Free School Meals Test of Change: Evaluation of expanded eligibility for S1-S3 pupils in receipt of Scottish Child Payment

An evaluation of the Free School Meals Test of Change, which expanded eligibility for free school meals to S1-S3 pupils in families receiving Scottish Child Payment in selected secondary schools


8. Conclusions

LA leads, senior school staff and catering staff generally welcomed the Test of Change. They felt it aligned with child poverty priorities and offered families support at a time of wider financial pressure. Participants also considered that the Test of Change had improved access to food during the school day for newly eligible pupils, including some who may otherwise have experienced hunger.

Overall, participating schools were generally able to deliver the Test of Change without reporting any insurmountable practical challenges. However, these findings should be interpreted in light of the selection of schools expected to manage within existing resources, existing capacity and actual uptake levels, which were lower than anticipated in some areas. The evaluation identified several lessons that would be relevant to any future rollout. These included:

  • Prioritising timely, targeted, and repeated communication. Around half of surveyed parents receiving SCP – the main target group for the Test of Change – said they were unaware of the Test of Change after implementation had begun. LAs and schools therefore need sufficient time before the start date to identify eligible pupils and plan communications with families. Targeting communications, where possible, and the use of multiple channels to publicise the change appeared most likely to reach families. These included letters and emails both from the LA and school, information on LA and school websites and social media channels, and engagement activities such as tasting sessions for parents.
  • Keeping the application process for families as simple as possible. Where eligible families can be identified in advance, for example through data shared by Social Security Scotland, they should not be required to provide the same evidence of eligibility again. Any approach to automatic or opt-out enrolment would need to comply with the legal arrangements governing passported benefits and data sharing, including a requirement for families to agree to receive entitlement. Providing communications in different languages and support with online application systems would also help reduce barriers experienced by some parents.
  • Using monitoring information proportionately to support awareness. Payment records could help identify where eligible pupils are making little or no use of their allowance, allowing schools or LAs to consider whether further general communication or support is needed. Any use of pupil-level information would require a clear and lawful purpose and appropriate data sharing agreements. It would also need to recognise that families may make an active choice not to use school meals and that repeated individual follow-up could be experienced as intrusive.
  • Addressing queues and other practical barriers to use. A quarter of surveyed pupils cited the queues for school meals being too long as a reason for not taking them. In participating schools, pre-order systems and separate ‘grab and go’ collection points were reported or observed to help manage queuing and allowed pupils receiving FSM to get a school meal while still joining friends who went elsewhere at lunchtime. Staggered lunchtimes and additional till points were also reported to help manage congestion, although the suitability of all of these approaches is dependent on local facilities and staffing.
  • Considering when pupils can access their allowance. In some participating schools, pupils described using part of their FSM allowance during the morning break or, in some cases, on arrival at school. This may indicate that pupils value being able to access food earlier in the school day, though the evaluation cannot determine whether they had eaten breakfast at home. Any future arrangements would need to clarify when the allowance could be used and how this related to the intended provision of a school meal.
  • Depending on their location, many school canteens operate within a wider lunchtime food environment that includes local shops and supermarkets, fast food outlets and takeaways. Pupils generally recognised that school meals could be more nutritious than many alternatives, but also acknowledged that nutrition was not a major factor influencing their choices. Taste, convenience, cost, peer groups and the opportunity for a break from the school environment were more important influences. Uptake therefore depended not only on entitlement, but also on whether the school offer was convenient, appealing and compatible with pupils’ lunchtime routines.
  • Survey responses did not suggest that overt embarrassment about receiving FSM was widespread: 6% of pupils said that it was seen as quite or very embarrassing to receive FSM at their school. However, 36% said they did not know how it was viewed, and qualitative evidence suggested that family attitudes, misconceptions about whether FSM use was visible at the till and less visible forms of stigma could still affect some pupils and families.
  • The clearest reported impact for families was reduced financial pressure. Most surveyed parents reported saving £11 or more a week, with savings most commonly redirected towards household expenses. These were parents’ estimates rather than verified expenditure data. Many parents also reported reduced stress or improved wellbeing, which qualitative accounts linked to financial savings, a reduced mental load and reassurance that their child had eaten during the school day.
  • Half of the pupils surveyed who had eaten school meals said that doing so made them feel less hungry in the afternoon. Smaller proportions reported perceived benefits for attendance, concentration or eating more healthily. These were self-reported perceptions and were not independently measured. The evaluation therefore cannot establish that the Test of Change caused changes in attendance, attainment, health, nutrition or wellbeing, nor does it estimate an attributable effect on child poverty.
  • Overall, the evaluation indicates that participating families commonly reported a valued financial benefit from the Test of Change, and that the change could be delivered within the selected participating schools. It also demonstrates that successful wider implementation would depend on more than extending eligibility. It would require effective data sharing and application arrangements, timely and targeted communication, sufficient catering capacity and a school meal offer that reflects the practical and social factors shaping pupils’ lunchtime choices.

Contact

Email: socialresearch@gov.scot

Back to top