less stressed when visiting. |
Activity descriptions, visitor feedback, reassurance/information activity and immediate experience examples. |
|
Family contact and relationships |
PVCs reduce barriers to contact and support better quality contact between families and people in custody. |
Visit/contact support activity, FCO links, bonding/family visit examples and narrative accounts. Contact quality itself was not consistently measured. |
|
Children and young people |
Children have a more child-friendly visit experience and are better supported to maintain contact. |
Child-friendly spaces, play provision, activity packs, children's visits and family activities. Child-reported outcomes were limited. |
|
Access to advice, information and practical support |
Families are better able to access support for practical, emotional, financial and wider needs. |
Information, signposting, referral and practical support activity. Take-up and downstream benefit were less consistently tracked. |
|
Family voice and system responsiveness |
Families can raise issues and influence prison practice or service improvement. |
Feedback mechanisms, comments, forums, advocacy examples and issue escalation. The full issue to action to outcome trail was inconsistent. |
This distinction between claimed and tracked outcomes is central to WP1. It means the evidence base is useful for describing activity and plausible contribution, but should not be read as proof of impact.
|
Assurance question |
WP1 position |
|---|---|
|
Can the evidence describe what PVCs do? |
Yes. The evidence base was sufficient to identify a recognisable set of PVC activities and describe local variation. |
|
Can the evidence describe activity scale? |
Partially. MI and reports evidence substantial activity and support interactions but counting rules and coverage vary. |
|
Can the evidence count unique people, families or children supported? |
Not consistently. National MI should generally be treated as activity or interaction data unless a unique-person method is explicitly stated. |
|
Can the evidence identify intended outcomes? |
Yes. Intended outcomes are visible in national guidance, applications and reporting templates. |
|
Can the evidence show outcomes consistently across sites? |
Partially. Evidence is strongest for outputs and immediate visitor-facing support, and weaker for longer-term outcomes. |
|
Can the evidence prove impact? |
No. WP1 supports plausible contribution claims, not causal attribution or comparative effectiveness. |
National MI interpretation
National MI was treated as evidence of activity volume and support interactions, not as a complete national count of unique people, unique families, children supported, outcomes or impact. Where figures are used elsewhere in the review, they should be interpreted as activity or interaction counts unless explicitly defined otherwise.
- Counting rules were not always specified consistently, particularly for interactions versus individuals and unique versus repeat contacts.
- Coverage was not always complete across all funded services for every reporting period.
- Activity/output fields were more consistently populated than outcome, child-specific and equity fields.
- Local workbooks and templates sometimes adapted national reporting formats, which limited like-for-like comparison.
Key decision rules used in WP1
To keep findings proportionate, WP1 applied a small number of consistent decision rules when reviewing and coding evidence:
- National guidance and strategy documents were treated as evidence of intent, standards and logic, not as evidence of delivery or effectiveness.
- Provider self-assessment was treated as valid descriptive evidence, but not as causal proof of outcomes.
- Qualitative examples and case studies were retained as evidence of experience and plausible contribution, with attribution limits noted.
- National MI was included as activity and output evidence, but not used on its own to rate outcome impact.
- Provider transitions and mobilisation periods were treated as contextual factors affecting interpretation, not as evidence of provider failure or success.
- Evidence gaps were treated as limitations in measurement and documentation, not as indicators that PVC activity was absent or ineffective.
How the WP1 evidence gaps were derived
Evidence gaps were identified through repeated coding notes across the evidence register, national MI review, evidence map and analytic decision log. Gaps were prioritised where they appeared across more than one source, affected cross-establishment comparability, limited interpretation of activity-outcome links, or identified areas where later work packages needed to add primary evidence.
Audit trail and retained materials
The full evidence register, detailed decision log and coded evidence map are retained by the study team as working audit materials. They are not reproduced in full in this appendix to avoid duplicating extraction material and document-level analytic notes. They provide a traceable route from WP1 judgements back to source documents if required.
Contact
Email: justice_analysts@gov.scot