Razor clams - commercial fishery using electric current gear: consultation analysis - business and regulatory impact assessment
Business and regulatory impact assessment (BRIA) for the consultation on a commercial fishery for razor clams using electric current gear in Scottish waters.
10. Scottish Firms Impact Test
The following Standard Industrial Classification[6] sectors are likely to be impacted by this policy:
- 03110 – Marine Fishing
- 10200 – Processing and preserving of fish, crustaceans and molluscs
- 46380 – Wholesale of other food, including fish, crustaceans and molluscs
The expected impacts are summarised below.
10.1 Option 1 (continue trial)
No impact expected.
10.2 Option 2 (commercial fishery)
We would expect this to have a mixed impact, as it would allow a small number of new entrants to be carefully introduced to the fishery, but this would also be expected to affect prices by adding more product to market, depending on the level of activity of all vessels in the fishery. We may expect additional employment in the region of 8 new jobs. We would expect a permanent status for fishing for razor clams to make it easier for authorised fishing businesses to raise finance for vessel and equipment purchases, premises rental, staff training and certification.
The minimum conservation reference size (MCRS) will be increased in the case of a commercial fishery. Overall, we would expect a MCRS increase to 125mm to reduce landings by between 0.2 and 2.1%. A MCRS increase to 130mm is expected to reduce landings by between 0.4 and 3.2%. Within this there are areas of regional impact that are likely to be higher, the proportion of clams impacted in the Sound of Sleat area for example could reach up to 30%, according to landings made during the trial. The approximate change in landed value is illustrated in Table 3. We therefore intend to increase the MCRS to 130mm, as the impact on landed value is small relative to the total landed value of razor clams during the trial.
| Trial Year | MCRS of 125mm | MCRS of 130mm |
|---|---|---|
| 2020-21 | -57.4 | -76.8 |
| 2021-22 | -23.8 | -47.0 |
| 2022-23 | -59.7 | -76.3 |
| 2023-24 | -16.9 | -27.8 |
| 2024-25 | -16.1 | -25.2 |
Note: Data from Scottish Government Marine Directorate. Values adjusted based on 2024 prices, see Scottish Sea Fisheries Statistics 2024 - gov.scot
10.3 Option 3 (new trial)
The overall economic value will remain tied to market demand being driven by reduced landings. In a new trial setting there would be only six active razor vessels compared to 21 derogation holders and eighteen active vessels in the current trial.
There would be a cost to industry as the current trial participants largely specialise in electrofishing for razor clams, and those not successful in gaining access to the new trial setting would be required to diversify. If unable to diversify these businesses could experience financial difficulties. We note vessels have consistently been warned not to focus exclusively on razor clams, and all vessels active in the trial to date have authorisation to fish for a variety of species per their domestic fishing licences.
10.4 Option 4 (prohibition)
There would be a significant cost to industry as current trial participants largely specialise in electrofishing for razor clams (Figure 2). Businesses would need to diversify or may experience financial difficulties. There is potential for 69 people to lose their employment. Businesses may struggle or fail if they cannot adapt to participating in other fisheries. In 2025-26 trial participants landings were valued at £5.2 million which would be reduced to zero.
Source: Marine Directorate internal data.