Razor clams - commercial fishery using electric current gear: consultation analysis - business and regulatory impact assessment
Business and regulatory impact assessment (BRIA) for the consultation on a commercial fishery for razor clams using electric current gear in Scottish waters.
9. Regulatory and EU Alignment Impacts
9.1 Intra-UK Trade
9.1.1 Option 1 (continue trial)
This option would have no impact on intra-UK trade.
9.1.2 Option 2 (commercial fishery)
There may have a slight positive impact on intra-UK trade, reflecting an increase in vessels with authorisation to fish from around 21 to around 24.
9.1.3 Option 3 (new trial)
This option would have an impact on impact on intra-UK trade as the market access for goods and services would be reduced, creating an opportunity for demand to be met by IUU fishing. Some razor clams are transported and sold in England, this would be expected to reduce in this scenario. This would not unduly affect fishers from other UK regions with most affected fishers being based in Scotland.
9.1.4 Option 4 (prohibition)
This option would have a significant impact on intra-UK trade as there would be no legal landings of razor clams to meet market demand which creates more of an opportunity for demand to be met by IUU fishing.
9.2 International Trade
9.2.1 Option 1 (continue trial)
Option 1 does not have the potential to affect trade flows internationally.
9.2.2 Option 2 (commercial fishery)
This option would be expected to increase trade flows, reflecting a change in number of vessels authorised to fish from around 21 to around 24.
Export market demand has increased for shellfish over time and razor clams represent a high value component of shellfish exports that can support a lucrative fishery with the appropriate controls to avoid adverse environmental impact or over-supply. Any increase in size, for example as a result of opening new areas to fishing, would require careful consideration of both of these factors. Even if environmental effects can be adequately controlled, expanding fishing too quickly may risk the price achieved in international trade. We therefore expect any increase in trade flows to be modest in the first years of commercial fishing.
Export figures in Table 2 are based on HMRC export trade data at the highest level of commodity-code disaggregation available. This commodity code encompasses multiple species and does not distinguish razor clams separately. Nevertheless, razor clams (family Pharidae) are captured within this classification and are therefore included in the reported export totals.
| 12-month period | Commodity | Commodity description | Total (£000) |
|---|---|---|---|
| January to December 2025 | 3077100 | Live, Fresh Or Chilled, Even In Shell, Clams, Cockles And Ark Shells "Families Arcidae, Arcticidae, Cardiidae, Donacidae, Hiatellidae, Mactridae, Mesodesmatidae, Myidae, Semelidae, Solecurtidae, Solenidae, Tridacnidae And Veneridae" | £5,134 |
| January to December 2025 | 3077290 | Frozen, Even In Shell, Clams, Cockles And Ark Shells "Families Arcidae, Arcticidae, Cardiidae, Donacidae, Hiatellidae, Mactridae, Mesodesmatidae, Myidae, Semelidae, Solecurtidae, Solenidae, Tridacnidae" | £251 |
| January to December 2025 | 16055600 | Clams, Cockles And Arkshells, Prepared Or Preserved (Excl. Smoked) | £25,299 |
| Grand Total | All commodities | All commodities | £30,684 |
Source: Seafish Trade & Tariff Tool | Tableau Public
9.2.3 Option 3 (new trial)
Option 3 would reduce the international exports of razor clams from Scotland. In a new trail there would be a six vessel limit. Plus hand gathering which is for personal use only.
This option may affect trade flows with several Asian countries due to high demand for the product. We may expect international buyers to shift to purchasing razor clams harvested by other European nations in preference to the Scottish product, though we may also expect the smaller amount produced in Scotland to gain further prestige as a premium hand gathered product in comparison to dredged clams from Ireland or the Netherlands.
9.2.4 Option 4 (prohibition)
This option will affect trade flows with several Asian countries due to high demand for the product. This option would have a significant impact on international trade as there would be no legal landings of razor clams to meet market demand creating an opportunity for demand to be met by IUU fishing.
9.3 EU Alignment
Assimilated Regulation 2019/1241[5] of prohibits the use of electric current to catch marine species. After EU exit, this regulation was retained in domestic law, now referred to as assimilated law.
9.3.1 Option 1 (continue trial)
Option 1 would see no change to the Scottish Government’s policy of alignment with the EU.
9.3.2 Option 2 (commercial fishery)
Option 2 would see a change to the alignment with the assimilated Regulation (EU) 2019/1241. This option would require new/amended legislation. The Scottish Government position is to preserve EU alignment insofar as doing so maintains standards. Our view in relation to this option is we are improving standards in comparison to reasonable alternative modes of harvest and therefore can justify diverging from alignment on this matter. The assimilated regulation seeks to promote innovative fishing methods through Article 15, where those methods contribute to the objective and targets of the regulation, for example minimising the negative environmental effects of fishing.
9.3.3 Option 3 (new trial)
This option would see no change to alignment with the EU. Under Article 25, fishing in support of scientific investigation is exempt from the technical measures in Regulation (EU) 2019/1241.
9.3.4 Option 4 (prohibition)
Option 4 would see no change to the alignment with the EU.