Place-based policy approaches to population challenges: Lessons for Scotland

This report by the independent Expert Advisory Group on Migration and Population analyses a range of place-based policy approaches to population challenges (including zonal approaches), and sets out lessons for Scotland.


Anderson, M. and Roughley, C. (2018) Scotland’s Populations from the 1850s to Today. Oxford University Press.

Ashcroft, B. and Taylor, J. (1977) ‘The movements of manufacturing industry and the effect of regional policy’, Oxford Economic Papers, 29(1) pp. 84-101.

Barca, F.; Casavola, P. and Lucatelli, S.; Eds. (2014) A strategy for inner areas in Italy; Definition, objectives, tools and governance. Doc-umenti Issue 31. Materiali UVAL: Roma,

Bartels, C.P.A, W.P. Nicol and van Duijn, J. (1982). ‘Estimating the impact of regional policy’. Regional Science and Urban Economics, 12 (1), pp. 3-41.

Bauder, H. and Green, R. (2022) Indigenous Perspectives of Immigration Policy in a Settler Country . Journal of International Migration,

Berlioux, S. (2020) Mission orientation et égalité des chances dans la France des zones rurales et des petites villes. Restaurer la promesse républicaine. Rapport remis le 5 mars 2020. Association Chemins d’avenirs. Mnistère de l’Éducation et da la Jeunesse, Paris.

Blamey, A. and Mackenzie, M., (2007) Theories of change and realistic evaluation: peas in a pod or apples and oranges?. Evaluation, 13(4), pp.439-455.

DTI North West Regional Office (1989) ‘British Regional Policy since the 1920s.’

Broadberry, S. and Leunig, T. (2013) ‘The impact of Government policies on UK manufacturing since 1945’, Government Office for Science Foresight paper

Bundesministerium für Innern, für Bau und Heimat (BMIBH), Bundesministerium für Ernährung und Landwirtschaft (BMEL) and Bundesministerium für Familie, Senioren, Frauen und Jugend (BMFSFJ). Unser Plan für Deutschland, Gleichwertige Lebensverhältnisse überall. Berlin, 2019.

Collantes, F. and Pinilla, V. (2019) Lugares que no importan? La despoblación de la España rural desde 1900 hasta el presente. Monografías de Historia Rural 15. Prensas de la Universidad de Zaragoza,.

Coleman, D. and Rowthorn, R. (2011) Who's afraid of population decline? A critical examination of its consequences. Population and development review, 37, pp.217-248.

Connell, J.P. and Kubisch, A.C. (1998) Applying a theory of change approach to the evaluation of comprehensive community initiatives: progress, prospects, and problems. New approaches to evaluating community initiatives, 2(15-44), pp.1-16.

Convention of the Highlands and Islands (COHI) (2020) Meeting Papers for October 2020, Paper 6, Population and Fragile Communities: Demographic Challenges in the Highlands and Islands – A focus on peripheral and fragile areas.

Convention of the Highlands and Islands (COHI) (2021a) Meeting Papers for March 2021, Paper 3, Population, National and Regional Update

Convention of the Highlands and Islands (COHI) (2021b) Meeting Papers for October 2021, Paper 5, Population Update

Convention of the Highlands and Islands (COHI) (2022a) Meeting Papers for October 2022, Paper 4, Population Update

Convention of the Highlands and Islands (COHI) (2022b) Meeting Papers for October 2022, Transcript of meeting, Copus, A. and Crabtree, B., 1992. Mapping economic fragility: an assessment of the Objective 5b boundaries in Scotland. Journal of Rural Studies, 8(3), pp.309-322.

Copus, Andrew K. (2001) 'From Core-periphery to Polycentric Development: Concepts of Spatial and Aspatial Peripherality', European Planning Studies, 9:4, 539 – 552 DOI: 10.1080/713666491

Copus, A. (2018) The wisdom of the fathers? Regional/rural development policy and structures for the Highlands and Islands of Scotland 1965–2015, through the lens of smart specialisation. In Kristensen, I., Dubois, A., and Teräs J. Strategic Approaches to Regional Development (pp. 108-124). Routledge.

