Free School Meals Test of Change: Evaluation of expanded eligibility for S1-S3 pupils in receipt of Scottish Child Payment
An evaluation of the Free School Meals Test of Change, which expanded eligibility for free school meals to S1-S3 pupils in families receiving Scottish Child Payment in selected secondary schools
Appendix A: Key features and approaches across LAs
Participating LAs took a range of approaches when implementing the Test of Change, reflecting differences in local systems, administrative processes and operating contexts. This Appendix describes how each area communicated with families and schools, identified and enrolled eligible pupils, and approached local delivery. The purpose of this annex is to describe the different implementation approaches across participating LAs, rather than to compare or judge effectiveness.
Aberdeen City
Number of newly eligible FSM pupils: 898
Total number of S1-S3 pupils: 6,419
The LA directly communicated with newly eligible families, to inform them of their eligibility and that the FSM allowance applied to term time only. Communication with schools was minimal, limited to the LA issuing lists of newly eligible pupils. A single LA staff member was responsible for managing the data shared by Social Security Scotland and updating the LA’s system to include the newly identified pupils. This centralised process covered all 11 secondary schools in the area with eligibility changes passed through to schools via updated lists.
The LA wanted to support families affected by the cost-of-living crisis, particularly those just above the low‑income threshold who would not previously have qualified. In keeping with this, the decision was taken to include all secondary schools rather than selecting specific schools.
Fife
Number of newly eligible FSM pupils: 3,400
Total number of S1-S3 pupils: 12,269
The LA issued a general group call to families, and then asked participating schools if they could issue further communications. Additionally, the LA organised a “Come try a meal” with local vendors which generated local newspaper coverage and was intended to raise awareness of FSM. At the start of the summer holidays in 2025, headteachers received an overview of the Test of Change and were asked to circulate information to families before summer. Communication with schools was then picked up again in the new academic year.
All 18 secondary schools were included. The area was described as a mixed landscape, with some very affluent and some very deprived areas. In this context, the LA took an “all or nothing” approach across schools to ensure a consistent offer across catchments. Fife used an application process, with families applying for LA tax/housing benefits also enrolled onto any other grants they were eligible for, including school clothing grants, and FSM.
Glasgow
Number of newly eligible FSM pupils: 288
Total number of S1-S3 pupils: 1,453
The LA launched the initiative with the First Minister in June 2025. A couple of weeks before the Autumn term started, the LA press team issued communications encouraging parents to apply if they thought they were eligible. Alongside this, schools sent out universal communications to families about the Test of Change. Information was also provided on the LA website and some social media channels.
Over the 2025 summer holidays and at the start of the school year in August, families were invited to complete an application to access FSM as part of the Test of Change. From January, the LA was able to access the relevant data and undertake a consolidation exercise, adding newly eligible FSM pupil information into SEEMiS (the school education management information system) and the parent pay system. The application route remained open for parents who believed they qualified or whose circumstances changed. Processing the data was undertaken by support staff in the customer contact centre.
Moray
Number of newly eligible FSM pupils: 100
Total number of S1-S3 pupils: 527
The LA agreed to participate in the Test of Change shortly before the 2025 summer holidays. Responsibility for delivery sat primarily with the Catering Manager, working closely with the business support team.
Social Security Scotland data was received the week before the start of the 2025 Autumn term. Letters were sent by the LA to eligible parents to inform them about FSM. Catering staff were informed about the introduction of the test and adapted provision as uptake changed over time. Throughout delivery, schools received updates on uptake to support ongoing engagement with eligible families.
Ahead of the start of the new school year, eligible families were contacted by letter and provided with information about the Test of Change and the support available. The business support team undertook the administrative work required to identify eligible pupils from the data provided and ensure access to the entitlement from the beginning of term.
The funding was provided through pupils’ Young Scot cards, with balances credited daily. Schools and catering services reported that pupils made use of the entitlement throughout the school day, including at morning break as well as lunchtime.
