Prison visitor centres and support services review: main report
This report presents the first full independent review of Scottish Government-funded Prison Visitors' Centres (PVCs) and support services in Scotland.
Executive summary
Purpose and approach
This report presents the first full independent review of Scottish Government-funded Prison Visitors' Centres (PVCs) and support services in Scotland. It covered all 14 funded services, comprising 11 full PVCs and three more limited support services. These independent third-sector services support families alongside formal prison visiting arrangements. For brevity, the report uses the term PVC to refer to all 14 services, whilst recognising that support services do not provide the same offer as full visitor centres.
The Review examined current practice, learning from experience to date, future options for support, organisation and funding, and equality and children's rights. Contribution Analysis was used to assess how and under what conditions PVCs contribute to outcomes. The study combined existing evidence and management information, an evaluation theory of change (ToC), national surveys, qualitative fieldwork and observations across nine prisons, and two co-interpretation workshops. The evidence included 198 family survey responses, service-level responses from all 14 funded services and qualitative accounts from 104 participants.
The Review did not rank providers or compare the effectiveness of delivery models. All services were represented in the provider survey, but not all were included as qualitative case studies. Evidence was stronger for families already visiting prisons or using services than for those who did not. Direct evidence from children was limited, and the study could not directly test longer-term outcomes.
Headline assessment
The Review finds clear and consistent value in PVCs. Their strongest and most consistently evidenced contribution is immediate and practical. They help make prison visiting more welcoming, understandable, and manageable for families navigating an unfamiliar, emotionally demanding, and highly regulated environment. Visible, trusted, and non-judgemental staff provide reassurance, information, practical guidance, and relational support.
PVCs may also contribute to child- and family-sensitive contact, wider family support, family voice, advocacy, safeguarding awareness, and more constructive interactions between families, people in custody, and prison staff. These contributions are more conditional. They depend on staff availability, suitable space, prison leadership and culture, clear organisational roles, effective local relationships, functioning referral and escalation pathways, and wider service availability.
Longer-term contributions to wellbeing, family stability, reintegration, and wider policy outcomes remain plausible but indirect. PVCs may help create some of the conditions associated with these outcomes, particularly by reducing immediate strain and supporting contact where it is wanted, safe, and appropriate. The Review cannot attribute longer-term outcomes directly to PVC provision.
The central strategic conclusion is that Scotland has a valuable PVC and support-service offer, but the surrounding national system is not yet sufficiently consistent, clearly specified, sustainably resourced, or accountable. The priority is to establish national minimum quality standards, align commissioning and funding with those standards, strengthen Scottish Prison Service (SPS) family-contact infrastructure, clarify governance and accountability, and improve evidence and learning whilst preserving justified local flexibility.
Current practice
Scotland has a recognisable PVC and support-service offer, but not a single delivery model. Common functions include welcoming and reassuring visitors, providing information, offering practical and emotional support, creating child-friendly environments, helping address problems affecting contact, connecting families with wider services, working with prison staff, and providing routes for families to raise concerns.
Delivery varies substantially. Services differ in physical space, location before or after security, staffing, opening hours, provider arrangements, prison relationships, access to additional funding, and capacity for wider support. Some mainly provide welcome, waiting space, and information. Others offer individual support, programmes, outreach, or referrals. The three support services operate with more limited provision where a full PVC cannot be accommodated.
Local variation is necessary because prisons and family populations differ. It becomes inequitable where access to basic information, dignity, staff support, privacy, refreshments, child-sensitive provision, or wider help depends mainly on which establishment a family visits. PVCs are part of the practical and relational infrastructure of prison visiting, but they sit within a wider system and do not control the whole experience.
Learning from experience to date
Prison visiting is experienced as a journey rather than as a single interaction in the visit room. Travel, cost, booking, waiting, security, communication, staff interactions, refreshments, the physical environment, and departure can all shape how contact is experienced. PVCs can improve important parts of this journey but cannot control the whole system.
Their clearest contribution is close to the visit itself. Families valued having somewhere to pause, prepare, settle children, ask questions, and receive reassurance. Three quarters of family survey respondents were satisfied or very satisfied with the services provided. The way support is offered matters as much as the facilities available: a physical space alone does not provide the same function where it is unstaffed, poorly understood, or disconnected from the visiting process.
