Prison visitor centres and support services review: main report
This report presents the first full independent review of Scottish Government-funded Prison Visitors' Centres (PVCs) and support services in Scotland.
Appendix H. Qualitative themes and examples (PVC providers)
This appendix provides supplementary qualitative evidence from PVC provider interviews and survey open-text responses beyond the summary provided in the Part 1 Main Report at Chapter 6. The first table supports the main themes used in the ‘Perspectives of PVC providers’ chapter. The second table captures other salient supplementary themes and detailed practical issues identified during the analysis.
Examples are drawn from interview summaries and open-text survey responses. Interview examples are attributed using participant IDs. Survey examples are attributed using survey response row numbers.
Table H1. Consistent PVC provider themes
Main Theme: Basic provision makes prison visiting more welcoming, dignified and manageable
Qualitative Examples:
“We just take them into the office and make them a wee cuppa, have a wee chat and just try and allay their fears.” [PVC staff #19, female]
“All trauma-informed. Most of it is trauma-informed. But we use a lot of soft lights and just white, clean tables and chairs.” [PVC staff #4, female]
“So there has been a lot of changes and it’s just the colour, the activities, the seating, everything about it.” [PVC staff #17, male]
“One of our visitors said that she comes in to us and when she comes in, she always comes about an hour early and she comes in and she feels as if she can breathe before she goes over.” [PVC staff #5, female]
“We give them a run down of what the procedure is, what’s to be expected for them, what happens when you go across, when you actually go across to the visit room, make sure they’ve got all the relevant documents. Just checking they’re alright as well, because for some visitors, it’s horrendous, depending who they’re coming to see.” [PVC staff #15, female]
"Your environment impacts on how your emotions are and again, it goes back to if you’re feeling comfortable and safe and not dysregulated going across, it all goes back to making people feel welcome and safe and not hungry. Things like, if a child comes in… the amount of children that come through this visitor centre blows my mind, it really does. But if you’ve got… coming from school, put in a car, driven here, it’s really important that you’ve got something to eat when you get here, that you get a drink, that you get a cup of tea." [PVC staff #14, female]
Main Theme: PVCs can provide wider support, although providers differed on the scope of their role
Qualitative Examples:
“I don't limit the team to the support that they can provide to a family.” [PVC staff #5, female]
"There is lots of strands to supporting families, it is not just a place you sit." [PVC staff #14, female]
“We provide emotional support, practical support, monetary support.” [PVC staff #19, female]
“So, it’s taking care of families and the children, safeguarding the children are fine in here as well, that’s another thing.” [PVC staff #15, female]
“I think we can negate a lot of child protection hard issues, because we get in early.” [PVC staff #4, female]
“I kind of see the visitor centre as very much a community centre, because it is a community of sorts, or it’s a number of different communities of sorts. So, there are some things that we can do ourselves and there are some things where we invite other people to come in and use the building, much as you would in any local centre.” [PVC staff #16, male]
“[There are] some programmes that would be nice to run. Some of the prisons are running different programmes. Some of them have got mobiles for when the prisoners come in, and it actually keeps them re-engaging. There's just no… it always comes back to there's no consistency across the board.” [PVC staff #23, female]
Main Theme: Collaborative working with prisons supports visitor and family-focused activity
Qualitative Examples:
“We have an information sharing agreement in place for the prison so we get anything we ask for.” [PVC staff #5, female]
"I think they see the value of us, we work closely with Head of Unit and Visits managers, so they understand what our service is and they appreciate it for what it does for them as well". [PVC staff #12, female]
“It feels very much like a partnership around that kind of stuff, and we can ask for things, and they’ll come to us and ask for advice on things. I think it feels like a really strong relationship.” [PVC staff #16, male]
“I think our practice has influenced it and the wider awareness of the needs of families, that’s the difference.” [PVC staff #4, female]
“If you're in the building of SPS, you're more likely to build better relationships with the staff.” [PVC staff #8, female]
“If not, I’ll do a referral to the family contact officers, and they’ll pick that up later on. That [the limited number of FCOs] can be a challenge at times.” [PVC staff #1, female]