North Ayrshire
Number of newly eligible FSM pupils: 886
Total number of S1-S3 pupils: 4,321
Over the summer of 2025, the LA emailed all families of newly eligible pupils, explaining the provision and encouraging them to access FSM from August. The application route was also publicised via social media and press releases, with a clear message that if families believed they were eligible but had not been contacted, they should get in touch. In the first weeks of term, the LA team gathered data on newly eligible pupils who had not accessed any FSM and shared this with headteachers, who then reached out to families to remind them that the programme was available. Additional communications were issued after the October break.
Communication between schools and families was described as direct and ongoing. The free meals service sits within the LA, providing a direct connection with headteachers. The Senior Manager for Facilities Management maintained a direct line of communication with each school (for example, to coordinate family communications, social media messaging and data updates). Headteachers appreciated being kept updated throughout the preparation process.
An application process remained available for parents whose circumstances changed. In these cases, parents contacted the customer services team, who guided them through the application form.
Shetland
Number of newly eligible FSM pupils: 35
Total number of S1-S3 pupils: 816
The LA wrote individually to all newly eligible families. Parents were asked to respond by phone or email to confirm they wished to take up FSM. Individual contact was chosen to minimise stigma, given the small community context. There was minimal communication with schools. Given the relatively small change in numbers eligible for FSM, there was no need to brief head cooks. By contrast, when Shetland previously expanded FSM eligibility, the approach was publicised more widely.
Participation in the Test of Change was seen as broadly consistent with existing local practice, given the alignment of eligibility criteria across several locally administered support schemes.
South Lanarkshire
Number of newly eligible FSM pupils: 379
Total number of S1-S3 pupils: 2,402
Due to data sharing agreement delays, the LA provided a manual application process for FSM as part of the Test of Change during the 2025 summer holidays. This was promoted via the LA magazine, social media and the LA website. Communications were also sent via schools encouraging parents who believed they were eligible to apply. The LA linked in with the senior management of the participating schools to inform them about the Test of Change, establishing a specific senior leadership contact in each school. A lead from the catering service met monthly with these school leads to track progress, uptake and any barriers.
The LA applied to participate in the Test of Change to widen accessibility to FSM for young people. Four schools were selected to take part by the LA based on criteria set out by the Scottish Government and to ensure a mix of geographical areas, school sizes, denominational status and areas of highest need.
Comhairle nan Eilean Siar
Number of newly eligible FSM pupils: 206
Total number of S1-S3 pupils: 822
The LA wrote to all families identified as in receipt of SCP individually and also issued a general group call, asking parents to confirm take‑up via a simple Microsoft Form. Communication with schools was minimal. Only a small number of additional pupils were being added to FSM and, with few off‑site options in Comhairle nan Eilean Siar, professionals reported that most pupils already took school meals. The catering lead informed canteen staff about the change and they were content with the arrangements.
Parents replied to the group call message to confirm enrolment. No further application steps were required. The LA supported the principle of the Test of Change and wanted to test whether they could implement it in their context.
Key similarities and differences
There was variation in how the Test of Change was delivered locally. For instance, while newly eligible families were typically contacted directly, the extent of school involvement varied. In some authorities, communication was led largely by LA teams, with schools receiving updated lists of eligible pupils, while in others schools played a more active role in raising awareness and encouraging take-up.
Approaches to enrolment also differed. Some LAs used data received from Social Security Scotland to identify and enrol eligible pupils, whereas others required parents to confirm participation or submit an application. Several authorities noted the administrative work involved in processing eligibility data and integrating newly eligible pupils into local systems.
Despite differences in delivery, a number of common considerations were evident across areas. These included a desire to reduce financial pressures on families, minimise potential stigma associated with FSM, and ensure that implementation could be accommodated within existing school catering capacity and administrative arrangements. Local context also influenced delivery decisions, including levels of deprivation, geography, existing eligibility processes and prior experience of extending support to low-income families.
Contact
Email: socialresearch@gov.scot