Free School Meals Test of Change: Evaluation of expanded eligibility for S1-S3 pupils in receipt of Scottish Child Payment
An evaluation of the Free School Meals Test of Change, which expanded eligibility for free school meals to S1-S3 pupils in families receiving Scottish Child Payment in selected secondary schools
Appendix D – Text from LA lead discussion guide
Introduction (5 minutes)
- Introduce self and Ipsos, thank participant for their time
- Remind them the purpose of the research:
- We've been commissioned by the Scottish Government to evaluate the targeted expansion of Free School Meals to S1-S3 this year. We’re starting off with a scoping phase to gain a better understanding of how the Test of Change has been implemented in participating LAs. This interview is part of the scoping phase, so it will be really useful in a moment to hear about your experiences of setting up the FSM programme and what has worked well or less well.
- The information from this conversation will be used to help us understand how the programme is working in practice and how to approach the rest of the evaluation. It will also inform our report for the Scottish Government, which will be published.
- We may include quotes from interviews in this report. Quotes will be anonymous as far as possible. However, due to the small number of people in some relevant professional roles, there is a chance that some parts of the report may be identifying to some readers (even if you are not quoted directly). Given this, do let us know if there is anything you do not want to be quoted directly in the report (I will check in on this at the end of the interview).
- While I will be taking notes, it would also be very helpful to audio-record the discussion today to make sure I’ve captured all the details accurately. The recording will only be used by the Ipsos research team for analysis purposes and will be securely deleted once the project is complete. Would you be happy for me to record the interview?
- If yes, start recording now. Let participant know that the recording has started, record verbal consent to take part and for the interview to be recorded.
Background and context (5 minutes)
To start off with, could you share your job role and your key responsibilities in relation to the FSM expansion?
- If not already clear: How/why did you become involved with the FSM expansion?
What is your general understanding of the FSM S1-S3 expansion and what it is aiming to achieve?
What were the key considerations for your Local Authority in deciding to participate?
- For instance, what did you assume about the level of need in your area, the existing catering capacity, or how families and pupils would respond to the offer?
Any initial concerns?
Overview of implementation (10 minutes)
Thanks very much. It would be great if you could give me an overview of what the rollout and implementation phase of the FSM S1-S3 expansion looks like in [LA].
Probe on how it works in practice:
- Number of schools involved
- Communication with schools
- Communication with families
- Application processes for parents/carers
- Admin/activities
Overall, what has gone well so far?
- Any differences by school?
- What have been the enablers that have supported this?
Overall, what have been the main challenges or unexpected issues encountered so far?
- Any differences by school? E.g. staffing/menu planning/canteen environment/uptake
- What is the impact of these challenges on the programme and how far it can meet expected outcomes?
- Any impact on the rollout timelines?
Planning and resources (8 minutes)
Thanks. Now that I have a better understanding of how everything is working, I want to think back for a moment to when you were first planning the programme.
What was your approach to planning and preparing for the expansion of FSM?
Were there any parts of the programme that were particularly influenced by the local context of [Local Authority]? E.g. things like your urban/rural mix, demographics, existing school food culture, or even transport links.
How long did it take to prepare to rollout the programme?
What types of preparation were needed?
Which resources, including staff time, (inputs) have been required to implement the programme?
How easy is it for the catering side of things and the education side to collaborate on the FSM programme (both at the LA level and within schools)?
Uptake (5 minutes)
How many additional pupils became eligible for FSM due to receiving SCP, who weren’t eligible before?
How many pupils are eligible for FSM under the old criteria? (Who were eligible before the expansion)
Do you have a sense of what uptake is looking like at the moment?
Note: Distinguish between uptake at registration level (how many pupils are registered for/have applied for FSM generally) compared to how often FSM are actually taken each day/week.
Note: Clarify whether participants have uptake information for just the SCP cohort, as well as for FSM generally.
For the following discussion of uptake, ideally this would be referring to SCP. But if they need to discuss uptake of FSM more generally, please note this in the codeframe.
