Family law reforms: consultation analysis
Analysis of responses to the public consultation on potential family law reforms in Scotland.
Consultation
2. Improving cohabitants’ financial rights
Questions 1 to 6 of the consultation is concerned with reform of the provisions in the Family Law (Scotland) Act 2006 (the 2006 Act) on financial provision for cohabitants when they cease to cohabit otherwise than by reason of death (referred to as ‘financial provision on separation’) or where one of them dies leaving money and / or property (the estate) but does not leave a valid will setting out how the estate should be distributed (referred to as intestacy).
Section 25 of the 2006 Act defines ‘cohabitant’ for the purposes of sections 26 to 29. Sections 26 and 27 create presumptions in relation to cohabitants’ rights in certain household goods and certain money and property, subject to any agreement made by the cohabitants to the contrary. Section 28 makes provision for claims for financial provision by former cohabitants within one year of the date of separation (when this is due to a reason other than death). Together, sections 26 to 28 of the 2006 Act deal with financial provision on separation.
Section 29 deals with intestacy. It allows a cohabitant to claim against their deceased cohabitant’s estate within six months of death by applying to the court. A claim can only be made where the deceased died without leaving a valid will, known as intestacy. The Scottish Parliament recently agreed to raise the time limit for making a claim to twelve months (under section 78 of the Trusts and Succession (Scotland) Act 2024), though this has not yet been brought into force.
The Scottish Law Commission (SLC) has made recommendations for the reform of sections 25 to 28 of the 2006 Act in their 2022 Report on Cohabitation, in particular that a Cohabitants (Financial Provision) (Scotland) Bill (the draft Bill) be introduced in the Scottish Parliament. The Scottish Government sought stakeholder views on the SLC’s recommendations and draft Bill, and on potential reform of cohabitants’ rights on intestacy under section 29 of the 2006 Act.
Financial provision on separation
The SLC have consulted on the definition of cohabitant for the purposes of applying to the court for financial provision when cohabiting partners split up. Chapter 3 of their report on cohabitation sets out its recommendation for change, notably to no longer rely on a comparison to marriage, instead referring to a couple in an ‘enduring family relationship’. The proposed amended definition is summarised in the consultation paper.
Chapter 4 of the SLC report considers provisions under sections 26 and 27 about household goods, money and property, with clauses 2 and 3 of the draft Bill implementing their recommended changes.
Under section 28 of the 2006 Act, a cohabitant can apply to the court for an order for financial provision from their former partner when they separate within a year of the parties having ceased to cohabit. In considering whether to make any of these orders, the court must take into account certain considerations. Recommended changes to address current criticism of these considerations involve implementing a new test requiring the court to make such an order for financial provision as is justified by the application of any or all of the specified ‘guiding principles’ set out below, and is reasonable having regard to the resources of the cohabitants:
- That an economic advantage derived by a cohabitant from the contributions of the other should be fairly distributed between them, and that a cohabitant who has suffered economic disadvantage in the interests of the other or the interests of any child under 16 of whom the cohabitants are parents or who is accepted as a child of the family, should be fairly compensated (Guiding principle A);
- A cohabitant who seems likely to suffer serious financial hardship as a result of the cohabitation having ended should be awarded such provision as is reasonable to provide for the short-term relief of that hardship (Guiding principle B); and
- The economic responsibility of caring for a child under 16, of whom the cohabitants are parents, or who is or was accepted by the cohabitants as a child of the family, should be shared fairly between the cohabitants (Guiding principle C).
Section 28(2) of the 2006 Act sets out remedies available to a former cohabitant seeking financial provision from their former partner. Clause 4 of the draft Bill would insert a new list of remedies in a new section 28(3), and these new orders are set out in the consultation document. These include an order for payment of a capital sum and an order for the transfer of property.
Other recommended changes are set out in the consultation document, and readers are advised to refer to the document for further details.
Q1. Do you disagree with any aspect of the SLC draft Bill to improve rights of cohabitants when their relationship ends otherwise than on death, or consider that any appropriate provision is missing?
| Respondent type | Sample size (n=) | % Yes
(disagree) |
% No | % Don't No | % No Answer |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| All answering | 51 | 39 | 49 | 12 | - |
Among those answering Q1, 39% answered ‘yes’, indicating they disagreed with an aspect of the SLC draft Bill to improve rights of cohabitants when their relationship ends otherwise than on death, or that they felt an appropriate provision is missing. Of the remainder, 49% answered ‘no’, indicating they agreed with the SLC draft Bill, and 12% were unsure.
Organisations were more likely to answer ‘yes’ (disagree) than individuals (55% compared to 29%, respectively). Concerns were more likely to be noted among the small number of women’s rights/protection organisations that answered (100% ‘yes’) and legal/judicial bodies (60% ‘yes), than by religion or belief-based organisations (33% ‘yes’).
