Family law reforms: consultation analysis

Analysis of responses to the public consultation on potential family law reforms in Scotland.


Appendix B: Quantitative Analysis

The consultation included 22 closed questions. This document details the responses to these questions.

Not all respondents answered every question. Some may not have answered as they hold no strong view on the question, or it may not relate to their area of knowledge or expertise. Where those who did not answer the closed questions expressed a view in their open comments, this has been noted in the qualitative analysis.

To allow comparisons across sub-groups, the tables below present the results of the closed questions based on those who answered each question.

For clarity, each closed question shows:

  • The number of respondents who answered each question out of the total sample of 124 (column “n=”).
  • The percentage of respondents from the total sample of 124 respondents who selected each response, and the corresponding percentage (grey row).
  • The percentage response among those who answered each question, broken down by individual and organisation responses and by type of organisation (rows including and under “All answering”.

Please note that the row percentages may not add to 100% due to rounding.

Q1: Do you disagree with any aspect of the SLC draft Bill to improve rights of cohabitants when their relationship ends otherwise than on death, or consider that any appropriate provision is missing?

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes % No % Don't Know % No Answer
All respondents 124 16 20 5 59
All answering 51 39 49 12 -
Individuals 31 29 58 13 -
Organisations: 20 55 35 10 -
  • Religion or belief-based
6 33 33 33 -
  • Legal/judicial
10 60 40 0 -
  • Children’s rights/protection
0 - - - -
  • Women’s rights/protection
2 100 0 0 -
  • Other
2 50 50 0 -

Q2: Should the scheme for the reform of cohabitants’ rights on separation apply to couples who separate after the date of commencement of the legislation implementing the proposed reforms?

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes % No % Don't Know % No Answer
All respondents 124 27 6 7 60
All answering 49 67 14 18 -
Individuals 30 63 20 17 -
Organisations: 19 74 5 21 -
  • Religion or belief-based
5 60 20 20 -
  • Legal/judicial
10 90 0 10 -
  • Children’s rights/protection
0 - - - -
  • Women’s rights/protection
2 50 0 50 -
  • Other
2 50 0 50 -

Q3: Do you have any comments on our draft impact assessments on the proposals for improving cohabitants’ rights when their relationship ends otherwise than on death?

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes % No % No Answer
All respondents 124 8 31 61
All answering 48 21 79 -
Individuals 29 14 86 -
Organisations: 19 32 68 -
  • Religion or belief-based
5 20 80 -
  • Legal/judicial
10 10 90 -
  • Children’s rights/protection
0 - - -
  • Women’s rights/protection
2 100 0 -
  • Other
2 100 0 -

Q4: Do you have any other comments on the proposals for improving cohabitants’ rights

when their relationship ends otherwise than on death?

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes % No % No Answer
All respondents 124 15 24 60
All answering 49 39 61 -
Individuals 30 27 73 -
Organisations: 19 58 42 -
  • Religion or belief-based
6 50 50 -
  • Legal/judicial
9 67 33 -
  • Children’s rights/protection
0 - - -
  • Women’s rights/protection
2 100 0 -
  • Other
2 0 100 -

Q5: Should the recommended definition of “cohabitant” under the SLC’s proposals for reform of cohabitants’ rights on separation, also apply to circumstances where a cohabitant is applying for financial provision from their deceased partner’s intestate estate?

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes % No % Don't Know % No Answer
All respondents 124 27 4 6 64
All answering 45 73 11 16 -
Individuals 28 71 18 11 -
Organisations: 17 76 0 24 -
  • Religion or belief-based
5 60 0 40 -
  • Legal/judicial
9 89 0 11 -
  • Children’s rights/protection
0 - - - -
  • Women’s rights/protection
2 50 0 50 -
  • Other
1 100 0 0 -

Q7: Should the Scottish Government legislate to raise the minimum age of marriage and

civil partnership to 18?