Copus, A., Kahila, P. and Fritsch, M. (2022) City region thinking, a zombie idea in regional and rural development? Scotland and Finland compared. Journal of Rural Studies, 89, pp.348-356

Dax, T., Macholt, I., Bauchinger, L. (2020) Case Study Mansfeld-Südharz, Germany, ESPON ESCAPE Final Report Annex 8.

da Rosa Pires, A., Pertoldi, M., Edwards, J. and Hegyi, F.B (2014) Smart Specialisation and innovation in rural areas. S3 Policy Brief Series, 9, p.2014.

De Rossi, A. (2019) Riabitare l'Italia: le aree interne tra abbandoni e riconquiste. Donzelli editore.

ESPON (2020) ESCAPE (European Shrinking Rural Areas: Challenges, Actions and Perspectives for Territorial Governance) Final Report. Retrieved from

Esping-Andersen, G. (2015) Welfare regimes and social stratification. Journal of European Social Policy, 25(1), pp.124-134.

European Commission (EC) (2018) Directorate-General for Communications Networks, Content and Technology, Worthington, H., Simmonds, P., Farla, K., et al., The silver economy: final report,

European Commission (EC) (2021) A Long-Term Vision for the EU’s Rural Areas,

Frost, M. E. (1975) ‘The impact of regional policy: a case study of manufacturing employment in the Northern Region’, Progress in Planning, 4(3), pp. 169-277.

European Network for Rural Development (ENRD) (2019) Smart Villages Pilot Project: Briefing Note [accessed 29th November 2022]

Grasland, C., et al. Shrinking Regions: A Paradigm Shift in Demography and Territorial Development. (2008) Study for Directorate-General for Internal Policies of the Union, Policy Department B: Structural and Cohesion Policy, European Parliament. Brussels: European Parliament.

Hansard (1960a) House of Lords Debate, 23 February 1960 Vol. 221, p. 226 (c.f. Lord Aberdare pp. 247-8).

Hansard (1960b) House of Lords Debate 23 February 1960 vol. V21 (Lord Clydesmuir, pp.235-6 and Lord Bilsland, pp. 255-6)

Hansard (1963) House of Commons, Parliamentary Questions, 14th March 1963, Vol. 673, Column 180.

Hagar, H. (2021) Just the Tip of the Iceberg: The first few months of the Rural and Northern Immigration Pilot . Northern Policy Institute . [accessed 28 October 2022]

Highland Council (2015) 2011 Census Results: Travel to Work Statistics (produced by the Information and Research Team, Planning and Development Service.

Hollander, J.B. and Németh, J. (2011) The bounds of smart decline: A foundational theory for planning shrinking cities. Housing Policy Debate, 21(3), pp.349-367. Network (2022) Rural and Northern Immigration Pilot. Accessed on 28 October 2022

IRCC (2022) Expanding the benefits of immigration in rural and northern communities . News Release (2022) [accessed 1 November 2022]

Kahila, P., Hirvonen, T., Jolkkonen, A., Kurvinen, A., Lemponen, V., Makkonen, T., Rautiainen, S., Copus, A., Teräs, J., Turunen, E., Lebbing, J., Vester, L., Meijer, M. (2021) Mitä on älykäs sopeutuminen? Finnish Prime Minister’s Office.

Kawka, R., Artmann, J., Huttenloher, C., Scholze, J. (2012) Partnership for sustainable rural-urban development: existing evidences. Report for European Commission DG Regio, Rurban project (2011.CE.16.0.AT.017) [accessed 25 June 2021]

Klimczuk, A. (2016) Comparative analysis of national and regional models of the silver economy in the European Union. A. Klimczuk, Comparative Analysis of National and Regional Models of the Silver Economy in the European Union, International Journal of Ageing and Later Life, 10(2), pp.31-59.

Lenihan A and McGuirk H (2022) Small enterprises and the silver economy, Small Enterprise Research, 29:1, 1-5, DOI: 10.1080/13215906.2022.2048205

Levitt, I. (1992) The Scottish Office: Depression and Recovery 1919-1959, Scottish History Society

Lutz, W. and Gailey, N. (2020) Depopulation as a policy challenge in the context of global demographic trends.

National Records of Scotland, Mid-year population estimates by administrative area and sex, 1981-2021.

