Prison visitor centres and support services review: main report

This report presents the first full independent review of Scottish Government-funded Prison Visitors' Centres (PVCs) and support services in Scotland.


Appendix A. Research design and methods

1. Methodological approach

The Review examined the nature and contribution of Scottish Government-funded Prison Visitors’ Centres and support services and considered options for their future development. It was not designed to rank providers or compare the effectiveness of different local models. PVCs operate within prisons that differ in population, geography, physical estate, security arrangements and visiting regimes. Services also vary in their location, facilities, staffing, opening hours, provider arrangements and access to additional resources. These differences were treated as important contextual conditions rather than as the basis for a comparative evaluation.

The Review addressed four themes. These concerned how PVCs and support services were delivered in practice, the strengths and challenges arising from experience to date, practical options for future support, organisation and funding, and the extent to which provision promoted equality and upheld children’s rights. A mixed-method, theory-based evaluation design was used to bring together documentary evidence, management information (MI), surveys, qualitative interviews and focus groups, observations of the visitor journey and stakeholder co-interpretation workshops.

The study was organised through five overlapping work packages. Evidence gathered through the earlier work packages informed the design and interpretation of the later stages. This allowed the Review to move from mapping intended and reported provision, through testing the proposed programme logic, to developing an integrated account of how PVCs contributed to outcomes and the conditions affecting that contribution.

2. Contribution Analysis

Contribution Analysis was selected as the overarching evaluation framework. It belongs to a wider group of theory-based approaches developed to assess complex programmes and systems where change cannot be understood through a simple relationship between one intervention and one outcome (Dart, 2004). Its origins lie principally in the work of Mayne, who developed the approach to address situations where experimental designs, comparison groups or other methods of establishing a counterfactual were impractical or inappropriate (Mayne, 2001, 2011, 2012).

Contribution Analysis does not seek to demonstrate that a programme caused an outcome independently of other influences. It instead examines whether the available evidence supports a credible and sufficiently evidenced account of how the programme contributed to change. This requires evaluators to identify the programme’s Theory of Change, gather evidence about whether the proposed activities and mechanisms operated, consider the influence of context and alternative explanations, and revise the resulting contribution or performance story accordingly.

Although Contribution Analysis is distinct from realist evaluation, it shares the realist concern with understanding what works, for whom, in what circumstances and through which mechanisms (Pawson and Tilley, 2004). It is especially useful where provision involves several organisations and where outcomes depend on the combined effect of service activity, institutional arrangements and wider social conditions. Previous applications have shown its value in analysing complex policy and service systems involving multiple actors and levels of influence (Livingston, Madoc-Jones and Perkins, 2020; Livingston et al., 2025). Its growing use within health and social care evaluation has also been documented through a recent scoping review (Buetti et al., 2024).

This approach was appropriate for the PVC Review because there was no single, standardised PVC intervention and no equivalent group of families who could provide a credible comparison condition. Provision was already established across Scotland and operated alongside prison processes, Families Outside and wider statutory and third-sector services. Families’ experiences and outcomes were also shaped by travel, cost, health, caring responsibilities, family relationships, prison regimes, staff practice and the availability of other forms of support. Immediate experiences of visiting could be closely connected to PVC activity, but family contact, wellbeing, stability and reintegration were influenced by a much wider combination of factors.

Contribution Analysis therefore allowed the Review to distinguish between outcomes according to their proximity to PVC activity. Immediate outcomes included whether families felt welcomed, informed, reassured and better able to navigate visiting. Intermediate outcomes included child- and family-sensitive contact, problem-solving, family voice, safeguarding awareness and connection with wider support. Longer-term outcomes included family wellbeing, stability and reintegration. The latter outcomes could plausibly be supported by PVC activity but could not reasonably be attributed to PVCs alone.

Mayne’s six stages provided the organising structure for the evaluation:

1. Set out the cause-and-effect issue or attribution problem to be addressed.

2. Develop the proposed Theory of Change and identify the risks and assumptions associated with it.

3. Gather the existing evidence relating to the Theory of Change.

4. Assemble and assess the initial contribution or performance story and identify challenges to it.

5. Gather additional evidence needed to test or strengthen the account.

6. Revise the contribution story and test its validity with relevant participants and stakeholders.

These stages were applied iteratively rather than as a wholly linear process. Work package (WP)1 mapped the existing evidence and identified where claims were based mainly on intended activity, provider reporting or incomplete management information. WP2 refined the existing PVC programme logic into an evaluation Theory of Change and logic model. These early stages established a provisional account of the activities, mechanisms and outcomes that required further examination. The surveys, qualitative fieldwork and observations undertaken through WP3 and WP4 then generated additional evidence, while the WP5 workshops were used to challenge interpretations, consider alternative explanations and identify wording that risked overstating the evidence.

