Scotland House London Evaluation

The evaluation found that Scotland House London is widely considered to be a valuable strategic asset supporting Scotland’s interests in the UK and internationally, while suggesting practical improvements to increase use and refine the offering of SHL


4. How is SHL used, and what are users’ experiences?

Key findings

  • Usage of SHL varies according to how its purpose is perceived. Those who see it as a networking hub tend to use it for events and relationship building, while those who see it as a workspace use it more functionally. Regardless of the frequency and nature of use, there is an appreciation of the flexibility offered by SHL.
  • There is consistently positive feedback about the support the SHL team provide to stakeholders and members.
  • The quality of the spaces and facilities in SHL is also rated highly, though a range of specific practical improvements, particularly in terms of access and booking, could help encourage greater use.

Flexibility to accommodate a variety of uses and users

Interviewees had a range of professional backgrounds, from those working in the Scottish Government, partner agencies, policy, trade, tourism, and those who have worked with SHL or been part of the SHL team. While some were based in London, many were based in Scotland and would access SHL when they visited London. The frequency of visits varied by interviewee from frequently to rarely, i.e. once or twice a year, based on their organisation, role and needs.

SHL is used in similar but varied ways by survey respondents and by interviewees. It is visited to use its facilities as a workspace or as a base when in London, attend or host meetings and events, and to network or connect. The ability to use SHL for a variety of purposes was noted as a positive by interviewees.

Networking and building connections

Reasons for interviewees visiting London and using SHL varied. Participants’ comments typically focused on maximising opportunities to connect Scotland with international markets and organisations to tap into potential trade, exports and investment, as well as meeting UK Government and EU officials. Both survey audiences also commented that SHL is used to network and connect with other businesses, organisations, and sectors, with stakeholder survey respondents using the facilities to promote policy activities or for stakeholder engagement, building connections with specific groups such as tech startups or climate investors.

“London is the place in the UK that we go to most frequently outside of Scotland. Then there are meetings that we might have as officials with investors or UK government counterparts” – SG Stakeholder

“We have used it both as an office and as a platform on which to convene, bring people together, hold high-level meetings and transact the business of government.” – SG Stakeholder

Interviewees considered SHL to be an effective location to host formal meetings and events. This was due to both the location of SHL (see Chapter 5) and the effectiveness of the SHL team (see below). Many survey respondents reported engaging with events held at SHL, either by attending events or by co-delivering or showcasing work related to their business or sector, such as the arts and net-zero energy.

“We're increasingly trying to use it as a recurring base for events, meetings and essentially a kind of central hub for a lot of the investor activity pursuant to the Scottish opportunity in London.” – Non-SG Stakeholder

“It's been invaluable in terms of meetings with external people, having somewhere that's professional and linked to Scotland, which is incredibly useful.” – Member

Positive experiences engaging with the SHL team

In response to a stakeholder survey question, two thirds stated that they had partnered or collaborated with teams at SHL. Of these, the vast majority (92%) agreed that partnering/collaborating with SHL helped them to meet their intended objectives, and almost all (96%) agreed they would consider partnering or collaborating with SHL again.

Interviewees also spoke in strong positive terms about their experiences with the team at SHL, highlighting positive and effective working relationships. The team were noted to be welcoming, helpful in running events, and provided excellent customer service. Interviewees also expressed the view that the team are always looking to make the most of resources available to them, contributing to overall positive experiences of SHL. One noted that SHL has a strong focus on learning and reflection to continually develop and improve its offering.

“The senior people in the office have been and continue to be high calibre.” – SG Stakeholder

“It's been really positive. The team are very helpful at helping us to facilitate our events, to identify stakeholders that can come to our events, and helping us to identify opportunities for the kind of work that we're doing. We have a very constructive, positive relationship with the team. And we have quite an informal relationship, so that is helpful as well.” – SG Stakeholder

“The team at Scotland House London are a real asset to Scotland. Without their work, Scotland simply would not be promoted as effectively to London.” – Survey respondent

“The team are always very nice and very helpful and very supportive. So, at a personal level, very, very grateful for what they do. And real professionals.” - SG Stakeholder

Some interviewees were asked how well the SHL team understands their organisation’s work, which drew mixed opinions. A few felt the SHL team had a good understanding of their organisation’s needs, highlighting good connections established between SHL and their organisation and reiterating the helpfulness of staff. Conversely, a few interviewees suggested the team did not have as much understanding of their organisation. One interviewee expressed the view SHL may be better able to help them network if the team had a fuller understanding of their work, while another stated they did not expect SHL to understand the nature of their work.

“In terms of going in, using the facilities, the staff that are on duty, they're always brilliant. I can't complain, the facilities are good, everything works, that's all fine. Whether they know much about us or what we do, or how we do it, or how they could facilitate networks or networking, not sure. I don't see as much of that to be honest,” – Member

SHL as a workspace

Many participants described using SHL as a place to work, either instead of working from home (if London-based) or as a base when travelling or working in London. Some use it as a venue to meet colleagues, clients or partners. For those who use it when they visit London, being able to use SHL was seen as a significant improvement on having to find temporary places to work from. More specifically, it was noted that the increase in remote working post-pandemic means SHL offers access to high-quality co-working spaces to those who no longer have access to traditional office space in London. SHL was also felt to offer a more focused work environment compared to other co-working spaces.

