Scotland House London Evaluation
The evaluation found that Scotland House London is widely considered to be a valuable strategic asset supporting Scotland’s interests in the UK and internationally, while suggesting practical improvements to increase use and refine the offering of SHL
8. How could Scotland House London work more effectively and have more impact?
Key findings
- There was a mostly consistent view that the current SHL model is working well, with a clear role in representing Scotland in London and supporting both policy and economic objectives. However, stakeholders often expressed the view that more could be done to refine SHL’s role and purpose to generate more impact for both Scotland and Scottish businesses in multiple areas. In particular, a recurring minority view was a call for a review of the strategic value of London to Scotland and to ensure SHL’s remit is aligned with any agreed focus.
- Possible refinements took several forms, again often reflecting the nature of stakeholders’ work. Continued or greater focus on economic growth was frequently mentioned, with partners in particular advocating for greater consideration of London and the Southeast as a potential market for Scottish businesses, with SHL being adequately staffed and resourced to capitalise on that opportunity.
- SHL’s work to facilitate bilateral cooperation with foreign governments was widely recognised, though a small number of interviewees advocated for even greater activity in this area. Conversely, while SHL is already seen as well-connected with Whitehall, some interviewees expressed uncertainty around SHL’s mandate to engage with the UK Government, and suggested its role could be more explicit. Others felt SHL’s role in intergovernmental relations could be developed further.
- While SHL’s activities are outlined in its business plan, interviewees suggested that SHL could benefit from being more deliberate and selective in where it focuses its efforts. However, reflecting the diversity of opportunities, there was no clear desire for any one sector to be prioritised over others, and interviewees also broadly agreed that having a range of organisations engaging with SHL would help improve SHL’s convening power.
- A common theme was the need to raise awareness of SHL, both in the Scottish Government and externally. Interviewees called for regular communication, both through internal channels and paid marketing, such as social media, as well as communication with members, to increase visibility and more clearly articulate the value of SHL’s work, which would require additional resources.
- While existing events at SHL are well-received and valued, there is a desire for greater awareness of the events programme and improved forward planning. Interviewees felt this would allow them to plan their involvement more effectively, align with their own activity, ensure that the right stakeholders are engaged, and enhance the overall impact of events.
Sharpening the focus of SHL’s work
Across the interviews, there was a consistent view that the core purpose and direction of SHL is appropriate. Interviewees described a model that is working well, with a clear role in representing Scotland in London and supporting both policy and economic objectives. There was little suggestion that SHL’s overall remit needs to change. Instead, comments focused on how the existing model could be refined to achieve a greater impact.
More broadly, a recurring theme raised by some interviewees was for the Scottish Government to consider how London is viewed and used strategically, which would in turn inform the future role of SHL. They suggested that there could be even greater recognition of the importance of London as a global city and as a forum to maximise international engagement. This includes facilitating greater engagement between SHL and international investors, multinational companies and foreign governments who are active in London. Interviewees felt that a more deliberate approach to using London’s networks could help extend SHL’s reach and have a greater impact in many of its areas of focus.
“I think the trick of it is to think about London a little bit as the capital of the UK, obviously, but also just as a global city. So I think the imagination really needs to kick in there. And for all of us, think about, London is the perfect place to be engaging with the Singapore government or potential investors from Indonesia or wherever it happens to be. And we should be exploiting that opportunity of London as a global city, every bit as much as London as the capital of the UK.” – SG Stakeholder
Economic growth, investment, and London as a market
A recurring theme across interviewees was the importance of continuing to align SHL’s work closely with Scottish Government priorities, in particular, economic growth. Interviewees indicated that this should remain an important lens through which activity is prioritised, particularly in the current policy context. In practice, this means ensuring that all strands of SHL’s work, including policy engagement, events and partnerships, are contributing clearly to that overarching objective.
“I've said that I think economic growth is always going to be the number one priority. And I think being based in London, financial services are going to be is going to be a big part of what I'd want them to be thinking about on economic growth. Having a knowledge of trade, investment, financial services, I would see as being key. I think they're in a reasonably good place on that, but that's always going to be the priority.” – SG Stakeholder
As noted in Chapter 5, some interviewees emphasised the importance of SHL in helping to establish and maintain relationships with capital investors and the financial services sector. They suggested that these relationships can be difficult to build and sustain from Scotland, and that SHL provides a useful platform to help bridge that gap; strengthening activity in this area could help deepen the connection between SHL’s presence in London and outcomes on inward investment and growth.