The Theory of Change proposed that PVCs could contribute through three linked functions. They could provide a welcoming and non-stigmatising point of support around visits, help families understand and navigate prison visiting and contact, and identify needs or provide routes into wider support. These functions were expected to contribute most directly to families feeling more settled, informed and able to manage the visiting process. They could also support more constructive family contact where contact was wanted, safe and appropriate.

The model made explicit that these pathways depended on wider conditions. These included staff visibility and continuity, physical space, funding, provider capacity, prison leadership and culture, clear organisational roles, effective relationships between PVC and prison staff, family awareness and trust, and functioning referral and escalation routes. It also recognised possible unintended consequences and risks, including unequal access between establishments, additional financial or emotional pressures associated with visiting, the exclusion of families who did not visit, and tensions between PVC independence and reliance on prison cooperation.

Contribution claims were assessed against the full body of evidence rather than accepted because they appeared within a strategy, funding application or logic model. The analysis considered whether the relevant activity occurred, whether the proposed mechanism was clear, how close the outcome was to PVC provision, whether evidence was repeated across methods or stakeholder groups, and whether contradictory or qualifying evidence was present. It also considered alternative explanations and distinguished evidence of activity from evidence of immediate experience, access to further support or sustained change.

3. Study design and work packages

The Review comprised five connected and partly overlapping work packages. Each work package addressed a different part of the evidence requirement, while also informing the design and interpretation of the others. The documentary review and Theory of Change work established the initial evidence base and evaluation framework. The surveys and qualitative case studies then tested and extended this account using primary evidence from services, families, people in custody and other stakeholders. The final workshops were used to challenge the emerging interpretation and develop practical options for the future.

WP1 involved a rapid evidence and management information synthesis. The research team reviewed available national and establishment-level material, including relevant policy and strategy documents, PVC funding applications, progress and evaluation reports, the existing programme logic model and available management information. The purpose was to establish what PVCs were expected to provide, what activities were reported as being delivered, what outcomes were claimed and what evidence was available to support those claims. The synthesis distinguished evidence of policy intention from evidence of delivery, reported experience and outcomes. It also examined how activity and reach were recorded and identified gaps in the existing evidence base, including inconsistencies in definitions, counting practices and outcome measurement. These findings provided a baseline for the Review and identified areas requiring further examination through the primary research.

WP2 focused on developing the evaluation Theory of Change and logic model. A short-life working group was convened to review and refine the pre-existing PVC programme logic model developed with support from Evaluation Support Scotland. Two meetings were held, involving five stakeholders across the sessions. Participants considered the principal functions of PVCs, the mechanisms through which these activities might contribute to change, the sequence of immediate, intermediate and longer-term outcomes, and the assumptions and external conditions affecting delivery. The resulting evaluation Theory of Change and logic model were used as analytical tools rather than as statements of proven effectiveness. They informed the questions included in the surveys and qualitative topic guides, helped identify the evidence needed to test the proposed pathways and provided the framework through which the final PVC contribution story was assessed.

WP3 comprised two national surveys. The family member and visitor survey gathered broad evidence about respondents’ visiting circumstances, experiences of PVCs and support services, and perceived needs and outcomes. It examined travel and visiting patterns, awareness and use of PVC provision, satisfaction with facilities and support, barriers to asking for or obtaining help, experiences of visiting with children, and access to information, referrals and wider services. The survey combined structured response options with open-text questions and received 198 responses. As participation was voluntary, the results were used to describe the experiences of respondents rather than to make statistically representative claims about all families affected by imprisonment.

The second survey was completed at service level by all 14 funded PVCs and support services. It profiled the national network by collecting information about facilities, staffing, opening hours, activities, child- and family-sensitive provision, accessibility, partnership and referral arrangements, funding, management information and future priorities. The full response from the funded network provided a national overview of current provision, while the small number of services meant that findings were analysed descriptively and were not used to rank providers or compare effectiveness between different models.

WP4 involved multi-site qualitative case studies across nine prisons. The sites were selected purposively to reflect variation within Scotland’s custodial estate and PVC network. The sample included different prison populations and functions, urban and more rural settings, different provider arrangements and variation in the location and physical form of PVC provision. One establishment associated with each of the nine PVC provider organisations was included. The purpose was not to produce a statistically representative sample, but to examine how PVC provision and the proposed contribution pathways operated across contrasting settings.

