Free School Meals Test of Change: Evaluation of expanded eligibility for S1-S3 pupils in receipt of Scottish Child Payment
An evaluation of the Free School Meals Test of Change, which expanded eligibility for free school meals to S1-S3 pupils in families receiving Scottish Child Payment in selected secondary schools
5. Operational capacity and scalability
Key findings
- Capacity challenges identified through this evaluation are likely to understate those that could arise under wider implementation. This is because participating LAs selected schools to take part in the Test of Change which they expected would be able to manage implementation within existing staffing, kitchen and dining space resources.
- Capacity impacts were driven by the number of newly eligible pupils and actual uptake, with lower-than-expected uptake sometimes keeping demand within existing resources.
- In schools with high pre-existing school meal uptake (both paid and free), the Test of Change meant an increase in the proportion of funded meals rather than increasing the volume of meals produced.
- Where volumes rose, pressure points centred on staffing, kitchen equipment (e.g. oven and freezer capacity) and dining space, with some settings close to their limits. Staffing was the most frequent constraint, particularly during illness peaks and where available relief cover was limited.
- Operational enablers included pre-order systems, additional till points, takeaway options and staggered lunches, which reduced queues and improved meal preparation and planning.
Capacity and scalability
As noted at the start of this report, schools participating in the Test of Change were expected to be able to manage within existing resources. The capacity challenges reported in this chapter may therefore be less extensive than those that could arise if eligibility were widened to schools that had not been selected on this basis.
The primary factor affecting participating schools’ ability to manage the Test of Change within existing resources was the number of newly eligible pupils and the level of uptake. For example, most participating schools in Shetland and Comhairle nan Eilean Siar had between one and five newly eligible pupils as a result of the Test of Change, which were reported not to have affected school resources. Shetland had extended the eligibility of FSM prior to the Test of Change, which contributed to the small number of newly eligible pupils in participating schools. Participants suggested that schools serving areas with lower levels of deprivation generally has fewer pupils becoming newly eligible through the Test of Change.
In other schools, although there was a substantial increase in the potential number of newly eligible pupils, there was lower than expected uptake which limited the potential strain on resources. For example, at the start of the Test of Change all participating secondary schools in one LA had between 3 and 30 newly eligible pupils registered for FSM. In this case, participants reported that no additional resources were required. However, it was noted that if all newly eligible pupils had taken up the offer of a FSM, that may have put the system under strain and may require future investment in additional resources and equipment.
“Potentially we would have had to have additional resources and equipment, etc, but because of our current uptake figures, it was [within our] capacity.” - LA Professional
The implications of the Test of Change for school resources also depended on the existing level of uptake of school meals. In schools with already high uptake of school meals, some newly eligible pupils had already been purchasing school meals. The Test of Change therefore transferred the cost of those meals from families to public funding without necessarily creating an equivalent increase in meals prepared or pupils using the canteen. This tended to be the case in schools with relatively few nearby takeaway options or schools that restricted pupils’ ability to leave school grounds during lunch.
“It wouldn't be a vast jump. Like I say, we have the majority of secondary pupils eating with us anyway, so, no, it wouldn't have a massive impact on us." - School catering staff member
For schools that saw a notable increase in pupils taking school meals during the Test of Change, their ability to manage depended on several factors, including staff capacity, kitchen equipment, and canteen seating capacity. For each of these factors, there were those that felt they could handle a further increase in uptake, those that managed but thought they would struggle with any further increase, and those whose resources had been strained. This did not appear to be related to location, with both schools in urban and rural areas experiencing capacity issues.
Several enabling factors were identified that supported school capacity at lunchtime. This included implementing a pre-order system which helped canteen staff estimate the number of each lunch option to prepare. Catering staff reported that pre-orders also helped reduce the length of queues by creating separate pick-up points and speeding up the queues since pupils had already ordered and paid. Some schools had also introduced pre-order kiosks similar to those found in fast-food restaurants to encourage more pupils to use the pre-order system. Other schools had options to pre-order through an app or at the till during morning break. Schools that had recently added extra tills also found this helped reduce queues.