Maja, P.W., Meyer, J. and Von Solms, S. (2020) Development of smart rural village indicators in line with industry 4.0. IEEE Access, 8, pp.152017-152033.

Ministére de la Transition écologique et de la Cohésion des territoires 2019 Agenda rural: faire des campagnes des territoires d’avenir, Press Release [accessed 29 November 2022]

Ministerio de Politica Territorial y Función Pública (2020) Estrategia Nacional frente al Reto Demográfico, Directrices Generales. Comi-sionado del Gobierno frente al reto demográfico. Madrid.

Müller, B., and Siedentop, S. (2004) Wachstum und Schrumpfung in Deutschland; Trends, Perspektiven und Herausforderungen für die räumliche Planung und Entwicklung. Deutsche Zeitschrift für Kommunalwissenschaften, 43(1), 14-32.

OECD (2013) Rural-Urban Partnerships: An Integrated Approach to Economic Development, OECD Rural Policy Reviews, OECD Publishing, Paris, .

OECD (2019) Highlights: Rural Policy 3.0. Paris

Pattison G. (2004) Planning for decline: the ‘D’‐village policy of County Durham, UK. Planning Perspectives, 19(3), pp.311-332.

Peters, D.J., Fisher, H. and Zarecor, K. (2017) Shrink-Smart Small Towns: Communities can still thrive as they lose population. Iowa State University Extension and Outreach Publications 486.

Pinilla, V. and Sáez, L.A. (2021) What do public policies teach us about rural depopulation: the case study of Spain. European Countryside, 13(2), pp.330-351

Rink, D., Haase, A., Bernt, M., and Großmann, K. "Shrink Smart." Fp7 Project. Workpackage1: Specification of Working Model (2009). Available at

Sato, Y. and Yamamoto, K. (2005) Population concentration, urbanization, and demographic transition. Journal of Urban Economics, 58(1), pp.45-61

Scottish Government (2019) The National Islands Plan

Scottish Government (2021) A Scotland for the Future: The opportunities and challenges of Scotland’s Changing Population

Scottish Government Expert Advisory Group (EAG) (2019) UK Immigration Policy after Leaving the EU Impacts on Scotland’s Economy, Population and Society.

Scottish Government Expert Advisory Group (EAG) (2020) Internal migration in Scotland and the UK: trends and policy lessons. Scottish Government.

Scottish Government Expert Advisory Group (EAG) (2021) Designing a pilot remote and rural migration scheme: analysis and policy options, Scottish Government.

Scottish National Party (2021) ‘2021 Manifesto, Scotland’s Future, Scotland’s Choice,’, p. 72 [accessed 7 December 2022].

Sepp, V., and Veemaa, J. (2017) Shrinking regions and innovative solutions: entrepreneurship, employment and the accessibility of services. Study report was commissioned by the Estonian Ministry of Finance, Department of Regional Development, Tartu. Retrieved from

Sodja, E. (2021) Boom Town: Amenity Migration in the Rural West and the Rise of the" Zoom Town" Series Summary. [accessed 28 November 2022]

Stein, D. and Valters, C. (2012) Understanding theory of change in international development. (JSRP and TAF collaborative project) (JSRP Paper 1). Justice and Security Research Programme, International Development Department, London School of Economics and Political Science, London, UK.

Syssner, J. (2016) Planning for shrinkage? Policy implications of demographic decline in Swedish municipalities. Ager. Revista de Estudios sobre Despoblación y Desarrollo Rural, (20), pp.7-31.

Syssner, J. (2020) Pathways to demographic adaptation: Perspectives on policy and planning in depopulating areas in Northern Europe. Springer Nature.

Taplin D. and Clark, H. (2012) Theory of Change Basics. A Primer on Theory of Change. Actknowledge, New York. [ [accessed 8 June 2022]

Vogel, I. (2012) Review of the use of ‘Theory of Change’ in international development. London: UK Department for International Development (DFID).

Wettmann, R. W. and Nicol, W.R. (1981) ‘Deglomeration policies in the European Community’, Luxembourg Office for Official Publications of the European Communities.

Wiginton, L. (2013) Canada’s Decentralised Immigration Policy Through A Local Lens: How small communities are attracting and welcoming immigrants.



Back to top