Free School Meals Test of Change: Evaluation of expanded eligibility for S1-S3 pupils in receipt of Scottish Child Payment
An evaluation of the Free School Meals Test of Change, which expanded eligibility for free school meals to S1-S3 pupils in families receiving Scottish Child Payment in selected secondary schools
Appendix H – Text from parent discussion guide
Notes for reviewers:
This topic guide is designed to serve as an aide memoir to the researchers, while also remaining flexible to allow for issues to be raised spontaneously. Obvious probing and follow-up questions like ‘why?’, ‘why not?’, etc. are not included, but there is no need to add these – the researchers will probe, ask for explanation/clarification, and sum up at appropriate points.
Although the guide is generally written in the form of questions or explanations that could be read out exactly as written, in reality, the researcher will amend the wording, rephrase and reorder as appropriate to make it feel more like a natural discussion.
Reminder to researchers: If participants raise party political views, interviewers should acknowledge briefly and re-focus on lived experience of the FSM expansion (awareness, process, uptake, and impacts). Researchers should not probe political opinions or comparisons between parties.
Introduction (5 mins)
Introduce self and Ipsos, thank participant for their time
Remind participant/s of the aims of the research: Ipsos is conducting the research independently on behalf of the Scottish Government to find out about the expansion of free school meals to some pupils in S1 to S3. We’re also speaking to young people at different schools as well as others involved in such as catering staff and teachers.
Once we have spoken to everyone, we’ll write a report on the findings and that will be published by the Scottish Government.
Provide reassurances of anonymity and confidentiality: No identifying information about individuals (e.g. names or contact details) will be passed on to anyone outside the research team (me and my colleagues at Ipsos). We will include quotes in the report, but these would be anonymous. That means nobody reading the report will be able to tell took who part in the research or what they said.
Nothing you say will have any impact on your child or their school meal entitlement.
Remind participant/s of scope of research: Just to be clear, because we won’t be sharing your feedback directly with the school, the school won’t be able to respond to specific suggestions you make today. The purpose of this research is to help improve the Scottish Government’s understanding of how this expansion of free school meals is working generally across different schools, and not to feedback directly to schools about changes they should make.
Remind participant that the interview will last around 45 minutes.
Remind participant that there are no right or wrong answers.
Emphasise that taking part is completely voluntary - they don’t have to answer any questions they don’t want to answer and can decide to stop the interview at any point.
Remind that they are free to change their mind and decide not to take part at any time before/during the interview, or after the interview until the findings have been written up.
Check if participant has any questions.
Check if participant happy to take part in interview.
Request permission to record interview. This is to make sure we capture everything you say and don't have to rely on our memories or scrappy notes when we come to writing the report. Recordings will not be shared outside the research team at Ipsos.
If yes: start recording now. Let participant know that the recording has started, record verbal consent to take part and for the interview to be recorded.
If don’t want to be recorded: That’s fine, I won’t record this. Are you still happy to take part in the interview and I’ll take notes?
Warm up (3 mins)
Could you start by telling me a little bit about your child?
What would you like me to call your child during the interview?
What year are they in now and what’s their favourite subject?
And what do you think is their favourite meal of the day? Why is that?
What’s their favourite food?
Any foods that they really hate?
FSM entitlement (10 mins)
Were you aware that Free School Meal entitlement has been expanded in the school since the start of this school year in August?
If yes – can you describe to me what has changed?
Probe on:
- Who is now entitled that wasn’t before?
- Which school years does this apply to?
- What information, if any, were you given about the purpose of this change?
If no, explain: In a certain number of schools across Scotland, Free School Meal entitlement has been expanded to children in S1 to S3 if their family receives the Scottish Child Payment.
- Had you heard anything about that?
- Does this affect you/your child?
If necessary: Do you receive the Scottish Child Payment?
