Prison visitor centres and support services review: main report

This report presents the first full independent review of Scottish Government-funded Prison Visitors' Centres (PVCs) and support services in Scotland.


Chapter 10. Discussion

Introduction

This chapter interprets the evidence from across the Review through the Contribution Analysis framework. It assesses the ToC developed through WP2 against the evidence gathered through WP1, WP3 and WP4, and refined through the WP5 co-interpretation and option-building workshops. Chapter 9 provides the cross-cutting synthesis on which this discussion builds.

The chapter considers where the contribution of PVCs is strongly supported, where it depends on particular conditions and where it remains plausible but cannot be established through the available evidence. It then discusses the implications against the four Scottish Government review themes.

Overall, the Review supports a well-evidenced but appropriately qualified contribution story. PVCs make their clearest contribution to the immediate visiting experience by helping make it more welcoming, understandable and manageable. Their contribution to child- and family-sensitive contact, wider support, advocacy, safeguarding and constructive interactions is more conditional. Longer-term contributions to wellbeing, family stability and reintegration remain plausible but indirect and cannot be attributed directly to PVCs.

The contribution made by PVCs

The evaluation LM, discussed in Chapter 3, sets out the pathways through which PVC activities are expected to contribute to immediate, intermediate and longer-term outcomes. The evidence supporting each part of this contribution story is considered below.

Making the immediate visiting experience more welcoming and manageable

The strongest evidence concerns the immediate experience around prison visits. Across the Review, families valued having somewhere to pause, settle children, obtain refreshments, ask questions and prepare before entering the prison. People in custody, providers and prison staff also described benefits where families arrived calmer, better informed and more able to manage the visit.

This contribution is delivered mainly through practical and relational support. A respectful welcome, visible staff, informal reassurance, and responsive help can reduce some of the uncertainty and emotional pressure associated with visiting. These interactions may be brief and difficult to capture through formal outcome measures, but were consistently identified as central to the value of PVC provision.

The contribution has clear limits because the visiting experience extends beyond the PVC. Travel, cost, booking, waiting, security, prison communication, the visit room and departure can all affect how families experience contact. In some establishments, families encounter prison staff or security before reaching PVC provision. In others, limited opening hours, unsuitable space or the absence of PVC staff restrict the support available.

The ‘soft landing’ described in the ToC should not be understood as covering the whole visitor journey. PVCs can soften the parts of the experience they influence, but cannot fully compensate for disruption, poor communication or difficult treatment elsewhere. The evidence supports a strong contribution to making the immediate visiting experience more welcoming, manageable and humane where families can access visible, trusted and staffed provision.

Helping families understand and navigate prison visiting

The evidence also strongly supports the contribution of PVCs to helping families understand prison visiting and contact arrangements. PVC staff answered questions, explained what to expect, helped with practical arrangements and directed families towards relevant information or assistance. This was particularly valuable for first-time visitors and where prison procedures were unfamiliar or difficult to understand.

PVCs can translate complex institutional processes into information families can use. This may reduce uncertainty, improve preparedness and prevent some avoidable difficulties. Their support can extend beyond in-person visits to information about telephone and video contact, travel assistance and other prison processes affecting families.

This contribution depends on PVC staff receiving accurate and timely information. Where arrangements change, communication is delayed, or booking systems fail, workers may be left explaining or trying to resolve problems they did not create and cannot control. Families may also receive conflicting or outdated advice from prison staff, people in custody, other visitors, and/or online sources.

The evidence therefore supports a strong contribution to understanding and navigation. It does not support a claim that PVCs control the systems that families must navigate. Their effectiveness depends partly on the quality of information and cooperation that they receive from the prison.

Supporting child- and family-sensitive contact

The contribution story is supported, but more conditionally, in relation to child- and family-sensitive contact. Families and people in custody described child-focused visits as enabling more ordinary forms of interaction through movement, play, shared food, physical closeness and practical care. PVC staff, FCOs, prison staff and other family-support workers contributed by preparing spaces, providing resources, reassuring families and resolving practical barriers.

Where suitable provision was available, sufficiently frequent and matched to children’s needs, it could make contact more manageable and recognisably familial. It also allowed people in custody to take a more active parenting or caring role than was possible during ordinary visits.

This contribution was uneven and shared across several services. Visit length, approval processes, prison rules, staffing, physical space and local visiting arrangements affected what children and families could do. Provision appeared less developed for teenagers, neurodivergent children, children experiencing anxiety and some larger families.

