Free School Meals Test of Change: Evaluation of expanded eligibility for S1-S3 pupils in receipt of Scottish Child Payment
An evaluation of the Free School Meals Test of Change, which expanded eligibility for free school meals to S1-S3 pupils in families receiving Scottish Child Payment in selected secondary schools
6. Free school meal uptake and influences
Key findings
- Available monitoring data indicated substantial variation in meal use among newly eligible pupils, although differences in data quality mean rates cannot be directly compared across LAs.
- Newly eligible pupils described using their FSM allowance multiple times per week. Some used their allowance outside of lunchtime, either for breakfast foods or snack at morning break time.
- Time, convenience and the physical canteen environment were important influences of lunchtime choices. Pupils valued pre-ordering, portable food and staggered lunchtimes where these reduced waiting times or made it easier to spend time with friends.
- Peer groups strongly shaped choices, pupils tended to do what friends did, including leaving site even when off‑site queues were similar to the queues in the canteen.
- Decisions to leave school at lunchtime were not solely about food. Pupils also valued spending time with friends, having fresh air and taking a break from the school environment.
- Few surveyed pupils described FSM as embarrassing, but a proportion were unsure how it was perceived. Qualitative evidence suggested that family attitudes and uncertainty about the discretion of payment systems could still affect a small number of pupils.
- Awareness and access barriers, including communication, language and digital literacy, were perceived by participants to limit access for some families. Participants described targeted and multilingual support as helpful in addressing these barriers
School meals uptake and lunchtime behaviours
Uptake and frequency of use
LA monitoring data showed considerable variation in the use of FSM by newly eligible pupils. Across the available data, recorded meals taken were equivalent to between 8% and 55% of a theoretical maximum of one meal per newly eligible pupil per school day. This is a measure of recorded meal use rather than the proportion of eligible pupils who took up or used their entitlement. Differences in recording practices and missing data mean these figures should not be compared directly across LA. Where sufficiently comparable data were available within individual LAs, recorded meal use among newly eligible pupils was sometimes of a similar order to that among existing FSM recipients, although this was not consistent across areas
Frequency of use varied among the newly eligible pupils interviewed. Most described purchasing food in school several times a week, while some said they used their allowance every school day.
In the pupil survey, 25% of pupils who reported receiving FSM said they ate a school meal every day, compared with 16% of pupils who reported they did not receive FSM. This difference was not statistically significant. A higher proportion of pupils who reported not receiving FSM said they never ate a school meal (25%) than pupils who reported receiving FSM (12%). As mentioned previously, due to low and uneven response rates across schools, these survey findings should be treated as indicative of respondent behaviours, not representative of all pupils.
Among survey respondents, 24% of boys said they had school meals every day, compared with 18% of girls. Conversely, 34% of girls said they had school meals ‘sometimes’, compared with 24% of boys.
Among survey respondents, 33% of S1 pupils reported having school meals every day, compared with 21% of S2 pupils and 14% of S3 pupils. The proportion reporting that they never had a school meal was 16% in S1, 25% in S2 and 29% in S3. These differences are descriptive and may also reflect differences in the composition of participating schools. Some professionals suggested that S1 may be more likely to take school meals due to restrictions on being allowed off school grounds or may be more enthused about a wider range of food options compared to primary school (881 pupils - 225 in S1, 295 in S2 and 349 in S3).
How FSM credit was spent
“Grab-and-go” items were a popular choice described by pupils taking part in the research, such as paninis, baguettes, soups, hot dogs and pizza. Pupils said they chose them because they were quicker to collect and could be eaten outside the canteen (either to sit in classrooms or off school grounds, typically to join friends not getting school meals). For some pupils, the choice simply reflected personal preference or established routine. There were pupils who preferred to do the same thing each day rather than try different lunch options.
There were also pupils who said they usually chose a two‑course meal. In one school, catering staff perceived that the reintroduction of dishware, following a period of using takeaway containers, aligned with a higher uptake of this. The evaluation did not independently assess whether this affected uptake.
While the Scottish Government intended for the FSM allowance to be used solely during the lunchtime break, in some LA’s pupils were allowed to use their allowance at other points in the school day. In these LAs, pupils described purchasing snacks at school during the morning interval or at the start of the school day for breakfast. Some then brought a packed lunch or bought lunch elsewhere rather than purchasing a second meal in school.