Over one in five of all respondents left an open comment to explain their answer at Q1. The most prevalent themes were comments on section 28 orders and remedies, general positive views on the Bill, and views on financial provision on separation.
Section 28 orders and remedies
Comments on the suggested changes to section 28 orders were raised by several respondents, with the extended range of orders the court can make largely welcomed as helping to overcome limitations of the existing section 28. Specific issues were raised with the orders and remedies proposed in the draft Bill for revised section 28, as noted below.
Orders for financial provision on separation –
Two respondents called for more attention to be paid to providing for sharing the economic responsibility of caring for children, with both believing the Orders fell short in this area, as they did not provide courts with the power to make periodical payments for future childcare. Again, this was noted as being different from cases involving marriage or civil partnerships, where periodic payments can be made. These respondents therefore disagreed with the SLC’s rejection of making similar provisions for former cohabitants on the grounds that it was seen as too similar to aliment.
New list of remedies under Clause 4 of the Draft Bill (new section 28(2)) –
Most commonly, the order for transfer or sale was raised in views expressed around the new list of section 28(2) remedies (see also ‘Economic disadvantage test’ below). Views on this order included:
- Concerns whether regulating occupancy, which was felt most likely to be linked to such an order, could mean excluding a party from the property, and if so, what factors would be taken into account. It was considered unclear whether, in practice, this could have the effect of an exclusion order, and how it would interact with a cohabitant’s rights under the 1981 Act.
- Asking the UK government to consider the tax implications of a transfer order, given that transfers on divorce generally attract hold-over relief from capital gains tax.
- That the inclusion of property transfer orders should address a major limitation of the current legal regime.
Morton Fraser MacRoberts and The Family Law Association noted that an order for payment of a capital sum could, in theory, be made as an interim order. If so, it was felt this could potentially be granted without having been led and tested through cross examination to justify the amount awarded. Both expected some form of evidence would need to be provided at an interim hearing. The former respondent also noted that it was currently unclear what would happen with interim orders if there were a fundamental dispute about whether the couple had in fact cohabited, or when they separated.
The Family Law Association noted mixed views among their members on the order for one of the cohabitants to make payments to the other over a period of no more than six months, with some welcoming the change and others expressing reservations. They observed that ‘serious financial hardship’ is not defined and that potentially a claim for these payments could be made at any stage from separation until the matter is settled. Another legal/judicial body suggested ‘relevant factors’ could include length of relationship, perhaps within a broader consideration of the extent of financial dependence.
The Faculty of Advocates disagreed with the SLC’s position on pension sharing orders. It was their view that such a remedy should be available to the court handling a claim for financial provision on separation.
‘Guiding principles’ -
A few respondents also commented on the ‘guiding principles’ for making orders under section 28. Views were split as to whether these would improve the law relating to cohabitation.
In relation to the ‘economic disadvantage’ test, a few respondents highlighted the need to consider further how unpaid care or student income should be addressed. For instance, the Scottish Women's Convention identified the need to ensure that unpaid care was valued adequately, noting this has not traditionally been the case, with a recommendation that any revised framework explicitly accounts for the economic consequences of care.
One legal or judicial body highlighted issues with this test, notably that an order for transfer of a property should be a remedy open to both parties, whereas the test implies that a party needs to fit within the test of ‘economic disadvantage’. Similarly, they felt an order for sale also appeared to need to fit within the test, which they felt perhaps made sense where only one party is the owner, whereas if the parties were joint owners, they should have the option of division and sale.
Another legal/judicial body felt principle A was no clearer in its application than the current law, while Burness Paull LLP queried the use of the term ‘compensate’ under principle A as it starts to imply fault/wrongdoing and suggested ‘taking fair account of’ or ‘making appropriate provision’ as better wording.
General positive views
Some respondents left positive views on the draft Bill relating to financial rights upon separation at Q1, as did some at Q4, incorporated here to avoid repetition.
General comments included that the draft Bill makes ‘modest improvements’, that it improved the existing framework by introducing guiding principles and widening the range of available orders, that implementation of the SLC report was welcomed, and positive views of the draft Bill. For instance, The Free Church of Scotland commended the desire to reduce injustice and provide clearer guidance to the courts, and The Sheriffs Principal of the six sheriffdoms in Scotland welcomed greater clarity in legislation in this area, suggesting this would lead to benefits both for applicants and the courts.
Specific aspects of the draft Bill that were cited as welcome included:
- Flexibility regarding time limits for raising proceedings.
- Availability of additional remedies.
- Limiting the circumstances in which an order, such as a periodical allowance, may be awarded.
- New section 28D giving the court power, when determining an application for financial provision under section 28(2) to vary or set aside any agreement, or any term of an agreement between former cohabitants, if the agreement or term of the agreement was not fair and reasonable at the time it was entered into.