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes % No % Don't Know % No Answer
All respondents 124 57 19 7 16
All answering 104 68 23 9 -
Individuals 70 71 27 1 -
Organisations: 34 62 15 24 -
  • Religion or belief-based
13 54 23 23 -
  • Legal/judicial
7 14 29 57 -
  • Children’s rights/protection
5 100 0 0 -
  • Women’s rights/protection
5 80 0 20 -
  • Other
4 100 0 0 -

Q7a. If you wish, you can choose a reason (or reasons) for your answer from the list below

and/or add your own reasons:

Reason % among all (n=124) % among all answering Q7a (n=105) % among those answering ‘yes’ at Q7 (n=69) % among those answering ‘no’ at Q7 (n=24)
Raising the minimum age would protect some children and young people from harm they would not otherwise suffer 48 58 88 0
Other measures can be taken to protect children from harmful conduct, without increasing the minimum age for marriage or civil partnership 5 6 4 13
In general, people aged 16 or 17 do not have the capacity to understand what it means to marry or enter a civil partnership 31 37 57 0
Raising the minimum age in Scotland would meet our international obligations 39 46 70 0
We should keep the minimum age at 16, as it’s consistent with some other rights that 16-year-olds can also exercise, like leaving home 15 18 1 75
There’s not enough evidence to justify reform 10 11 0 50
Selected ‘other’ or left a comment 55 65 49 92
Not answered 15 N/A N/A NA

Q8: Do you agree or disagree that the Scottish Government should legislate to extend the

forced marriage offence?

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Agree % Disagree % Don’t know % No answer
All respondents 124 61 14 3 22
All answering 97 78 18 4 -
Individuals 68 76 22 1 -
Organisations: 29 83 7 10 -
  • Religion or belief-based
9 78 0 22 -
  • Legal/judicial
7 57 29 14 -
  • Children’s rights/protection
5 100 0 0 -
  • Women’s rights/protection
4 100 0 0 -
  • Other
4 100 0 0 -

Q9: Do you have any comments on our draft impact assessments about the minimum age of marriage and civil partnership? We are particularly interested in any evidence about the experience of harm (or other impacts) for parties aged 16 or 17 who are permitted to marry or enter a civil partnership in Scotland, to their children or to others.

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes % No % No Answer
All respondents 124 15 55 31
All answering 86 21 79 -
Individuals 58 21 79 -
Organisations: 28 21 79 -
  • Religion or belief-based
9 22 78 -
  • Legal/judicial
8 0 100 -
  • Children’s rights/protection
3 33 67 -
  • Women’s rights/protection
4 50 50 -
  • Other
4 25 75 -

Q10: Do you have any other comments on the minimum age of marriage and civil

partnership?

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes % No % No Answer
All respondents 124 27 45 27
All answering 90 38 62 -
Individuals 61 36 64 -
Organisations: 29 41 59 -
  • Religion or belief-based
9 44 56 -
  • Legal/judicial
10 40 60 -
  • Children’s rights/protection
3 33 67 -
  • Women’s rights/protection
3 100 0 -
  • Other
4 0 100 -

Q11: Should the Scottish Government lay down qualifying requirements for religious or belief bodies to meet when they solemnise marriage or register civil partnership?

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes % No % Don't Know % No Answer
All respondents 124 37 6 8 49
All answering 63 73 11 16 -
Individuals 37 73 11 16 -
Organisations: 26 73 12 15 -
  • Religion or belief-based
15 60 13 27 -
  • Legal/judicial
5 80 20 0 -
  • Children’s rights/protection
0 - - - -
  • Women’s rights/protection
2 100 0 0 -
  • Other
4 100 0 0 -

Q12: Should the qualifying requirements outlined in this consultation be laid down? [Q13

asks about requirements that you think have been omitted]

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes % No % Don't Know % No Answer
All respondents 124 26 11 6 56
All answering 54 59 26 15 -
Individuals 32 69 16 16 -
Organisations: 22 45 41 14 -
  • Religion or belief-based
12 42 50 8 -
  • Legal/judicial
4 50 25 25 -
  • Children’s rights/protection
0 - - - -
  • Women’s rights/protection
2 0 50 50 -
  • Other
4 75 25 0 -

If you answered No, please confirm whether you think this is because:

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % The requirements should generally be laid down as outlined, but with modification(s) % Only some of the requirements outlined should be laid down % No answer
All respondents 124 8 4 88
All answering 15 67 33 -
Individuals 7 86 14 -
Organisations: 8 50 50 -
  • Religion or belief-based
5 60 40 -
  • Legal/judicial
0 - - -
  • Children’s rights/protection
0 - - -
  • Women’s rights/protection
1 0 100 -
  • Other
2 50 50 -

Q13: Should any further qualifying requirements be laid down?

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes % No % Don't Know % No Answer
All respondents 124 13 21 13 53
All answering 58 28 45 28 -
Individuals 34 26 41 32 -
Organisations: 24 29 50 21 -
  • Religion or belief-based
13 31 46 23 -
  • Legal/judicial
5 20 60 20 -
  • Children’s rights/protection
0 - - - -
  • Women’s rights/protection
2 50 0 50 -
  • Other
4 25 75 0 -

Q14: Should the Scottish Government and NRS draw up a Code of Conduct for celebrants instead of laying down qualifying requirements?