“I cannot stress this enough. Every prison is entirely and absolutely different. You cannot assume that what happens here is what's going to be happening elsewhere.” [PVC staff #23, female]
"I think what we lost over the last year is we used to have a later visit, we used to have a 18:30 visit and a 19:45 – a lot of the families were okay with the later visit going but the 18:30, if you work you can only come at the weekend now really – our last visit is 17:15.” [PVC staff #12, female]
Main Theme: PVCs support child-focused visiting, but provision is constrained by space, prison arrangements and resources
Qualitative Examples:
“Volunteers, they take some arts and crafts out… we try and have toys, have books everywhere.” [PVC staff #15, female]
“[We use] SHANARRI [Safe, Healthy, Achieving, Nurtured, Active, Respected, Responsible and Included] and the GIRFEC [Getting it Right for Every Child] and the UNCRC [United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child] and we’ve got guidance notes for the SPS.” [PVC staff #11, female]
“We've got a tea bar, we've got a space for younger children to play. We've got a teenage area for older kids to hang out in.” [PVC staff #8, female]
"As I say, we’ve got the tablets and things like that through there. I just wish there was a wee bit more for the older kids, to be honest, but I’m trying to get away from the technology. I know that’s what all the kids are into, but we definitely need something for that age." [PVC staff #11, female]
“Unfortunately, I think the timings may not work well because some folks travel longer distances and I think school gets out till 3, 3.30.” [PVC staff #28, female]
“I think there could be more probably but it’s the logistics.” [PVC staff #19, female]
“We're aware there's a lot of children now with ADHD, autism, you know, neurodiverse.” [PVC staff #8, female]
Main Theme: Insufficient and short-term funding constrains staffing, planning and PVC availability
Qualitative Examples:
"It’s the money. I would love to have more staff and do more. If we had the money, we could do a lot more." [PVC staff #14, female]
“We're open Monday through Sunday, but that's only because we've got dedicated volunteers as well.” [PVC staff #8, female]
“It all comes down to money. Staffing… the rota is complicated because we’re open a lot of hours and we don’t have an awful lot of staff. There’s no slack to play with.” [PVC staff #16, male]
“It would be absolutely brilliant if we had more staff and I’m always conscious that when I go off on annual leave, there isn’t anybody.” [PVC staff #1, female]
"We couldn’t do the work that we’re doing if we didn’t have the additional funding coming in. The funding landscape is getting harder and harder every year." [PVC staff #13, female]
“The planning that you can actually make realistically can only be year to year.” [PVC staff #17, male]
“Everybody's working at different objectives, so it does get a bit messy… if you're changing providers, you're never going to get consistency.” [PVC staff #23, female]
Table H2. Additional PVC provider themes
Main Theme: Partnership working
Qualitative Examples:
"So, if it’s a family we think, do you know what, they need support in the community, we will refer them on to Families Outside to get that and then we can work together, and that works really well." [PVC staff #12, female]
“Families Outside are really good at holding the strategy and the framework of it all. But also, they do a drop in once a month for families as well, and we all signpost to Families Outside.” [PVC staff #14, female]
“Lots of partnerships. Six months’ time, I’ll probably give you a different list because somebody will have said something that sparked something that took us to somebody. I think that’s very much the way it is in here. People tell us what they need and then we hear it and see where it takes us all.” [PVC staff #16, male]
“Families Outside, we go to them quite often about the school situations and stuff. They’re great with schools.” [PVC staff #2, female]
“Housing, the addictions team, we’ve got a guy that works at the Jobcentre.” [PVC staff #2, female]
“We have [the Department of Work and Pensions] going up, we have the Smile Team.” [PVC staff #5, female]
“I kind of see myself as like water that kind of goes between lots of different organisations.” [PVC staff #18, female]
Main Theme: Financial impact on families
Qualitative Examples:
“There’s a lot… financial poverty is stunning. So, we do a lot around food, clothing, mostly around donations. So, I’m sure people have explained to you already, so we are linked in with Cyrenians and FareShare.” [PVC staff #16, male]
“And it doesn’t really matter what social status you really have, because if your main breadwinner has gone… we’ve got a lady whose husband was a doctor. She comes to get food parcels. She doesn’t do it when her visit is on, she comes at quiet times. She is still trying to pay the mortgage, but she can’t afford food.” [PVC staff #14, female]
