Prison visitor centres and support services review: main report

This report presents the first full independent review of Scottish Government-funded Prison Visitors' Centres (PVCs) and support services in Scotland.


Appendix G. Qualitative themes and examples (people in custody)

This appendix provides supplementary qualitative evidence from interviews with people in custody beyond the summary provided in the Part 1 Main Report at Chapter 5. The first table supports the main themes used in the ‘Perspectives of people in custody’ chapter. The second table captures other salient supplementary themes identified during the analysis.

Quotes are verbatim extracts from people in custody and are attributed using participant IDs.

Table G1. Consistent people in custody themes

Main Theme: Family contact is central to stability, identity and connection

Qualitative Examples:

Subthemes reflected: contact as coping and survival; parenting, grandparenting and family identity; visits as valued but emotionally difficult.

"Visits are the only thing which sometimes keep people stable enough to want to live for another day." [Person in custody #7, male]

"If your family's okay, you're okay." [Person in custody #1, male]

"Before I came into prison, I was chaotic, so it's like I've got my bond back with my kids and my mum and dad and my grandson." [Person in custody #23, female]

"Just keeping in touch keeps you more motivated." [Person in custody #10, male]

"My wife and I want to make sure that my son knows that he's still loved, my wife and I love each other, he's from a two-parent, stable, loving family despite our circumstances." [Person in custody #15, male]

"Every time visitors leave and all that, you just feel terrible... it would mess up my full week." [Person in custody #10, male]

Main Theme: Family contact can be difficult to maintain

Qualitative Examples:

Subthemes reflected: geography, transport and transfer location; cost and phone charges; booking, timing and communication; family health, age, disability and caring responsibilities.

"She travels a long distance. She's 100 miles away. She has two trains and a bus to get here and back again. So it's a total of six hour round trip." [Person in custody #8, male]

"My family is too far away to visit, but I've got a friend who comes up and visits me." [Person in custody #2, male]

"Money on the phone, it's too much... you're getting a couple of hours at £20 on the phone." [Person in custody #19, male]

"How are you meant to order yourself toiletries, food, keep yourself going and have contact with your family? It's impossible." [Person in custody #18, male]

"Timing is a big problem here... Your visitors are in the hall... so it's stress again everywhere." [Person in custody #1, male]

"She'll not go shopping if there are too many people there... Point blank. But I understand." [Person in custody #1, male]

Main Theme: Child-focused visits are essential but limited

Qualitative Examples:

Subthemes reflected: ordinary visits not working well for children; PLCs, bonding and children's visits enabling normal parenting; short, limited or uncertain provision; age-appropriate and sensory-aware provision; food, play and small gestures; PVC, FCO and family-support staff helping create supportive conditions around some child-centred visits where visible.

"A standard visit, you have to sit down. It's a very busy room... they're not allowed to stand up, they're not allowed to move around the room and play." [Person in custody #15, male]

"When you get children visits... you're actually allowed to get up and walk about with them and play games with them, eat some snacks. It's just kind of normal." [Person in custody #24, female]

"You get to get up and run about with the kids, play games with the kids... It's such a lot healthier." [Person in custody #20, male]

"For me, 45 minutes away your child to me is criminal." [Person in custody #18, male]

"Because you go from an infant, some kids just want to play and draw, and then you go to the older kids, they want to maybe run about and play." [Person in custody #12, male]

"Someone say, 'Oh, you've had a haircut,' to my son or, 'You're saying a new word'... those little, small acts of kindness are so important for all of us." [Person in custody #15, male]

Main Theme: PVCs, FCOs and other family-support staff act as relational bridges

Qualitative Examples:

Subthemes reflected: PVCs reducing anxiety; FCOs and support staff repairing system failures; support extending beyond visits; uneven awareness and direct access.

"It's a good experience for my wife. It's a huge comfort." [Person in custody #8, male]

"My little boy absolutely loves it over in there... He's already had a good time. Before he even gets in here." [Person in custody #24, female]

"They come and they get into the centre, they're more relaxed... they'll destress from their travel with a tea or a juice." [Person in custody #20, male]

"If that wasn't for the FCO stepping in, the jail just would have sent my kids and [ex-partner] away." [Person in custody #18, male]

"There's never a time when [Names of PVC staff], they won't come and see you or try and help you with whatever it is." [Person in custody #10, male]

"I only know the centre as a place to rest. I don't know anything else much about it." [Person in custody #20, male]

Main Theme: Visit quality depends on dignity, consistency, staff culture and environment

Qualitative Examples:

Subthemes reflected: visitor treatment and staff tone; consistency, clear rules and communication; physical and material environment; surveillance and security practices.