The Review also gathered substantially less direct evidence from children than from adult stakeholders. Existing evidence and management information did not provide a consistent national account of children’s views or outcomes. Claims about children’s experiences must therefore remain appropriately cautious.

PVCs can contribute to child- and family-sensitive visiting, but they do not alone determine the quality of family contact or ensure that children’s rights are consistently realised. A rights-based approach requires attention to children’s understanding, voice, safety and individual circumstances. The presence of toys, activities or a play area is not sufficient in itself to establish child-centred practice.

The evidence also qualifies any assumption that maintaining contact is always beneficial. Contact may be highly valued, emotionally difficult, unwanted or unsafe. Contact should therefore be supported where it is wanted, safe and appropriate, with safeguarding and individual circumstances taking priority over any general assumption that more contact is necessarily better.

Connecting families to wider support

The evidence supports the potential for PVCs to connect families with support beyond the immediate visit, but this pathway was not consistently established. Providers described responding to emotional, financial, housing, health, parenting and relationship needs. In some establishments, PVCs operated as bridges to community services or offered wider support directly.

The position of PVCs around prison visits means that staff may encounter families who are not already connected to formal support. Trusted, informal conversations can help needs become visible and provide an opportunity to identify where further help may be available.

The step from identifying a need to receiving appropriate support was less secure. Families Outside staff described few routine referrals from PVCs and substantial local variation in referral arrangements and organisational relationships. The family member survey indicated that receiving information about other services was more common than being formally referred. Existing evidence did not consistently show whether families acted on information, accessed the service, or benefited from it.

The Review therefore supports a conditional gateway contribution. PVCs may help families identify where to go next, make a referral or address an immediate practical problem. It does not show that signposting or referral routinely leads to access or benefit.

This distinction is important in relation to financial hardship. PVCs may help families access travel support, food, clothing, benefits advice, or other practical assistance. This can mitigate some immediate pressures associated with imprisonment and visiting. It should not be presented as evidence that PVCs directly reduce poverty, which is shaped by much wider economic and structural conditions.

A visit-centred model also has an inherent limit to its reach. Families who do not visit, cannot visit or have no ongoing contact with the person in custody may experience substantial imprisonment-related needs but remain outside the usual reach of PVC provision.

Supporting family voice, advocacy and safeguarding

The evidence supports a potential contribution to family voice and advocacy. PVC staff may help families explain a problem, raise a concern, understand a decision or communicate with prison staff. Their independent and non-uniformed position can make them easier for families to approach, particularly where visitors feel anxious about raising issues directly with the prison.

The route from raising an issue to securing action was less consistently evidenced. Families and Families Outside staff described uncertainty about complaints, escalation, and feedback. Existing information records that concerns were raised or discussed more clearly than whether they resulted in a response, resolution, or operational change.

PVCs can therefore strengthen opportunities for family voice, but this depends on safe and visible feedback mechanisms, clear escalation routes and responsive prison partners. Their position also creates a potential tension. Independence is part of what makes PVC staff trusted by families, but their ability to obtain information or resolve problems often depends on maintaining constructive relationships with prison staff.

PVCs may also contribute to safeguarding because families can disclose concerns to independent workers through informal and trusted interactions. The qualitative evidence included examples of staff noticing changes in presentation or family dynamics, responding to distress, and sharing their concerns.

The contribution supported by the evidence is to recognising, recording, and escalating concerns. Responsibility for assessing risk and achieving protection outcomes sits within wider statutory and inter-agency systems. PVCs should not be treated as solely responsible for outcomes they do not control.

A meaningful safeguarding role requires clear responsibilities, appropriate training and supervision, agreed confidentiality arrangements and reliable information-sharing pathways. This includes attention to child protection, adult protection, domestic abuse, coercion and financial pressure.

Supporting constructive interactions at the PVC-prison interface

The evidence supports a cautious pathway from PVC activity to more constructive interactions between families, people in custody and prison staff. Providers and prison staff described PVC workers reducing confusion, resolving practical issues and helping each side understand the pressures experienced by the other. Family members and people in custody described the consequences of these arrangements where problems were either addressed or left unresolved.

Joint working enabled some child-focused visits, family events, practical adaptations and safeguarding responses that neither PVC nor prison staff could deliver independently. Where relationships were strong, information could be exchanged more quickly and family-focused activity was easier to organise.