“They’re girls with young children, so they’re having to manage everything outside and then probably no money, having to come in, having to hand money in across there, having to buy clothes across there, and there’s often the girls are like, “I’m going to go in here, it’s going to be annoyed because I haven’t bought these trainers that are £170”. She’s got no money.” [PVC staff #15, female]
"Because it is not really working properly for our visitors up here, but I try to encourage them to fill it in [travel expenses claim] – the problem is they need the money now, they don't need the hassle or have the time to claim it back." [PVC staff #11, female]
“The [travel expenses] scheme itself doesn’t actually work because people take the forms, but they don’t actually…” [PVC staff #4, female]
Main Theme: Supporting families to do ordinary family things
Qualitative Examples:
"We’ll give pamper bags away. Anything again that just makes life a wee bit easier and makes the majority… it’s not just females but the majority are mums as we know and so for them, even to get a wee box of chocolates or a wee pamper bag that’s got a facemask and a bath bomb, anything that just makes people feel a wee bit valued. And some of the feedback we get, some people have said, “I’ve not had a Mother’s Day gift for about six years”, and you just think – oh gosh.” [PVC staff #13, female]
“The mothers will get a pamper pack and at the same time the dads will be making cards and planting sunflower seeds.” [PVC staff #17, male]
“Each gift that we get every Christmas is given from the dad, it's not given from us.” [PVC staff #26, female]
“So, we’ve got Cakes for Kids. So, we’ll order cakes for children’s birthdays. So, every child will get a birthday cake with their dad on a PLC [Play, Learn, Connect session]. That’s core memories, isn’t it?” [PVC staff #14, female]
"It will never be normal having a birthday party in a prison visit room with guards around but getting to have a cake and a laugh and a play with their dad which a few years ago, they might not have done, and it’s a step closer to a normal childhood experience. That’s got to mean something. It’s not going to remove every impact of imprisonment, but it’s got to round over a couple of rough edges." [PVC staff #16, male]
Main Theme: Food and drink in the visiting room
Qualitative Examples:
“There’s no tea bar now. It’s all vending machines, which are really expensive and it really blows my mind how much people spend in vending machines. So, if you go across to the vending machine, you can take ten £1 coins or a bank card… and a bank card, although sometimes… apparently the tap on the bank card is not working at the moment, so people are desperate to get to the vending machines so they can get what they need for the visit to sit down and spend time in the visit.” [PVC staff #14, female]
“But inside the visit room… there used to be an amazing tea bar in there, run by a charity, I can't remember what they were called, but that's been gone for years now.” [PVC staff #8, female]
“So, we’ve got families coming up at seven o’clock at night, and the only thing that they can offer their children is chocolate bars. So, all these kids are eating two chocolate bars, going home at half eight at night and bouncing off the walls.” [PVC staff #3, female]
“There’s a tea bar through there which has not been operational now for a number of years… at the moment, it’s just overpriced vending machines that people can use.” [PVC staff #17, male]
Main Theme: Outcomes
Qualitative Examples:
"If a prisoner's got regular visits, good quality visits, he will be a better prisoner in terms of being managed." [PVC staff #6, male]
“It almost kind of reduces that barrier for them to come and see their dad.” [PVC staff #17, male]
“That wee boy was then in a better place mentally for dad coming home and being back in that environment again.” [PVC staff #1, female]
“I think what happens here enables people to go and have positive visits within the prison and whether that’s about having somewhere to lock your stuff up before you go, or having somewhere quiet where you can sit and get yourself in the zone or somebody you can talk to, or peers or advice or whatever the hell it is, I think what happens here and in visitor centres all across the country, is an important part of people then going in there and having a positive experience.” [PVC staff #16, male]
“But I think what we can do impact-wise is we can hear people, we can represent them. We can get alongside them and support and link people in with organisations.” [PVC staff #16, male]
“It is about prevention and long-term reducing re-offending, but also about reducing the adverse childhood experiences.” [PVC staff #18, female]
"There would be payback for society down the line." [PVC staff #6, male]
“I think that's what Scottish Government really get here is a lot of bang for their buck.” [PVC staff #9, female]
Contact
Email: justice_analysts@gov.scot