"You don't treat prisoners’ families like prisoners... they haven't done anything wrong and they have their own pressures and tension and they have their own anxiety coming for visits." [Person in custody #7, male]

"See when your visitors come in, they shouldn't be getting treated as criminals." [Person in custody #1, male]

"It should be uniform all the way down... You need to know where you're at." [Person in custody #2, male]

"The visit hall's quite compact, so there's not much movement in here... there's not very much space for them to run around." [Person in custody #12, male]

"They're making you more conscious of how you interact with your bairns, so it's not quite as relaxed as what it could be or it should be." [Person in custody #16, male]

"Fair enough, there is folk that chance their arm... but there is folk in here, all they want is to see their family, and you cannae treat everybody the same way." [Person in custody #1, male]

Several accounts also described structured groups, parenting classes, recovery support, peer support and other forms of practical help that sat alongside visits and family contact. These are reported separately below because they extend beyond the main visit-focused themes.

Table G2. Additional people in custody themes

Main Theme: Parenting classes and fatherhood groups extend family work beyond visits

Qualitative Examples:

"They've started a programme thing. You go up on a Monday and a Thursday, for fathers to come up with ideas, baking, and things like that." [Person in custody #6, male]

"It's just trying to help people to be better fathers or help them to cook, just things like that." [Person in custody #6, male]

"In the parenting class we were allowed to be vulnerable because we knew them... it was a real support group as well as being a class about parenting." [Person in custody #15, male]

Main Theme: Recovery, release and practical throughcare groups provide support beyond contact

Qualitative Examples:

"It's a six weeks course. It was all different stuff each week." [Person in custody #9, male]

"[PVC staff member] was telling us the help you could get when you get out and all that." [Person in custody #9, male]

"She goes to appointments with you and all that, if you need her to go with you." [Person in custody #9, male]

"Get the housing sorted." [Person in custody #9, male]

Main Theme: Peer support groups, listeners and mutual help are part of the support ecology

Qualitative Examples:

"Brilliant. Brilliant. It was a heavy lifesaver for me it was." [Person in custody #10, male]

"I went in and I spoke to the boys, and I talked to them about what I got from the group and maybe they should just stick in at it and all that." [Person in custody #10, male]

"The Listeners are a good thing. The [PVC], they're a good thing." [Person in custody #2, male]

Main Theme: Wider groups and courses support reflection, change and family reassurance

Qualitative Examples:

"This is like a respite from my crazy life outside to coming in here and being able to go to these groups, grow, see that I've had problems that I didn't actually know I had." [Person in custody #24, female]

"I've done community safety; so, all different things, I've done anti-bullying, hate crime, domestic violence, domestic abuse." [Person in custody #19, male]

"Because everyone sees it like, it's a big, bad place, but there are people that actually help you in here." [Person in custody #19, male]

Main Theme: Managing what children are told about imprisonment

Qualitative Examples:

"So she doesn't know I'm in prison, she just thinks this is my work, but now, she's 11 now." [Person in custody #6, male]

"We're having the conversation with her; we were hoping to try and get out of it, without telling her, but it's not going to happen." [Person in custody #6, male]

Main Theme: People in custody actively contribute to improving family-contact and spaces

Qualitative Examples:

"We were making Mother's Day cards there, and then... we bake." [Person in custody #6, male]

"I don't mind buying stuff [toys for all] and handing it in for people." [Person in custody #6, male]

"I work in the shop. I serve the... wives, girlfriends, mother, fathers, sons, daughters." [Person in custody #2, male]

“Working here, with the general public, is my escapism. So, it takes me away as if – so I’m not in prison. I’m at work.” [Person in custody #12, male]

Main Theme: Contact is used to reassure family about wellbeing and change

Qualitative Examples:

"It's good to let them know, that they can tell with talking to me and all that, that I'm not back on drugs and that." [Person in custody #10, male]

"It tells them that I'm in here, I'm alright, I'm doing alright." [Person in custody #19, male]

"That's all I can do you know provide support from here." [Person in custody #7, male]

Main Theme: Shame, guilt and embarrassment shape how contact is experienced

Qualitative Examples:

"You feel guilty for having to bring them here and see me." [Person in custody #1, male]

"I feel [expletive] horrible about it, you having to come up here on a Sunday morning." [Person in custody #1, male]

"It's almost embarrassing bringing them into here." [Person in custody #18, male]

Contact

Email: justice_analysts@gov.scot

Back to top