“I do not disagree with the SLC draft Bill to improve the rights of cohabitants when their relationship ends. I broadly support the proposals and welcome the recognition that cohabiting partners, particularly women, are currently left financially and legally exposed when relationships break down. Improved cohabitation rights are an important protective measure…. Strengthening the legal rights of cohabitants upon relationship breakdown can reduce vulnerability, provide financial protection, and support women to leave unsafe situations without facing destitution.” - Individual
“We support the extension of orders that the court can make; the new provisions for time limits and extensions, with a longstop and judicial discretion; and the more focused tests and guiding principles for an award under s28.” - SKO Family Law Specialists Ltd
Financial rights on separation
Views on financial rights upon separation were raised by several respondents.
Comparisons were made between arrangements for people who are married or in a civil partnership compared to those for cohabitants, with the perception that the former were entitled to greater financial protection than the latter.
The law in relation to those who are cohabiting was seen as an area largely guided by discretion, which could lead to unease among the legal profession. It was also suggested that the requirements to scrutinise spending over many years in relation to claims for separating cohabitants were not equivalent to how divorce claims are presented. One individual highlighted that shifts in societal attitudes made a distinction between cohabitants and marriage or civil partnership less relevant today and called for the underlying policy rationale for retention of a separate regime of financial provision for cohabitants upon relationship breakdown to be reviewed.
“This is an area of law that is largely guided by discretion, and legal professionals and judges have remarked that they feel uneasy with little statutory text/detail in this area. This is particularly pressing as we know that the rate of cohabitation is ever increasing and that a large percentage of cohabitants believe they are entitled to the same protections that are afforded to couples in legally recognised relationships; having similar financial provisions for cohabitants would help bridge the social and legal chasm we currently have.” - University of Glasgow Class Adult Relationships & Law 2026
Comments on the time limit for a claim under section 28
Views on the time limit for a claim under section 28 were given by some respondents. The consultation document sets out the SLC considers that the court should have discretion to accept a claim after the one-year period has expired ‘on special cause shown’ within a further one-year period. While these respondents generally supported extending the period in which a claim could be made, two respondents felt a longer extension of automatic entitlement should be given without the need to show ‘special cause’, for instance as this was seen to be fairer and less complex. Two also supported having a final backstop date, as this was considered clear and simple.
However, the Church of Scotland cautioned that while extending the deadline may be useful, it could serve as a means of continuing abuse, and suggested further evidence from groups with relevant experience and expertise should be sought. Further, it was noted by the Centre for Scots Law, School of Law, University of Aberdeen, that the suggested reforms would leave untouched any potential claims in ‘unjustified enrichment’ as such claims negatively prescribe after five years; therefore, unjustified enrichment may still come to the aid of cohabitants claiming after the two-year backstop.
The Family Law Association felt that a lack of awareness of the time limit should not be sufficient for the exercise of discretion to extend the time limit.
Comments on the definition of ‘cohabitant’
A range of views were expressed by some respondents on updating the definition of ‘cohabitant’ under section 25 of the 2006 Act to that suggested by the SLC by removing comparison with marriage. Points raised included:
- Two respondents at Q1, and two at Q5, incorporated here, who felt the revised definition would also need to be reflected in the Matrimonial Homes (Family Protection) (Scotland) Act 1981.
- Two respondents who suggested that removing reference to marriage could impact benefits associated with retaining it, such as it being interpreted more expansively than at present, weakening the link with a committed and exclusive relationship and opening the possibility of claims arising from non-exclusive or multi-party domestic arrangements (such as polyamorous relationships).
- Removing comparison with marriage was seen as potentially having benefits by two respondents, such as having a more flexible approach in certain circumstances, such as where one party moves into residential care, where the relationship continues in a meaningful sense, or that it removes suggestions of consistent behaviour between spouses and civil partners and appeared ‘sensible’.
- That the suggested definition change does not suggest what relative weight should be given to factors the court should have regard to, meaning that a highly fact specific and discretionary test will remain. The change, therefore, was felt to not necessarily address the practical concerns expressed about the current definition.
Should / should not align with marriage and civil partnerships
Some respondents expressed opposing views over whether the proposals should either align or not align with arrangements for marriage and civil partnerships.
The need to retain a distinction between cohabitation and marriage was suggested by a few respondents at Q1, and two at Q4 and two at Q5, incorporated here. These respondents felt that marriage should be prioritised rather than strengthening cohabitation rights. Considerations raised included that the nature of marriage was substantially different from cohabitation, such as it being a lifelong commitment or an exclusive partnership, or that strengthening rights could create new financial obligations without the commitments of marriage.
