Free School Meals Test of Change: Evaluation of expanded eligibility for S1-S3 pupils in receipt of Scottish Child Payment
An evaluation of the Free School Meals Test of Change, which expanded eligibility for free school meals to S1-S3 pupils in families receiving Scottish Child Payment in selected secondary schools
Appendix E – Text from senior teacher discussion guide
Introduction (5 minutes)
Introduce self and Ipsos, thank participant for their time
Remind participant of the purpose of the research: We are evaluating, on behalf of the Scottish Government, the targeted expansion of Free School Meals to S1-S3 Test of Change this year. We’re speaking to staff in the schools taking part as well as newly eligible pupils and some of their parents. It will be really useful in a moment to hear about your experiences of the FSM expansion Test of Change, how it has been working and any impacts you’ve seen so far.
Once we have spoken to everyone, we’ll write a report on the findings and that will be published by the Scottish Government.
We may include quotes from interviews in this report. Quotes will be anonymous as far as possible. However, due to the small number of people in some relevant professional roles, there is a chance that some parts of the report may be identifying to some readers (even if you are not quoted directly). Given this, do let us know if there is anything you do not want to be quoted directly in the report (I will check in on this at the end of the interview).
There are no right or wrong answers. You don’t have to answer any questions you don’t want to answer and can decide to stop the interview at any point.
Check for any questions. Ask if they’ve received the privacy notice.
While I will be taking notes, it would also be very helpful to audio-record the discussion today to make sure I’ve captured all the details accurately. The recording will only be used by the Ipsos research team for analysis purposes and will be securely deleted once the project is complete. Would you be happy for me to record the interview?
If yes, start recording now. Let participant know that the recording has started, record verbal consent to take part and for the interview to be recorded.
If participants express views about political parties, government priorities or funding decisions, acknowledge briefly and redirect discussion to operational experience.
Background and context (5 minutes)
If did not take part in scoping interview:
To start off with, could you share your job role and your key responsibilities in relation to the FSM expansion Test of Change?
- If not already clear: How/why did you become involved with the FSM expansion Test of Change?
What were you told about the purpose of the expansion? How was it explained to you?
- Did you have any initial concerns? (e.g. resourcing/capacity)
- Did you feel sufficiently informed before rollout?
When and how did you find out about the FSM expansion?
If took part in scoping interview:
Researcher: note down anything that was unclear or not covered from the scoping interviews and ask for clarification when necessary.
Have there been any changes to your job role or your role in relation to the FSM expansion since we spoke late last year?
Have there been any changes to what you hope the FSM expansion will achieve in your school?
Overview of implementation (10 minutes)
If did not take part in scoping interview:
Did your school volunteer to participate in the Test of Change or was this decided at the LA level?
- If school volunteered: What were the key considerations for your school in deciding to participate? For instance, what did you assume about the level of need in your area, the existing catering capacity, or how families would respond to the offer?
- Did you have any initial concerns?
Could you give me an overview of what the FSM S1-S3 expansion looks like in your school?
Probe on how it works in practice:
- Who is involved (which staff) in running the programme
- Approach to identifying & inviting eligible families
- Communication with families & application processes
- What a typical lunchtime looks like & how pupils pay for food/receive FSM
- Plans/steps taken to mitigate any anticipated stigma
- Any other admin/activities
- Overall, what have you needed to do that you didn’t before taking part in this Test of Change?
Overall, what has gone well so far?
- What have been the enablers that have supported this?
Overall, what have been the main challenges encountered so far?
- What is the impact of these challenges on the programme and how far it can meet expected outcomes?
- Have these challenges had any impact on the rollout timelines?
- Did you feel the timescale was realistic?
If took part in scoping interview:
Interviewer: Recap our understanding of how FSM works in their school and the difference the Test of Change has made
Since we last spoke, what changes have you made, if any, to your approach to implementing the FSM expansion?
Probe on:
- Communication with families
- Application process (and support) or auto-enrolment
- Any other admin/activities
Interviewer: Note down challenges mentioned during scoping interview and summarise for participant
[For challenges mentioned previously] Are any of these still a challenge?
Have you encountered any new challenges? What impact, if any, has that had on the programme?