People in custody consistently described family contact as important to coping with imprisonment, maintaining family identity, and staying connected to life outside. Contact could provide reassurance, routine, and motivation, whilst also making separation or family strain more visible. Access was uneven and affected by distance, cost, booking, visit timing, phone credit, work, caring responsibilities, health, disability, and local prison processes. PVCs and other family-facing staff could reduce some barriers but did not determine whether contact was available or of good quality.
Child-focused visits were valued because they enabled more ordinary family interaction through movement, play, shared food, and physical closeness. Provision varied and was constrained by visit length, frequency, staffing, facilities, approval processes, and prison rules. Teenagers, larger families, neurodivergent children, and children experiencing anxiety or additional needs were not always well served.
PVCs can identify needs beyond the visit, including financial, housing, health, emotional, parenting, and relationship difficulties. This gateway role is important but not consistently established. Referral pathways between PVCs, Families Outside, and wider services were uneven, and existing evidence records signposting more clearly than whether families subsequently accessed or benefited from support. Families who do not or cannot visit are also less likely to encounter PVC provision.
The PVC-prison interface is central to what support can achieve. Where relationships and responsibilities are clear, information can be shared, problems resolved ,and family-focused activity organised more easily. Where arrangements are weak, support can depend on individual relationships and local goodwill. Funding and staffing also shape opening hours, continuity, and partnership work. Flat cash funding has reduced the purchasing power of the PVC resource in real terms, whilst current evidence remains stronger for activity and immediate experience than for unique reach, equality, child and family voice, referral follow-through, and sustained change.
Future options for support, organisation and funding
The Review recommends comprehensive national minimum quality standards for prison visiting, PVCs, and support services. These should set out the minimum provision every family can expect, cover the responsibilities of both PVC providers and SPS, and be clearly specified, monitored, and linked to accountability and improvement. The standards should be a floor rather than a ceiling, allowing local services to adapt or exceed them in response to prison population, geography, estate, and family need.
The standards should cover visible independent support during agreed core visiting periods; accurate and accessible information; practical guidance; suitable waiting, toilet and privacy facilities; child- and family-sensitive practice; equality and accessibility; safeguarding; visitor voice and complaints; referral and warm handovers; workforce skills; dedicated family-facing prison capacity; prison-PVC working arrangements; visiting environments and refreshments; and proportionate monitoring and learning.
The current commissioning and provider model should also be formally reviewed. Nine provider organisations deliver across the 14 funded services, alongside national coordination through Families Outside. Scottish Government should appraise whether provider numbers should be reduced and examine national, regional, multi-site, and single-provider options, value for money, duplicated management and administrative overhead, specialist capability, local responsiveness, independence, accountability, and transition risks. The Review does not prescribe a single-provider model; it recommends a transparent appraisal of the options.
The future model should also resolve the ambiguity surrounding Families Outside and the National PVC Lead. The role supports national coordination, providers, and shared learning but does not currently hold all the contractual or performance-management powers that might be assumed from an oversight function. Strategic leadership, coordination, provider support, contract or grant management, performance management, quality assurance, escalation, and formal accountability should therefore be allocated clearly, with responsibility matched by authority.
Expectations must be matched by funding. Scottish Government should review the funding level and mechanism against the actual cost of delivering the minimum standards, including staffing and management costs, coverage of core visiting periods, workforce retention and training, referral and partnership work, evidence requirements, and national coordination. Future arrangements should avoid sustained real-terms erosion and use multi-year funding where possible to support continuity and planning.
SPS has direct responsibility for important parts of the visitor journey and prison-PVC interface. Every Scottish prison should have at least one appropriately trained, dedicated Family Contact Officer (FCO) whose principal responsibility is family contact, with protected capacity and additional provision where prison size or complexity requires it. SPS should also require clear local operating agreements with PVC providers and replace the vending-machine-led refreshments model with reliable, affordable, and healthier food and drink. National oversight should have named ownership, assurance, and escalation routes, supported by a proportionate evidence, quality, and learning framework.
Equality and children's rights
PVCs can reduce some inequalities within the visiting experience but cannot remove the structural barriers affecting family contact. Travel distance, rurality, transport, income, disability, health, neurodivergence, language, digital exclusion, stigma, age, gender, caring responsibilities, and family circumstances all influence whether families can visit, how often, and at what cost. A model centred only on people entering PVC spaces will miss some families who do not visit, visit rarely, rely on telephone or video contact, or do not wish to maintain contact.