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes % No % Don't Know % No Answer
All respondents 124 15 19 11 54
All answering 57 33 42 25 -
Individuals 34 41 29 29 -
Organisations: 23 22 61 17 -
  • Religion or belief-based
12 33 50 17 -
  • Legal/judicial
5 0 80 20 -
  • Children’s rights/protection
0 - - - -
  • Women’s rights/protection
2 50 0 50 -
  • Other
4 0 100 0 -

Q15: Do you have any comments on the draft Impact Assessments about the Qualifying

Requirements?

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes % No % No Answer
All respondents 124 5 39 56
All answering 54 11 89 -
Individuals 31 6 94 -
Organisations: 23 17 83 -
  • Religion or belief-based
12 25 75 -
  • Legal/judicial
5 0 100 -
  • Children’s rights/protection
0 - - -
  • Women’s rights/protection
2 50 50 -
  • Other
4 0 100 -

Q16: Do you have any other comments on the Qualifying Requirements?

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes % No % No Answer
All respondents 124 13 32 55
All answering 56 29 71 -
Individuals 32 16 84 -
Organisations: 24 46 54 -
  • Religion or belief-based
13 62 38 -
  • Legal/judicial
5 0 100 -
  • Children’s rights/protection
0 - - -
  • Women’s rights/protection
2 0 100 -
  • Other
4 75 25 -

Q17: The Scottish Government is considering making simplified divorce and dissolution procedures available in cases where:

  • there are children (one or more) of the family under 16; and
  • the spouses or civil partners have agreed about the upbringing of the children and so neither applies for an order under section 11 of the 1995 Act in relation to the children.

Do you agree or disagree with making the simplified procedures available in these cases?

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Agree % Disagree % Don’t know % No answer
All respondents 124 32 10 5 53
All answering 58 69 21 10 -
Individuals 35 71 23 6 -
Organisations: 23 65 17 17 -
  • Religion or belief-based
8 38 25 38 -
  • Legal/judicial
9 100 0 0 -
  • Children’s rights/protection
1 0 100 0 -
  • Women’s rights/protection
3 33 33 33 -
  • Other
2 100 0 0 -

Q18: Should Ministers amend the Orders which helped establish the simplified divorce and dissolution procedures to remove the references to “mental disorder” and instead exclude only cases where one of the parties actually “lacks capacity”?

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes [the Orders should be amended] % No % Don't Know % No Answer
All respondents 124 28 7 9 56
All answering 55 64 16 20 -
Individuals 34 68 21 12 -
Organisations: 21 57 10 33 -
  • Religion or belief-based
6 67 0 33 -
  • Legal/judicial
10 60 20 20 -
  • Children’s rights/protection
1 0 0 100 -
  • Women’s rights/protection
2 50 0 50 -
  • Other
2 50 0 50 -

Q19: Considering these points, do consultees think any changes are required to the

procedures for withholding addresses in simplified divorce and dissolution cases?

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes % No % Don't Know % No Answer
All respondents 124 21 12 15 52
All answering 60 43 25 32 -
Individuals 36 36 22 42 -
Organisations: 24 54 29 17 -
  • Religion or belief-based
6 50 17 33 -
  • Legal/judicial
11 45 45 9 -
  • Children’s rights/protection
1 0 100 0 -
  • Women’s rights/protection
4 100 0 0 -
  • Other
2 50 0 50 -

Q20: Do you have any comments on our draft impact assessments about extending the simplified divorce and dissolution procedures?

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes % No % No Answer
All respondents 124 9 31 60
All answering 49 22 78 -
Individuals 29 21 79 -
Organisations: 20 25 75 -
  • Religion or belief-based
6 17 83 -
  • Legal/judicial
9 11 89 -
  • Children’s rights/protection
0 - - -
  • Women’s rights/protection
3 67 33 -
  • Other
2 50 50 -

Q21: Do you have any other comments on extending the simplified divorce and dissolution procedures?

Respondent type Sample size (n=) % Yes % No % No Answer
All respondents 124 11 31 57
All answering 53 26 74 -
Individuals 31 23 77 -
Organisations: 22 32 68 -
  • Religion or belief-based
6 33 67 -
  • Legal/judicial
11 27 73 -
  • Children’s rights/protection
0 - - -
  • Women’s rights/protection
3 67 33 -
  • Other
2 0 100 -

Contact

Email: family.law@gov.scot

Back to top