The evidence does not show that PVCs can repair relationships across the prison system. Their effectiveness depends on timely information, prison cooperation, clear roles and working relationships that can withstand changes in personnel, provider or local leadership.

An unqualified claim that PVCs improve relationships would therefore overstate their influence. A more defensible conclusion is that they can help create conditions for more constructive interactions where the operational interface between the PVC and prison is clear and functional.

Where this interface is weak, support can become dependent on individual relationships, informal problem-solving and local goodwill. The PVC-prison relationship is therefore not simply an organisational issue. It is a central condition affecting what family-facing support can achieve.

Contributing to longer-term wellbeing, reintegration and wider outcomes

The ToC identifies improved wellbeing and reduced harms associated with imprisonment as outcomes to which PVCs may contribute over time. This pathway is plausible. Families described reassurance and reduced immediate stress, whilst people in custody linked family contact with motivation, identity, emotional stability and connection to life outside.

If PVCs make visiting easier to navigate, support safe and appropriate contact, help families manage immediate pressures and connect them to wider assistance, they may strengthen some of the conditions associated with wellbeing, family stability and reintegration. These pathways are meaningful and consistent with the wider policy rationale for supporting families affected by imprisonment.

The Review cannot establish that PVCs produce these longer-term outcomes. Existing monitoring does not demonstrate sustained outcomes or allow change to be attributed to PVC provision alone. The Review did not include longitudinal follow-up, a counterfactual comparison, or outcome data which would be capable of isolating the effect of PVC activity.

Wellbeing and reintegration are shaped by family relationships, housing, income, health, prison experience, sentence planning, community services, and many other factors. Longer-term outcomes should remain within the ToC because they explain the wider relevance of PVC provision. However, their relationship to PVC activity should be described as indirect, mediated, and non-attributable.

Conditions that strengthen or weaken contribution

The contribution of PVCs depends on the conditions in which they operate. Funding and staffing affect opening hours, staff presence, continuity, privacy, child-focused activity and partnership capacity. Physical location affects whether families encounter PVC staff before or after security, whether provision is visible and whether sensitive conversations can take place.

Prison leadership, operational pressures and staff culture affect visiting arrangements, access to reliable information, safeguarding processes and the organisation of child- and family-focused activity. Provider capacity, workforce skills and role clarity shape whether provision extends beyond welcome and information into wider support, advocacy or referral.

Family awareness and trust are also necessary. A service cannot contribute where families do not know it exists, do not encounter staff or do not regard the support as safe and relevant. The availability and accessibility of wider services determine whether needs identified by PVCs can lead to further help.

The Review also confirmed several anticipated risks. Visiting can add financial, practical and emotional strain. Access and provision are uneven. Families who do not visit may remain outside PVC reach. Increased expectations without additional resources may create staff pressure, unmet demand and uncertainty about the core role. Monitoring can become burdensome where it takes time away from direct support without producing useful learning.

These findings do not weaken the case for PVCs. They clarify the boundaries of their contribution and show that their value depends on realistic expectations, proportionate resources and supportive local and national arrangements.

Interpretation against the Scottish Government review themes

Current practice

Current practice is best understood as a recognisable national offer delivered through different local models. Across the prison estate, PVCs commonly provide welcome, information, practical assistance, child-friendly resources, support around contact and routes towards wider help. The balance and intensity of these functions vary according to establishment, provider, physical space, location, staffing and local relationships.

Some PVCs operate primarily as welcome and information points. Others provide broader family support, activities, referrals or community-facing provision. The three support-service models operate differently where a full PVC cannot be accommodated and should not be assumed to provide an equivalent offer.

Local variation is necessary where it responds to differences in prison population, geography, physical estate and family need. It becomes inequitable where access to basic information, dignity, staff support, privacy or child-sensitive provision depends mainly on which establishment a family visits.

The current-practice challenge is therefore not to impose an identical delivery model. It is to establish which elements should be consistently available and which should remain locally adaptable.

Learning

The main learning is that the quality of PVC provision rests as much on relationships as on facilities or formal activities. Families valued staff who were present, approachable, knowledgeable, and non-judgemental. These interactions helped turn information, refreshments, or waiting space into reassurance and usable support. Relational practice is therefore a core delivery mechanism rather than an optional addition. It also explains why apparently similar facilities can function differently depending on staffing, continuity and local culture.

A second lesson is that PVCs are one part of the full visitor journey. Travel, booking, prison communication, security, waiting, visit-room conditions and contact arrangements can strengthen or undermine the support provided by the centre. Positive PVC provision does not necessarily result in a wholly positive visit.

