Prison visitor centres and support services review: main report

This report presents the first full independent review of Scottish Government-funded Prison Visitors' Centres (PVCs) and support services in Scotland.


Chapter 5: Perspectives of people in custody

  • People in custody described family contact as central to coping with imprisonment, maintaining identity, and staying connected to loved ones.
  • Access to family contact was uneven and affected by travel, timing, phone credit, booking, family circumstances, and prison arrangements.
  • Child-focused visits, including PLCs, bonding visits and children’s visits, were described as essential for more natural family interaction, but often too short, limited, or not reliably accessible.
  • PVCs, FCOs and family-support staff were valued where they made visits calmer, helped families navigate the process, supported children, and resolved practical problems that might otherwise disrupt contact.
  • Visit quality depended on dignity, consistency, staff culture and environment, with people in custody describing family-aware practice (which recognises the family unit) alongside experiences where families felt criminalised or unsupported.

Introduction

This chapter presents the perspectives of people in custody (n=23) and people with direct experience of custody (n=1). The evidence is drawn from accounts collected through the review and is reported together as a combined ‘people in custody’ dataset.

The chapter reports on the following five main themes:

  • family contact as stability, identity and connection;
  • unequal and fragile access to contact;
  • child-centred visits;
  • PVCs, FCOs and family-support staff; and
  • the quality of visits as shaped by dignity, consistency, staff culture and environment.

Further supporting quotations and lower-frequency findings are provided in the Part 2 Supporting Evidence report at Appendix G.

Overview of people in custody’s perspectives

People in custody consistently described visits, telephone calls and video contact as important ways of coping with imprisonment and staying connected to loved ones. Interviewees associated family contact with reassurance, routine, motivation, emotional regulation and continuity with life outside. Contact was also linked to maintaining identities as parents, partners, grandparents and siblings.

Interviewees described access as uneven. Family willingness did not guarantee contact, which could depend on where the person was held, whether relatives could afford or manage the journey, phone credit, visit timings and local arrangements. Several described families making substantial efforts despite financial pressure or uncertainty about whether visits would proceed.

Visit quality was described as depending on staff tone, consistency, privacy, food, comfort and suitability for children. Positive accounts described visits as calm, welcoming and family-aware. Negative accounts included families feeling criminalised, children becoming frightened, contact being shortened or disrupted and ordinary family interaction being constrained by the visit environment.

Family contact is central to stability, identity, and connection

‘The only time you’ll see them functioning or actually motivated enough to change and get ready or to have a shower or whatever is when they have a visit… visits are the only thing which sometimes keep people stable enough to want to live for another day.’ [JD02P-M]

‘If your family’s okay, you’re okay.’ [AP01P-M]

All interviewees described family contact as one of the main ways people in custody coped with imprisonment. Some described visits as something to look forward to or as a break in the routine. Others used stronger language, describing contact as a lifeline, a reason to keep going, or the main connection to ordinary life. For these interviewees, family contact was linked to emotional survival and maintaining a sense of personhood whilst inside.

Family contact was also frequently linked to reciprocal reassurance. Interviewees described wanting to know that family members outside were safe, whilst assuring them that they were coping inside. Phone and video calls were particularly important where physical visits were limited due to family circumstances or barriers. Contact gave people information about home, reduced uncertainty, and helped contain worry about what was happening outside.

The maintenance of family identity was prominent within this theme. Fathers described missing children’s milestones, wanting to remain emotionally present, and relying on child-focused visits to sustain relationships with their children. Mothers and grandmothers described contact with children and grandchildren as central to maintaining family connection. Other interviewees stressed the importance of maintaining their roles as partners, parents, and siblings. Across these accounts, contact preserved family roles that custody had disrupted but not removed – for example, still being ‘a dad’.

Visits were also described as emotionally difficult. Interviewees’ accounts included guilt about their families having to enter prison, sadness after visitors left, painful goodbyes, and anxiety about children’s reactions, which sometimes led people to avoid visits altogether. Contact was therefore reported as both stabilising and painful, supporting connection – but also making separation, missed time, and family strain more visible.

Family contact can be difficult to maintain

‘She travels a long distance. She’s 100 miles away. She has two trains and a bus to get here and back again. So, it’s a total of six hour round trip.’ [JD03P-M]

‘The money on the phone, it’s too much… You’re getting a couple of hours at £20 on the phone.’ [KG01P-M]

People in custody described different levels of practical access to family contact. Almost all interviewees discussed barriers or conditions affecting contact. For some, visits were relatively manageable because family members lived nearby, had access to a car or could attend within existing routines. For others, distance, cost, booking problems, limited phone credit, health needs, caring responsibilities or work patterns made contact more difficult to sustain.

Distance and transfer location were prominent. Interviewees with family nearby described visits as more straightforward, particularly where relatives could drive. Others described journeys involving several hours and multiple forms of public transport. Being held or transferred far from home reduced the frequency and practicality of visits and, in some cases, interrupted contact.

Cost was another recurring barrier. Interviewees described families paying for travel, food, childcare and vending machines. They also described rationing phone credit, email and canteen money. Families on benefits, single parents and households with limited income were reported as having to balance contact with other essential costs.

Visit administration could also disrupt contact. Interviewees described late starts, unclear booking confirmation, rejected requests without explanation, failed virtual visits, families arriving without appearing on the visit list and delays in approving child-focused visits. Poor communication during serious incidents left some families distressed or uncertain. These problems carried particular weight because visits were costly, limited and emotionally important.

