Razor clams - commercial fishery using electric current gear: consultation analysis - business and regulatory impact assessment
Business and regulatory impact assessment (BRIA) for the consultation on a commercial fishery for razor clams using electric current gear in Scottish waters.
7. Benefits
7.1 Option 1 (continue trial)
This is the ‘Do Nothing’ option so the impacts of other options are compared against Option 1. In 2025-26, active trial vessels landed 659 tonnes of razor clams, at a value of £5.2 million which contributed to Scotland’s economy. Throughout 2025-26, around 69 people were employed by vessels enrolled and active, at any point in the trial. Of which, the majority were regularly employed (regularly employed being those whose primary occupation was fishing)[3].
7.2 Option 2 (commercial fishery)
Under Option 2, a limited commercial fishery would be established. The fishery could be slightly larger (by around 10%) or alternatively reduced to only those areas with stock assessments (Colonsay, Firth of Forth, Firth of Clyde and Broad Bay trial areas). A change to the economic activity stemming from the fishery would differ at the national scale depending on the scale of the limited fishery.
Table 1 sets out our estimates for landings in the trial year 2026-27. We estimate landings based on three possible outcomes, all based on 2025-26 landings data:
| Scenario | Tonnage | Value (£m) | Total Scottish Employment [1] | Of which, Regularly Employed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| current activity | 659 | 5.2 | 69 | 58 |
| 10% larger | 722 | 5.7 | 77 | 66 |
Source: Marine Directorate internal data.[4]
The values for a larger fishery are estimated by assuming that two additional vessels join the fleet. Based on the 2025-26 average of 31 tonnes landed per vessel, this would increase total landings by around 10 per cent relative to 2025-26. Prices are assumed to remain unchanged, at £7,950 per tonne of razor clams landed. This assumption is subject to uncertainty, as a range of market factors could affect prices in 2026-27. Under the assumption of constant prices, the total value of razor clam landings would potentially estimated to increase to £5.7 million in 2027.
We assume that the two additional vessels notionally entering the fleet in 2026-27 would employ around 8 people in total, 6 of whom would be in regular employment. This estimate is based on the average employment levels on active trial vessels in 2025-26. It is, however, subject to uncertainty as the size and characteristics of any new vessels are currently unknown.
The landings of the trial were widely distributed between ports in Scotland. In 2025-26, landings were reported from 24 ports in 6 districts. Figure 1 shows the shares of landings of razor clams into Scottish ports in 2025-26. Pittenweem had the largest share of landings, with 22 per cent of landings in 2025-26. Smaller ports may benefit further economically and socially from a limited commercial fishery.
Figure 1: Share of value of landings into Scottish ports in 2025-26
Source: Marine Directorate internal data.
The proposed change to establish a limited commercial fishery as a direct result of this consultation, may result in new opportunities for fishers to utilise this resource and may widen diversity in the inshore fleet. There is potential for further contribution to the economy. The expected impacts on fishers is found in the Scottish Firms Impact section of the BRIA.
Option 2 is expected to have higher social benefits compared to Option 1, as there would be a permanent settled status for fishing for razor clams. The social benefits include stability of employment, opportunities closer to home for traditionally nomadic diving work and improved access to high quality Scottish seafood.
New fishers may be able to access the stock which potentially increases competition and market stability. Access to the commercial fishery will be subject to an application process where criteria must be met in order to gain an electrofishing for razor clam entitlement.
Necessarily, a commercial fishery maintains regulatory access, ensuring that fishing is developed at the appropriate level of activity to ensure the conservation objectives of the MPA network are not compromised, and the product is safe to eat, and is harvested safely. These benefits would be no different to option 1 but their status as a permanent fixture of a commercial fishery helps regulators (NatureScot, Food Standards Scotland, Health and Safety Executive, Local Authorities) make business plans more effectively.
7.3 Option 3 (new trial)
Under Option 3, a new trial, limited to 6 vessels would be established. The proposed change, would result in new scientific data but would be limited to those vessels and the areas targeted.
Assuming such a trial operates at this scale, then the corresponding seabed footprint of activity would be reduced. While we can ensure fishing at the current scale remains sustainable with the appropriate controls, the direct fishing pressure of a reduced fishery would be lessened.
7.4 Option 4 (prohibition)
While a prohibition would notionally bring fishing mortality to zero, we could expect this option to lead to a dynamic of some fishers seeking to fish illegally, and compliance enforcement officials acting to enforce a prohibition. While we cannot determine the extent to which this may occur, we can estimate that it would be at a higher rate than Option 1.