Semi-structured individual and group interviews explored experiences of prison visiting, the support provided by PVCs, the mechanisms through which that support became accessible and the local conditions affecting delivery. Participants included 22 family members, 24 people in custody or with direct experience of custody, 28 PVC provider staff or volunteers, 16 prison staff and 14 Families Outside staff. Topic guides were adapted for each stakeholder group but covered common areas including the visitor journey, information and practical support, family contact, child-focused visiting, equality and accessibility, wider family needs, referrals, advocacy, safeguarding, partnership working, staffing, funding and future priorities. The semi-structured format ensured that comparable issues were considered across the case studies while allowing participants to raise experiences and concerns that had not been anticipated by the research team.

The qualitative fieldwork was supplemented by non-intrusive observations of the visitor journey at all nine sites. A common observation framework was used to examine arrival at the establishment, the visibility and accessibility of PVC provision, entry and security processes, waiting arrangements, facilities, information and signage, staff presence, child-friendly and sensory resources, and movement between the PVC, security and visit areas. These observations provided contextual evidence about how spaces and procedures operated in practice. They were not used to assess individual staff performance or record private conversations.

WP5 comprised two online co-interpretation and option-building workshops. The first workshop involved seven participants and the second involved nine. Emerging findings and provisional contribution claims were presented to stakeholders involved in PVC funding, coordination, prison delivery and family support, alongside family or lived-experience representation where available. The workshops were used to test whether the emerging interpretation reflected participants’ experience, identify gaps or alternative explanations, examine areas of disagreement and challenge wording that risked overstating the evidence. Participants also considered the feasibility and likely implications of different options for future support, organisation and funding.

The workshops informed the final analysis and recommendations but did not replace the independent assessment of the research team. Consensus was not required, and no stakeholder group was able to approve or reject findings. Instead, the workshops provided an additional source of challenge and contextual interpretation, helping to strengthen the connection between the evidence, the Contribution Analysis and the practical recommendations arising from the Review.

4. Analysis and integration

Survey data were exported from Jisc Online Surveys and prepared and checked in RStudio. Single-choice and rating questions were summarised using counts and percentages. Multiple-response questions were reported according to the number and proportion selecting each option. Percentages were based on the number answering each question and could exceed 100 where more than one response was permitted. Open-text responses were reviewed thematically and used to explain or qualify the structured findings.

Qualitative interviews, focus groups and observation notes were analysed thematically using a structured framework approach. The initial analytical framework was informed by the four review themes, the Theory of Change, the WP1 evidence gaps and the stakeholder topic guides. Further codes and themes were developed where additional patterns or explanations emerged from the data. Each stakeholder dataset was initially considered separately to preserve differences in perspective before findings were compared across groups and sites.

The cross-work-package synthesis examined convergence and divergence across documentary evidence, management information, surveys, qualitative accounts and observations. Triangulation was used as a means of cross-checking interpretations and strengthening analytical confidence, while recognising that different methods and participant groups provided different forms of knowledge rather than interchangeable accounts (Bryman, 2016). Differences were treated as findings in their own right. For example, provider accounts of signposting and referral activity were considered alongside evidence from families and Families Outside about whether referral routes were visible, routinely used and followed through.

An evidence-alignment matrix was used to maintain a clear connection between source material, stakeholder findings, cross-cutting themes, contribution claims and recommendations. Findings that recurred across independent evidence sources received greater analytical weight, although frequency alone did not determine importance. Lower-frequency evidence was retained where it identified a significant risk, an important minority experience or a condition affecting whether provision worked.

The integrated evidence was then assessed against the Theory of Change. This produced a graded performance story rather than a binary judgement of effectiveness. Contribution was judged to be most strongly supported where activities and outcomes were closely connected, mechanisms were clear and similar evidence appeared across several sources. Claims were expressed more conditionally where outcomes depended heavily on prison cooperation, referral pathways, wider services or individual circumstances. Longer-term outcomes were described as plausible contributions only where the Review could not establish a direct or sustained effect.

5. Ethics, safeguarding and governance

Primary research was undertaken through the Edinburgh Napier University ethical review process [reference ID1463, 17/12/2025] and the relevant Scottish Prison Service research-access and governance arrangements. The study was conducted in accordance with relevant professional guidance and the requirements of the Data Protection Act 2018 and UK General Data Protection Regulation.