“If couples want to have the rights of married couples, they should marry. I don't believe widening rights for cohabiting couples is the answer to this, as it just makes marriage unnecessary.” - Individual
A few respondents felt arrangements should be the same and were opposed to the SLC recommendation that a distinction should be made. Reasons for holding this view included that there is a need for reform of the law on cohabitation, that there was little evidence for the rationale set out by the SLC, that implications of changes will be left for the courts to work through which brings uncertainty and cost for those who should be protected, and that there was public support for bringing the law more in line with that for spouses and civil partners.
Other views
One individual felt the draft Bill would not address shortcomings identified with the current legislation, as it was based around three principles from the 1985 Act, which were considered problematic and that while it, in some ways, moves closer to mirroring the 1985 Act, the language and structure are different. For instance, guiding principle C was seen as a replacement of section 28(2)(b) that changed the language but not necessarily the approach. Another individual specifically highlighted missing provisions they felt should be considered, notably the need for stronger safeguards against claims by individuals who entered the relationship primarily for residency or financial gain.
The order in which impact assessments were set out was mentioned by the Centre for Scots Law, School of Law, University of Aberdeen, who noted they were unclear whether a particular order had been followed for setting out the commentary on the impact assessments.
The Law Society of Scotland highlighted that the Children’s Rights and Wellbeing Impact Assessment (CRWIA) should consider the impact of the proposals on children aged 16 and 17 and identify any incompatibility gaps in rights protections when their cohabiting parents separate.
Q2. Should the scheme for the reform of cohabitants' rights on separation apply to couples who separate after the date of commencement of the legislation implementing the proposed reforms?
| Respondent type | Sample size (n=) | % Yes
|
% No | % Don't No | % No Answer |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| All respondents | 124 | 27 | 6 | 7 | 60 |
| All answering | 49 | 67 | 14 | 18 | - |
Two thirds (67%) of those answering felt that the scheme for the reform of cohabitants’ rights on separation should apply to couples who separate after the date of commencement of the legislation implementing the proposed reforms, while 14% felt it should not, and 18% were unsure. A majority of both individuals and organisations who answered agreed (63% and 74%, respectively), with particularly high support recorded among legal/judicial bodies (90%).
Around one in eight of all respondents left a comment at Q2. The most prevalent themes were agreement that cohabitants’ rights on separation should apply in such cases, implementation challenges, and that it should be possible to backdate the rights.
Yes, the scheme should apply after the date of commencement
Most commonly, several respondents expressed support for the scheme for reform of cohabitants’ rights on separation, applying to couples who separate after the date of commencement of the legislation implementing the proposed reforms.
General views included that this seemed sensible. It was felt that this aligned with the principles of legal certainty and fairness. Brodies LLP also highlighted that it was consistent with the approach taken when the 2006 Act was introduced. Similarly, it was noted that allowing rights to be backdated would be complex or confusing to implement. The Humanist Society Scotland noted this approach could avoid retrospective interference in settled cases. Two respondents felt it would be unfair to retrospectively apply the rights as separating couples may already have planned their property and economic decisions on the basis of existing legislation.
Implementation considerations
A few respondents raised considerations for implementing the proposed changes, with two highlighting a low awareness of cohabitation rights among the public and suggesting action to increase awareness. Another two respondents noted that the law should evolve over time and recommended that any reforms be applied as early as possible following enactment to deliver the benefits of the improved scheme without unnecessary delay.
Other views
The need to ensure appropriate protections for people who were separated before commencement was noted by two respondents. Views included ensuring that existing legal remedies, including those relating to coercive control and domestic abuse, are robustly applied and accessible, and that the current statutory regime under section 28 of the 2006 Act should continue to apply.
Q3. Do you have any comments on our draft impact assessments on the proposals for improving cohabitants' rights when their relationship ends otherwise than on death?
| Respondent type | Sample size (n=) | % Yes
|
% No | % No Answer |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| All respondents | 124 | 8 | 31 | 61 |
| All answering | 48 | 21 | 79 | - |
Among all respondents, 8% indicated at the closed question that they had comments on the draft impact assessments on the proposals for improving cohabitants’ rights when their relationship ends otherwise than on death.
Fewer than one in ten left an open comment at Q3. Only one theme emerged, mentioned by a few respondents. Other views were left by one or two respondents.
Comments on certain groups
A few respondents left comments on the draft impact assessments on the proposals for improving cohabitants’ rights. Three called for stronger gender analysis with recognition that this was likely an area where the proposals would have the most impact. Women on low incomes, with caring responsibilities or from communities where coercion, harmful practices and honour-based dynamics are present were all mentioned as groups that could be disproportionately impacted. The Humanist Society Scotland called for consideration of the impact on LGBTQ+ couples, whom they considered had traditionally faced barriers to marriage and may still prefer cohabitation for personal or safety reasons.
