Razor clams - commercial fishery using electric current gear: consultation analysis - business and regulatory impact assessment

Business and regulatory impact assessment (BRIA) for the consultation on a commercial fishery for razor clams using electric current gear in Scottish waters.


11. Competition Assessment

11.1 Will the measure directly or indirectly limit the number or range of suppliers?

11.1.1 Option 1 (continue trial)

Not expected to limit the number or range of suppliers.

11.1.2 Option 2 (commercial fishery)

This would increase the number and range of suppliers by around 2-3 vessels from current activity.

11.1.3 Option 3 (new trial)

The measure would directly limit the number and range of suppliers, as a new trial would potentially be limited to six vessels which would be a 72% reduction in suppliers. Depending on the focus of the new trial there could be a significant shift in areas fished, which may directly limit suppliers ability to compete and the range, companies geography would dictate their ability to participate in the new trial. For example if fishing was authorised in a new area like Shetland and discontinued in other areas, this would disrupt existing supply chains. The measure places a barrier to new entrants to the Scottish fishing sector, as there would be no way to fish for razor clams other than within the new trial setting which would be limited to six vessels.

11.1.4 Option 4 (prohibition)

A prohibition would limit the number and range of suppliers to zero.

11.2 Will the measure limit the ability of suppliers to compete?

11.2.1 Option 1 (continue trial)

Not expected to limit ability of suppliers to compete.

11.2.2 Option 2 (commercial fishery)

Not expected to limit ability of suppliers to compete.

11.2.3 Option 3 (new trial)

Vessels would be able to apply for conditional access to the new scientific trial by meeting application criteria. Depending on the focus of the new trial there could be a significant shift in areas fished, which may directly limit suppliers ability to compete, companies geography would dictate their ability to participate in the new trial. Reduced Scottish output of the product could result in buyers opting for Irish or Dutch clams, and a degree of domestic IUU fishing to replace lost fishing opportunities to undermine licenced fishers ability to compete.

11.2.4 Option 4 (prohibition)

There would be no suppliers to compete with due to prohibition.

11.3 Will the measure limit suppliers’ incentives to compete vigorously?

11.3.1 Option 1 (continue trial)

Not expected to limit incentives.

11.3.2 Option 2 (commercial fishery)

Not expected to limit incentives.

11.3.3 Option 3 (new trial)

The overall economic value would remain tied to market demand being driven by reduced landings. In a new trial setting there would potentially be only six active razor vessels compared to 21 derogation holders and eighteen active vessels in the current trial. Reduced Scottish output of the product may increase competition from the Irish razor clam fishery which would have a much larger output of razor clams to meet market demand.

11.3.4 Option 4 (prohibition)

There would be no suppliers to compete vigorously due to prohibition.

11.4 Will the measure limit the choices and information available

11.4.1 Option 1 (continue trial)

Not expected to limit choices and information available.

11.4.2 Option 2 (commercial fishery)

Not expected to limit choices and information available.

11.4.3 Option 3 (new trial)

Potential to limit choices and information, depending on sale of fishery. The default basis would be six vessels, which would reduce choices in line with expected reduction in fishing activity outlined above.

11.4.4 Option 4 (prohibition)

Will limit choice and information available to consumers to zero.

11.5 Consumer Assessment

11.5.1 Option 1 (continue trial)

Landings expected to remain in line with trends during the trial.

11.5.2 Option 2 (commercial fishery)

The overall catch of razor clams may increase if a limited commercial fishery is introduced. The fishery may increase in size modestly and we have assessed at 10% larger if so local markets, selling directly to hospitality businesses may increase. We would also expect the Asian market to expand if two extra vessels added 62 tonnes of landings to the market at a value of £7,950 per tonne.

11.5.3 Option 3 (new trial)

The overall catch volume of razor clams would potentially decrease by 72% with a six vessel limit on a new trial and will impact availability to consumers on a local, national and international level.

11.5.4 Option 4 (prohibition)

Prohibition would reduce overall catch volume to zero and would directly impact availability to consumers on a local, national and international level. Consumers would have to turn to imports from Ireland or the Netherlands, or purchasing black fish illegally.

Contact

Email: Accesstoseafisheries@gov.scot

Back to top