Independence in the modern world. Wealthier, happier, fairer: why not Scotland?

This paper sets out a detailed analysis of the UK’s performance across a range of economic and social indicators relative to that of ten European countries. It is the first in the 'Building a new Scotland' series, focusing on independence.


Barrett Academy for the Advancement of Human Values and AxiaOrigin. Global Wellbeing Indicators (Barrett Academy for the Advancement of Human Values and AxiaOrigin), URL: (Accessed March 2022)

Bell A et al. (2019) Who Becomes an Inventor in America? The Importance of Exposure to Innovation (The Quarterly Journal of Economics), URL:

Bell T et al. (2021) The UK's decisive decade: The launch report for The Economy 2030 Inquiry (Resolution Foundation), URL:

Besley T and Dann C (2022) How might an independent Scotland build fiscal capacity? (Economics Observatory), URL:

Besley T (2020) State Capacity, Reciprocity, and the Social Contract (Econometrica), URL:

Bickerton C (2018) Brexit and the British Growth Model: Towards a new social settlement (Policy Exchange), URL:

Bjorsted E, Bova E and Dahl S (2016) Lessons Learnt from the Nordics: How to Fight Long-term Unemployment (Intereconomics), URL:

Brewer M et al. (2022) Social Insecurity: Assessing trends in social security to prepare for the decade of change ahead (Resolution Foundation), URL:

Byrne S, Conefrey T and O'Grady M (2021) The Disconnection of GDP from Economic Activity Carried out in Ireland (Central Bank of Ireland), URL:

Cameron D (1978) The Expansion of the Public Economy: A Comparative Analysis (The American Political Science Review), URL:

Cazes S, Garnero A and Martin S (2017) The state of trade unions, employer organisations, and collective bargaining in OECD countries (Vox EU), URL:,collective%20bargaining%20in%20OECD%20countries&text=Trade%20union%20membership%20has%20been,inequality%20and%20poor%20wage%20growth

Clarke S (2019) Mapping gaps: Geographic inequality in productivity and living standards (Resolution Foundation), URL:

Cominetti N et al. (2022) Changing jobs? Change in the UK labour market and the role of worker mobility (Resolution Foundation), URL:

Conchon A (2015) Workers' voice in corporate governance: A European perspective (Trades Union Congress), URL:

Coulter S (2018) Social Partnership in Europe in the face of the future (London School of Economics and Political Science), URL:

Coyle D and Muhtar A (2021) UK's Industrial Policy: Learning from the past? (The Productivity Institute), URL:

Cunliffe J (2017) Are firms underinvesting – and if so why? (Bank of England), URL:

Damgaard J, Elkjaer T and Johannesen N (2019) The Rise of Phantom Investments (International Monetary Fund), URL:

Danish Government (2019) Prepared for the future of work: Follow-up on the Danish Disruption Council (The Danish Government), URL:

Danninger S (2016) What's Up with U.S. Wage Growth and Job Mobility? (IMF Working Paper), URL:

De Loecker J, Obermeier T and Reenen J. (2022) Firms and inequality (Institute for Fiscal Studies), URL:,can%20foster%20higher%20wage%20inequality

Esping-Andersen G. The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism, Princeton University Press, 1990.

Euricse Research Team (2021) World Cooperative Monitor: Exploring the cooperative economy (International Cooperative Alliance), URL:

European Commission (2021) Bloomberg Innovation Index 2021 [News Release] (European Commission), URL:

European Commission (2021) The EU-UK Trade and Cooperation Agreement (European Commission), URL:

European Commission (n.d.) Flexicurity (European Commission), URL:

European Commission (n.d.) Internal Market, Industry, Entrepreneurship and SMEs (European Commission), URL:

European Commission (2022) Net Replacement Rate including UB (European Commission), URL: (Accessed March 2022)

European Commission (2021) The Digital Economy and Society Index (DESI) (European Commission), URL: (Accessed March 2022)

European Monitoring Centre on Change (2021) Job security councils (Eurofound), URL:

European Observatory of Working Life (2020) Co-determination (Eurofound), URL:

Eurostat (2022) Child specific material deprivation rate by age (children aged 1 to 15) (Eurostat), URL: (Accessed March 2022)

Eurostat (2022) Gender pay gap in unadjusted form (Eurostat), URL: (Accessed March 2022)

Eurostat (2022) In-work at-risk-of-poverty rate by age and sex - EU-SILC survey (Eurostat), URL: (Accessed March 2022)

FitzGerald J (2018) National accounts for a global economy: the case of Ireland (Economic and Social Research Institute), URL:

