Razor clams - commercial fishery using electric current gear: consultation analysis - business and regulatory impact assessment
Business and regulatory impact assessment (BRIA) for the consultation on a commercial fishery for razor clams using electric current gear in Scottish waters.
5. Options Considered
Following analysis of consultation responses, four options are considered in this BRIA. These are:
5.1 Option 1 – Status Quo – Original Trial Setting
This is the ‘Do Nothing’ Option. The baseline for this BRIA will measure against the original trial setting with associated costs and benefits. However, it should be noted that the original trial will end 31 January 2027 and fishers will be unable to fish for razor clams in Scotland after this date unless Ministers decided to extend the trial. Fishing for razor clams in other circumstances would continue to be prohibited by Scottish Statutory Instrument (SSI) 2017/419[1]. Fishing using electricity would also be prohibited in accordance with Article 7 of assimilated Regulation (EU) 2019/1241.[2]
5.2 Option 2 - Establish a limited commercial fishery
This option considered the establishment of a limited commercial fishery. Following analysis of the consultation responses, the Marine Directorate has developed Option 2. In this option we have assumed a commercial fishery could be approximately 10% larger than the current trial. All variations would be subject to the same management measures as the current trial, such as catch limits, REM requirements and days at sea.
The key difference between Option 1 and Option 2 is:
- Electrofishing for razor clams would become legal and commercial fishing for razor clams would be permitted using only this method.
- This would require changes to the law resulting in divergence from the EU electrofishing prohibition. In doing so, environmental standards as they relate to fishing would be enhanced in comparison to other alternative options.
- Fishing would no longer be restricted to trial areas, but would be subject to spatial control through the shellfish harvesting area classification process, and fisheries assessments relating to the MPA network and priority marine features as necessary.
- This would represent an opportunity for new fishers.
- Access to the fishery would be on an application basis leading to area-specific authorisations.
Other criteria may also be utilised and will be developed in time for provision in 2027.
5.3 Option 3 – A new scientific trial
This option was put forward for views, particularly in consideration for regions where stock assessments and landings per unit effort (LPUE) data are lacking, or to progress research goals that were not met such as studying effects of electric current gear on sandeels and flatfish. A new scientific trial could be implemented in a subset of areas with a subset of fishers but would be limited to 6 vessels, unless a larger trial was justified on scientific grounds.
The key differences between Option 1 and Option 3 are:
- Electrofishing for razor clams could be prohibited to all but six selected active participants in the new trial, representing a 72% reduction in authorised fishing activity.
- The places where trial activity was authorised could differ, and some currently authorised fishing activity could stop. This would be informed by the scientific objectives of a new trial.
5.4 Option 4 - Trial ends (razor fishing with electricity becomes illegal)
A return to prohibition, the trial ends and fishing for razor clams would no longer be permitted. Fishing for razor clams would be prohibited according to Scottish Statutory Instrument (SSI) 2017/4191, and fishing using electricity would also be prohibited in accordance with Article 7 of assimilated Regulation (EU) 2019/1241. The trial ending option would mean that fishers would be unable to fish for razor clams in Scotland after 31 January 2027.