Free School Meals Test of Change: Evaluation of expanded eligibility for S1-S3 pupils in receipt of Scottish Child Payment

An evaluation of the Free School Meals Test of Change, which expanded eligibility for free school meals to S1-S3 pupils in families receiving Scottish Child Payment in selected secondary schools


Appendix G – Text from pupil discussion guide

Notes for reviewers and researchers:

This topic guide is designed to serve as an aide memoir to the researchers, while also remaining flexible to allow for issues to be raised spontaneously. Obvious probing and follow-up questions like ‘why?’, ‘why not?’, etc. are not included, but there is no need to add these – the researchers will probe, ask for explanation/clarification, and sum up at appropriate points.

Although the guide is generally written in the form of questions or explanations that could be read out exactly as written, in reality, the researcher will amend the wording, rephrase and reorder as appropriate to make it feel more like a natural discussion.

Introduction (5 mins)

Introduce self and Ipsos, thank participant for their time

Note: Collecting informed consent is important here. Spend time making sure CYP understands what the interview is about and what we/the Scottish Government will do with the information. Offer to go through information sheet if they would like to.

Remind participant/s of the aims of the research: The Scottish Government has asked us, Ipsos Scotland (an independent research organisation), to find out about school meals and what pupils think about them. We’re speaking to young people at different schools as well as others involved in such as catering staff and teachers.

Once we have spoken to everyone, we’ll write a report on the findings and that will be published by the Scottish Government.

Provide reassurances of anonymity and confidentiality: No identifying information about individuals (e.g. names or contact details) will be passed on to anyone outside the research team (me and my colleagues at Ipsos). We wont tell your parents or teachers what you say. The only time we might need share something is if you tell us something that makes us worried about your safety or someone else’s safety. If that happened, we would talk to you about what we need to do.

We will include quotes in the report, but these would be anonymous. That means nobody reading the report will be able to tell took who part in the research or what they said. We won’t use your name in any of the reports.

Remind participant that the interview will last around 40 minutes.

Remind participant that there are no right or wrong answers.

Emphasise that taking part is completely voluntary - they don’t have to answer any questions they don’t want to answer and can decide to stop the interview at any point.

Give the young person a yellow (pause) and red (stop) card and let them know they can use these at any time without explanation.

Remind that they are free to change their mind and decide not to take part at any time before/during the interview, or after the interview until the findings have been written up - even though they’ve told the teacher they were happy to participate.

Check if participant has any questions.

Check if participant happy to take part in interview.

Request permission to record interview. This is just a recording of what we are saying, so it only records sound. This is to make sure we capture everything you say and don't have to rely on our memories or scrappy notes when we come to writing the report. Recordings will not be shared outside the research team at Ipsos. After the project is ended, the recording is securely deleted. There is more information about this in the privacy notice for the project.

If yes: start recording now. Let participant know that the recording has started, record verbal consent to take part and for the interview to be recorded.

If don’t want to be recorded: That’s fine, I won’t record this. Are you still happy to take part in the interview and I’ll take notes?

Warm up (5 mins)

Could you start by telling me a little bit about yourself?

What year are you in and what’s your favourite subject?

And what’s your favourite meal of the day? Why is that?

What’s your favourite food?

Any foods that you really hate?

Current lunch arrangements and history with school meals (10 mins)

What do you typically do at lunchtime when you’re at school?

Probe on:

  • Where do you go?
  • Who do you spend lunchtime with?
  • What do you eat?
  • What do you drink?
  • How do you decide what you eat/drink at lunchtime?

Do you do the same thing every day or does it depend?

Probe on reasons/what it depends on

  • Who decides where you go and what you eat at lunchtime?
  • If it depends: What do you prefer doing?

If not mentioned: do you ever think about whether something is healthy when choosing what or where to eat?

If not mentioned, check: Have you ever had school meals for lunch?

  • If yes, probe: When they’ve done this/how often, what they get

How many fruit and vegetables do you tend to eat when you have a school lunch?

  • If no many: What, if anything, would encourage you to eat more?

What would your ideal lunchtime at school be like?

Do you buy food at school at any other time of the day apart from lunch time?

  • If no: Have you ever done this?
  • If yes, probe: When they’ve done this/how often, what they get and where from

Has what you do at lunchtime changed at all since the start of the school year last August? Probe on reasons for any change (both in terms of where they go & what they eat/drink)

And what did you do last year, when you were in [previous school year]?

Probe on reasons for any change (both in terms of where they go & what they eat/drink)

Payment (2 mins)

How do you pay for food at school?

If mention card:

  • Do you know where the money on the card comes from?
  • Do you know if this is the same for other pupils at school?

Views on school meals (10 mins)

What are school meals like at your school?

If had school meals before:

What do you like, if anything, about getting school meals?

Probe on:

  • The food
  • The canteen
  • Queuing
  • Who they spend lunch with

If had school meals before:

What do you not like, if anything, about getting school meals? PROBE AS ABOVE.

For pupils who take school meals: What, if anything, would you like to be different about school meals?

Probe on:

  • The food?
  • The canteen?
  • Anything else?

Have school meals got better or worse over time, since you’ve been at school?

Have you been aware of any changes to school meals since you were in [previous school year]?

For pupils who do not take school meals/take them very rarely: What would need to be different in order for you to get school meals for lunch [more often]?

Awareness of free school meals (5 mins)

Just as a reminder, remember you can use the red or yellow cards at any point if you want to pause or stop.

Are you aware that some pupils are entitled to free school meals?

If yes:

  • Do you know how it’s decided who gets free school meals and who doesn’t?
  • Did you know that the number of pupils entitled to free school meals has increased a bit since last August?
  • If yes: How did you know that? Why do you think that might be?

Without mentioning any names, do you know anyone who gets free school meals?

  • If yes, how do you know that?

Do pupils generally know who gets free school meals and who doesn’t?

  • If yes, how do they know?
  • What do you think about that?

If they mention themselves

  • How long have you been entitled to free school meals?
  • How do you feel about being entitled to free school meals?
  • What difference, if any, has getting this free meal made to you?
  • If yes: What difference has it made?
  • And what difference, if any, has it made to your mum or dad?
  • If yes: What difference has it made?

Food from outside of school (5 mins)

If they say they sometimes/usually get food from shops/bring packed lunch

You said that you [sometimes/usually] get food from [outside of school]. What are the main reasons you do that?

  • What do you usually get?
  • How does the food compare to school meals?
  • Is the food more or less healthy than school meals?
  • Is this something you think about when choosing lunch?

How much does that cost?

Does it cost more or less than the food at school?

Where do you get the money for that?

  • If from parents: Do they know what you spend it on?

Educational impacts (3 mins)

Some people think that how much pupils eat and what pupils eat can affect how they are in classes, for example, how well they concentrate and how they behave.

Do you think it makes a difference?

  • If yes – in what way?

Do you think it makes a difference to you personally?

  • If yes – in what way?

Do you think school meals affect pupils’ attendance at all?

Do school meals affect your attendance at all?

Nutritional impacts

Wrap up

That’s everything I wanted to ask you today. Thank you very much for taking the time to talk to me. Is there anything we haven’t covered that you would like to say something about?

Is there anything we spoke about that you would like us not to include?

I’ll stop the recording now [stop recording].

Contact

Email: socialresearch@gov.scot

Back to top