“I think the government needs to make up its mind as to whether it is serious about using London as a forum from which it drags mobile capital up to Scotland for the big infrastructure investment it needs to advance our economy. At the moment, we kind of play at that. I'm not sure we're serious enough about it. Are we putting the right kind of people in that market at the right level to engage credibly with some of the really powerful capital players that occupy that market about Scotland's offer?” – SG Stakeholder
However, a potential gap noted by some interviewees, particularly Partners, was that London and the Southeast of England should be seen as a potential market for Scottish businesses, and that SHL could be used to provide more support to capitalise on this opportunity. For example, it was noted that SDI staff in other SG international offices provide support to Scottish businesses to export to those markets. Conversely, while teams in SHL may help Scottish organisations access foreign investment and international networks, there is not the same support to ‘export’, or sell, Scottish products to the UK market. Scotland Food and Drink joining as a partner in SHL was seen as a valuable addition in this respect, with their support for the sector helping to market Scottish produce more widely. However, these interviewees felt more could be done to maximise Scotland’s presence in London into tangible economic outcomes.
“One of the things I think Scotland House could do is treat London and the Southeast like a big market for businesses… [SHL] meeting rooms, they're all full of stuff from Scotland. I went and sat in a meeting room, and there was, I think, [Scottish] gin, or there was certainly produce from the Highlands and Islands. And it made me feel really quite proud of it. And then I thought, are we actually selling that stuff? So we're displaying it all, but are we using that for trade missions for the Southeast market? So that might be something that could be done.” – Non-SG Stakeholder
“[The rest of the UK is] a relatively straightforward market to sell to. And if you need a little bit of support, that can be provided by someone in [Scotland] rather than someone in London. But if resources were no option here, or if the Scottish government said to us, ‘we'll fund half a dozen export people for you’, I suspect we would put them on the ground in London and that you would then see more activity and more use of the office taking place specifically for that activity that we're not delivering at the moment.” – Partner
Related to this, a few interviewees reflected on the need to see the potential economic value of all sectors that could engage with SHL, particularly the cultural sector.
“And when I say economically, I count our culture sector in that… For example, an event that I ran for the publishing sector… which promoted some of our top authors. [This event] brought together the London publishing sector with some of our top authors and some of our aspiring authors and some of our publishing houses. That's not a cultural event, that's a hard-edged economic event. So I think we need to be really clear about what London represents to us as a market.” – SG Stakeholder
Increased diplomatic and intergovernmental activity
As highlighted by the examples earlier in this report, SHL’s role in broadening the Scottish Government’s engagement with embassies, ambassadors and the diplomatic corps was recognised by interviewees. This current activity was felt to be effective, with meetings and events resulting in ministerial, trade, investment and cultural opportunities. However, a small number of interviewees advocated for SHL to help facilitate even greater bilateral cooperation, to take full advantage of the scale of London’s diplomatic community.
Some other respondents considered SHL’s role in supporting relations between the Scottish and UK Governments. There was general agreement that SHL is already well connected with Whitehall, providing practical support and local knowledge to help facilitate engagement between Scottish Ministers and officials and their UK counterparts. Even though much of the current inter-governmental liaison is undertaken by relevant Scottish Government policy teams in Scotland, SHL’s business plans outline steps that have been taken to increase cooperation. For example, in 2024, the Scottish Government Permanent Secretary undertook a series of meetings with other Permanent Secretaries across Whitehall on priority policy issues and current affairs. This was then followed by a breakfast briefing, which provided a platform for the Permanent Secretary to present to Whitehall and industry leaders on public service delivery in Scotland, highlighting Scotland's priorities and the role of SHL and the Scottish Government in delivering improved economic outcomes
However, some interviewees highlighted uncertainty around SHL’s mandate regarding engagement with the UK Government, and suggested there could be benefits from clarifying responsibilities and making SHL’s role more explicit. Others suggested SHL’s role could be developed further, again supported by a clear agreement over when SHL enables, convenes, gathers intelligence or owns a relationship. This was seen as potentially beneficial for both government and external partners, particularly where navigating relations between the two Governments is increasingly important, and now that there is a different relationship with the European Union and European countries.
