Publication - Report

The land of Scotland and the common good: report

Published: 23 May 2014
Directorate:
Environment and Forestry Directorate
Part of:
Environment and climate change
ISBN:
9781784124809

The final report of the Land Reform Review Group.

263 page PDF

15.9 MB

263 page PDF

15.9 MB

Contents
The land of Scotland and the common good: report
Annex 3

263 page PDF

15.9 MB

Annex 3

Land Reform Review Group

LIST OF PUBLISHED SUBMISSIONS

The Land Reform Review Group issued a Call for Evidence on 4th October 2012. By the close of the Call for Evidence on 18th January 2103, the Group had received a total of 484 submissions. 321 of these were published (56 anonymously) and are listed below. The remaining 163 were not published, because either privacy was requested by the respondents (93) or the respondents failed to return a Respondent Information Form authorising publication.

During this Call for Evidence period, the Group also visited several areas of Scotland and had meetings with a variety of different interests. As part of this, the Group arranged public events and open meetings in:

Greenock 12th November 2012

Tarbert, Harris 11th December 2012

Fort William 12th December 2012

Dumfries 10th January 2013

Glasgow 27th February 2013

Published Submissions [1]

Ref No Name / Organisation
1 Greenspace Scotland
2 Scotland's Rural College ( SRUC)
3 Scottish Branch, Chartered Institute of Arbitrators
8 John Muir Trust
9 Di Alexander
13 Ian Thomas
15 East Ayrshire Council
16 Orkney Islands Council
18 Sir Peter Hutchison
19 Anonymous
20 Robbie Pennington
21 Scottish Anglers National Association
23 Julia Campbell
26 Reforesting Scotland
27 South Lanarkshire Horse And Pony Access Group
28 Hazel Cameron
29 Centre for Human Ecology
30 Derek Pretswell
31 Jamie McIntyre
32 Jamie McKenzie Hamilton
33 Leith Community Crops in Pots
34 Jonathan Agnew
35 Anonymous
36 Henry Trotter
37 Sideactivity
38 Alex Gordon-Duff
39 Scottish Land & Estates
40 Anonymous
41 Scottish Natural Heritage
42 Anonymous
43 North East Mountain Trust
44 Anonymous
45 Oxfam
46 Dr Robert McMorran
48 Ross Paton
49 Scottish Tenant Farmers Association
50 Steve James
52 East Lothian Council
53 Eadha Enterprises
54 Riddell Estate
56 Kinnordy Estate
58 Ron Greer
59 John Sinclair
60 Ludwig Appeltans
61 Anonymous
62 Comhairle nan Eilean Siar
63 Rio Tinto Alcan
64 Highland Council
65 Laurence Keeley
69 Tenant Farming Forum
70 Paul Cochrane
73 Anonymous
74 Dunnichen Community Company
75 Arran Centre for Strategic Land Use
79 I.M.M.Crichton
81 Shared Voices Group
84 Malcolm Combe
89 John MacKintosh
90 Association of Deer Management Groups
93 James Hutton Institute
94 Anonymous
96 Womens Land Reform Group
100 Alastair Riddell
101 Stonefield Farms
102 R Coleman
103 Balnamoon Farms Co
104 Joyce Bruce
105 Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations
106 Church of Scotland
107 Highlands & Islands Enterprise
108 Anonymous
109 Historic Houses Association
110 The Applecross Trust
111 Anonymous
114 Nourish Scotland
115 Shinness Estate
116 Scottish Rights of Way and Access Society (ScotWays)
117 Andrew Finlayson
118 Vanessa Halhead
119 John Thomas
120 CTC scotland
121 Planning Aid for Scotland
122 Scottish Crofting Federation
123 Anonymous
124 Southern Uplands Partnership
125 Anonymous
129 Val Robson
130 Highland Perthshire Communities Land Trust
131 Stewart Jamieson
132 Anonymous
133 Anonymous
134 Mary Howlett
135 Ian Gillies
136 Aigas Community Forest
137 North Harris Trust
138 Catherine Francis
140 Northern Deer Management Group
141 Ekklesia
142 Prof Denis Mollison
143 Calum MacLeod
145 Confederation of Forest Industries
147 Gilbert Bannerman
148 Jamie Roberts
149 Andy Wightman
150 Anonymous
152 Forest Policy Group, wild deer management
153 UPM Tilhill
154 Forest Policy Group, forestry reform
155 Comrie Croft
156 Deirdre Stewart
157 Scottish Borders Council
159 Anonymous
161 Anonymous
162 Ronald MacLean
163 Alasdair Laing
165 Community Woodlands Association
166 Centre for Rural Development
167 Sue Hilder
168 Islay Estates Company
169 Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors
172 Scottish Agricultural Arbiters & Valuers Association
173 Wemyss Estates Trustees
176 The Crown Estate
180 Loch Choire Estate
181 Anonymous
182 NFUS
185 Ramblers Scotland
186 Andy Inglis
187 Wemyss and March Estates
188 The National Trust for Scotland
189 Donna Mackenzie
193 Rural Housing Service
194 Strutt & Parker LLP
196 Michael Foxley
197 Richard Callander
198 Anonymous
199 Anonymous
200 Game & Wildlife Conservation Trust
