Scotland House London Evaluation

The evaluation found that Scotland House London is widely considered to be a valuable strategic asset supporting Scotland’s interests in the UK and internationally, while suggesting practical improvements to increase use and refine the offering of SHL


Executive Summary

Established in 2017, Scotland House London (SHL) is a co-working and events space in central London, acting as a platform for Scottish Government (SG) and agency staff based in London. It is a collaboration between four partners – the Scottish Government and Scottish Enterprise (including Scottish Development International), VisitScotland, and Scotland Food and Drink.

SHL activity at a glance

SHL currently has a staffing allocation of 13 Scottish Government staff, nine SDI staff and one market trade specialist working for Scotland Food and Drink. VisitScotland does not have permanent staff based on the platform. In 2023-24, the latest year for which full details are available, SHL delivered a substantial programme of activity across Scotland's international priorities, as well as supporting 94 members. Activities included hosting 98 events attracting 2,353 attendees, welcoming 5,241 visitors, hosting 190 partner business meetings and facilitating 11 ministerial visits. These covered trade and investment promotion, diplomatic engagement, university partnerships, cultural programming and stakeholder convening.

Overview of the evaluation

The Lines Between (TLB) was commissioned to undertake an evaluation of SHL. This involved three main activities: (i) a review of SHL reporting since 2019, (ii) analysis of responses to online surveys of 81 stakeholders and SHL partners and 26 members (January to March 2026), and (iii) qualitative interviews with 28 SHL partners, stakeholders and members (May to June 2026).

This evaluation aims to answer the following questions and to present evidence-based recommendations to Scottish Ministers on the future of SHL. The evaluation also acts as a small-scale pilot for potential future evaluations of Scotland’s International Network.

What do partners, stakeholders and members see as SHL’s mission and purpose?

  • There is no single consistent definition of SHL’s purpose among stakeholders, partners and members. While members may be less likely to need or want to understand SHL’s wider mission, interpretations nevertheless varied across all interviewees, depending on the nature and frequency of their engagement with and use of SHL.
  • Perceptions of SHL’s core mission centred around three themes which reflect previous and ongoing work: promoting Scotland’s economic and strategic interests; facilitating networks through convening and relationship-building; and providing a Scottish presence and platform in London, through a physical base and symbolic representation.

How is SHL used, and what are users’ experiences?

  • Usage of SHL varies according to how its purpose is perceived. Those who see it as a networking hub tend to use it for events and relationship building, while those who see it as a workspace use it more functionally. Regardless of the frequency and nature of use, there is an appreciation of the flexibility offered by SHL.
  • There is consistently positive feedback about the support the SHL team provide to stakeholders and members.
  • The quality of the spaces and facilities in SHL is also rated highly, though a range of specific practical improvements, particularly in terms of access and booking, could help encourage greater use.

How effectively does SHL deliver on its objectives and contribute to SG’s international priorities?

  • SHL reporting evidences a range of activities that align with its long-term priorities and support Scotland’s interests in the UK and internationally. This volume and variety of work has taken place despite reductions in staffing, changes in working practices and membership numbers during and post-pandemic, and unanticipated changes to the SHL partners and their financial contributions.
  • The most commonly identified benefit of SHL relates to positive economic impact. Participants highlighted SHL’s role in supporting economic diplomacy, acting as a base to attract inward investment, and providing soft power or influence in promoting Scotland’s profile. SHL also has significant convening power, building connections between the Scottish and UK Governments, as well as supporting Scottish businesses and SHL members to meet their own objectives by facilitating engagement with relevant stakeholders.
  • A consistent theme was the value of the well-located, modern, visibly Scottish space. SHL was viewed as convenient and accessible, and its facilities were felt to create a positive impression for visitors and enhance Scotland’s reputation.
  • SHL is widely seen by evaluation participants as an important strategic asset. While SHL’s annual reporting highlights a range of work undertaken and its impact, several interviewees alluded to difficulties in articulating tangible impacts or giving concrete examples of added value from SHL activity.

Does membership and investment in SHL offer value for money?

  • There was agreement thatinvestment in SHL offers strong value in terms of avoided costs and efficiencies. However, as is often the case with platforms such as SHL, interviewees highlighted that assessing return on investment is challenging. Much of SHL’s value relates to indirect and intangible outcomes or activities that may take time to generate impact, making it difficult to attribute specific results or quantify economic impact.
  • Survey results indicate that there would be a significant negative impact on users if SHL was no longer available to users. Such a change was felt likely to lead to increased costs for seeking out and using alternatives, and have a detrimental impact on users’ business connections and capabilities.