Interviewees expressed the view that strengthening this function could enhance SHL’s value, particularly in terms of providing insight, access and influence within the UK system. This was reinforced by comments highlighting the value of SHL’s position within Westminster and the potential to make more of this insight.
“I think they do a lot of put a lot of shoe leather into engaging with what's happening in that Westminster bubble, but I'm not sure that always gets packaged up in a way that's usable by us as partners or as business. And that's probably again one of those things which should be pretty simple to do.” – Non-SG Stakeholder
“If they were able to better connect us with MPs, for example, that's an area where we've really struggled with bandwidth. And given that they do have really strong policy people there, what if they were to help us do a quarterly roundtable of key MPs? What's stopping that from happening? Is that because it's just unconscionable for the Scottish government to be looking to influence Westminster, and these are two streams that will never cross? I suppose the broader question might be, is there a way in which, since they're already good at it, there's a way that they could further seek to influence policy in London?” – Non-SG Stakeholder
A few interviewees also suggested that SHL could play a stronger role in connecting Scottish actors to think tanks, policy communities and wider networks in London, which could broaden perspectives and strengthen policy development.
Other policy areas or sectors
SHL’s business plans highlight the range of SHL’s work across multiple policy areas. For example, the 2024-25 business plan includes:
- 24 objectives supporting economy, trade and investment, covering financial services, capital investment, tourism and food and drink.
- Seven objectives covering climate change, biodiversity and renewable energy.
- 13 objectives facilitating reputation, influence and relationships, including culture and higher education.
Interviewees were asked whether they felt this range of work was appropriate for SHL, and if there were any specific policy areas or sectors they felt SHL should prioritise, or add value or expertise. It was widely felt that having this range of activity was appropriate. There was also no clear desire for any one sector to be prioritised over others, though interviewees often reflected on how SHL could best support their own sector. However, interviewees generally indicated that SHL could benefit from being more deliberate and selective in where it focuses its effort, particularly where London offers a clear strategic advantage.
“Given the importance of London in the Southeast for Scotland's tourism industry, plus London being a gateway into the world, as well, I would think there's more that could be done there. I think from a cultural perspective, from a business perspective, we're well served. Perhaps some of our sectors could use it a little bit more. We leverage Scottish food and drink at every opportunity. But it's more that different segments of the Scottish food and drink sector could be doing more down there.” – Partner
Interviewees generally agreed that engaging a wider range of organisations with SHL, particularly those operating in sectors without an established London presence, could help extend SHL’s reach and impact. It was also suggested that this could support better utilisation of the space and strengthen SHL’s role as a convening point.
“It would be the more the merrier, fundamentally, the more that we can as a nation present or get people into London representing the various sectors that we excel in or we want to grow, then that makes sense. I think it's probably fair to say the big hitters are there.” – Non-SG Stakeholder
“In a way, for me, probably more important is the partnership piece. Because if you had a dozen partners which really brought in a lot of these external organisations and brought their interest in London really under the same umbrella and footing as us, that's a step change. Then I don't know what would happen. Suddenly, that would be completely different. You'd have a whole wealth of Scottish organisations pronouncing their vested interest in London all sitting around the table and the opportunity from that surely would be on another level.” – Partner
When interviewees were asked if they felt any other agencies or bodies would benefit from using SHL, a small number questioned which bodies are currently partners in SHL or using its space, highlighting a challenge around visibility (see below). A few also noted that other Scottish-based organisations continue to operate in London without using SHL. In some cases, this reflects a preference for neutrality or independence from the Scottish Government. There were also suggestions that some sectors already have an established London presence through their own premises or industry bodies, and that SHL may wish to focus more on sectors that do not have this kind of infrastructure.
One stakeholder suggested there could be value in engaging with the third sector:
“There are a number of large charitable foundations that donate around the UK or internationally, and there are a number of large charities that are headquartered in London. I wonder if we should be engaging with them around attracting offices to Scotland, for the jobs that would bring in itself, but also in the case of large foundations, if you bring them to Scotland or if they have a presence in Scotland, then they'll be closer to initiatives that they might want to then fund as foundations.” SG Stakeholder
Capacity for increased collaboration
Existing collaboration between various SHL users was widely seen as a strength, with positive feedback on partnership working and that users were focused on how to achieve Scottish Government priorities. However, some interviewees suggested there may be opportunities for improvement.
