Free School Meals Test of Change: Evaluation of expanded eligibility for S1-S3 pupils in receipt of Scottish Child Payment

An evaluation of the Free School Meals Test of Change, which expanded eligibility for free school meals to S1-S3 pupils in families receiving Scottish Child Payment in selected secondary schools


Executive Summary

Policy context

In the 2025-26 academic year, the Scottish Government funded a Free School Meals Test of Change, extending eligibility to pupils in S1-S3 whose families receive the Scottish Child Payment (SCP). The Test of Change was delivered across 60 schools in eight participating local authorities (LAs): Aberdeen City, Fife, Glasgow City, Moray, North Ayrshire, South Lanarkshire, Shetland Islands and Comhairle nan Eilean Siar. This evaluation was commissioned to understand implementation, uptake, impacts and scalability, to inform future policy decisions.

Report and methods

The evaluation used a mixed-methods approach to explore how the Test of Change was implemented and experienced across participating LAs. The research included virtual qualitative interviews with eight LA leads; in-person and virtual interviews with 13 senior teachers, 27 catering staff, 72 newly eligible pupils and 21 parents across 14 case study schools; observations of lunchtime provision in the 14 case study schools; a parent survey with 2,717 respondents; a pupil survey with 881 respondents; and analysis of available LA monitoring data.

Planning and early implementation

Participating LAs welcomed the Test of Change and viewed it as closely aligned with local child poverty priorities. Cross-departmental partnership working, including collaboration between education, catering, finance, benefits, legal and communications teams, supported implementation in many areas. However, the time required for establishing data sharing arrangements between Social Security Scotland and LAs compressed implementation timescales and increased pressure on administrative teams. Some areas experienced delays in matching eligibility data and communicating with families, which stakeholders believed contributed to lower uptake. Monitoring uptake of the Test of Change separately to wider FSM uptake was challenging in some LAs.

Engaging newly eligible families

Parents generally described application processes as straightforward, particularly where families only needed to confirm participation rather than provide evidence of eligibility. However, barriers remained for some families, including language barriers, literacy difficulties, digital exclusion and requirements to upload SCP award letters. Communications were most effective when they combined messaging from LAs and schools, used multiple channels and clearly targeted newly eligible families. Despite a wide range of communication activity, around half of surveyed parents receiving SCP reported that they were not aware of the Test of Change. Evidence suggested that earlier communication and ongoing follow-up activity appeared to support greater awareness and uptake. Cashless payment systems were viewed positively for helping maintain confidentiality and reducing stigma.

Operational capacity and scalability

Participating schools were selected by LAs on the basis that they were expected to be able to manage the Test of Change within existing resources. As a result, findings on capacity are likely to represent a more favourable picture than might be expected under wider national implementation. Capacity pressures depended largely on the number of newly eligible pupils and levels of uptake. In many schools, lower-than-expected uptake limited operational burden.

Where pressures emerged, these typically related to staffing, kitchen equipment and dining space. Staffing was the main reported challenge, particularly during periods of illness or where relief cover was limited. Schools identified several approaches that helped manage demand, including pre-ordering systems, additional till points, takeaway options and staggered lunchtimes. Findings suggest that any future expansion would benefit from local assessments of staffing, catering infrastructure, dining capacity and expected demand.

Free school meal uptake and influences

Monitoring data indicated substantial variation in meal use among newly eligible pupils across participating areas. Qualitative research suggested that newly eligible pupils typically used their FSM allowance several times each week, although frequency varied. Uptake was influenced by a range of interacting factors including food quality, convenience, peer relationships, awareness of entitlement, personal preferences and the lunchtime environment. While there was limited perceived stigma around FSM described by participants, there was a suggestion that uncertainty about how free school meals were perceived by others and misconceptions about payment systems may still be barriers for some pupils and families. Communication, language and digital literacy barriers also limited uptake in some cases.

Perceived impacts for pupils and parents

Most surveyed parents whose child became newly eligible reported saving money, with many using these savings to help cover household costs such as food, bills and clothing. This was in line with findings from qualitative interviews with parents, who also described improved wellbeing as a result of this and a reduced mental load. Pupils generally reported positive or neutral experiences of school meals. Among surveyed pupils who ate school meals, the most commonly reported perceived benefit was feeling less hungry during the school day, while pupils were less certain about benefits for concentration, attendance and nutrition.

Conclusions

The Test of Change was broadly welcomed by LAs, schools, parents and pupils. Overall, participating schools were generally able to deliver the Test of Change without insurmountable practical challenges. Findings suggest that successful wider implementation would depend on ensuring effective data-sharing arrangements, sufficient operational capacity, and a school meal offer that reflects the practical, social and behavioural factors influencing pupils' lunchtime choices.

Contact

Email: socialresearch@gov.scot

Back to top