One headteacher considered that morning use of the allowance might, in some cases, reflect pupils arriving to school hungry. However, the evaluation did not collect evidence on whether pupils had eaten breakfast at home.
Use of pre‑ordering
In schools where it was available, many pupils used pre‑ordering online or through an app on a regular basis. Pupils suggested two main reasons for this: first, that queue times for pre‑orders were usually shorter than other queues; and second, that certain items were at risk of running out quickly during the lunch service, so pre‑ordering provided reassurance that they would have what they wanted for lunch. Pre-ordered food was most often packaged in brown takeaway bags or boxes, which pupils reported made it easier to take off site if they wished to join friends.
A few pupils described receiving the wrong order or finding items missing on collection. In these instances, pupils reported that they had been refused a refund for missing items. Some pupils reported being put off using the pre-ordering system due to these issues. However, reports of incorrect or incomplete orders did not emerge as a widespread concern across participating areas.
Alternatives to school lunches
Among the newly eligible pupils who chose not to have a school lunch, alternatives tended to be a packed lunch or buying food from elsewhere (although some pupils returned home for lunch). Packed lunch items typically included sandwiches, crisps, chocolates, biscuits and a soft drink. In relation to off‑site options, pupils mentioned going to supermarkets, takeaways (chicken shops, Chinese restaurants, fish and chip shops), or community centres. Pupil survey findings indicated that in general (among all pupils and not only newly eligible pupils), boys were more likely than girls to buy food from outside retailers (67% vs 50%), while girls were more likely than boys to bring a packed lunch (31% vs 19%).
Across all pupil survey respondents, 9% of girls and 3% of boys reported skipping lunch. The survey did not establish why pupils skipped lunch or whether this was linked to cost, food preferences, appetite, health, the canteen environment or other factors.
Uptake expectations
Schools’ views on whether FSM uptake among newly eligible pupils aligned with expectations were mixed. Several reported increases since launch. Others felt levels were lower than hoped, or broadly in line with expectations once attendance patterns were factored in (e.g., pupil absence and those on flexible or adapted timetables).
While school staff were not always aware of precise uptake figures, there was a perception that canteens had generally been busier. It was pointed out that many staff were unable to distinguish newly eligible pupils from existing FSM recipients, which made it harder to be certain about who was driving any change.
Across the professional interviews, lower than hoped uptake was reported more often than uptake meeting or exceeding expectations. In one LA, a participant said that low FSM uptake occurred alongside a perceived reduction in other financial aid applications, such as the school clothing grant. (Assessing impacts of uptake on wider financial support was not in scope for this evaluation, and therefore this perception cannot be independently verified).
Influences on FSM uptake
There was a wide range of factors suggested in relation to whether pupils took up FSM, spanning prior habits, cost, convenience, social influences, awareness of eligibility, application processes, and the canteen environment.
What pupils enjoyed about the canteen
Food quality and taste were central to positive experiences of the canteen among interviewed pupils. Pupils who regularly used their FSM allowance commonly described the food as “good” or “tasty” and that enjoying the food encouraged them to return.
Choice and variety were also frequently highlighted. Pupils valued having a range of options at lunch and liked to try new items, while others stuck to the same order every day. Pupils expressed interest in greater variety within the offer, and pupils appreciated that, while schools had to adhere to school food nutritional standards, items perceived by pupils as “unhealthier” (such as cookies, brownies and pizza) were still available. There was a view that retaining these options added to the sense of choice and appeal, catering both to those who wanted something familiar and to those keen to experiment.
Positive relationships between canteen staff and pupils was another valued aspect. Pupils commented on staff being patient and handling the service well, and canteen staff, in turn, spoke about knowing pupils well and building relationships to support pupils’ confidence in using the canteen. There was a perception among headteachers that pupils being known by staff and feeling welcomed made the canteen easier to navigate and more comfortable to use, particularly for pupils who might otherwise be hesitant.
“I think it’s really, really good. The staff are brilliant. They’re patient with people and, yeah, they handle it very well every day.” - Pupil
Continuity with previous behaviour
Pupils taking school meals at least three times a week this year had, for the most part, also taken school meals last year. Among those previously in primary school, patterns typically involved either having school meals or bringing a packed lunch, suggesting that habits formed earlier tended to carry over. By contrast, pupils who reported taking school meals very infrequently this year had a higher reported proportion who have not taken school meals in the previous academic year. Some said they had previously bought lunch in school but had chosen to stop, with the main reason being the canteen queues, which pupils and school staff perceived to have become longer since the Test of Change.