Participation was voluntary. Participants received accessible information about the Review, what participation involved, how their data would be used and the limits of confidentiality. Informed consent was obtained before interviews and focus groups. Participants could decline questions, pause or end an interview without adverse consequences. People in custody were informed explicitly that participation would not affect their treatment, privileges, sentence management or access to services.

The research addressed potentially sensitive experiences involving imprisonment, family separation, stigma, financial pressure, relationships and safeguarding. Data collection was therefore trauma-sensitive and sought to protect participants’ safety, dignity and choice. Topic guides focused on visiting and support rather than requiring detailed accounts of offences or trauma. Participants were reminded that they did not need to discuss anything they found uncomfortable, and information about relevant support was available where needed.

Participants were informed that confidentiality might be limited where information indicated an immediate or serious risk of harm. Any such concern was managed through agreed project and establishment safeguarding procedures. The study did not assume that family contact was necessarily positive or appropriate and remained attentive to domestic abuse, coercion, child and adult protection and circumstances in which contact was unwanted or unsafe.

Interviews and focus groups were audio-recorded where consent was provided and transcribed for analysis. Direct identifiers were removed and participant codes were used in working files and reporting. Potentially identifying details were removed or altered where necessary, particularly where a participant held a distinctive role or described unusual circumstances. Data were stored securely with access restricted to authorised members of the research team.

The WP2 working group and WP5 workshops provided stakeholder involvement at key stages of theory development and interpretation. Their role was advisory. Stakeholder feedback was used to test the relevance and credibility of emerging findings, but participants were not required to reach consensus and did not approve the final conclusions. Responsibility for the design, analysis and reporting remained with the independent research team.

6. Strengths and limitations

The Review achieved coverage of all 14 funded services through the provider survey and examined nine contrasting prisons in qualitative depth. It combined evidence from family members, people in custody, PVC providers, prison staff and Families Outside staff with documentary material, management information and direct observation. The Theory of Change made the assumptions underpinning PVC provision explicit, while Contribution Analysis supported a transparent distinction between service activity, immediate outcomes, conditional pathways and longer-term outcomes.

The findings should nevertheless be interpreted within the limits of the design. The qualitative case studies did not cover every funded service and the Review was not designed to compare providers or establish the relative effectiveness of different models. The family survey relied on voluntary, non-probability participation and should not be regarded as statistically representative of all families affected by imprisonment. Families who attended prisons or already used PVC services were more visible than those who did not visit, visited rarely or did not engage with support.

The Review did not collect primary evidence directly from children and young people, and conclusions about their experiences relied mainly on adult accounts. Existing management information also varied in definition, coverage and quality. Interaction figures could not always be interpreted as counts of unique people, while information about equality, contact quality, referral follow-through and sustained outcomes remained limited. The Review did not include longitudinal follow-up, a comparison group or linked administrative outcome data. It could therefore assess the credibility and strength of PVC contribution but could not attribute longer-term family, wellbeing or reintegration outcomes directly to PVC provision.

References (Appendix A)

Bryman, A. (2016). Social Research Methods. 5th ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Buetti, D., Fitzgerald, M., Barber, C., et al. (2024). The use of Contribution Analysis in evaluating health interventions: A scoping review. Evaluation & the Health Professions. https://doi.org/10.1177/01632787241281745

Dart, J. (2004). Six normative approaches to evaluation. Clear Horizon.

Livingston, W., Madoc-Jones, I. and Perkins, A. (2020). The potential of Contribution Analysis to alcohol and other drug policy strategy evaluation: An applied example from Wales. Drugs: Education, Prevention and Policy, 27(3), 183–190. https://doi.org/10.1080/09687637.2019.1645093

Livingston, W., Perkins, A., Holloway, K., Murray, S., Buhociu, M. and Madoc-Jones, I. (2025). Final report: Review of the introduction of minimum pricing for alcohol in Wales. Cardiff: Welsh Government, GSR Report 80/2024.

Mayne, J. (2001). Addressing attribution through Contribution Analysis: Using performance measures sensibly. Canadian Journal of Program Evaluation, 16, 1–24.

Mayne, J. (2011). Contribution Analysis: Addressing cause and effect. In R. Schwartz, K. Forss and M. Marra, eds. Evaluating the Complex. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers, pp. 53–96.

Mayne, J. (2012). Contribution Analysis: Coming of age? Evaluation, 18(3), 270–280.

Pawson, R. and Tilley, N. (2004). Realist Evaluation. London: Cabinet Office.

Contact

Email: justice_analysts@gov.scot

Back to top