Areas to strengthen
Two respondents felt intersectionality should be considered in the impact assessments, for instance, to:
- Recognise that women, disabled people and those on lower incomes were disproportionately impacted by weak cohabitation rights. For example, an individual noted there is no explicit analysis of whether legal costs can deter claims, which could impact women on lower incomes or who struggle to obtain legal aid despite eligibility.
- To consider the intersection of cohabitation, forced marriage and coercive control, particularly in communities where informal or unregistered relationships are common and where women may have limited awareness of, or access to, legal protections.
- To consider whether the proposed reforms are accessible to women whose first language is not English, who may be isolated from mainstream services or who face community or family pressure that prevents them from asserting their legal rights.
Other views included:
- That the CRWIA should address how the law and legal processes can be a source of harm and could have engaged more thoroughly with trauma-informed practice literature.
- That the principle of fairness should be incorporated into the statutory framework to avoid uncertainty or ambiguity.
- One individual who welcomed attention given to gender and socioeconomic impacts.
- Another individual who felt the document was not in plain English or ‘public-friendly’.
Q4. Do you have any other comments on the proposals for improving cohabitants' rights when their relationship ends otherwise than on death?
| Respondent type | Sample size (n=) | % Yes
|
% No | % No Answer |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| All respondents | 124 | 15 | 24 | 60 |
| All answering | 49 | 39 | 61 | - |
Among all respondents, 15% indicated at the closed question that they had other comments on the proposals for improving cohabitants’ rights when their relationship ends otherwise than on death.
Almost two in ten respondents left an open comment at Q4. The most prevalent themes were general positive views (which have been incorporated into the analysis of Q1), suggested areas to strengthen and other general views relevant to the question.
Areas to strengthen
Some respondents suggested areas to strengthen in relation to the proposals to improve cohabitants’ rights. Mainly, these respondents felt the proposals should be strengthened to prevent coercive control or better protect those experiencing domestic abuse, with greater protections in law, or protection arising from changes in the law suggested.
For instance, Scottish Women’s Aid provided an extensive discussion on this topic, and readers are advised to refer to their published response for details. For instance, they suggested more work was needed to identify and protect economically vulnerable cohabitants and felt domestic abuse should be expressly named as a ‘relevant factor’ that courts must consider, clearly linked to how the court assesses fairness, disclosure, capacity to negotiate and the validity of ‘agreements’. SKO Family Law Specialists noted that the court can take account of abusive behaviour in section 28C(4)(b) but considered the wording should be ‘conduct’ rather than ‘behaviour’ to avoid behaviour claims being made, which could promote higher-conflict claims.
One individual suggested introducing a mechanism like the Legal Services Payment Orders (LSPOs)[2]. It was felt that these could address the problems where one party controls the financial resources, to help ensure access to justice and ensure accessibility of the expanded rights and remedies.
SKO Family Law Specialists suggested introducing another provision like the section 14(2)(k) of the Family Law (Scotland) Act 1985 to allow the court to make ‘any
ancillary order which is expedient to give effect to the principles set out in [s9 of this Act or to any order made under section 8(2) of this Act]’ with the wording in square brackets amended to reflect the equivalent principles and orders under the 2006 Act.
General views
A range of miscellaneous points was expressed by some respondents, including:
- Two respondents raised risks of the proposals, such as the potential to incentivise unstable relationships that harm children and strain public services if reforms were not minimal and tightly drawn, and that the revised definition could compromise the definition of cohabitants in several other pieces of legislation relevant to domestic abuse[3].
- That cohabitants’ occupancy rights should be reviewed and considered alongside the remedies under the 2006 Act.
- That the law should reflect the availability of two legal frameworks for couples, only one of which envisages a permanent commitment.
- An individual who felt legislation should be accessible to those for whom it applies and therefore suggested avoiding complicated numbering.
- To also review the 1985 Act and consider making explicit reference to ‘abusive’ behaviour in it, to align with section 28C(4) of the draft SLC Bill.
- The need to expand access to legal aid provision.
- To ensure clear, accessible guidance is available.
The need for public awareness
Public awareness campaigns or education were called for by some respondents. It was felt that people, such as cohabitants or women, particularly those from marginalised or isolated communities, were unaware of their rights and responsibilities in this area. For instance, it was felt that many people mistakenly believe in a ‘common law marriage’ that does not exist or that many women may not be using the provisions set out in sections 26, 27 and 28 as they are unaware of their rights under them.
“Any reform must be accompanied by a meaningful, accessible, and multilingual public awareness campaign. Specialist VAWG organisations must be funded to support women navigating these new rights. Legal rights without accessible support are rights in name only.” - Individual
Address legal or court practices
Changes in legal processes or improved awareness among legal or judicial personnel were sought by a few respondents. Points raised included:
- The need for solicitors who raise a ‘holding action’ to be clear that the court papers must be served to be able to start the process.
