Razor clams - commercial fishery using electric current gear: consultation analysis - business and regulatory impact assessment
Business and regulatory impact assessment (BRIA) for the consultation on a commercial fishery for razor clams using electric current gear in Scottish waters.
8. Costs
8.1 Option 1 (continue trial)
This is the ‘Do Nothing’ option but will come with the associated costs of the original trial.
Annual Marine Directorate costs for administering the trial are estimated to be:
- £55,904 for Science Evidence Data and Digital (SEDD) scientific support.
- £31,387 for Domestic Fisheries Management policy support.
- £31,387 for Coastal Operations compliance enforcement support.
Average survey costs, like those carried out in the Solway, are around £80,000 but vary depending on work undertaken and days required. We estimate one survey a year to be required.
We therefore consider the annual cost to the Scottish Government of option 1 to be in the region of £198,678.
Food Standards Scotland are required to undertake work connected to shellfish harvesting area classification, and depending on whether this is provisional or standard classification, and whether an area goes on to become a biotoxin representative monitoring point, this costs between £33,316 and £60,683 per area. This would be an ongoing cost that would vary according to the number of new areas being submitted for classification.
8.2 Option 2
As noted in 6.5 dependent on the scale of the fishery the associated establishment costs may vary. The divergence from EU alignment will contribute to policy and EU alignment colleague’s time and workload. Legislation will need to be amended to legalise electrofishing for razor clams in Scotland, an entitlement will need to be obtained to fish for razor clams in addition to a fishing licence. The finalisation of the trail and a new application process for the limited fishery will have some additional staff time costs, though these may be similar to the costs/time constraints of setting up and management of the current scientific trial. There may be additional costs to current trial fishers if there is a pause in fishing between the trial and the new limited-fishery. For new fishers there will be associated start-up costs such as obtaining the electrofishing equipment and the REM kit/data management costs.
Annual Marine Directorate costs for administering the commercial fishery are estimated to be:
- £55,904 for Science Evidence Data and Digital (SEDD) scientific support.
- £31,387 for Domestic Fisheries Management policy support
- £31,387 for Coastal Operations compliance enforcement support
In our consultation analysis and outcome, we set out that we would continue to address remaining evidence gaps, including information on effects of electric current on species identified as likely to interact, including sandeels and flatfish. We assume at least some of these matters will require fieldwork. We estimate average survey costs, like those carried out in the Solway, are around £80,000 per survey but vary depending on work undertaken and days required, and we estimate that we would require one survey a year for three years to address these uncertainties.
We therefore consider the annual cost to the Scottish Government of option 2 to be in the region of £198,678 for the first three years, reducing to £118,678 thereafter. This is for a fishery of similar scale to the scientific trial.
Food Standards Scotland are required to undertake work connected to shellfish harvesting area classification, and depending on whether this is provisional or standard classification, and whether an area goes on to become a biotoxin representative monitoring point, this costs between £33,316 and £60,683 per area. This would be an ongoing cost that would vary according to the number of new areas being submitted for classification.
We consider the risk of adverse impact on the MPA network and PMFs can be adequately controlled. However uncertainties remain regarding effects of electric current and gear abrasion on some fish and benthic seabeds, as well as potential cumulative effects if fishing was authorised in inappropriate new areas. The cost in this regard is mainly in relation to the administrative requirements to assess impacts and ensure fishing continues to operate within acceptable margins.
8.3 Option 3 (new trial)
Under Option 3, depending on the specific scientific focus of the new trial, costs may vary.
Without a scientific justification for a larger trial, a new trial would be limited to six vessels which may reduce staff time needed on the project. SEDD would be monitoring 6 vessel’s landings/catch/REM data compared to the 18 active vessels they currently oversee. We may expect the staff costs to be reduced somewhat, however some tasks do not scale with the number of data points and so we estimate the reduction compared to Option 1 and 2 to be no more than 20%.
Annual Marine Directorate costs for administering the new trial are estimated to be:
- £44,723 for Science Evidence Data and Digital (SEDD) scientific support.
- £25,109 for Domestic Fisheries Management policy support
- £25,109 for Coastal Operations compliance enforcement support
Average survey costs, like those carried out in the Solway, are around £80,000 but vary depending on work undertaken and days required. If the new trial were to focus on impact on sandeels or benthic disturbance, we estimate one survey a year would be required. A survey would have the same cost regardless of the scale of the new trial.
We therefore consider the annual cost to the Scottish Government of option 3 to be in the region of £174,942.
Food Standards Scotland are required to undertake work connected to shellfish harvesting area classification, and depending on whether this is provisional or standard classification, and whether an area goes on to become a biotoxin representative monitoring point, this costs between £33,316 and £60,683 per area. This would be an ongoing cost that would vary according to the number of new areas being submitted for classification.
Although reduced in scale, a scientific trial would still involve removal of razor clams, localised seabed disturbance and potential disturbance to non-target species. If effort became too limited in some areas, there is also a risk that insufficient data would be collected to support robust stock assessments and long-term fisheries management decisions. Environmental uncertainties associated with electric current fishing would remain unless specifically addressed through targeted research.
8.4 Option 4 (prohibition)
The return to prohibition of could involve a substantial costs for Marine Directorate Compliance to ensure appropriately dissuasive action. Razor clam enforcement work before the trial included inspections, high profile patrols, casework, seizing illegal equipment and dealing with the equipment and storing/transporting seized boats. Marine Patrol Vessels (MPVs) also spent a considerable portion of their tasking time maintaining a presence in high profile areas. We estimate the annual cost to the Scottish Government of option 4 to be in the region of £3.5 million.
Compared to before the trial, more tools are at officials disposal, which may mean the regulatory impact in the event of a prohibition outcome is lower than anticipated. For example any vessel found with razor clams on board without an authorisation can be investigated for a fishery offence, which was not the case before the trial, when vessels needed to be caught with electric current fishing gear.
Nonetheless we expect illegal fishing to occur at a higher frequency in this option compared to others, ultimately leading to increased risk of harm to the MPA network and PMFs, razor clam stocks, food safety and black market economic activity. For this reason we assess this option as having higher costs than others. We cannot estimate with certainty where such impacts might occur.