Free School Meals Test of Change: Evaluation of expanded eligibility for S1-S3 pupils in receipt of Scottish Child Payment
An evaluation of the Free School Meals Test of Change, which expanded eligibility for free school meals to S1-S3 pupils in families receiving Scottish Child Payment in selected secondary schools
3. Planning and early implementation
Key findings
- LAs welcomed the Test of Change as it aligned with child poverty priorities and offered families support during the cost-of-living crisis.
- Awareness of the Test of Change among school staff varied, though centralised processes for communication and enrolment of newly eligible pupils mitigated potential operational impacts. Some catering staff were interested in earlier notice to allow more time to prepare.
- The time required to establish necessary data sharing agreements between LAs and Social Security Scotland compressed timelines for processing and matching data from the latter. Earlier transfer of data (e.g. pre-summer) would have enabled cleaning, verification and system testing.
- Delays and errors in data matching led to a few cases of families not being properly enrolled and requiring refunds. Issues with data matching also delayed targeted communications, which stakeholders linked to lower uptake.
- Catering and benefits systems could not always distinguish Test of Change participants from existing provision, requiring manual workarounds and complicating monitoring uptake of the Test of Change. However, this challenge was due to this being a Test of Change and any permanent expansion would not need to be distinguished from existing provision.
Communication and partnership working
At the LA level
Participating LA leads expressed strong support for the Test of Change. There was a high degree of buy-in among LA leads, who saw the Test of Change as an opportunity to help families experiencing or at risk of poverty, especially given current cost-of-living pressures. The Test of Change also aligned with existing child poverty agendas and food initiatives within LAs. In Shetland in particular, it is worth noting that the Test of Change overlapped significantly with a prior expansion of FSM to align eligibility with that of the school clothing grant. Eligibility for the school clothing grant is set by each LA.
Governance of the Test of Change depended on the size and structure of LA departments. In some LAs, facilities management teams operated within the same department as education teams, allowing for efficient communication and data sharing. In larger LAs, implementation of the Test of Change typically required collaboration across separate teams, which participants said could lengthen decision making processes. To mitigate this, two LAs had created cross-departmental working groups to facilitate the Test of Change, involving departments such as finance, education, facilities management, revenues and benefits, communications, data protection, and legal teams. Participants viewed this as a key facilitator in implementing the Test of Change.
“[We brought colleagues] from education, from the facilities management teams, from our financial inclusion team, from our comms team as well, just into a kind of short-term working group, […] data protection colleagues as well, […] legal colleagues. […] I think everyone got a common vision, could see the benefits of what we were wanting to do here. So we had buy in […] It was probably more difficult at the time of the year this fell as well, right around summer holidays […] So a lot of hard work from a lot of people and a lot of goodwill went into getting us to where we needed to be.”- LA Professional
To aid partnership working and knowledge sharing, an informal cross-LA working group was initiated by catering staff at the start of the Test of Change. This was generally thought to have worked well by LA leads, particularly when navigating the practicalities of processing Social Security Scotland data and learning how implementation was working in different local contexts. While Scottish Government had previously offered to facilitate a similar group, it was felt that two groups were unnecessary which led Scottish Government officials to join the informal group to disseminate information and seek updates. This allowed LAs to share updates and queries with Scottish Government and allowed Scottish Government to disseminate information and updates to LA leads.
At the school level
Participation of LAs in the Test of Change was confirmed in June 2025. As a result, most LAs notified participating secondary schools about the Test of Change just before or just after the summer holidays. This also impacted timelines for communicating with families (see Chapter 5 for more information about communication with families).
Awareness of the Test of Change among education and catering staff in participating secondary schools varied widely, with some staff members actively promoting and monitoring uptake and others only learning about the Test of Change when invited to take part in this research (which tended to be when staff would not be operationally involved or impacted). Although some education staff found out about the Test of Change after the start of the school year, this does not appear to have impacted rollout timelines since enrolment and communication with families in those cases was handled at the LA level.
Education and catering staff held mixed views about if, and when, they would have liked to have been notified about the Test of Change. In schools where the Test of Change was not thought to make a difference operationally, there was a view that it did not matter. Others felt additional time was needed to prepare. This included time for potentially ordering higher quantities of food, or for communicating effectively with families. For example, education staff wanted to provide advance notice to guidance teams to give them time to speak directly and discreetly with newly eligible pupils or have more time to create comprehensive communications which could be shared across multiple platforms.