- If asked about SCP explain: This is a payment of around £27 a week that you can apply for if you have a child under 16 and you get one of the following benefits: Universal Credit; income-based Jobseeker's Allowance; Income Support or income-related Employment and Support Allowance (ESA)
How do you feel about this change?
Do you know how [name] feels about this change?
What are the benefits, if any, for your child?
What are the benefits, if any, for you?
What are the downsides, if any, for your child?
What are the downsides, if any, for you?
Communication/application process (10 mins)
Can you remember when you first heard about the expansion of Free School Meals?
Probe on:
- How did you first hear about it/who from?
- Did you get any communication about from the school? Or from the LA?
- Was it clear what you needed to do, if anything?
- Did you need to complete an application form?
- Did you need to provide any evidence that you receive the Scottish Child Payment?
- What would make the application process easier?
Is there anything that could have been better about the way it was communicated?
What was your initial reaction?
Did you have any concerns about it?
What, if anything, did you say to [name] about it?
Has [name] been entitled to free school meals before?
- If yes – When was that? Why was that?
Were you entitled to free school meals when you were at school?
- If yes – how did you feel about that?
- Did you actually take the meals?
Current lunch arrangements and history with school meals (10 mins)
What does [name] typically do at lunchtime at school these days?
What are the main reasons for that?
Probe on:
- Where do they go?
- Do you know who they spend lunchtime with?
- What they eat?
Do they do the same thing every day or does it depend?
Probe on reasons/what it depends on
If not mentioned, check: Have they ever had school meals for lunch?
- If yes, probe: When they’ve done this/how often, what they get
If they don’t often take school meals
- Why doesn’t [name] have school meals (more often)?
- Would you like them to have school meals (more often)?
- Why/Why not?
What could be done to encourage them to have school meals (more often)?
Probe on:
- Choice of food
- Taste of the food
- Dining hall
- Time constraints
- Peer influence
And what did they do last year, when they were in [previous school year]?
- Probe on reasons for any change (both in terms of where they go & what they eat/drink)
Payment (3 mins)
Do you know how the payment system works?
Probe on:
- Is it a cashless system?
- Does [name] have a card they can use to pay for meals?
Do pupils at the school generally know who gets free school meals and who doesn’t?
- If yes, how do they know?
- What do you think about that?
- Has it influenced whether you or [child] has chosen to take up FSM?
Financial or other impacts (3 mins)
What has been the impact on you of [name] now being entitled to free school meals?
What difference, if any, has that made to you?
If not mentioned:
- Has it had a financial impact?
If applicable: You don’t have to answer this if you don’t want to, but I’m interested in what have you done with the money that you now don’t have to spend on [name’s] lunch?
Educational impacts (3 mins)
Some people think that how much pupils eat and what pupils eat can affect how they are in classes, for example, how well they concentrate and how they behave.
Have you noticed any changes in [name] since they started having school lunches?
If yes – in what way?
Do you think it makes any (other)difference to [name]?
If yes – in what way?
Do school meals affect [name’s] attendance at school all?
Nutritional impacts (3 mins)
Compared to what pupils would otherwise have for lunch, do you think school meals are healthier, less healthy, or about the same?
When you say “healthy” what does the mean for you? (e.g. fruit/veg, portion size, sugar, hot meal etc.)
Do you have any concerns about the menu (e.g. allergens, dietary needs, religious requirements?)
Is this something that you think about much?
If they encourage their child to take school meals/would they like them to take school meals more
: Is that a factor in you wanting [name] to take school meals (more often)?
Do you think [name] thinks about that aspect when choosing what to have?
Wrap up (2 mins)
That’s everything I wanted to ask you today. Thank you very much for taking the time to talk to me. Is there anything else about your experience of the change that you would like to say something about?
Is there anything we spoke about that you would like us not to include?
I’ll stop the recording now [stop recording]
Check if they want a voucher or BACS transfer and take necessary details.
Contact
Email: socialresearch@gov.scot