“We have quite a few innovative ways of working […] We have been trying to promote [pre-ordering] […] to take away some of the pressure and that's working quite well.” - LA Professional
In some schools, kitchen upgrades completed before the Test of Change, were cited as enabling factors in some schools. Schools that saw high uptake and had not undergone recent kitchen renovations tended to report struggling with oven capacity and freezer space.
“Talking about oven spaces, things like that. Fridges, freezers. Oven space. Definitely. Because some days we struggle now to fit everything in, to get it out for the right time.” - School catering staff member
Changes made before the Test of Change, such as increasing canteen seating capacity by replacing or adding new seating, also helped manage increased footfall in some schools. Additional measures to prevent canteen capacity being overwhelmed included encouraging takeaway options and staggering lunchtimes. Although catering staff in some of the older schools described struggling more with older kitchen equipment, newer schools were not necessarily better able to manage the Test of Change. One view among professionals was that new schools were generally designed with smaller dining facilities and smaller kitchens when compared to older school designs, which limited the amount of seating and the amount of equipment they could put in the kitchen, resulting in the need for renovations despite being recently built.
As a result of the additional food and canteen traffic from the Test of Change, some schools required extra staff or staff overtime to help with preparing and cleaning facilities and managing longer queues. Staffing was the most frequently raised ‘pinch point’, particularly when dealing with staff illness in the winter.
“One wee spell of bad absences here in the winter as gave us these pressure points. But it was really good to know because we, I was a bit naive thinking we were really healthy for staff, we'd be absolutely fine. But we've not been. There's definitely been a few schools that have some pressure points in them.” - LA Professional
Staffing shortages in nearby schools also influenced capacity, as kitchen staff would fill in for absences elsewhere when needed. Similarly, the ability to manage absences relied on the availability of staff in nearby schools. Finding coverage for staff absences was highlighted as particularly difficult in rural and island areas.
“There was a period there when there was a lot of staff absence because of illness. It was just like, a perfect storm. […] We had a lot of relief canteen staff in […] Cover for any of the roles in the school here is hard to come by.” - Senior teacher
Several schools reported that maintaining provision at higher levels of uptake would be likely to require additional staffing and more reliable access to relief cover. Planning would therefore need to consider capacity across the wider LA staffing pool, rather than assessing each school in isolation. Further, any potential rollout to additional schools should consider the schools’ unique contexts. For example, while funding for FSM is agreed at the national level with rural weighting, professionals in island authorities still highlighted that food costs were substantially higher compared to the mainland. This was not reported as a major issue during the Test of Change due to low uptake but could be in any future rollout.
Furthermore, it was also noted that school rolls are decreasing nationally and may decline rapidly in some areas in the next few years, which may affect future demand and capacity. However, schools in other areas are continuing to grow. Despite some concerns about capacity for further rollout, teachers and catering staff expressed generally positive views about the Test of Change and its aims and said they would like it to continue or be further expanded.
One concern among professionals was how expanded eligibility for FSM might impact additional support traditionally linked to receipt of FSM. For example, participants discussed the Pupil Equity Fund (PEF), which is allocated to schools based on the number of pupils registered for FSM. Although PEF funding is not required to be spent on pupils registered for FSM, some participants expressed concern that a future expansion of FSM eligibility could affect the PEF allocation model and increase administrative requirements for schools.
Overall, findings indicate that planning for any wider implementation would benefit from school level and LA level capacity assessments. These could take account of:
- the estimated number of newly eligible pupils at the school
- likely uptake levels based on uptake rates of existing FSM recipients within the school (given the wide range of uptake levels across schools this would be more accurate than a single national rate)
- likely impact on total school meal uptake, accounting for newly eligible pupils already taking paid school meals
- kitchen capacity, including freezers, fridges and ovens
- canteen seating capacity, including alternative seating areas
- staffing capacity in the school and across the local area, accounting for potential absences in nearby schools that may require staff to fill in and accounting for seasonal fluctuations in staff capacity and illnesses
- price of additional meals, accounting for regional variations in food costs, particularly on islands
Schools with concerns about capacity may consider additional measures to help manage increased school meal uptake, including pre-order kiosks, increased takeaway options, additional till points or staggered lunches. In some cases, expanded FSM eligibility may necessitate investments in additional staffing or renovations to kitchens or canteens.
Contact
Email: socialresearch@gov.scot