Scotland House London Evaluation

The evaluation found that Scotland House London is widely considered to be a valuable strategic asset supporting Scotland’s interests in the UK and internationally, while suggesting practical improvements to increase use and refine the offering of SHL


7. How effective is the membership model, and what other approaches may add value?

Key findings

  • Current members benefit from using SHL facilities for their own work and stakeholder engagement, and being associated with a positive, professional space.
  • Members broadly agree that SHL offers them good value for money, with membership seen as affordable relative to similar private sector office space, especially given the quality of space, central London location, and range of facilities and services provided at SHL.
  • Most non-member interviewees felt they had insufficient detail to comment on the future of the membership model. While it was a minority view, a few interviewees expressed concern about whether SHL’s role should include providing affordable office space and questioned whether doing so is sustainable.
  • Members are keen for their membership to add value through providing more support for their businesses and facilitating connections and networking across a larger membership.

It should be noted that, as only four members participated in interviews, the majority of findings in this section come from member survey responses as well as other interviewees’ views on the membership model.

Benefits of SHL membership

Members’ survey responses on the use of SHL facilities highlight the primarily practical nature of members’ engagement:

  • Hot desking was most used monthly (46%), and one third (31%) used it weekly.
  • SHL meeting rooms are used monthly (62%) or annually (27%).
  • Most members (92%) had not hosted an event at SHL, and over two thirds (71%) had not attended an event at SHL.

However, many interviewees - both members and non-members - commented on the benefits of SHL membership. These typically reflected the overall positives of engaging with SHL described throughout this report, such as: support to build relationships with similar organisations; the effective space for stakeholder engagement, including hosting meetings with potential partners and customers; the benefit of being associated with a positive, professional space; and using SHL to enhance their profile.

Example 20: (Member Survey Response) "Brand Scotland" is easy to convey within such a high-quality venue and its support staff. Obviously, we could hire other space in London, but the positive impact of this venue on our business and every other member would be diluted if this were not at SHL. I have brought at least 5 CEO's of the UK's largest charities to SHL, and each one of them was impressed by the concept and reality of the venue and the staff. More member organisations and promotion of the venue would increase use.

“Stability, privacy, as I say, the reputational benefit of having a space that's linked rather than inviting someone into a shared workspace with half of London. You know, you've got somewhere which feels like it's part of Scotland.” - Member

“The team's already been doing work, for example, to build links between the membership and things like the London Chamber of Commerce and other similar bodies down there.” - SG Stakeholder

“A lot of the Scottish food and drink producers are SMEs, they're quite small sort of setups, so for it to be worthwhile, I think they've got to have a presence in London.” - Partner

Views on whether membership delivers value for money

Membership is broadly perceived as offering good value in relation to the benefits and services received, with between 79% and 92% of member survey respondents agreeing to some extent that their membership provides good value for money, meeting room hiring costs being fair, allocation of hot desk hours, benefits and services included in membership (Figure 5). While only 37% agreed that the cost of hiring event space is fair, over half (58%) could not answer this question, presumably due to not having hired event spaces.

Figure 5: Member survey whether your membership offers good value in relation to the benefits and services you receive (%) (n=24)
Stacked horizontal bar chart showing perceptions of value for money from Scotland House London membership. Most respondents agreed or strongly agreed that membership benefits and services (92%), membership overall (92%), and hot desk allocation (88%) provide good value. Views were also positive on meeting room hire costs (79%), while opinions on event space hire were less certain, with 58% selecting 'don't know'.

Broadly, members who were interviewed agreed that SHL offers an affordable, cost-effective membership which provides a high-quality business space at a convenient central London location. This view was typically shared by non-members who felt able to comment. Comments on the cost of the membership were positive, with some noting that the price point compares favourably with other co-working spaces in central London.

“It's very cheap, it's £200 a year from memory, it might have gone up, but I think it's about that… I think, given that, it's always surprising to me that it's not more utilised because that sort of quality of office space in this prime location in London is not normally priced at that sort of level.” – Non-SG Stakeholder

Concerns about the value and sustainability of the membership model

Non-member interviewees were asked if they had any views on the future of the membership model. Most were unable to comment, as they felt unaware of how membership operates or of the impact it has on members.

A few interviewees expressed the view that providing shared working and meeting space as part of SHL membership is not particularly beneficial because other similar facilities are available, or because Scottish organisations tend to meet at the premises of the London-based organisations they are visiting.

“Often people, if they want a meeting, if they're visiting clients, they'll tend to go to their place… I think the aim was to have it as a bit of a hot desk facility. There are more and more places now where you can go and do that kind of thing.” – Non-SG Stakeholder

“I don't know why we have a membership model, because why are we playing in an office offering space when you've got Regus and WeWork, and god knows how many other providers of that ilk? Are we just providing subsidised office accommodation, with very little added on? Why is that core to what we exist to do? I'm not sure that makes sense.” – Partner

“We work with businesses right across Scotland, and over the years we've promoted and provided advocacy for Scotland House, but it's never really shifted the dial in terms of companies that then become regular users of the space.” - Partner

More broadly, a small number of interviewees questioned the sustainability of the SHL membership model as part of the wider question of whether it is viable for the Scottish Government and partners to continue funding SHL. A few noted that an additional source of income to fund SHL is beneficial, but it was recognised that membership income is not able to cover SHL’s running costs. Interviewees suggested that the intended function and role of SHL, and how it is to be sustained, need to be considered and clearly defined.

“There's also a strategic question, around the financial, around the sustainability of that membership model. It doesn't bring in a lot of money. It does require us to run it as a publicly accessible building. It brings with it staffing costs and someone to staff the reception desk… Personally, I think that it should remain open to other partners, and I think that it is worth beating the cost of that. Overall, it probably washes its face just about in terms of the marginal costs of staffing it for that.” - SG Stakeholder

Suggestions for enhancing the membership model

Member survey respondents agreed that the current membership model offers clear value for money in terms of access to affordable, high-quality office and meeting space. However, the evaluation also explored what else might enhance the offer and provide added value to members.

Members were asked in the online survey what they would like in the future. Though most were happy with the current benefits, they also suggested potential improvements, such as increased member benefits from partner organisations, hotel partners, or affiliations. Suggestions for offering meeting or event space for free or at a reduced fee were also made, though it should be noted that the rates members are charged are already lower than similar private sector space hire offers.

While these suggestions focus on reducing costs, there also appears to be a desire to move beyond a purely transactional relationship, where members pay a fee in exchange for workspace, towards a more collaborative model. This would give members greater access to networking, learning and business opportunities, and support to make the most of those opportunities. For example, in response to the member survey, just over one third (36%) felt more networking opportunities would be beneficial, one sixth (16%) wanted more events/workshops, and one sixth (16%) wanted more tailored support for businesses.

Some interviewees also felt that SHL could do more to support its members, to strengthen the membership offer and grow the membership. A few suggested that, alongside enhanced support for Scottish businesses seeking to export products and services internationally, greater consideration should also be given to supporting Scottish businesses who wish to enhance their presence or sell in the London and Southeast markets. This is explored more in Chapter 8.

Other suggestions included:

  • Encouraging greater use of hot desking and meeting space among members.
  • Extending the membership model to include access to Scotland House Brussels.
  • Increasing visibility of the membership offer and individual members. For example, ‘spotlighting’ a variety of members as part of regular communication and providing lists of members so potential members or users of SHL could understand how easily or effectively they might be able to build connections.

Contact

Email: socialresearch@gov.scot

Back to top