How effective is the membership model, and what other approaches may add value?

  • Current members benefit from using SHL facilities for their own work and stakeholder engagement, and being associated with a positive, professional space.

Members broadly agree that SHL offers them good value for money, with membership seen as affordable relative to similar private sector office space, especially given the quality of space, central London location, and range of facilities and services provided at SHL.

  • Most non-member interviewees felt they had insufficient detail to comment on the future of the membership model. While it was a minority view, a few interviewees expressed concern about whether SHL’s role should include providing affordable office space and questioned whether doing so is sustainable.
  • Members are keen for their membership to add value through providing more support for their businesses and facilitating connections and networking across a larger membership.

How could Scotland House London work more effectively and have more impact?

  • There was a mostly consistent view that the current SHL model is working well, with a clear role in representing Scotland in London and supporting both policy and economic objectives. However, stakeholders often expressed the view that more could be done to refine SHL’s role and purpose to generate more impact for both Scotland and Scottish businesses in multiple areas. In particular, a recurring minority view was a call for a review of the strategic value of London to Scotland and to ensure SHL’s remit is aligned with any agreed focus.
  • Possible refinements took several forms, again often reflecting the nature of stakeholders’ work. Continued or greater focus on economic growth was frequently mentioned, with partners in particular advocating for greater consideration of London and the Southeast as a potential market for Scottish businesses, with SHL being adequately staffed and resourced to capitalise on that opportunity.
  • SHL’s work to facilitate bilateral cooperation with foreign governments was widely recognised, though a small number of interviewees advocated for even greater activity in this area. Conversely, while SHL is already seen as well-connected with Whitehall, some interviewees expressed uncertainty around SHL’s mandate to engage with the UK Government, and suggested its role could be more explicit. Others felt SHL’s role in intergovernmental relations could be developed further.
  • While SHL’s activities are outlined in its business plan, interviewees suggested that SHL could benefit from being more deliberate and selective in where it focuses its efforts. However, reflecting the diversity of opportunities, there was no clear desire for any one sector to be prioritised over others, and interviewees also broadly agreed that having a range of organisations engaging with SHL would help improve SHL’s convening power.
  • A common theme was the need to raise awareness of SHL, both in the Scottish Government and externally. Interviewees called for regular communication, both through internal channels and paid marketing, such as social media, as well as communication with members, to increase visibility and more clearly articulate the value of SHL’s work, which would require additional resources.
  • While existing events at SHL are well-received and valued, there is a desire for greater awareness of the events programme and improved forward planning. Interviewees felt this would allow them to plan their involvement more effectively, align with their own activity, ensure that the right stakeholders are engaged, and enhance the overall impact of events.

What lessons arise for future evaluation approaches across the international network?

  • While it is evident that the SHL team collect a significant amount of information to inform their reporting, it is currently challenging to systematically identify and evaluate the extent to which strategic objectives are being met. Challenges include frequent updates and changes to SHL’s long-term priorities and the strategic objectives associated with these, a lack of SMART objectives and a lack of consistency across years in what data is collected and how it is reported.
  • As is often the case when evaluating organisations focusing on strategic delivery and soft power/diplomacy, many interviewees found it challenging to present tangible examples of SHL’s impact. However, they also found it difficult to suggest how impact could be evidenced more effectively beyond collecting more data.
  • The mixed method approach used in this pilot evaluation has provided an initial assessment of SHL’s work. A similar approach would work well on an ongoing basis and for the wider International network, but key considerations include ensuring a range of participants is included to reflect both the strategic and practical role of international offices and having long-term, SMART objectives against which they can be assessed.

Conclusion

SHL is considered by evaluation participants to be a valued and effective strategic asset in Scotland’s international network. Its high-quality offer is seen as essential in helping to advance and deliver a range of economic and diplomatic objectives, as well as having wider value in its convening power and enhancing Scotland’s reputation. However, it is currently challenging to fully demonstrate this impact, in part because of a lack of consistent data.

The findings of this evaluation highlight the need to sharpen and strengthen the existing model. This will require a more focused view of whether SHL’s priority is diplomatic influence, economic growth, member support, Scottish presence in London, or a clearly defined combination of these. Clarity about this purpose, which can then be presented in SMART objectives in future business plans, will help to increase engagement and use.

Other areas for development include improved visibility of both SHL’s agreed mission and the work it undertakes, and a more consistent approach to evidencing impact and value over time. However, recommendations should be considered in the context of SHL’s current operating model, budget and staffing levels, and the wide range of activities that are currently being delivered.

Contact

Email: socialresearch@gov.scot

Back to top