Haldane A (2015) Who owns a company? (Bank of England), URL:

Hall P and Soskice D (2001) Varieties of Capitalism: The Institutional Foundations of Comparative Advantage (Oxford Scholarship Online), URL: (

Hammar K and IMF Survey (2015) IMF Survey : Iceland Makes Strong Recovery from 2008 Financial Crisis (International Monetary Fund), URL:

Hansmann H and Thomsen S (2021) The Governance of Foundation-Owned Firms (Journal of Legal Analysis), URL:

Hayden G and Bodie M (2021) Codetermination in Theory and Practice (Saint Louis University School of Law), URL:

Helliwell J et al. (2021) World Happiness Report 2021 (World Happiness Report), URL: (Accessed March 2022)

Holmberg S (2017) Fighting Short-Termism with Worker Power: Can Germany's Co-Determination System Fix American Corporate Governance? (Roosevelt Institute), URL:

Howell D and Kalleberg A (2022) Labour market inequality: a comparative political economy perspective (The IFS Deaton Review of Inequalities), URL:

Hsieh et al. (2019) The Allocation of Talent and U.S. Economic Growth (Econometrica), URL:

Hutton W. How Good We Can Be: Ending the Mercenary Society and Building a Great Country (2nd Edition). London: Little, Brown, 2015.

IMD World Competitiveness Centre. World Competitiveness Ranking (IMD World Competitiveness Centre), URL: (Accessed March 2022)

Institute for Codetermination and Corporate Governance (2019) Why codetermination? A collection of good arguments for strong workers' voice (Institute for Codetermination and Corporate Governance), URL:

International Monetary Fund (2022) IMF Staff Statement on the Economic Impact of War in Ukraine (International Monetary Fund), URL:

Jager S, Noy S and Schoefer B (2021) What Does Codetermination Do? (Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance), URL:

Jager S, Schoefer B and Heining J (2020) Labor in the Boardroom (The Quarterly Journal of Economics), URL:

Just Arrived, Luxembourg (2022) Luxembourg: a dynamic labor market (Just Arrived, Luxembourg), URL:

Kay J (2012) The Kay Review of UK Equity Markets and Long-Term Decision Making (UK Government), URL:

Knight Frank (2022) UK Cities: Themes for 2022 (Knight Frank), URL:

Koo J, Choi Y and Park I (2019) Innovation and welfare: the marriage of an unlikely couple (Policy and Society), URL:

Kruse D (2016) Does employee ownership improve performance? (IZA World of Labor), URL:

Living Wage Foundation (2021) Almost two-fifths of working adults given less than a week's notice of working hours (Living Wage Foundation), URL:

Logue J and Yates J (2006) Cooperatives, Worker-Owned Enterprises, Productivity and the International Labor Organization (Economic and Industrial Democracy), URL:

Mayer C (2022) Inequality, firms, ownership and governance (The IFS Deaton Review of Inequalities), URL:

Mayer C. Firm Commitment: Why the corporation is failing us and how to restore trust in it, Oxford University Press, 2013.

Mayer C. Prosperity: Better Business Makes the Greater Good, Oxford University Press, 2018.

McCann P (2019) Perceptions of Regional Inequality and the Geography of Discontent: Insights from the UK (Regional Studies), URL:

Michie J and Sheehan M (2003) Labour market deregulation, 'flexibility' and innovation (Cambridge Journal of Economics), URL:

Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment, New Zealand (2022) Fair Pay Agreements, URL:

Montgomery S (2022) War in Ukraine is changing energy geopolitics (The Conversation), URL:

Nance M and Daly J (2018) The Nordic Model and Structural Change: Lessons from the Collapse of Saab Automobile AB (Intereconomics), URL:

O'Connor S (2021) We're still in the dark about insecure work (Financial Times), URL:

O'Grada C and O'Rourke K (2021) The Irish economy during the century after partition (The Economic History Review), URL:

O'Rourke K (2017) Independent Ireland in Comparative Perspective (Irish Economic and Social History), URL:

O'Rourke, K. A Short History of Brexit: From Brentry to Backstop. Pelican Books.

