Scotland House London Evaluation
The evaluation found that Scotland House London is widely considered to be a valuable strategic asset supporting Scotland’s interests in the UK and internationally, while suggesting practical improvements to increase use and refine the offering of SHL
1. Introduction
Background and context
Scotland’s International Network
Scotland has a network of international offices in strategic locations around the world. These offices promote Scottish interests overseas, strengthen relationships with priority countries, and support collaboration between Scotland and international organisations. The network also provides a Scottish presence in particular countries, cities, or regions.
Scotland’s international network comprises seven Scottish Government international offices (Ireland, Germany, France, Denmark, China, Canada and the USA) and two Scotland Houses in Brussels and London. The Scotland Houses are standalone sites operated by the Scottish Government in partnership with various organisations. The two Scotland Houses operate differently, with Scotland House London (SHL) providing a distinct membership offer that is unique within the network.
The priorities and focus of the international network vary, depending on the resources and opportunities available as well as Scotland’s priorities in that country or region. However, all components of the international network work towards the three priority areas set out in Scotland’s International Strategy: Economy, Trade and Investment; Climate Change, Biodiversity and Renewable Energy; and Reputation, Influence and Relationships
Scotland House London (SHL)
Established in 2017, SHL is a platform for Scottish Government (SG) and agency staff based in London and is a co-working and events space in central London. SHL’s location was chosen to be between Westminster and the City of London. It is a collaboration between four partners – the Scottish Government and Scottish Enterprise (including Scottish Development International), VisitScotland, and Scotland Food and Drink (the Partners). More information about SHL and the role of each partner is in Appendix A.
SHL has a unique approach within the international network, focusing on:
- Using strategic engagement with the diplomatic community to develop opportunities for cooperation with partner countries to pursue Scotland’s international agenda as defined in the International Strategy.
- Supporting a comprehensive programme of engagement with investors, central to increasing capital investment flows into Scotland, to promote Scotland’s high-growth industries and strengths in research, innovation, and future technologies.
- Advancing the internationalisation of Scotland’s cultural sector by creating opportunities for Scotland’s creative talent, festivals and institutions to develop partnerships and access new markets through London.
- Offering a modern, high-quality office with a distinctly Scottish identity, providing co-working space, meeting rooms, event facilities, and networking opportunities. It serves as an official London base for public sector organisations to conduct official business and engage with stakeholders, while also offering an affordable, flexible membership model for Scottish businesses.
The need for evaluation
Scottish Ministers hold the lease for SHL on behalf of the Partners. The original ten-year lease on the SHL premises runs from November 2016 to November 2026. Ministers agreed to a 3-year lease extension to November 2029 (with a break clause after 2 years) to allow continuity of presence without committing Ministers appointed after the 2026 Scottish Parliament election to long-term financial commitments.
The extension offers a valuable opportunity to explore options for maximising SHL and to present evidence-based recommendations to Ministers on the future of SHL post 2029.
Since 2017, the international network has been monitored through an internal monitoring and evaluation process. Going forward, the Scottish Government is looking to develop a robust and transparent approach to monitoring and evaluation of the international network, using the lessons from this evaluation to inform it. The Lines Between (TLB) were commissioned to undertake an evaluation of SHL, with the findings from the evaluation to contribute to:
- Assessing SHL’s purpose, role and added value.
- Articulating the impact and effectiveness of SHL, particularly where measurement is currently challenging.
- Informing strategic choices about future operation, resourcing and membership models for SHL.
- Generating learning for wider diplomatic, soft power and international collaboration work undertaken by the Scottish Government and SHL partners.
Methodology and respondent profile
Following an initial familiarisation and design stage, the evaluation involved three main activities: (i) a review of SHL reporting, (ii) analysis of responses to online surveys of SHL stakeholders and members, and (iii) qualitative interviews with 28 SHL partners, stakeholders and members.
Review of SHL reporting
A review of reporting documents was undertaken to glean insights into SHL’s performance since 2019, when the Scottish Government took over management of the membership service from an external company. These documents included business planning spreadsheets, Scotland’s International Network annual reports and SHL reporting. Data was considered across 2019/20 to 2024/25, though the most comprehensive data was available for the years 2022/23 to 2024/25.
The documents were mapped by objectives, activities, and outcomes across the main priority themes of the International Strategy: economy, trade and investment; climate change, biodiversity and renewable energy; and reputation, influence and relationships. In addition, any detail on challenges, impact and relevant background information was captured.
Online surveys of SHL stakeholders and members
The team at SHL designed and hosted two online surveys to explore the perspectives of those who engage with SHL, which were live from 14 January to 25 March 2026. A survey for Stakeholders and Partners (‘stakeholder survey’) received 81 responses, while a survey of Members (‘member survey’) received 26 responses.
Both surveys asked respondents a series of closed (quantitative) and open (qualitative) questions. There were more closed questions in the member survey than in the stakeholder survey. Please note that not all respondents answered every question.
Qualitative interviews
Following discussion with TLB, the team at SHL provided a list of 36 potential contacts to interview in the evaluation. Interviews were conducted with 25 of these 36 contacts (a 69% response rate) and with three other contacts who attended interviews alongside their colleagues or who were recommended by the original contacts. We note that many of the individuals who took part in the interviews held very senior roles within the organisations they represented; the participation of these stakeholders indicates the importance they attached to contributing to conversations about the future of SHL.
In total, 28 stakeholders, partners and members were interviewed between 8 May and 5 June 2026. Interviews were conducted via MS Teams and lasted between 20 and 45 minutes. Interviewees included:
- 18 stakeholders, from the Scottish Government, Scottish Enterprise and industry bodies who use SHL. This included senior Scottish Government staff who have, or who have had, ultimate responsibility for SHL, and former heads of SHL.
- Six chief executives or senior staff from SHL partners, including Scottish Enterprise, VisitScotland and Scotland Food and Drink. This included contacts who had been involved in different stages of SHL’s evolution, such as setting up SHL.
- Four SHL members.
Analysis approach
With agreement from interviewees, all interviews were recorded and transcribed to ensure all perspectives were accurately captured and included in the analysis.
A thematic analysis was conducted of all qualitative interviews. Following a workshop where the research team reviewed a sample of interview transcripts, a coding framework was developed, based on the research questions and emerging themes. Respondent details were recorded to support analysis by respondent type. The evaluation team systematically coded all interview transcripts, breaking down each element into discrete parts and categorising and labelling it against the coding framework; during the analysis process, additional descriptive codes or subcodes were created to capture the breadth of discussion in each data extract.
Survey data was analysed using Excel. Frequency counts were calculated for closed questions, and thematic analysis was undertaken for responses to open questions.
Direct quotes are included to illustrate some of the points made. Some have been lightly edited for brevity or to protect confidentiality, but their meaning has not been changed.
Limitations of the research
Interviewees’ levels of engagement with, and knowledge of, SHL varied considerably. For example, stakeholders and partners could offer their perspectives on the overall strategic value of SHL but may be less likely to use SHL than their wider team and therefore be less able to comment on specific details. Other interviewees, particularly members, used SHL in different ways and may be less expected to comment on SHL’s strategic mission. Given this, interviews sought to produce a cumulative understanding of SHL’s work and impact, based on each interviewee’s own engagement and usage.
The sample invited to take part in interviews did not include all SHL stakeholders, partners or members. While the online surveys were widely distributed, the response rate was not 100%. As a result, the research findings cannot be assumed to be representative of everyone with an interest in SHL.
The online surveys were designed and hosted by SHL, not TLB. Survey evidence is strongest on perceived value and use, not long-term outcomes.
Contact
Email: socialresearch@gov.scot