Senior education staff in participating secondary schools reported that they learned about the Test of Change from LAs in different ways, with some receiving an email about it and others having meetings with LA leads. Among those who learned by email, there was interest in also holding a dedicated meeting to discuss the Test of Change, provide more information and address any queries or concerns. This was also seen as a way to ensure the announcement wasn’t missed in an email sent during a busy period. However, when the option to have a meeting was available, this was not always taken up if the headteacher believed the Test of Change would have no operational implications for their school. There was also a call for greater clarity on expectations for gathering monitoring data and measuring impact of the Test of Change, separately from routine FSM monitoring. One LA lead said that they established a senior leadership contact in each participating school and set up monthly meetings to track progress, uptake, and any implementation challenges.
Identifying newly eligible participating pupils
School selection
The Test of Change was intended to apply only in schools that would be able to manage within existing resources. Some LAs chose to include all secondary schools to avoid differences in provision between catchment areas. In LAs where some schools did not have capacity (e.g. kitchen or dining space) to participate, schools were chosen in line with Scottish Government criteria. This included areas of highest need in the LA, a mix of geographical areas, rurality, school sizes and denominational status. This was intended to capture a range of different school contexts.
Data sharing and processing
To identify pupils who became newly eligible through receipt of the Scottish Child Payment, Social Security Scotland shared relevant data with participating LAs. Establishing these data sharing arrangements required both a legal gateway, introduced through secondary legislation, and individual data sharing agreements between Social Security Scotland and each participating LA. While these arrangements were successfully established, participants described the process as complex and noted that variation in when agreements were completed compressed implementation timescales in some areas.
Participants also highlighted that matching the SCP data with local education records required substantial data processing and verification. Social Security Scotland does not hold information on the schools that pupils attend, their school year or whether they already receive free school meals, as this information is not required to administer the SCP and therefore cannot lawfully be held. As a result, LAs needed to match the SCP data with their own education records to identify pupils who were both eligible for the Test of Change and attending participating schools. This also involved identifying pupils who were already receiving FSM under existing eligibility criteria. Participants reported that this process required more administrative resource than initially anticipated.
When individual data sharing agreements were completed later, LAs had less time to clean, match and validate the data before the start of the school year. Most participating LAs completed this in time for implementation, although participants noted that the compressed timetable increased pressure on administrative teams. In a small number of LAs, the matching process continued after the start of the school year. In one area, communications inviting newly eligible families to apply for FSM were not issued until October. In another, the involvement of several teams in local governance and approval processes meant that targeted communications could not be issued until January, although broader communications were shared earlier. Participants perceived these delays to have contributed to lower uptake among newly eligible pupils.
Participants also linked time pressures to a small number of early implementation issues. In one LA, where all secondary schools participated in the Test of Change, updates to the catering system were required before implementation. There was insufficient time to complete testing before the start of term and the system malfunctioned during the first week of the school year. Interviewees believed this may have been associated with the system updates, although this was not independently confirmed. During the outage, catering staff recorded transactions manually and ensured pupils continued to receive meals. Where families paid for meals that should have been provided free of charge, the LA subsequently identified those cases and reimbursed affected families.
“So the system had to get taken down and they reverted […] back to manual processes. But after a week or so the system was then updated. But at that time, they had something like 300 or 400 backdated claims to process.”- LA Professional
Data collection and monitoring
Professionals reported some challenges in establishing monitoring processes to track use of FSM catering systems. Not all LAs were able to create a separate identifier within their catering systems for pupils receiving FSM through the Test of Change, as distinct from those already eligible under existing criteria. This led to difficulties monitoring uptake of the Test of Change. However, if the changes in eligibility were rolled out nationally, separate identification of a Test of Change cohort would no longer be required, reducing this monitoring burden.
Additionally, receipt of FSM was often used by secondary schools as a way of targeting additional one-to-one pupil support from guidance and pastoral teams. Senior teachers shared that one of the unintended consequences of the expanded FSM provision was that pupils who may be experiencing hidden poverty could now be provided with additional support in school. However, staff in some schools raised that, in order to provide that support, they needed to be given a list of newly eligible pupils as early as possible and at regular intervals (in other schools, senior staff had this information). This list of newly eligible pupils was often held centrally by the LA, whether that be the education team or revenue and benefits team.
“You need to know every year who is entitled to it so that you can put those targeted supports in place if needed. You don't always need them. Entitlement to FSM may not always mean that you're struggling with your attendance or your engagement or your attainment. But where there's a requirement to support, having that data early is really important.” - Senior teacher
This list also allowed schools to target communications about the Test of Change to those families who were newly eligible. By providing a list with uptake numbers at regular intervals, schools could also target follow up communications to pupils who were eligible but not taking up the provision. See Chapter 4 for more information about communications with pupils and families.
Contact
Email: socialresearch@gov.scot