- That in section 28C(4)(c) it would be better for the court to focus on ‘all the relevant circumstances of the case’ rather than all the ‘other’ circumstances, which was considered too wide.
- That the SLC recommendations ‘relied heavily’ on those involved as advisors and in the court process being alerted to risks of domestic and economic abuse and to employ robust processes for the testing of evidence, adherence to procedure and swift resolution of claims. As a result, court personnel should have a thorough understanding of the role that economic abuse plays, in that the issue is not solely restricting women’s access to money, as they can be made to be financially responsible for everything.
Views on age for cohabitation
A few respondents commented on the age for cohabitation. One individual noted that observations of forced marriage suggested some 16 and 17-year-olds would be placed into cohabiting arrangements as a way of circumventing the intention of the law, should the minimum age of marriage be raised. As a result, they felt the redesign of cohabitants’ rights should bear this in mind. Another individual strongly supported that the age of 16 should be specified as part of the definition of cohabitant, even if the legal marriage age is raised. Burness Paull LLP felt the age for making a claim on cessation of cohabitation should be kept in line with the minimum age for marriage.
“Whatever the age of marriage, there will be, in fact, 16- and 17-year-olds who are in lawful relationships which may involve them living together. The question is therefore whether we should deny them the legal protections that the law grants to older cohabitants, even if the rights and responsibilities of marriage are no longer to be available to them. The justification for increasing the age of marriage is that it tends to reduce life choices (particularly for young women); cohabitation does not have that effect and is in itself a protective concept in the way that marriage is not. These protections should not be removed from the small number of persons aged 16 to 18 who are cohabiting with an intimate partner… It would increase the vulnerability of these young people to deny them the protections that cohabitation law currently grants to them.” - Individual
Greater clarity needed
Two respondents called for greater clarity in the proposals, notably to clarify:
- Whether the ‘same residence’ referred to in section 25(A3) would cover situations where parties reside in more than one residence, especially where these are owned separately. It would be helpful to clarify this in the definition.
- If it is intended that the new wording ‘joint household expenses’ in section 27 should create a new and potentially broader category of ‘joint expenditure’, beyond ‘household expenditure’, as the proposed new wording could impact legal understanding.
- Whether a section 28 claim considered past, present and/or future disadvantage to one party, or the need for contributions from the other.
- How ‘foreseeable resources’ in new s28G would be calculated and identified.
“Our member services queried ‘enduring family relationship’, why ‘enduring’ and/or ‘family’ is needed, what these terms mean in this context and how it would be measured/identified, as it is inconsistent with the definitions relating to domestic abuse, particularly in relation to ‘family.’” - Scottish Women’s Aid
Financial provision on intestacy
Under the current law, a surviving cohabitant can make an application to the court for financial provision from their deceased partner’s intestate estate. Under section 29 of the 2006 Act, a cohabitant has the right to make a claim on their deceased cohabitant’s estate where there is no will within six months from the date of death. Section 78 of the Trusts and Succession (Scotland) Act 2024 extends the time limit in section 29 of the 2006 Act to 12 months, though this is not yet in force.
Q5. Should the recommended definition of "cohabitant" under the SLC's proposals for reform of cohabitants' rights on separation, also apply to circumstances where a cohabitant is applying for financial provision from their deceased partner's intestate estate?
| Respondent type | Sample size (n=) | % Yes
|
% No | % Don't Know | % No Answer |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| All respondents | 124 | 27 | 4 | 6 | 64 |
| All answering | 45 | 73 | 11 | 16 | - |
Among those answering Q5, 73% agreed that the recommended definition of “cohabitant” under the SLC’s proposals for reform of cohabitants’ rights on separation should also apply to circumstances where a cohabitant is applying for financial provision from their deceased partner’s intestate estate. Of the remainder, 11% disagreed, and 16% were unsure. Seven in ten (71%) individuals and three quarters (76%) of organisations that answered were in favour of this approach, as were 89% of legal/judicial bodies and 60% of religion or belief-based organisations.
Almost one in five of all respondents left an open comment to explain their answer at Q5. The only theme identified that directly answered the question was agreement that the recommended definition of ‘cohabitant’ under the SLC’s proposals should also apply to circumstances where a cohabitant is applying for financial provision from their deceased partner’s intestate estate.
It should apply / be consistent
Almost all open comments at Q5 indicated that the definition of ‘cohabitant’ under the SLC’s proposals for reform should apply to circumstances where a cohabitant is applying for financial provision from their deceased partner’s intestate estate. Several respondents left such comments, a third of whom were legal or judicial bodies. Reasons given for this were that a coherent legal framework promotes fairness and clarity, avoids confusion and complexity, and reduces litigation. It was also felt to promote equality and reduce the potential for discrimination. One individual felt it should go further and the new definition should apply to all other pieces of legislation where the fact of cohabitation has legal consequences, such as the Matrimonial Homes (Family Protection) (Scotland) Act 1981 and the Redress for Survivors (Historic Child Abuse in Care) (Scotland) Act 2021.