Office for Budget Responsibility (2022) Brexit analysis (Office for Budget Responsibility), URL:

Office of the United States Trade Representative and Executive Office of the President. (2019) United States-United Kingdom Negotiations: Summary of Specific Negotiating Objectives (Office of the United States Trade Representative and Executive Office of the President), URL:

OECD (2018) A Broken Social Elevator? How to Promote Social Mobility (OECD), URL:

OECD (2020) Supporting people and companies to deal with the COVID-19 virus: Options for an immediate employment and social-policy response (OECD), URL:

OECD (2020) Better Life Index (OECD), URL:

OECD (2020) Paid sick leave to protect income, health and jobs through the COVID-19 crisis (OECD), URL:

OECD (2021) Economic Policy Reforms 2021 (OECD), URL:

OECD (2022) Average wages (indicator). doi: 10.1787/cc3e1387-en. URL: (Accessed March 2022)

OECD (2022) Employment rate (indicator). doi: 10.1787/1de68a9b-en. URL: (Accessed March 2022)

OECD (2022) Gross domestic spending on R&D (indicator). doi: 10.1787/d8b068b4-en. URL: (Accessed March 2022)

OECD (2022) Household disposable income (indicator). doi: 10.1787/dd50eddd-en. URL: (Accessed March 2022)

OECD (2022) Income inequality (indicator). doi: 10.1787/459aa7f1-en. URL: (Accessed March 2022)

OECD (2022) Life expectancy at birth (indicator). doi: 10.1787/27e0fc9d-en. URL: (Accessed March 2022)

OECD (2022) Investment by sector (indicator). doi: 10.1787/abd72f11-en. (Accessed March 2022)

OECD (2022) General government spending (indicator). doi: 10.1787/a31cbf4d-en. URL: (Accessed March 2022)

OECD (2022) General government revenue (indicator). doi: 10.1787/b68b04ae-en. URL: (Accessed March 2022)

OECD (2022) Income distribution, OECD Social and Welfare Statistics (database), URL: (accessed March 2022)

OECD (2022) Poverty rate (indicator). doi: 10.1787/0fe1315d-en. URL: (Accessed March 2022)

OECD (2022) Public spending on labour markets (indicator). doi: 10.1787/911b8753-en. URL: (Accessed March 2022)

OECD (2022) Trust in government (indicator). doi: 10.1787/1de9675e-en. URL: (Accessed March 2022)

OECD (2022) Wage levels (indicator). doi: 10.1787/0a1c27bc-en. URL: (Accessed March 2022)

OECD (2022) Indicators of Employment Protection (OECD), URL:
(Accessed March 2022)

OECD (2022) Indicators of Product Market Regulation (OECD), URL: (Accessed March 2022)

OECD (2022) Level of GDP per capita and productivity (OECD.Stat), URL: (Accessed March 2022)

OECD (2022) GDP per capita and productivity levels, OECD Productivity Statistics (database), URL: (Accessed March 2022)

OECD (2022) Purchasing Power Parities - Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) (OECD), URL: (Accessed March 2022)

OECD (2022) Statutory corporate income tax rate (OECD.Stat), URL: (Accessed March 2022)

OECD (2022) Trade Union Dataset (OECD.Stat), URL: (Accessed March 2022)

Ortiz-Ospina E and Roser M. (2022) Happiness and Life Satisfaction (Our World in Data), URL:

Pannini E. (2018) The hidden damages of labour market deregulation and the underrated merits of trade unions (The London School of Economics and Political Science), URL:

Perotin V. (2020) What do we really know about worker co-operatives? (Co-operatives UK), URL:

Rees-Mogg, J. 'I want Sun readers to write to me and tell me of any petty old EU regulation that should be abolished', The Sun, 10 February 2022. URL:

Rodrik D. (1998) Why do More Open Economies Have Bigger Governments? (Journal of Political Economy), URL:

Sandbu M. Brexit and the Future of UK Capitalism, The Political Quarterly, Vol 90, Issue S2, 2019. URL:

Sanders F. (2021) Post-Brexit trade (KPMG), URL:

Schwab K, Zahidi S and World Economic Forum. (2020) The Global Competitiveness Report: Special Edition 2020 - How Countries are Performing on the Road to Recovery (World Economic Forum), URL:

Scott A and Arnold P. (2021) Why rising FDI beckons for Scotland but engagement remains key (Ernst and Young Global Limited), URL:

Scottish Development International. Health and Life Sciences Industries (Scottish Development International), URL:

Scottish Enterprise. (2021) GlobalScot – 20 years of promoting Scotland internationally (Scottish Enterprise), URL:

Scottish Government (2019). Scotland's place in Europe: assessment of the revised EU withdrawal agreement and political declaration (Scottish Government), URL:

Scottish Government. (2019) Arctic Connections: Scotland's Arctic policy framework (Scottish Government), URL:

Scottish Government. (2019) Scotland: a trading nation (Scottish Government), URL:

Scottish Government. (2020) Scottish Social Attitudes 2019: attitudes to government and political engagement (Scottish Government), URL:

Scottish Government. (2020) The European Union's Strategic Agenda 2020-2024: Scotland's Perspective (Scottish Government), URL:

Scottish Government. (2020) UK internal market: initial assessment of UK Government proposals (Scottish Government), URL:

Scottish Government. (2021) After Brexit: The UK Internal Market Act and devolution (Scottish Government), URL:

Scottish Government. (2021) Scottish connections (diaspora) work: literature review (Scottish Government), URL:

Scottish Government. (2022) Scottish Natural Capital Accounts: 2022 (Scottish Government), URL:

Scottish Government. (2021) Steadfastly European, Scotland's past, present and future (Scottish Government), URL:

Scottish Government. (2021) The Brexit vote, 5 years on - what do we know so far? (Scottish Government), URL:

Scottish Government. (2021) Gross expenditure on research and development Scotland 2019 (Scottish Government), URL:

Scottish Government. (2022) Scotland's National Strategy for Economic Transformation (Scottish Government), URL:

Scottish Government. (2022) Scottish Household Survey 2020 - telephone survey: key findings (Scottish Government), URL:

Scottish Government. (2022) Tackling Child Poverty Delivery Plan 2022-26 (Scottish Government), URL:

Scottish Government. Wellbeing Economy Governments (WEGo) (Scottish Government), URL:

Skilling D. (2018) Policy insights for Scotland from small advanced economies (Reform Scotland in association with the Scottish Policy Foundation), URL:

Smithers A. (2013) The Road to Recovery: How and Why Economic Policy Must Change, Wiley, 2013.

Smithers A. (2015) Executive pay holds the key to the productivity puzzle (Financial Times), URL:

Smithers A. (2019) Productivity and the Bonus Culture (Oxford Scholarship Online), URL:

Springford J. (2021) The Cost of Brexit: October 2021 (Centre for European Reform), URL:

Sustainable Growth Commission (2018) Scotland – The New Case For Optimism: A strategy for inter-generational economic renaissance, URL:

The Purposeful Company Task Force. (2017) The Purposeful Company (Big Innovation Centre), URL:

The State of European Tech 2020. Investments by Geography & Industry (The State of European Tech 2020), URL:>

The University of Manchester, Alliance Manchester Business School (2022) AMBS appoints world-renowned regional economist (The University of Manchester, Alliance Manchester Business School). URL:

Thormann K. (2018) The Disruption Council: A partnership for the future of Denmark (The Danish Ministry of Employment), URL:

Times Higher Education. (2022) World University Rankings 2022 (Time Higher Education), URL:!/page/0/length/25/sort_by/rank/sort_order/asc/cols/stats

Tomlinson D. (2018) Irregular payments: Assessing the breadth and depth of month to month earnings volatility (Resolution Foundation), URL:

Trade Union Advisory Committee (2018) The Swedish Job Security Councils – A case study on social partners' led transitions (TUAC), URL:

UK Government. (2010) Transforming the British economy: Coalition strategy for economic growth (UK Government), URL:

UK Government. (2022) Levelling Up the United Kingdom (UK Government), URL:

UK Government. (2022) New jobs mission to get 500,000 into work (UK Government), URL:

UK Government. (2022) The Benefits of Brexit: How the UK is taking advantage of leaving the EU (UK Government), URL:

United Nations Development Programme. (2020) Income share held by richest 1% (United Nations Development Programme), URL: (Accessed March 2022)

United Nations Development Programme. Human Development Report 2020: Human Development Index (HDI) Ranking (United Nations Development Programme), URL: (Accessed March 2022)

Weldon D. The British Model and the Brexit Shock: Plus ça Change? The Political Quarterly, Vol 90, Issue S2, 2019, URL:

Wilson T. (2022) Way to Work - a first step, but we can and must do better (Institute for Employment Studies), URL:

World Bank (2022) Gross fixed capital formation (% of GDP) Data. URL: (Accessed March 2022)

World Economic Forum. (2020) Global Social Mobility Index 2020: why economies benefit from fixing inequality (World Economic Forum), URL: (Accessed March 2022)

World Intellectual Property Organization. (2020) World Intellectual Property Indicators 2020 (World Intellectual Property Organization), URL: (Accessed March 2022)

World Intellectual Property Organization. (2021) Global Innovation Index 2021 (World Intellectual Property Organization), URL: (Accessed March 2022)




Back to top