Children's rights require more than toys or occasional activities. Children need information they can understand, suitable spaces, and opportunities for safe and meaningful interaction. Positive practice was evident, but provision varied and was constrained by staffing, space, visit length, and prison arrangements. Teenagers, neurodivergent children, and children experiencing anxiety or additional needs require more consistent consideration. Direct evidence from children was limited, strengthening the case for safe and proportionate ways of including their views in future development and monitoring.
A rights-based approach must also recognise that contact is not always beneficial. It may be supportive, emotionally difficult, unwanted, or unsafe. Practice should therefore be guided by whether contact is wanted, safe, and appropriate, with attention to child and adult protection, domestic abuse, coercion, financial pressure, and wider family safety. Equality, children's rights, family voice, and safeguarding should be embedded in the minimum quality standards, commissioning, funding, workforce practice, and evidence framework rather than treated as optional enhancements.
Conclusions and recommendations
The Review supports a well-evidenced but appropriately qualified contribution story. The rationale for PVCs is sound and their immediate value is clear. The principal weakness lies in the infrastructure surrounding delivery. National expectations are not sufficiently specified, funding has diminished in real terms, local arrangements vary, responsibilities are distributed across several organisations, SPS family-contact provision is inconsistent, referral and escalation routes are uneven, and existing evidence does not adequately show reach, equity, or follow-through.
The Review makes seven high-level recommendations.
1. Develop national minimum quality standards. Scottish Government and SPS should jointly lead their development, agreement, implementation, and monitoring, with providers, Families Outside, people with lived experience, and relevant partners. The standards should cover both independent PVC provision and SPS-controlled elements of prison visiting.
2. Review the commissioning and provider model. Scottish Government should undertake a formal options appraisal covering provider numbers, value for money, duplicated overhead, national and local delivery options, capability, continuity, independence, accountability, and transition risk. It should also clarify the role and authority of Families Outside and the National PVC Lead.
3. Align funding with the minimum standards. Scottish Government should review the funding level and mechanism against the actual cost of delivery, address real-terms erosion and support realistic staffing, core visiting coverage, workforce development, partnership work, evidence requirements, and national coordination.
4. Strengthen national oversight and implementation. Scottish Government should refresh and mandate the national oversight and implementation group, with named organisational ownership, timescales, reporting and assurance arrangements, escalation routes, responsibility for corrective action, and routine review of the standards.
5. Establish consistent SPS family-contact infrastructure. SPS should ensure that every Scottish prison has at least one appropriately trained, dedicated Family Contact Officer with protected capacity, alongside clear local operating agreements with PVC or support-service providers. Larger or more complex establishments will require additional dedicated provision.
6. Replace the vending-machine-led refreshments model. SPS should review current contractual arrangements and provide reliable access to hot and cold drinks, sandwiches or equivalent light food, and affordable, healthier snacks suitable for adults and children. Vending machines may supplement this provision but should not be the sole or primary offer.
7. Develop a national evidence, quality, and learning framework. Scottish Government should lead proportionate monitoring aligned with the ToC, logic model (LM) and minimum standards, improving evidence on reach, equality, visitor experience, child and family voice, contact quality, referrals, issue resolution, safeguarding, and short- to medium-term outcomes.
The 30 outcome-based recommendations contained within the main report describe the preferred future across ten connected themes:
- national minimum quality standards and local flexibility;
- commissioning, funding, and sustainability;
- governance, leadership, and accountability;
- SPS family-contact infrastructure and the prison-PVC interface;
- the visitor journey and physical environment;
- information, advocacy, and visitor voice;
- child- and family-sensitive visiting;
- equality, access, and safeguarding;
- wider family support and referral pathways; and
- workforce, evidence, and continuous learning.
These recommendations are mutually dependent. Standards without adequate funding would raise expectations without enabling delivery. Additional funding without clearer commissioning and accountability would not necessarily reduce inconsistency. Stronger monitoring without shared definitions could increase burden without improving learning. Coordinated national and local implementation, clear ownership, sustained resourcing, and routine review offer the strongest route to preserving the relational and locally responsive strengths of PVCs whilst making their contribution more consistent, equitable, accountable, and sustainable across Scotland.
Contact
Email: justice_analysts@gov.scot