“It is generally desirable that a defined legal term should carry a consistent meaning across the statute book unless there is a clear and justified reason for divergence. Consistency of terminology supports legal certainty and assists both practitioners and the public in understanding the scope and effect of the law.” - Law Society of Scotland
It should not apply
One individual suggested that the definition should not automatically apply to intestacy claims, suggesting that cohabitation should not be treated the same as marriage, and that the proposal risked creating automatic inheritance-style rights. This respondent suggested any financial provision on intestacy for cohabitants must remain strictly discretionary, evidence-based and limited, allowing Scottish courts wide powers to refuse or reduce awards where the relationship is short-term, where the claimant has no strong ties to Scotland or where the claim appears driven by residency or financial motives.
Other views
Some respondents highlighted legislative considerations. Two respondents mentioned the inclusion of ‘enduring family relationship’ within the definition, with Brodies LLP suggesting its inclusion was aligned to other areas of family law, such as adoption and surrogacy and was therefore appropriate as ‘the courts are already considering the nature of relationships in this way’. However, Thorntons Law LLP noted that neither the Succession (Scotland) Act 1964 nor the Trusts and Succession (Scotland) Act 2024 defines a cohabitant or refers to ‘enduring family relationship’ and felt it was difficult, therefore, to see how the proposed definition of enduring family relationship could be applied to section 29 without conflicting with provisions in those Acts. Similarly, Scottish Women’s Aid queried at Q4 how an ‘enduring family relationship’ would be proven, noting that the terminology ‘enduring relationship’ is used for quite a different purpose of adoption rather than financial provision.
The Faculty of Advocates suggested a further subparagraph be added to the
recommendation at paragraph 1.75 to clarify a remaining uncertainty in the existing test for the determination of whether or not a person is a cohabitant for all purposes. In this regard, they felt it should be made clear that a person should not be regarded as having ceased to be the cohabitant of another person by reason only of circumstances such as hospitalisation, periods spent in residential care, imprisonment, offshore employment or service overseas in the armed forces. An individual felt there should be a clause for when there is no agreement on the separation date, such as when they physically stopped living together.
Q6. Other than the time limit, what other practical difficulties are encountered by persons making an application for financial provision on intestacy under section 29 of the 2006 Act?
Over one in five of all respondents left an open comment at Q6. A disparate range of practical difficulties was identified, with the main themes emerging being difficulties arising from the impact of grief, challenges associated with cost or complexity, and executor or estate-related difficulties.
Difficulties due to grief
The need to take legal action at a time when applicants are likely to be experiencing grief or trauma due to the death of a partner was considered by some respondents to cause difficulties. Challenges included feelings of guilt and discomfort around serving court papers in relation to a section 29 claim on the deceased’s next of kin, and difficulties for a party to be able to give meaningful instructions and understand the urgency with which one must proceed to raise an action within the time limit. One anonymous legal/judicial body suggested that consideration could be given to an alternative dispute resolution process for cases where there is a section 29 claim, so it feels less adversarial for the parties involved.
“It is daunting for cohabitees to serve court papers in relation to a section 29 claim on the deceased's next of kin. Clients often express feelings of guilt and discomfort at serving court papers at a time when they and the deceased's family members are grieving.” - The Family Law Association
Difficulties due to cost and complexity
Some respondents raised challenges around the cost and complexity of making an application for financial provision on intestacy. Points raised included that access to legal aid could be challenging, that a LSPO could be introduced to support with legal fees and made available for cohabitants as well as married couples, and that there is a lack of specialist legal support for women experiencing harm.
“The need to raise court proceedings may involve cost and complexity, which can act as a barrier to accessing the remedy in practice.” - The Free Church of Scotland
Executor or estate-related difficulties
Some respondents, almost all legal/judicial bodies, felt that there could be challenges relating to executors. For instance, difficulties appointing an executor can lead to delays, which impacts the time limit for making an application. Brodies LLP observed that in some cases a person who intends to act as executor may delay applying for appointment to frustrate an application under section 29. This can be a particular concern where the relationship between the surviving cohabitant and the deceased cohabitant’s family has broken down.