Is it in line with expectations?
- If lower than expected: What factors may be limiting uptake? How can these factors be addressed, if at all?
- If higher than expected: has this caused any problems for you?
If yes: How have these problems been dealt with?
- Is this expected to change throughout the year?
Are you seeing variations in uptake across different schools or types of family?
- If yes: What do you think the reasons for that are?
Probe re factors influencing this: communication to families, menu choices, dining environment, social aspects, ability to leave school premises, proximity of external food outlets, payment systems
Data availability (7 minutes)
How did you make newly eligible families aware?
- Were there any challenges with that? Did anything help?
What data, if any, are you collecting on uptake?
We have also been told that data sharing permissions have been established with Social Security Scotland so that eligible families can be identified and contacted directly. How has this approach been working in practice for your LA/schools?
We understand that LAs have formed a working group to share best practices on data collection. Is that something you’re involved with?
- If yes: How has this been going? Have any useful insights/solutions been shared so far?
Impacts & outcomes (10 minutes)
While it's still early days, what impacts do you think the FSM expansion will have (or is already having) for families in participating schools?
For each impact:
- What specific aspects of the FSM expansion do you think will lead to this? (reference activities mentioned earlier, e.g. communications with families, menu planning, school coordination)
Probe on types of possible impacts, if needed:
- Short-term outcomes e.g. uptake/canteen dynamics/immediate relief for family budgets
- Support for families facing food insecurity or reducing child poverty
- Pupils' health, wellbeing, or nutritional choices
- Academic engagement, attendance, or behaviour
Might there be any unintended consequences, positive or negative, as a result of the FSM expansion?
Are there any particular local factors that might influence the extent to which the programme can achieve intended impacts in your local authority?
Do you think any of the outcomes of the expansion might influence each other in any way?
From your perspective, what are the key questions or areas that this evaluation should focus on to inform future policy decisions regarding the FSM programme?
Evaluation practicalities (8 minutes)
For the final part of the interview, it would be helpful to discuss some practicalities of the evaluation.
We plan to conduct in-depth qualitative fieldwork in some case study schools in March next year. This will include 2 of the participating schools in each Local Authority. We would like to select a mix of schools to reflect different contexts and experiences (e.g., rural vs. urban, large vs. small, high vs. low deprivation, varying uptake rates).
- Firstly, could you confirm which schools are participating in your LA? (Can ask for a written list via email if easier, but good to check on the overall number)
- Do you have any thoughts on which schools might be best to visit in [your LA]? Why?
- Are there any schools you would advise us to avoid? If yes: why is that?
- Anything to be mindful of around visiting schools at that time of year?
Once we've agreed on the case study schools with the Scottish Government, would you be able to put us in touch with the most appropriate contact at the schools?
In March, we'll be looking to interview pupils, parents, catering staff, and senior teachers within these schools.
Are there particular topics you think we should ask about? (Particularly for parents and pupils)
For the pupil interviews we want to speak to those who are newly eligible for FSM, including both those who have chosen to take them up and those who have not taken them up. Do you think it will be possible to identify pupils in these two groups?
- Are there any other characteristics you think it will be important for us to be mindful of when sampling pupils?
We are also planning to conduct two short 10-minute surveys – one with pupils and one with parents. We can discuss the practicalities further nearer the time, and with the case study schools directly too, but we thought it would be helpful to put this on your radar just now.
- The plan for the parents survey is to share a survey link with all parents of S1-S3 pupils at participating schools. We would prepare materials for schools to send to parents on our behalf..
- The pupil survey will only be S1-S3 pupils at the schools we visit, because that will need to be done in class and we will work closely with schools to support with administering it.
- Does this approach sound generally okay? Any immediate concerns?
Wrap-up (2 minutes)
Thanks very much, that’s all the questions I had to ask today. Is there anything else you'd like to add that we haven't covered?
Thank you again for your time. I’ll just stop the recording now. Stop recording
We’ll be back in touch about school selection and school visits.
Contact
Email: socialresearch@gov.scot