Scotland House London Evaluation
The evaluation found that Scotland House London is widely considered to be a valuable strategic asset supporting Scotland’s interests in the UK and internationally, while suggesting practical improvements to increase use and refine the offering of SHL
3. What do partners, stakeholders and members see as SHL’s mission and purpose?
Key findings
- There is no single consistent definition of SHL’s purpose among stakeholders, partners and members. While members may be less likely to need or want to understand SHL’s wider mission, interpretations nevertheless varied across all interviewees, depending on the nature and frequency of their engagement with and use of SHL.
- Perceptions of SHL’s core mission centred around three themes which reflect previous and ongoing work: promoting Scotland’s economic and strategic interests; facilitating networks through convening and relationship-building; and providing a Scottish presence and platform in London, through a physical base and symbolic representation.
Promoting Scotland to London and the world
SHL was described by evaluation participants as a platform to promote the Scottish Government’s agenda, including in areas such as net zero, supply chains, and increasing investment in Scotland and Scottish businesses. They were clear that a key part of SHL’s mission is to engage a wide range of economic, political and diplomatic stakeholders to support these aims.
Some felt SHL’s core purpose was to represent Scotland more broadly, acting as a promotional showcase for the country. Comments on this theme encompassed Scottish culture and heritage, and supporting trade, investment and other economic opportunities.
“This is presenting a front for Scotland, a shop window for Scotland that tells a story. I think that's quite an interesting and instructive one. I was really taken by the story we were trying to tell.” - SG Stakeholder
Other interviewees viewed the core purpose of SHL as promoting Scottish businesses. These interviewees highlighted the large number of potential clients and markets in London, which present opportunities for Scottish businesses to grow through increased UK and international trade. They felt that SHL should play a key role in promoting and facilitating these opportunities. However, it was also noted that this role is limited by the current lack of trade support from SDI in SHL, as well as overall capacity within SHL. This is explored more in Chapter 8.
However, there were differences in interviewees’ views about this aspect of SHL’s mission. For some, SHL’s role was seen as promoting Scotland’s interests internationally, through European or global organisations and their representatives who are based in London. Others felt there could be a greater focus on helping Scottish businesses operate in London; for example, the promotion of Scottish tourism to the south of England consumer market. This is explored more in Chapter 8.
“I think the main focus of Scotland House has been about promoting Scotland as an inward investment location rather than promoting Scottish businesses in London and the Southeast.” – Non-SG Stakeholder
Example 4: SHL hosted a delegation from the German Bundestag Committee on Family Affairs, Senior Citizens, Women and Youth, which was presented with information about Scotland's interventions to support children's start in life, such as the Babybox and Scottish Child Payment.
Example 5: A Dutch circular economy and sustainable construction delegation visited SHL, which set out the Scottish Government policy landscape and promoted the Scottish Futures Institute and the Built Environment – Smarter Transformation (BE-ST), Scotland’s innovation centre for construction and the built environment, to a range of Dutch businesses and policymakers. This laid the ground for a potential visit of Dutch businesses to Scotland, and vice versa.
Example 6: SHL worked with Scottish ecosystem builders Foras Ventures to showcase Scotland’s tech talent. This provided opportunities for CodeBase to engage and showcase founders from the Scottish Government-funded Techscaler programme.
Example 7: Converge Challenge – Scotland’s largest company creation and enterprise programme for the university sector – worked with SHL to showcase the achievements and innovations of Scotland’s universities and, partnering with SDI, ensured Scottish life sciences companies had the opportunity to pitch to a visiting delegation of over 20 venture capitalists from the USA.
Facilitating connections and networks
Interviewees also noted that facilitating access to people and networks was a core component of SHL’s mission. SHL was seen as having a role in:
- Supporting Scotland to build and maintain its own diplomatic networks.
- Linking relevant stakeholders into wider networks and identifying opportunities, such as for trade and investment.
- Supporting different stakeholders within sectors to come together, making connections, facilitating conversations and collaboration around important issues.