Convenience and time
Time and convenience were prominent influences on pupils’ lunchtime decisions. Pupils weighed the time required to queue and collect food against alternatives such as visiting nearby shops. However, leaving the school site was not necessarily quicker. Some pupils acknowledged that queues at local retailers could be as long as those in the canteen, particularly where travel time was also considered.
“I can’t be bothered going to the shop… it takes a bit of time to get to [the] shop then the line will be [long].” - Pupil
Lunch period organisation
Although not all schools had adopted this approach, some had put in place staggered lunches for younger year groups, with certain cohorts allowed into the canteen earlier than the rest of the school. Pupils who experienced staggered lunches described them positively. They enjoyed a less noisy and crowded queue and felt reassured that the items they wanted would not run out before they were served. Pupils consistently highlighted the calmer environment and improved access to preferred items as key benefits of staggered lunchtimes. It was also noted that earlier entry reduced waiting time at the peak of service, which in turn gave pupils more time to eat and to join friends or attend lunchtime clubs. In relation to wider lunchtime pressures described elsewhere (for example, concerns about crowding and queuing), staggered access was perceived as a practical way to ease congestion and improve the experience for many pupils and staff.
Pupils also valued pre‑ordering, where this was available. Observations in some schools indicated that pre‑order queues were generally shorter and moved faster than the main lunch line. As food was pre‑packed and already paid for, pupils were able to be served (or just pick up the bag with their name on it) much more quickly. Pupils also valued the predictability that pre‑ordering provided, as they could secure items before they ran out. Catering staff noted an increase in pupils using the pre‑order function and commented that it helped them manage the lunchtime queues. In particular, the pre‑order queue tended to be located away from the main lunch queue, meaning there were fewer pupils grouped in one area at the start of the lunch period. There was a view from school staff that this separation reduced congestion and supported a smoother flow through.
It was also mentioned by one pupil that they felt safer staying on school grounds during the lunch period in case they experienced a medical issue.
Queues, crowding and the canteen environment
Queuing was a strong theme among pupils who were dissatisfied with the canteen experience. Pupils described queues as “rowdy” or “chaotic”. This could put them off getting a school meal, even if queues at shops were equally long. In some settings, pupils pointed to measures such as staggered lunches for younger year groups or using pre‑ordering as effective ways to reduce queuing, although these were not universal and did not address all concerns.
The canteen environment could also be off-putting. There were pupils who described their canteen as being “noisy” or “messy” which could make it unpleasant to eat in. Some were concerned about behavioural issues that disturbed their lunch break. When possible, there were pupils who took food to another area of the school to avoid this.
School staff also identified the canteen environment as a potential barrier to uptake of school meals. Several schools noted increases in wait times and busier canteens since the Test of Change. Staff reported that crowding was greatest at peak service times. They considered that longer waits left less time to eat and increased the likelihood that popular items would no longer be available by the time some pupils were served. This was also echoed by parents.
“I think it does get really noisy at lunchtime [according to my child]. With the amount of children that are actually in the school, I can imagine that'll be quite off putting sometimes.” - Parent
“People were skipping the queue and by the time [my child] got their lunch, like it was time to go to class and they weren’t [getting time to eat it]. They were hungry, so I thought if I give them a packed lunch, […] they’re not having to wait.” - Parent
Peer group influence
Participants across all groups interviewed described peer influence as an important factor shaping lunchtime decisions. Pupils described not wanting to be “left behind” in the canteen if their friends went out for lunch, with the desire to stay together as a group often taking precedence over individual food preferences. Pupils reported mirroring what friends were doing, with lunchtime choices varying day to day depending on group plans. Survey findings showed that girls were more likely than boys to say they get school meals because their friends do (23% vs 14%).
This dynamic operated in both directions. For some, going off site was primarily about being with friends for the whole lunch period. As noted above, a few acknowledged that local shop queues could be just as long as the canteen queue but still preferred to go out to remain with their group. For others, staying in was easier when friends also chose the canteen, some pupils described adjusting what they bought (for example, opting for grab‑and‑go items) so they could eat with friends in classrooms or other spaces rather than sit in the canteen.
School staff similarly noted that some shy pupils did not want to stand out by doing something different from their friends. As one staff member put it:
“The secondary schools are so different. They have the ability to leave. They have more peer pressure to leave or to do X, Y and Z.” - Senior teacher
Staff emphasised that this peer influence could outweigh other considerations, such as queue length or weather, when groups were set on leaving the school grounds.