Has there been anything else that has gone particularly well?
Planning and resources (5 minutes)
If did not take part in scoping interview:
Thanks. Now that I have a better understanding of how everything is working, I want to think back for a moment to when you were first planning the programme.
What was your approach to planning and preparing to rollout the FSM expansion to pupils whose families receive Scottish Child Payment?
- What preparation was needed?
- Were there any parts of the programme that were particularly influenced by the local context of [town/area]? E.g. things like your urban/rural mix, demographics, existing school food culture, or transport links.
- How long did it take to prepare for the FSM expansion?
Which resources, including staff time have been needed to implement the FSM expansion?
We have been told that data sharing permissions have been established with Social Security Scotland so that eligible families can be identified and contacted directly. How has this approach been working in practice for your school?
Uptake (10 minutes)
Do you have a sense of what uptake among newly eligible pupils is looking like at the moment? (If had scoping: How much, if at all, has uptake changed since we last spoke in November/December?)
- Is it in line with expectations?
- If higher than expected: why do you think this is?
- has this caused any problems for you?
- If yes: How have these problems been dealt with?
What factors may be limiting uptake?
- How can these factors be addressed, if at all?
Have you taken any actions intended to increase uptake?
- Have these actions been effective? Why or why not?
Are you seeing variations in uptake across different types of family or pupil?
- Probe: more or less deprived families? Minority ethnic families?
If yes: What do you think the reasons for that are?
Probe on what influences this (e.g. communication to families, menu choices, dining environment, social aspects, ability to leave school premises, proximity of external food outlets, payment systems)
Apart from the FSM expansion, is there anything else that may have contributed to uptake of school lunches (or any change in uptake throughout the year)?
Probe on: change in menu, change in dining hall, change in availability/price of external food outlets
Impacts & outcomes (15 minutes)
What impacts do you think the FSM expansion to pupils whose families receive Scottish Child Payment is having or will have for pupils in your school?
(Note: Distinguish between current & future expected impacts)
Probe on:
- Impacts on academic engagement/attendance/behaviour (Probe fully) (Ask for examples of anything they have observed directly)
- Impacts on pupils’ health/wellbeing/nutritional choices (Ask for examples of anything they have observed directly)
- Impacts on canteen dynamics and uptake of school meals among non-FSM pupils (Ask for examples of anything they have observed directly)
For each impact: Apart from the FSM expansion, is there anything else that may have contributed to this impact? (e.g. other attendance programmes, academic support programmes, or health/wellness programmes, breakfast/food programmes)
What impacts do you think the FSM expansion will have (or is already having) for families?
- Impacts on family food insecurity
- Impacts on financial pressures on families
- Impacts on child poverty
For each impact: Apart from the FSM expansion, is there anything else that may have contributed to this impact? (e.g. other local/national financial support programmes, food programmes)
Might there be any unintended positive consequences as a result of the FSM expansion? (e.g. Pupil safety increased from staying on campus for lunch)
Might there be any unintended negative consequences as a result of the FSM expansion? (e.g. stigma, increase queue times leading to reduced eating time, pressure on facilities)
If stigma not mentioned: Do you think there is any stigma attached to having FSM at this school?
- If yes: What could be done about that?
Are there any particular local factors that might influence the extent to which the programme can achieve these impacts for pupils in your school and their families?
Scalability & considerations for expansion (7 minutes)
If more eligible pupils were to take up FSM, would your school be able to manage within your existing resources?
- Probe on how much additional uptake do you think would be feasible - a rough estimate is fine – we’re not looking for exact numbers and you won’t be held to whatever estimate you give us just now
- If not: what additional resources would be required? (e.g. staff time/numbers, equipment)
If this approach was expanded to more schools, what changes, if any, should be made?
What advice would you give to other schools implementing this FSM expansion in the future?
Wrap-up (2 minutes)
Thanks very much, that’s all the questions I had to ask today. Is there anything else you'd like to add that we haven't covered?
Can I check that are happy to be quoted anonymously in the research report that will be published later this year?
Is there anything we spoke about that you would like us not to include?
Thank you again for your time. I’ll just stop the recording now. Stop recording
Contact
Email: socialresearch@gov.scot