“There's a real softer side to the purpose of Scotland House and having that base in London, which is all around building those networks. Because you can't build those networks as easily when you're [working] remotely. We rely on [SHL] to build those networks, to be opening doors, to be establishing the relationships, to be gathering the intel to then be identifying the opportunities for us to plug into.” – Non-SG Stakeholder
Interviewees with more limited SHL engagement tended to describe it in terms of the services and opportunities it provides, such as workspaces, meetings and events and were less likely to refer to a wider economic, strategic or diplomatic mission.
Example 8: Delivered a Deputy First Minister-led Offshore Wind Investor event that engaged 14 of the most prominent Global Offshore Wind Investors. This engagement acted as a ‘stepping stone’ event, facilitating connections with global corporations and gathering investor feedback to inform the planning of the Scottish Government’s 2025 Global Offshore Wind Investment Summit.
Example 9: Delivered a roundtable discussion hosted by the EU Ambassador to the UK and Ambassadors from the 27 EU Member States with the First Minister as guest of honour through which he set out Scotland’s commitment to remaining a constructive and active partner to the European Union.
Example 10: The SHL team harness opportunities to tap into visiting global audiences in London to build Scotland’s profile in areas offering new market opportunities, such as working with the Scottish Artificial Intelligence Alliance to host an official community fringe event during CogX Festival 2023 and facilitating a keynote speaking opportunity for the Minister for Innovation to spotlight Scotland’s progress in becoming a leader in trustworthy, ethical, and inclusive Artificial Intelligence.
Having a physical presence and representation in London
Stakeholders and members were asked about the value of a working base in London. There was alignment in what they found important and the prevalence of these views, as shown in Figure 1.
‘Sector-specific opportunities’ were considered most important by both groups (54% stakeholders, 65% members), followed by ‘trade, investment, or commercial opportunities’ (51% stakeholders, 65% members). Though important for both audiences, stakeholders were more likely than members to feel that proximity to international networks is important (48% compared to 35%, respectively) or that access to the UK Government is important (42% compared to 31%, respectively). For members, 35% highlighted the importance of sector-specific institutions, which was not selected by any stakeholders.
Interviewees also stressed the importance of London to Scotland, and of having a physical presence, given the city’s size and importance as a critical economic and diplomatic hub. Some described the existence of SHL as a visible symbol of Scotland in London. Several interviewees highlighted the need for a physical presence in London as they felt that representatives of foreign governments or businesses were far less likely to travel to Scotland for meetings. By being in London, and ‘meeting them in the middle’, interviewees felt they were much better able to capitalise on opportunities.
“London is, for better or worse, such an important spoke in the wheel of Scotland's economic development; it makes real sense to have a base. In principle, I'm very supportive of this, and I think that there's more that could be done. Scotland's growth does depend on its businesses and its business people making regular trips to London and maintaining relationships there. So, the idea of physical presence is really important.” – Non-SG Stakeholder
For several interviewees, SHL is therefore understood to support a Scottish presence in London, and interviewees valued SHL’s agility and ability to respond to requests from their organisations for support. Similarly, a few interviewees expressed the view that SHL allows the Scottish Government to engage with people and businesses that are part of the Scottish diaspora in London, facilitates engagement between different elements of the diaspora, and provides a platform to conduct or promote their business more widely.
Example 11: Scotland House partnered with the Scottish Business Network to host a hybrid Emerging Scotland in London event, which featured a panel of Scottish University alumni officers. This resulted in securing several visits and events throughout the year.
Example 12: Through existing links with the Polish Embassy’s Economic Team, the Embassy reached out to SHL to ask for support in facilitating the visit of a Polish Trade Mission to Scotland. A trade delegation then visited Scotland to undertake a range of engagements, including with the Chambers of Commerce, hosting a Business Forum and Ministerial engagements.
Example 13: The First Minister delivered an address to the Green Horizon summit, achieved through SHL’s relationship with the City of London Corporation. The event encouraged concrete actions and commitments from financial sectors ahead of COP26.
Contact
Email: socialresearch@gov.scot