Parents also agreed that peer group choice was a major influence on what their child did at lunch.
Personal preference
A major influence identified by pupils, staff and parents was personal preference. Some pupils simply did not like the food on offer, often self‑identifying as “picky eaters.” Predictability mattered, going to local shops or bringing a packed lunch allowed them to ensure they got something they knew they liked. Descriptors of school food used by pupils included “bland,” “plain” and “greasy”. As one pupil put it,
“I’ve never tried them, but I’ve saw my friend eat some once […] they look bland […] I just wouldn’t […] choose that over Chinese.” - Pupil
Pupils eligible for FSM had a higher reported proportion who say meals had improved since the start of the school year in Autumn 2025 (26%) than those not eligible for FSM (16%). S1 pupils were most likely to say meals had become better (23%), compared with S2 (19%) and S3 (12%). Conversely, S3 pupils were most likely to report that meals had become worse (22%), compared with S2 (9%) and S1 (7%). Boys were more likely than girls to say meals had become worse (16% vs 10%).
In some schools, nearby supermarkets and takeaway outlets provided easily accessible alternatives to the school canteen. Staff noted that nearby retailers were not subject to the same nutritional standards governing food provided within schools, although the evaluation did not compare the nutritional content of pupils’ purchases.
“Some of the kids just want to go get chips.” - School catering staff member
Several parents wanted pupils to be involved in menu planning, proposing group discussions to gather their preferences. Pupils echoed this, suggesting a voting system so everyone feels included in what the canteen serves.
Another aspect related to the desire for “freedom” during the lunch period. Pupils commonly described needing a break from school and wanting some “fresh air” by leaving the premises:
“You’re with your pals and like something to do other than just sitting in at lunch time waiting for time to go past.” - Pupil
School staff recognised this preference:
“Sure they like to go out, you know they do just like to get out and escape for a wee while.” - School catering staff member
The findings suggest that off-site lunchtime choices were influenced not only by food preferences but also by pupils’ desire for autonomy, a change of environment and spending time with friends
For some, going out offered a change of scene and, at times, access to what they perceived as a bigger or fresher selection of food in a quieter environment; for others, staying in was preferable when the on‑site food options aligned with their tastes. Survey data showed that S1 and S2 pupils were more likely than S3 to choose school meals because they liked the food on offer (37% and 36% vs 23%).
A further consideration raised by schools concerned pupils not attending school, or those on flexible or adapted timetables, whose individual arrangements meant they were not always present during the lunch period. Although some could arrive earlier or remain later to access a meal, staff considered that these arrangements could make the entitlement less practically accessible. The evaluation did not establish how many newly eligible pupils were affected.
Stigma and perceptions
Some staff considered that stigma associated with FSM might still influence a small number of pupils and families, despite the use of cashless systems that did not visibly identify recipients at the till.
“There may be stigma attached to free school meals and even if that’s… due to family perception… that may be a potential barrier.” - Senior teacher
“Even just calling it free school meals is a bit of a… [issue]… when they feel that they’re getting a handout.” - Senior teacher
There was a view that some pupils might hesitate to use their FSM allowance, not realising that the process at the till is very discreet and that other pupils would not be able to tell who was entitled to FSM. This overlapped with wider peer considerations reported elsewhere, including not wanting to “stand out” by doing something different from friends.
Some participating parents were uncertain about whether other pupils could identify FSM recipients at the point of sale, which could make them hesitant about accessing FSM. Although participants did not report witnessing overt stigmatisation, some staff considered that concerns about being identified might not always be visible to schools.
Survey responses did not indicate that overt embarrassment was widespread among respondents. Six per cent described receiving FSM at their school as quite or very embarrassing, while 58% said it was not very or not at all embarrassing. However, 36% said they did not know. These findings do not rule out less visible forms of stigma or concerns among particular groups of people.
A quarter of survey parents thought there was at least some stigma associated with FSM, while 29% thought there was little or none, and 42% were unsure.
Language and communication barriers
As discussed in Chapter 4, language and communication barriers were mentioned by staff as possibly limiting FSM uptake.
Time of year
Staff in many schools reported that canteen use varied with weather conditions and the school calendar. They perceived higher use during cold or wet weather and lower use on warmer days. Lunch uptake was also noted as lower during Ramadan and varied across different days of the week.
Contact
Email: socialresearch@gov.scot