In addition to encouraging more agencies to use SHL, as noted above, a small number noted the potential to strengthen connections between SHL with other locations and initiatives. For example, more connections and inter-site visits with Scotland House Brussels, or better alignment with the Scotland Office and its Brand Scotland activity. This reflects a view that SHL could be positioned more clearly within a wider network of Scottish Government and partner activity.
However, it should be noted that a few interviewees referred to broader resourcing pressures that are outwith SHL’s control. They suggested that their organisations or teams may not have sufficient capacity to fully capitalise on the opportunities that SHL offers. Other practical barriers, such as time constraints, travel costs and competing priorities, were also cited as factors that influence the extent to which SHL is used in practice.
“I think it's being used pretty well by some people. But I don't think we're capitalising on the asset as best we might… I don't think me and my Directorate are capitalising on it as best we might. And if we're not doing it, then I'm pretty sure the rest of the organisation won't be.” – SG Stakeholder
“There's an opportunity in terms of what more could be done, and how do we manage supply and demand, which would include also stimulating demand so that my colleagues in Edinburgh and in Glasgow are also aware of that base and are always thinking about the opportunities that could be delivered through that platform.” – SG Stakeholder
Skills and expertise of SHL staff
Interviews also explored the extent to which the SHL team was felt to have the skills and expertise needed to perform potential additional functions, and if not, what additional resources would be required. A few interviewees expressed positive views, reflecting that, as generalist civil servants, the team takes a broad yet effective view on how they can work strategically to achieve the Scottish Government’s overall priorities.
“I do think there's a chance to have a look at the strategic proposition and not spread themselves too thin. At the moment, they do a bit of everything because they've got a whole ton of folks asking them, "Could you do a bit of this? Could you do a bit of that?” And they probably need to sharpen up their focus a little bit to be able to do the things that would have a big impact… But the thing is, when they do stuff for us, when we're working with them on the events or something, they're a good outfit, and they should be proud of that side of things.” – SG Stakeholder
However, a few specific issues were raised. While the importance of SHL in facilitating connections was widely recognised, a small number of interviewees suggested there could be benefits from greater oversight of connections and improved stakeholder management, which is currently limited by the resources available in SHL. This could be both at a policy level – for example, recognising that the higher education sector is likely to have valuable input across multiple policy areas – and at an individual level, ensuring that the right SHL or agency team members are speaking to the most appropriate connections and avoiding duplication of effort.
More specifically, two stakeholders considered whether additional resources are required if SHL aims to facilitate greater bilateral cooperation with foreign governments than is currently the case.
“Sometimes I think about all the international offices, given what we're trying to do with Scotland's Place in the World, do we resource them at a senior enough level? Is there a senior enough person in those offices, particularly in key places like London, to influence on a day-to-day, week-to-week, month-to-month basis? We did have much more senior support in Brussels, I think we still do, and that was right because Europe is the heart of everything happening. Actually, that emphasis has shifted quite a bit… to London. We don't have that parity of senior support, dedicated support, or resource in London. I just wonder if there's more we could do.” - SG Stakeholder
Visibility and communication
A prevalent theme was the need to raise awareness of SHL, as several interviewees indicated that SHL’s offer is not as visible as it could be within the Scottish Government, as well as among external partners. They expressed the view that this lack of visibility may be resulting in missed opportunities and can limit how fully SHL is used, as users do not feel connected to it. It should be noted that there have been proposals for paid marketing activity, but these have been deferred due to cost savings.
Interviewees indicated that improving communications and promotion could help increase usage of SHL, broaden the range of organisations involved, and strengthen relationships between users. It was also suggested that this could help articulate more clearly the value of SHL, particularly to those who are less familiar with its offer. These interviewees were typically unsure about the extent of the existing communication from SHL, but felt that more regular activity would benefit visibility.