The Review also identifies important limits in current evidence. Monitoring is stronger for activity, facilities and immediate experience than for unique reach, referral follow-through, equality, child and family voice, contact quality or change over time. These are evidence gaps rather than evidence of ineffective provision, but they restrict what can confidently be concluded.

The central learning is that PVC value is relational, immediate and dependent on the wider visiting system. Future development needs to protect this relational role whilst improving the conditions that allow it to be delivered consistently.

Future options

Future decisions should begin with the support and outcomes expected from PVCs rather than organisational structure alone. If services are expected to provide a respectful welcome, reliable information, practical assistance, child-sensitive support and routes to wider help, funding and partnership arrangements need to make these functions possible.

The evidence supports a clearer national core offer combined with purposeful local flexibility. A core offer would describe what families should be able to expect across establishments, whilst local delivery could continue to reflect prison type, geography, population, physical space and community connections.

A consistent offer also requires clearer governance and a stronger PVC-prison interface. The current system involves Scottish Government, SPS, Sodexo, Families Outside, the National PVC Lead, multiple providers and local partners. This distributed arrangement brings different expertise and local knowledge, but can blur responsibility for information, referrals, escalation, safeguarding, monitoring and improvement.

Resourcing needs to be aligned with expectations. Short-term or insufficient funding limits staffing, planning, continuity and coverage. Expanding expectations without matching resources is more likely to increase inconsistency and pressure than to strengthen provision.

Proportionate evidence arrangements are needed. Monitoring should help establish who is reached, what support is provided, whether referrals and concerns are followed through, and where inequalities remain. It should support learning and accountability without placing disproportionate levels of admin on small teams.

Equality and children’s rights

PVCs can reduce some inequalities within the visiting experience but cannot remove the structural barriers that determine who can visit, how often and at what personal or financial cost. Distance, transport, income, disability, health, caring responsibilities, work and prison location all shape access to family contact.

These pressures are unevenly distributed. The same visiting arrangements may be manageable for one family and prohibitive for another. Equality therefore concerns both what happens at the prison and whether families can reach, understand and use the available support.

The Review is less able to represent families who do not visit, visit rarely or have no contact with PVCs. Some may be unable to travel, rely on telephone or video contact, not know that support exists or choose not to maintain contact. A model focused only on people entering PVC spaces will miss part of the population affected by imprisonment.

Children’s rights require more than toys or occasional family activities. Children need information they can understand, suitable spaces and processes, and contact arrangements that allow safe and meaningful interaction. The Review identified positive practice but also variation in visit length, frequency, sensory provision and support for teenagers and children with additional needs.

Direct evidence from children was limited. Future learning should therefore include proportionate and safeguarded ways of understanding children’s experiences without placing inappropriate demands on them.

A rights-based approach must also recognise that family contact is not always wanted, safe or appropriate. PVC independence may help adults and children disclose concerns, but this benefit depends on clear safeguarding responsibilities and trusted routes for action.

Equality, children’s rights, family voice, and safeguarding need to be embedded within expectations, funding, partnership arrangements, workforce support and monitoring rather than left to the capacity or priorities of individual providers.

Overall interpretation

The Review supports the main logic set out in Chapter 3, but the strength of evidence differs across its stages. PVCs make their clearest and most consistently supported contribution by making the immediate visiting process more welcoming, understandable and manageable.

The evidence also supports contributions to child- and family-sensitive contact, wider support, advocacy, safeguarding awareness and constructive interactions. These contributions are more conditional. They require staff presence, suitable space, clear roles, responsive prison relationships, and functioning routes into wider services.

Longer-term effects on wellbeing, reintegration and wider Scottish Government outcomes remain plausible but cannot be attributed to PVCs through this Review. PVCs may help establish practical and relational conditions that support these outcomes, particularly by reducing immediate strain and supporting wanted, safe and appropriate family contact. The appropriate judgement is one of contribution rather than proof of impact.

The central policy question is how to make this contribution more consistent, equitable and sustainable across Scotland. The evidence points towards a clearer national core offer, proportionate and stable resourcing, clearer governance, stronger local partnership, reliable information and referral routes, embedded equality and children’s rights, and a focused evidence framework.

The recommendations that follow address these conditions whilst retaining the flexibility required to respond to different prisons, families and communities.

Contact

Email: justice_analysts@gov.scot

Back to top