“The executor/s are not always easily identifiable. Some actions may be raised relying on a potential debt being due against the deceased’s estate, with a view to amending the action later to be against the executor/s when the executors become known and are appointed. This can make the actions more complex and expensive. Others are raised against those who might be appointed executor but are not, and this runs the risk of raising action against the wrong party, which could, in theory, lead to dismissal of the action.” - Thorntons Law LLP
Other issues included practical difficulties caused by a cohabitant raising a claim prior to the appointment of the executor, such as how a claimant in such circumstances can enforce their right to an order for transfer or that the claimant becomes a creditor against the estate if the court grants an order for a capital sum. The Faculty of Advocates, who raised this issue, considered that a statutory basis for these orders to be implemented, such as execution of transfer by the sheriff clerk or Deputy Principle Clerk of Session, would resolve this issue. They called for a range of incidental orders to be available in section 29 actions, e.g. an incidental order for the valuation of the property. An anonymous legal/judicial body suggested consideration should be given to allowing a cohabitant to be appointed as executor dative or for a judicial factor to be appointed where there is a section 29 claim.
The Free Church of Scotland noted that the progression of estate administration before a claim is made can create procedural difficulties for applicants, though it did not give further details on this issue.
Evidential difficulties
Challenges in being able to produce evidence to support or challenge claims were raised by some respondents, over half of whom were individuals, notably around establishing the nature and extent of the relationship and proving financial contributions, such as in the absence of written receipts. One individual felt, however, that stricter evidential requirements were needed to discourage reliance on intestacy claims by cohabitants and reinforce marriage and will-making as the responsible choices for people living in Scotland.
“The burden is placed on the surviving cohabitant … to prove contributions. For example, if the surviving cohabitant didn't contribute on a regular basis to the household because his/her partner said it wasn't fair for them to do so (due to disparity in incomes), how does the survivor then prove that he/she has a right to an award? … There may also be cases where the surviving cohabitant did contribute financially from time to time but paid in cash and didn't keep documentation of these.” - Individual
Difficulties caused by disputes or the involvement of third parties
Difficulties arising from disputes or the involvement of others were raised by some respondents. Issues included:
- Lack of cooperation from family or others involved in the estate.
- Challenges to the claim from family or friends.
- People causing problems or making false allegations that could affect a claim.
- Fear of family or community reprisal, e.g. for women from communities where honour-based dynamics are present.
- Coercive control and unequal relationships, for instance, impacting an ability to obtain information about finances, assets or property.
- Conflicts between parties created by raising the court action, particularly when the success or otherwise of an action can hinge on a technical legal argument, such as not raising a claim within the specified time limit or not all parties being called to an action.
Lack of awareness or access to information
Practical difficulties could be caused by a lack of awareness of rights and legal processes, according to a few respondents. For instance, access to detailed information, legal advice and legal aid were all considered key requirements by one individual. The Free Church of Scotland noted that claims may not be pursued, or could be raised too late, due to a lack of awareness. One individual noted this meant the ‘law exists in name only’ for women unaware of their rights and felt this especially impacted women in marginalised and isolated communities.
‘Relevant factors’ are too broad / lack of statutory criteria
A few respondents felt the statutory factors that the court must consider under the current section 29 of the 2006 Act were too broad and lacking in focus. This was felt to make it very difficult to focus on those factors of most significance in a case. Two of these respondents cited the case of Kerr v Mangan where Lord Drummond Young called for the reform of section 29 and observed that the lack of statutory criteria for an award made the task of the court extremely difficult.
“The absence of clear statutory aims and the diffuse nature of the current factors create uncertainty for litigants and limit the court’s ability to reach consistent and principled decisions. Reform of section 29 is therefore necessary to provide a clearer framework and a more workable basis for applications for financial provision on intestacy.” - Law Society of Scotland
Other views
Difficulties relating to identifying the likely beneficiaries of the deceased’s intestate estate, such as delays in the processing of litigation, were identified by one respondent. An individual also highlighted that immigration status or language barriers, where a surviving cohabitant does not have English as a first language, could create difficulties by deterring people from engaging with any legal process.
Although not directly answering the question, some respondents left comments on the time limit for making an intestate claim. For instance, it was noted that the timescale for cohabitants’ claims following the death of an intestate had been extended to 12 months by section 78 of the Trusts and Succession (Scotland) Act 2024, though this was not yet enacted. Two respondents felt that extending the time limit for the purpose of section 29 would cause delays in winding up estates, with one anonymous legal/judicial body recommending the extended timescale not be enacted and the other, the Centre for Scots Law, School of Law, University of Aberdeen, emphasising that the one year time limit should be the absolute final time limit, with no scope for extensions even on cause shown.
Conversely, the Faculty of Advocates noted in their experience that there are occasions where injustice arises due to a failure to meet the six-month deadline (and would do so even when the limit is extended to 12 months), particularly where the delay was not the claimant’s fault. As a result, they felt that section 29 should be revised to include a provision whereby, on special cause shown, the court could allow a late application to be received.
Contact
Email: family.law@gov.scot