Health, caring and household responsibilities often overlapped with these barriers. Interviewees referred to elderly relatives, disability, illness, anxiety, neurodivergent children, single parents managing childcare and family members balancing visits with shift work. Contact was most fragile where several of these pressures occurred together.

Child-focused visits are essential but limited

‘I tried a normal visit with him, but because of how busy the visits are, and he’s not good with crowds, it was not good.’ [JD13P-M]

‘See when your visitors come in for a bonding visit, they’re there giving them all the games and whatever else... I think [PVC provider] are there to answer questions, whereas the officers cannot.’ [AP01P-M]

More than two thirds of interviewees supported this theme. As noted in Chapter 4, the distinction between normal social visits and child-focused visits (i.e. PLCs, bonding visits) was important. Interviewees described normal visits as difficult for children because they required children to remain at a table, manage noise and crowds, and tolerate limited movement or physical contact. This was reported as particularly difficult for toddlers, larger families, and children with neurodivergence, anxiety, or other sensory needs.

Child-focused visits were described as more relaxed than social visits. Interviewees described their joy at walking around with children, playing and reading books, sitting on the floor, making cakes and sharing snacks, holding babies, and responding to children’s movement and play. PVC, FCO and specialist family-support staff (see Table 2 above) were acknowledged as enabling this, preparing games or activity packs, answering questions, engaging with children, helping families arrive more settled, and resolving practical issues. Some described limited or no direct contact with PVC staff however, with support instead provided by FCOs, other prison staff, or specialist family-support staff.

Child-focused visits were described as including soft play and toys, books, sensory rooms, quiet spaces, and age-appropriate activities. Visitors were also able to share food and partake in additional activities for special occasions such as birthdays, Mother’s Day, and Christmas. interviewees described these features as helping children feel settled and giving families something ordinary to do together during the visit.

Limits to child-focused provision were also repeatedly described, including limited spaces, uncertainty, and last-minute updating about PLC allocation, large gaps between available children’s visits, approval delays, and difficulty accommodating larger families. Child-focused visits were also reported as being too short. Forty-five-minute visits were commonly described as insufficient for children to settle, play, and reconnect with the person they are visiting. Several interviewees described even small increases in time as a meaningful improvement for children and parents.

PVCs, FCOs, and other family-support staff act as relational bridges

‘Yes, my little boy absolutely loves it over in there… He’s already had a good time. Before he even gets in here.’ [RF02P-F]

‘If that wasn’t for the FCO stepping in, the jail just would have sent my kids and (ex-partner) away.’ [JD13P-M]

All but one interviewee supported this theme. Interviewees described PVCs, FCOs, and specialist family-support staff as important in making visits calmer and easier to navigate. They described their families being welcomed, given space to settle, offered refreshments, and reassured before entering the prison. Such support was described as both practical and relational.

PVCs were described as useful for before and after visits, giving families a space to rest after travelling, settle children, speak to staff, or ask questions outside of the formal prison setting. Some interviewees described children having a positive experience in the centre before the visit began, which then positively affected the tone of the visit itself.

FCOs and support staff were described as resolving practical problems, including helping with booking and visiting arrangements, travel-expense forms, and responding to concerns. Interviewees described these functions as especially important when ordinary systems did not work smoothly or when families needed someone to explain, chase-up, or correct a problem.

Some interviewees described support provided by PVC staff beyond the visit itself, including parenting and relationship courses, support for alcohol and other drug use, as well as other practical support, relapse prevention, and release planning. These examples were less frequent than visit-specific support but were reported as important where they occurred. Interviewees described this support as helping them prepare for release, manage relationships, access community services, and rebuild routines outside custody.

Visibility and uptake of support were uneven. Some people in custody described their family members as only briefly passing through PVCs, knowing little about what support was available, and the support they offer being perceived as distant from people inside. Other accounts described families knowing support was there but not using it because they felt they did not need it. The dataset showed both strong examples of relational support and examples where support was present but not fully visible or connected.

Visit quality depends on dignity, consistency, staff culture, and environment

‘You don’t treat prisoners’ families like prisoners… they haven’t done anything wrong, and they have their own pressures and tension and they have their own anxiety coming for visits.’ [JD02P-M]

‘It should be uniform all the way down… You need to know where you’re at.’ [AP02P-M]

People in custody described visit quality as depending on the full process rather than the visit room alone. Most interviewees discussed the effects of staff tone, consistency, privacy, facilities or security. Positive accounts described calm, predictable and family-aware practice. Negative accounts described anxiety arising from disrespectful communication, inconsistent rules, intrusive monitoring or poor facilities.

Visitor treatment was a recurring concern. Some interviewees reported families arriving already anxious and becoming more distressed when spoken to as though they had done something wrong. This could generate embarrassment or anger for the person in custody. Other interviewees described prison staff as respectful, helpful and family-aware, recognising children’s needs and resolving access problems rather than only enforcing procedure.

Consistency and communication were also important. Interviewees described preventable confusion after families had made long journeys. Clear and consistently applied processes allowed families to know what to expect and reduced the likelihood of disputes or delays immediately before contact.

The physical environment affected the quality of contact. Interviewees described cramped or noisy rooms, limited space, broken toys, insufficient books, poor food options and uncomfortable seating. Cleanliness and basic facilities shaped whether visits felt family-aware and manageable or institutional and difficult.

Security and surveillance were understood as necessary but experienced differently. Interviewees generally accepted thorough security processes. Some nevertheless felt that staff presence could become intrusive, searches could frighten children and parents could become self-conscious about physical affection or play. Their accounts distinguished accepted security from security experienced as degrading, excessive or disruptive to family contact.

Contact

Email: justice_analysts@gov.scot

Back to top