Razor clams - commercial fishery using electric current gear: consultation analysis - business and regulatory impact assessment

Business and regulatory impact assessment (BRIA) for the consultation on a commercial fishery for razor clams using electric current gear in Scottish waters.


3. Summary of Outcome

Following consideration of the evidence gathered during the scientific trial, the responses received to this consultation, and the Scottish Government's wider fisheries management objectives, Ministers have concluded that the next phase of razor clam fishing in Scotland should be the establishment of a limited and tightly controlled commercial fishery using electric current gear. This reflects the majority view expressed by consultation respondents, whilst recognising the concerns raised regarding environmental protection, remaining evidence gaps and the need for effective compliance and monitoring arrangements.

The Scottish Government considers that the trial has demonstrated that a regulated fishery can operate within a robust management framework. However, commercialisation will not represent a move away from precaution, and we recognise evidence gaps remain. The future fishery will retain strong controls on fishing activity, including limits on vessel numbers, effort restrictions, spatial management measures, remote electronic monitoring (REM), stock assessment requirements and adaptive management arrangements designed to respond to new evidence as it emerges.

Implementation of these proposals will require changes to legislation and further operational development. These processes will be informed by continuing engagement with stakeholders, scientific advice and assessment of environmental, social and economic impacts. The Scottish Government will publish further information on implementation arrangements as policy development progresses.

3.1 Background

The Marine Directorate of the Scottish Government consulted on views on the establishment of a commercial fishery for razor clams using electric current gear (after the completion of the electrofishing for razor clams scientific trial 2027).

The trial has been in place from 1 February 2018. Annual reports are been published from each trial year and are available on the Scottish Government website, Electrofishing for Razor Clams Scientific Trial - Annual Reports. A landmark biological and ecological progress goals report was also published on the website in 2026 by the Science Evidence, Data and Digital portfolio of the Marine Directorate, Electrofishing for Razor Clams Scientific Trial - Biological and Ecological Goals: Progress Report. Furthermore a fisheries assessment was also published to assess the potential impact of the trial with reference to priority marine features, and the conservation objectives of a variety of sites in Scotland’s MPA network, Electrofishing for Razor Clams Scientific Trial: Fisheries Assessment.

3.2 Objective

The objective of this assessment is to outline the potential business and regulatory impacts of different outcomes, in the context of stakeholder and consultation respondent views, as well as Scottish Government fisheries management priorities and obligations. This BRIA does not assess the potential impacts of the options to be brought forward out of the ‘Call to Evidence’ section of the Consultation document as these are to be developed further.

3.3 Rationale for Government Intervention

Fishing for razor clams using electric current presents an opportunity for the Scottish fishing industry and for coastal communities that depend upon fishing activity. Evidence gathered through the scientific trial indicates that a commercially viable fishery can be developed which delivers socio-economic benefits while maintaining a relatively low environmental impact. Government intervention is therefore aimed at using the evidence obtained through the trial to establish and regulate a small-scale, sustainable and economically valuable commercial fishery.

This approach is consistent with Scotland's wider fisheries management framework. It supports the objectives of the Fisheries Act 2020, particularly the precautionary, ecosystem, sustainability and scientific evidence objectives, by enabling the utilisation of a marine resource while ensuring appropriate safeguards are in place.

Precautionary objective: The fishery has been developed through a controlled scientific trial, enabling evidence gathering on stock, operational practices and impacts before commercialisation. In particular, we have applied a stock assessment model that estimates maximum sustainable yield, and propose to make authorisation to fish for razor clams conditional on producing a relevant stock assessment if one is not already in place.

Ecosystem objective: We have assessed fishing activity in a fisheries assessment and made changes to authorisations to reduce the risk of hindering conservation objectives and to avoid undermining the achievement of conservation objectives. We therefore consider authorisation of commercial fishing in some circumstances to be possible in the same way that scientific trial fishing has been possible.

Sustainability objective: The scientific trial has demonstrated that electrofishing for razor clams can support a commercially viable fishery while maintaining a relatively low environmental impact, and without overexploiting razor clam stocks.

Scientific evidence objective: The scientific trial has demonstrated that data relevant to management of the fishery can be gathered and used effectively in partnership with the fishing industry, representing management based on the best available scientific evidence. This would be a core continuing component of a commercial fishery.

The proposed new fishery aligns with paragraphs in the Joint Fisheries Statement (JFS) relating to innovation and diversification. In particular, establishing a new fishery:

  • supports opportunities to diversify to promote resilience and enable communities to become adaptable to the current and future needs of the seafood sector and associated support industries (JFS paragraph 4.2.17.15)
  • recognises coastal communities' ambition for development and to encourage diversification to enable and maximise opportunities for the benefit of the seafood sector (JFS paragraph 4.2.17.16)
  • encourages collaboration between industry, academia and government to find innovative opportunities for sustainable economic success and diversification (JFS paragraph 4.2.17.17)
  • supports "innovative solutions" such as engine upgrades, alternative fuels, green technology, and gear changes that reduce emissions and seabed abrasion, contributing to the ecosystem and scientific evidence objectives (JFS paragraph 4.2.14.3)

Establishing a commercial fishery is consistent with Scotland’s Fisheries Management Strategy that balances environmental protection with the long-term economic viability of fishing businesses and the communities they support. By establishing a carefully managed fishery based on robust scientific evidence, the Scottish Government can support economic opportunities in coastal areas while ensuring that harvesting activity remains environmentally sustainable and consistent with Scotland's national fisheries policies.

The following National Performance Framework outcomes are supported by electrofishing for razor clams:

  • Economy
  • Communities
  • Fair Work and Business
  • Poverty
  • Environment

Contact

Email: Accesstoseafisheries@gov.scot

Back to top