“We're all home-based, ultimately. So, if we're in London for meetings or with client delivery work, it's a good opportunity, it's a good place either to meet as a team during gaps between meetings, or if someone's in on their own, it's a good place to just hunker down for a few hours and work. And sometimes we've also used it to meet people where they've not had premises in London.” - Member

The facilities available in SHL are mostly viewed positively (see below), and a few interviewees explicitly expressed the view that SHL is well-used, reflecting the level of activity outlined in SHL reporting, i.e. 98 events and 325 business meetings in 2023-24. These interviewees appreciated the vibrant atmosphere which this creates.

“It's just well set up, you know, the internal events team and everyone at Scotland House really sort of are absolutely brilliant at their jobs, and it's very welcoming. Obviously, there's quite a hustle and bustle normally going on in the sort of front section where you'll have the hot desks being utilised by paying members. It's always got a nice little feel to it.” – Member

“I see a massive uptick in the use of the space, which is quite positive because it gives the place a wee buzz, and that's quite important when you're inviting people there. You want them to feel like this is a place where activity is happening.” - SG Stakeholder

Conversely, there were suggestions that the secure staff area in SHL can feel relatively quiet at times. This reflects the nature of many staff’s roles, which means they are frequently out of the office engaging with stakeholders, as well as the fact that partners are not using the facilities as frequently post-COVID-19. These interviewees nevertheless suggested that increasing the number of organisations or individuals making regular use of SHL could create a more active and dynamic environment. Interviewees implied that this could make the space more attractive and valuable to users. Some interviewees, particularly Partners and Chief Executives, felt SHL is not used to its full capacity, especially the desk space reserved for Partners. However, they recognised that hybrid working means less space is needed now than was originally planned. While the regular use of meeting rooms and event space was noted, as above, a few others felt there was not enough physical space within SHL or enough diary or staff capacity to allow more events to take place, given the overall number of events suggests between two and three events are held on average each week. This led a small number of interviewees to question whether the space could be reconfigured to provide more room for members, or to accommodate more, or larger, meeting rooms.

“I find the support team there and the facilities provided really excellent, actually. But would also echo comments that I don't particularly find it well used. I think we could make more use of the facility.” – Partner

“I think the capacity for nearly 40 desks in the back office, and on most normal days, if there are 10 people in, then that's good. That doesn't stand up to scrutiny.” – Partner

Satisfaction with SHL

Evidence from the surveys also indicates high levels of satisfaction with SHL. Open comments centred on users' satisfaction with SHL’s location and facilities, and the positive impact these have (see Chapter 5).

There were very high levels of overall satisfaction with the SHL facilities among stakeholders, with 96% satisfied (82% ‘very satisfied’, 14% ‘somewhat satisfied’). Similarly high levels of satisfaction with facilities were noted by members, who were asked more detailed questions about facilities as outlined in Figure 2. Lower satisfaction levels were generally due to respondents selecting ‘neutral’ or ‘don’t know,’ rather than being dissatisfied. Total satisfaction was highest for:

  • The space is well maintained and clean (100% total, 84% ‘very satisfied')
  • Staff are helpful and responsive when I need support (100% total, 84% ‘very satisfied')
  • The lighting is pleasant (96% total, 88% ‘very satisfied')
  • Booking and using meeting rooms is easy (96% total, 72% ‘very satisfied')
Figure 2: Member survey: Satisfaction with physical spaces and facilities at SHL (%) (n=24-26)
Stacked horizontal bar chart showing satisfaction with office facilities and services. Most respondents were satisfied or very satisfied across all measures, with highest ratings for lighting (88% very satisfied), cleanliness (84%), and staff support (84%). Satisfaction was lower for co-working facilities, comfort levels, opening hours, noise levels, and the online members portal, which received more neutral and negative responses.

Challenges and barriers to using SHL

Interviewees were asked about possible challenges or barriers encountered in working with SHL, and if there was anything else SHL could do to improve their experience. The majority reflected that there were no issues, or if there were, that they were relatively minor. Some reiterated positive views that have been noted throughout this report.

“They're a good team; they do a good job. You can always do more, but there's nothing that I feel that they're not [doing], that I would highlight as something where I have concerns about.” - SG Stakeholder

However, a few interviewees highlighted practical frustrations with access arrangements, opening hours and booking systems. These were described as adding a degree of friction, particularly for those making regular or short-notice visits. Similarly, dissatisfaction was typically noted by small numbers of member survey respondents (see Figure 2), and primarily for aspects of the office environment.

“It'd be lovely to have slightly longer hours because we sort of get kicked out. It's not the end of the world. If we need to go somewhere else, we can sit down in a cafe after 5pm and carry on working there. There are only minor things that I would say could be improved. But the overall advantages, way, way, way outweigh any small disadvantages there are.” – Member

Contact

Email: socialresearch@gov.scot

Back to top