“We definitely need to shout about it more. I think some comms presence and some marketing and budget would be very helpful just to let Scottish businesses know it's there and it's their home from home.” – Partner
“There's something about - and it's just hard work - selling it or making more people within government, our partners and businesses aware of its existence, even 10 years plus in. I still think that's a bit of an uphill struggle. You just need to keep working at that.” – SG Stakeholder
“There isn't really a regular drumbeat of communication from Scotland House, London, that they're there, and I don't see it up here. And I'm right at the centre of government. So I think we can more proactively use our internal communications channels to promote. And that can be a personal thing, and it can also be using digital channels.” – SG Stakeholder
“It would be good to see it utilised by more. I think that having that awareness piece and comms piece, hitting into different sectors, for Scottish businesses to be made aware of what they can get from Scotland House, would be only a benefit for everyone.” – Partner
Improvements to events planning
While almost 100 events were hosted at SHL in 2023-24, and despite concerns from a few interviewees that there is not enough diary or staff capacity to allow more events to take place, respondents across both surveys expressed a desire for SHL to host more regular events and opportunities to collaborate. Some respondents suggested specific types of events, such as capital investment networking and European innovation. Stakeholder survey respondents suggested that information sharing and visibility can be improved in relation to events being held at Scotland House to encourage participation and enhance networking and collaboration opportunities.
Interviewees’ views on the events programme were generally positive, particularly on the quality of events. However, aligned with the survey findings, the most prevalent issue, raised by several interviewees, was the need for greater awareness of the events programme and improved forward planning. A few stakeholders commented that they did not have sufficient visibility of the full programme to be able to comment. More broadly, other interviewees indicated that earlier visibility of upcoming events would allow them to plan their involvement more effectively, align with their own activity, ensure that the right stakeholders are engaged, and enhance the overall impact of events.
“The more forewarning that we have, the better we can make this work. And the better we can optimise the time that we have in London by lining up other stakeholders as well. So what would be really helpful for us would be, for instance, if we could get some more foresight on the potential events that are coming up. Because the [SHL] team are great and they really do their best to familiarise themselves with our subject area… but they can only know what they know, and when you're dealing with something day-to-day, you might see more opportunity for connection than the team themselves see because they're spread over such a wide kind of area… We could maybe think about how we could better align our diaries to support some of that, or get a wee bit more out of it.” – SG Stakeholder
“Scotland House has got a programme of activity. We're not really involved in, I don't think, in contributing to the planning of what that might look like or what our role in that might be. That's maybe something for the future that could be considered.” – Partner
“One thing I do think that could be done here to improve it, would be I don't know how the events program here is designed and curated. I'm not sure that it is. I get the feeling it's responsive rather than proactive. And I think if it's about what the Scottish government wants to get out of having Scotland House, you could get more out of it if the events program was more curated across the year. It doesn't have to be more in terms of quantity, but more sort of structured.” – Member
A few interviewees suggested using events more deliberately to connect Scottish businesses with London markets and to convene stakeholders around shared challenges. Sectors such as renewables, food and drink and offshore wind were mentioned in this context, particularly where there are ongoing policy or regulatory issues that would benefit from dialogue with the UK Government. Interviewees suggested that greater clarity in this area could help ensure that events are more closely aligned with intended outcomes, whether that is supporting business development, influencing policy, or building networks.
A small number of other considerations were noted by interviewees. These included ensuring that invites to events are well-targeted and include a broad range of potential audiences and not just ‘the usual suspects’ and exploring opportunities for collaboration with other London-based organisations to capitalise on their existing networks.
“You want to expand your network, you need new companies and new people coming in, and that's harder to attract because you're starting with people who ask, ‘Who are you, and why would I come to an event at Scotland House?’ So that's again comes back to your marketing and really pushing it aggressively.” – Partner
“In terms of getting more people here for events, I think you have to attract people… You have to be interesting. And being interesting in London is quite hard because there's a lot of competition for attention. The LSE and King's College are just over there and have fantastic events programmes. There's nothing to stop Scotland House collaborating with them. There's absolutely nothing to stop Scotland House working with, [for example], the Arts Council to do something about cultural policy.” – Member
Interviewees noted that some organisations choose not to use SHL for events, either because they have alternative arrangements or because they prefer to operate in more neutral venues. This was seen as a potential limitation on SHL’s reach, and interviewees suggested that there may be value in considering how the offer is positioned to a wider range of users.
“Scotland House is a Scottish government office. And it's used by ministers to promote Scottish Government interests. And sometimes those interests might rub up against wider interests that some of the partners may have down in London. I think sometimes that political dimension can be a bit of a sensitivity. But if there was a way, across all the key partners, key bodies in Scotland, to try and stimulate more use and activity, then that would help.” – Partner
Contact
Email: socialresearch@gov.scot