201 Andrew Hamilton
203 Shelter Scotland
206 Royal Town Planning Institute Scotland
207 Scottish Water
208 Malcolm Nicol
209 Anonymous
210 Scottish Community Alliance
211 Glenernie Estate
213 Anonymous
215 Anonymous
216 Loch Lomond & The Trossachs National Park
219 Anonymous
220 Alastair Riddell
221 Anonymous
222 Development Trusts Association Scotland
223 Scottish Sports Association
224 Anonymous
226 Moray Estates
227 Malcolm Younger
230 Mark laing
231 Lianne Hackett & Chris Fremantle
233 Colin Corlett
234 Association for the Protection of Rural Scotland
235 Stirling Council & Stirling Area Local Access Forum
236 Cromar Community Council
237 West Harris Trust
241 Woodland Crofts Partnership
242 Bowhill and Dalkeith Estates of Buccleuch Estates
243 Anonymous
247 Scottish Council for Development and Industry
248 Carnegie UK Trust
249 British Horse Society
250 Association of Salmon Fishery Boards
251 Mark Nicolson
252 Smiths Gore
253 Dr Jayne Glass
255 Sustrans Scotland
256 Richard Stirling-Aird
257 Blair Atholl & Struan Community Council
258 Achentoul Estate Company Ltd & Achentoul Farms Ltd
259 RSPB Scotland
260 Anonymous
262 Trustees of Cawdor Maintenance Trust, Cawdor Estate
263 Brian Inkster
264 Anonymous
265 Alexander Baillie
266 Robert Balfour
268 Scottish Allotments and Gardens Society
269 Joe Gibbs
271 Haddington Estate
272 Roxburghe Estate
272A Duke of Roxburghe
273 Eilidh I.M. Ross
274 Dunecht Estates
277 James Baillie
280 Philip Astor
281 Lord Balniel
282 Queensberry Estate
284 Anonymous
285 Anonymous
287 Esk District Salmon Fishery Board
288 Daye Tucker
289 Richard Sidgwick
290 Nordic Enterprise Trust
291 Kinghorn Community Land Association
293 Brian Marden
294 Andrew T Wood
295 Anonymous
296 Scottish Woodlot Association
298 Tom Gray
300 Caledonia Centre for Social Development
302 Douglas & Angus Estates
303 Andrew Salvesen
305 Anonymous
307 David Robertson
308 James Galbraith
310 Anonymous
311 Anonymous
313 William Parente
314 Law Society of Scotland rural sub-committee
315 Seafield and Strathspey Estates
317 Community Land Scotland
320 James Baillie
321 Justin Kenrick
325 Greens Chartered Surveyors
326 Scottish Outdoor Access Network
328 Know Edge Ltd
329 Peter Landale
330 Euan J. Webster
331 Big Lottery
332 The Mountaineering Council of Scotland
333 Noel Darlow
336 Scottish Countryside Alliance
337 Kevin Findlater
339 Dr Jean Balfour
342 Mid West Association of Highland Estates Deer Management Group
346 John Digney
347 British Association for Shooting and Conservation
350 Scottish Canoe Association
351 The MacRobert Trust
353 Society of Local Government Lawyers and Administrators in Scotland
355 Anonymous
357 Anonymous
358 Holmehill Community Buyout Group
359 Glenfalloch Estate
361 Scottish Land & Estates Moorland Group
364 Bidwells
366 Donna Skelly
368 Arthur Greenan
369 Storas Uibhist Ltd
370 Anonymous
372 Anonymous
373 Anonymous
375 J. Martin Haldane
376 Stracathro and Careston Estate
377 Alvie & Dalraddy Estates
378 Atholl Estates
379 Drummuir Estate
380 Balloch Riders Access Group
382 Anonymous
384 Lochcarron Estate
385 Richard Cooke
387 Torwoodlee and Buckholm Estate
388 William John Buchanan
392 Anthony Foyle
393 Anonymous
394 Martin Girvan
395 Anonymous
399 Anonymous
400 Jack Whitaker
401 Peter Graham
402 Anonymous
403 Friends of Loch Lomond and The Trossachs
404 Embo Trust
406 John Macdonald
407 Andrew Lorrain-Smith
408 James Duncan Millar
409 Anonymous
410 Ewan G Kennedy
412 Ewen MacPherson
413 Helmsdale District Salmon Fishery Board
414 Argyll and Bute Local Access Forum
415 Anonymous
416 Cove Harbour Conservation
419 Anonymous
421 Anonymous
423 Kincardine Estate
425 Prof. Colin T. Reid and Dr. Walters Nsoh
426 Prof Jane Bower
427 Michael Wigan
428 Anonymous
431 Hawick & Jedburgh Branch of NFUS
432 Anonymous
434 Woodland Trust Scotland
435 Glenmuick Estate
436 Edward Baxter
437 Dunbeath Estate
438 John Randall
440 Stratherrick and Foyers Community Trust
443 RHS Gordon
444 Mark Crichton Maitland
445 Anonymous
446 Graham Tuley
447 Colin Strang Steel, Threepwood
448 Jamie Orr Ewing
449 Marion Boyle
452 Anonymous
453 Anonymous
455 J & S Grant
458 Alexander Gordon Morison
459 Druidaig Estate
463 Dormont Estate
465 Miff Tuck
467 Cambo Estate
470 Anonymous
471 Hopes Estate
475 Michael Maciocia
477 Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
478 Reginald Melton
480 Anonymous
481 Highlands Small Communities Housing Trust
482 Environmental NGOs, Centre for Mountain Studies
483 Scottish Environment LINK
484 David Merrick

Contact