Family law reforms: consultation analysis

Analysis of responses to the public consultation on potential family law reforms in Scotland.


1. Introduction

Background

The Scottish Government undertook a public consultation on family law reform between 29 December 2025 and 21 April 2026. The consultation was issued by the Minister for Victims and Community Safety and covered several potential reforms to family law in Scotland. Views were sought on potential reforms including cohabitants’ financial rights, raising the minimum marriage age to 18, qualifying requirements for religious or belief bodies and extending simplified divorce to cases involving children under 16.

Respondent profile

In total, 124 consultation responses were received. Almost all were submitted via the online consultation platform, Citizen Space. Those received in an alternative format, for example, an email or PDF document, were reviewed separately by the research team.

Individuals provided 82 responses to the consultation; the remaining 44 responses were from organisations. Individuals were made up of a number of interests such as members of the public, academics and experts in the field. A list of organisations that responded and gave permission to publish can be found in Appendix A. To aid analysis, organisations were grouped according to the nature of their work. Table 1 shows the number of each type of respondent.

Table 1: Respondent profile

Respondent type Number of respondents % of total sample
Individuals 80 65
Organisations[1] 44 35
  • Religious or belief-based organisations
16 13
  • Legal or judicial body
12 10
  • Children's rights and protection organisations
6 5
  • Women's rights and protection
5 4
  • Other
5 4

Public consultations invite everyone to express their views; individuals and organisations interested in the topic are more likely to respond than those without a direct or known interest. This self-selection means the views of respondents do not necessarily represent the views of the entire population.

Analysis approach

The Lines Between was commissioned to provide a robust, independent analysis of the responses to the public consultation. The main purpose of consultation analysis is to understand the full range of views expressed, and, where possible, using closed questions, to quantify how many respondents hold particular views. This report provides a thematic analysis of responses based on the analysis approach outlined below.

Reflecting the number and knowledge of respondents, it is impossible to detail every response in this report; some, especially organisations, shared lengthy submissions reflecting their specific subject matter expertise. These responses are referenced where possible. Full responses to the consultation, where permission for publication was granted, can be found on the Scottish Government’s consultation website.

Similarly, the technical nature of some of the suggestions outlined in the consultation means it is impractical to fully repeat or explain these within this report. Further information on the suggested reforms can be found in the consultation paper.

Quantitative analysis

The consultation included 22 closed questions. Not all respondents answered every question. To compare across sub-groups, this report presents the closed question results based on those who answered each question. For clarity, each results table shows:

  • The percentage of respondents from the total sample of 124 respondents who selected each response (grey row).
  • The percentage response among those who answered each question, broken down by individual and organisation responses (rows including and under “All answering”).

A full breakdown for each question, including a breakdown by each type of organisation answering, can be found in Appendix B. Please note that the row percentages may not add to 100% due to rounding.

Qualitative analysis

Qualitative analysis identifies the key themes across responses to each question. The research team developed a draft coding framework based on a review of the consultation questions and a sample of responses. Codes were refined during the full coding process, where all responses were manually coded against the key themes identified.

In a small number of instances where a response received via email or in a PDF document contained information that did not align with specific questions, analysts exercised judgment about the most relevant place to include this material for analysis purposes.

Where appropriate, quotes from a range of the 124 consultation responses are included to illustrate key points and provide useful examples, insights and contextual information.

Weight of opinion

On average, each open question was answered by fewer than one quarter of all respondents. This report presents the themes identified in responses from most to least commonly mentioned by those respondents at each question. All themes, including views shared by small numbers of respondents, are covered; a view expressed by a very small number of participants is not given less weight than more general comments shared by a majority.

Similarly, all responses have an equal weighting. We recognise this means a response from an individual has the same weight as the response from an organisation which may represent many members, but this approach ensures all views are presented.

Qualitative analysis of open-ended questions does not permit the quantification of results. However, to assist the reader in interpreting the findings, a framework is used to convey the most to least commonly identified themes in responses to each question:

  • Several respondents, 10 or more respondents
  • Some respondents, between five and 10 respondents
  • A few / a small number, three or four respondents
  • Two/one respondents; a singular comment or a view identified in two responses.

This framework is used solely to present the prevalence of themes within consultation responses. This does not necessarily represent the importance of a theme, given the subjective nature of attributing importance and the self-selection of consultation respondents.

Contact

Email: family.law@gov.scot

Back to top